Fiveable
Fiveable
Cram Mode Banner
👩🏾‍⚖️AP US Government

👩🏾‍⚖️ap us government review

1.3 Federalist No. 10 & Brutus 1 Summary

Verified for the 2025 AP US Government exam4 min readLast Updated on March 3, 2025

Federalist No. 10 Summary

Federalist No. 10 is an essay written by James Madison and published in 1787 as part of The Federalist Papers. It addresses the problem of faction, which Madison defines as a group of citizens who have a common interest contrary to the rights of other citizens or the good of the whole community. The essay argues that a large and diverse republic is the best form of government to guard against the danger of factions, as it makes it more difficult for any one faction to gain control. Madison also outlines the necessity of a strong central government to control the destructive effects of factions. In conclusion, Federalist No. 10 asserts that a federal system, which divides power between a central government and constituent states, is the best solution to the problem of factions and will ensure the preservation of liberty and the protection of the rights of citizens.

Here is an example of an application of Federalist No. 10 in a contemporary context:

Today in the United States, factions are still cause for concern. Our country has such a diverse population with varying interests, and many groups seeking to advance their interests at the expense of others. For instance, the debate over gun control is a classic example of a faction problem, with the interests of gun owners and gun control advocates often being in conflict.

Federalist No. 10 provides insight into how to manage this problem. The essay's argument is that a large and diverse republic is the best form of government to guard against the danger of factions is still relevant today. The federal system of the United States has proven to be an effective way of balancing the interests of different groups and ensuring that no one group gains too much power.

In this example, the principles outlined in Federalist No. 10 can be applied to the current debate over gun control. The federal system provides a mechanism for balancing the interests of different groups and ensuring that the rights of all citizens are protected. By understanding and applying the principles of Federalist No. 10, policymakers can work to compose solutions that protect individual rights and promote the common good.

Brutus No. 1 Summary

Brutus No. 1 is an essay written by an anonymous author, believed to be Robert Yates, and published in 1787 as a response to The Federalist Papers. It argues against the ratification of the proposed U.S. Constitution, claiming that it would lead to the concentration of power in the hands of a few and the erosion of individual liberty. The essay asserts that the Constitution fails to provide sufficient checks and balances to prevent the abuse of power by the national government and that it gives too much power to the central government at the expense of the states. The author also argues that the Constitution lacks a bill of rights to protect individual liberties, such as freedom of speech, religion, and the press. In conclusion, Brutus No. 1 argues that the Constitution represents a threat to the rights and freedoms of citizens and should not be ratified.

Here is an example of an application of Brutus No. 1 in the present day context:

In the United States today, there is ongoing debate about the role of the government in protecting individual rights and promoting the common good. For example, the debate over privacy rights versus national security is a classic example of this conflict. On one hand, privacy advocates argue that the government should not have access to individuals' personal information without a warrant. On the other hand, proponents of national security argue that the government needs access to this information in order to prevent terrorism and protect the country.

Brutus No. 1 provides insight into how to manage this problem. The essay's argument that the Constitution fails to provide sufficient checks and balances to prevent the abuse of power by the national government is still relevant today. In the debate over privacy rights versus national security, the author of Brutus No. 1 might argue that the government's access to individuals' personal information should be limited in order to protect individual rights and prevent the abuse of power.

In this example, the principles outlined in Brutus No. 1 can be applied to the current debate over privacy rights versus national security. By understanding and applying the principles of Brutus No. 1, policymakers can work to find a solution that protects individual rights and promotes the common good, while also ensuring that the country remains safe.

Image courtesy of Pixabay

🎥 Watch: AP GOPO - Federalist 10 and 51, and Brutus 1

Key Questions

Here are some key questions about Federalist No. 10 and Brutus No. 1:

Federalist No. 10:

  • What is the main argument of Federalist No. 10?
  • How does James Madison define the problem of faction?
  • What does Madison argue is the best form of government to guard against the danger of factions?
  • Why does Madison believe a federal system is the best solution to the problem of factions?

Brutus No. 1:

  • What is the main argument of Brutus No. 1?
  • Why does the author believe that the U.S. Constitution should not be ratified?
  • What are the main criticisms of the Constitution made by the author in Brutus No. 1?
  • What is the author's position on the concentration of power and individual liberty in the proposed Constitution?

Review Time

Reviewing with friends or others studying the same content can be super helpful if you have any questions or need clarification. 

Key Terms to Review (22)

Bill of Rights: The Bill of Rights is the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution, ratified in 1791, which guarantee essential rights and liberties to individuals. It was created to protect citizens from potential government overreach and ensure fundamental freedoms that reflect the ideals of democracy.
Brutus No. 1: Brutus No. 1 is an influential anti-Federalist essay written in 1787 that argues against the proposed U.S. Constitution, warning that a strong central government could threaten individual liberties and state sovereignty. The essay emphasizes the dangers of consolidating power in a large republic and advocates for a decentralized government that prioritizes local governance and direct representation.
Central Government: A central government is the primary governing authority in a political system, responsible for making and enforcing laws, administering public policy, and managing national affairs. It contrasts with local or state governments, which have authority over specific regions. The central government plays a critical role in addressing issues like civil rights, economic stability, and national defense.
Checks and Balances: Checks and balances is a foundational principle in the American government system that ensures no single branch of government becomes too powerful by allowing each branch to limit the powers of the others. This system promotes accountability and prevents abuse of power, ensuring that government actions reflect the will of the people while maintaining individual rights.
Concentration of Power: Concentration of power refers to the centralization of authority and control within a government or political system, often leading to the dominance of a single entity or group over decision-making processes. This concept is crucial in understanding the debates surrounding the structure of government, particularly in relation to the balance between liberty and authority. The concentration of power raises concerns about the potential for tyranny and the erosion of individual freedoms, which are central themes in discussions about governance and democracy.
Faction: A faction is a group of individuals within a larger entity, often united by shared interests, beliefs, or goals, that seeks to influence or control political decisions. In the context of governance, factions can pose challenges to the stability and unity of a political system, as they may prioritize their own interests over the common good. The discussion around factions highlights the tension between liberty and order in a democracy.
Federal System: A federal system is a form of government where power is divided between a central authority and smaller political units, such as states or provinces. This division allows for a balance of power, where both the national and local governments have their own responsibilities and powers. The federal system is essential in understanding how various levels of government interact and share authority, influencing the way laws are made, implemented, and interpreted.
Freedom of Speech: Freedom of Speech is a fundamental right protected by the First Amendment, allowing individuals to express their thoughts, opinions, and ideas without government interference. This right plays a crucial role in democratic societies, as it fosters open dialogue, promotes individual autonomy, and enables the criticism of government actions.
Gun Control: Gun control refers to the laws and policies that regulate the manufacture, sale, transfer, possession, and use of firearms. This issue often raises questions about individual rights versus public safety, making it a significant topic in discussions about civil liberties and government power.
Individual Liberty: Individual liberty refers to the personal freedoms and rights that each person possesses, allowing them to act according to their own will, as long as it does not infringe on the rights of others. This concept is foundational to democratic societies, emphasizing the importance of protecting citizens' rights against government overreach and ensuring that individuals can pursue their own happiness and interests.
James Madison: James Madison was the fourth President of the United States and is often called the 'Father of the Constitution' for his pivotal role in drafting and promoting the U.S. Constitution and the Bill of Rights. His contributions to the formation of the government are foundational to the principles of democracy, federalism, and governance in America.
Large and Diverse Republic: A large and diverse republic is a political entity characterized by a wide range of cultural, ethnic, and ideological differences among its citizens, often spanning a vast geographic area. This concept highlights the potential for varied interests and perspectives to coexist within a single governmental framework, allowing for a broader representation of the populace. The framers of the Constitution believed that such a republic could effectively manage the challenges of factionalism while ensuring stability and governance.
Liberty: Liberty refers to the state of being free within society from oppressive restrictions imposed by authority on one's way of life, behavior, or political views. It is a fundamental principle that underscores the rights of individuals to act and think freely, shaping discussions on governance and civil rights. The concept is crucial in understanding the debates between federalists and anti-federalists regarding the balance of power in government and the protection of individual rights through constitutional amendments.
National Security: National security refers to the protection and defense of a nation's sovereignty, territorial integrity, and interests against external threats. It encompasses a wide range of areas including military defense, economic stability, and diplomatic relations, playing a critical role in shaping government policies and actions.
Privacy Rights: Privacy rights refer to the fundamental human rights that protect individuals' personal information and private lives from government intrusion and public exposure. This concept is rooted in the belief that people should have control over their personal information and the ability to keep certain aspects of their lives confidential. Privacy rights are essential in discussions about government power, individual freedoms, and the balance between security and personal liberties.
Press: The press refers to the media outlets that disseminate news and information to the public, including newspapers, magazines, television, and online platforms. It plays a crucial role in shaping public opinion and informing citizens about government actions and societal issues. The press is essential for a functioning democracy, providing checks on power and fostering accountability through the free exchange of ideas and information.
Ratification: Ratification is the formal approval process by which a proposed law or constitutional amendment is officially accepted. This process often requires a specified majority of votes from a governing body or the electorate, marking the transition of proposals into legally binding laws or amendments.
Religion: Religion refers to a system of beliefs, practices, and values often centered around the worship of a higher power or deity. It plays a crucial role in shaping individual identity and community values, influencing legal frameworks and political discourse throughout history.
Rights of Citizens: The Rights of Citizens refer to the legal and moral entitlements granted to individuals within a state, ensuring protection from government abuse and promoting individual freedoms. These rights are essential for maintaining a democratic society and include civil liberties such as freedom of speech, religion, and assembly. In discussions surrounding governance, the protection and balance of these rights are crucial elements debated by founding thinkers.
Robert Yates: Robert Yates was an influential American politician and a key figure during the Constitutional Convention of 1787, known for his opposition to the federal Constitution. He was a staunch Anti-Federalist who believed that the proposed Constitution would create a powerful central government at the expense of state sovereignty and individual liberties. Yates's ideas were prominently expressed in his writing of 'Brutus 1,' where he articulated concerns about factions, representation, and the potential for tyranny within a large republic.
The Federalist Papers: The Federalist Papers are a collection of 85 articles and essays written in the late 18th century to promote the ratification of the U.S. Constitution. Authored by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay, these writings addressed key issues related to government structure, individual rights, and the need for a stronger national government. They played a crucial role in shaping public opinion and providing a framework for understanding the newly proposed Constitution.
U.S. Constitution: The U.S. Constitution is the foundational legal document of the United States, establishing the framework for the federal government and its relationship with the states and citizens. It embodies the principles of democracy, outlines the powers of government branches, and protects individual rights through amendments.
Glossary