1.6 Cross-Cultural Comparison and Cultural Relativism
3 min read•june 24, 2024
encourages understanding beliefs and practices within their specific contexts. This approach helps anthropologists avoid biases and appreciate diverse cultural adaptations. It contrasts with , which judges other cultures based on one's own standards.
Applying relativistic thinking involves suspending personal assumptions when examining social issues in other cultures. This approach allows for deeper understanding of marriage practices, gender roles, and religious beliefs across different societies. It promotes cross-cultural respect and objectivity in anthropological research.
Cross-Cultural Comparison and Cultural Relativism
Concept of relativism in anthropology
Top images from around the web for Concept of relativism in anthropology
The Eight Cultural Forces - The lens & the lever — The Learner's Way View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Cross-Cultural Differences and Similarities in Human Value Instantiation View original
Is this image relevant?
An Ethical Relativism Example: Are Human Rights Universal? View original
Is this image relevant?
The Eight Cultural Forces - The lens & the lever — The Learner's Way View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Cross-Cultural Differences and Similarities in Human Value Instantiation View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Concept of relativism in anthropology
The Eight Cultural Forces - The lens & the lever — The Learner's Way View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Cross-Cultural Differences and Similarities in Human Value Instantiation View original
Is this image relevant?
An Ethical Relativism Example: Are Human Rights Universal? View original
Is this image relevant?
The Eight Cultural Forces - The lens & the lever — The Learner's Way View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Cross-Cultural Differences and Similarities in Human Value Instantiation View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
emphasizes beliefs, values, and practices should be understood and evaluated within their specific
Highlights no single, universal standard exists for judging
Encourages anthropologists to suspend judgment and avoid ethnocentric biases when studying other cultures (Yanomami, Inuit)
Significance of relativism in anthropology
Enables more objective and unbiased understanding of diverse cultures (Maasai, Hmong)
Helps anthropologists appreciate unique ways different societies adapt to environments and meet needs
Promotes and respect for
Cultural relativism vs ethnocentrism
Cultural relativism
Evaluates beliefs, values, and practices within their specific cultural context
Assumes no culture is superior to another and all cultures are equally valid
Encourages understanding and respect for cultural differences (Amish, Maori)
Ethnocentrism
Views one's own culture as superior and judges other cultures based on own cultural standards
Can lead to biases, misunderstandings, and cultural conflicts
Hinders objective cross-cultural analysis and understanding (colonialism, racism)
Comparison
Cultural relativism promotes more objective and unbiased approach to cross-cultural analysis, while ethnocentrism can lead to biased and judgmental attitudes
Cultural relativism encourages respect for cultural diversity, while ethnocentrism can lead to cultural intolerance and discrimination
Cultural relativism allows deeper understanding of reasons behind cultural practices, while ethnocentrism often results in superficial and misguided interpretations
Application of relativistic thinking
Identify and suspend one's own cultural biases and assumptions when examining social issues in other cultures
Consider historical, environmental, and cultural factors that shape social practices and beliefs in different societies
Examples of applying relativistic thinking to social issues
Marriage practices
Understand cultural, economic, and historical reasons behind different marriage practices (monogamy, polygamy, arranged marriages)
Avoid judging practices based on own
Gender roles and expectations
Recognize gender roles and expectations vary across cultures and are influenced by factors like religion, economics, and history
Examine how roles and expectations function within their specific cultural contexts (matrilineal societies, gender egalitarian hunter-gatherers)
Religious beliefs and practices
Acknowledge diversity of religious beliefs and practices worldwide (animism, monotheism, polytheism)
Understand significance of beliefs and practices within their respective cultural contexts
Avoid evaluating religious practices based on own religious or secular standards
Cultural Adaptation and Diversity
refers to how societies adjust their practices and beliefs to suit their environment and circumstances
Cultural diversity reflects the wide range of cultural norms and practices across different societies
Cross-cultural understanding involves recognizing and appreciating differences in cultural contexts
Studying cultural practices helps anthropologists identify both unique and universal aspects of human behavior
Key Terms to Review (19)
Cross-Cultural Comparison: Cross-cultural comparison is the systematic examination and analysis of similarities and differences between two or more cultures or societies. It involves the comparative study of cultural practices, beliefs, values, and behaviors across different cultural contexts to gain a deeper understanding of the diversity and commonalities of the human experience.
Cross-Cultural Understanding: Cross-cultural understanding refers to the ability to appreciate, respect, and effectively navigate the differences and similarities between cultures. It involves developing a deep awareness and appreciation of diverse cultural perspectives, values, and practices, and using this knowledge to foster meaningful and productive interactions across cultural boundaries.
Cultural Adaptation: Cultural adaptation refers to the process by which a group of people modify their behaviors, beliefs, and practices to better fit the demands of their environment or the norms of a new cultural context. It is a crucial concept in understanding how cultures evolve and thrive across different settings and circumstances.
Cultural Context: Cultural context refers to the specific social, historical, and environmental factors that shape the beliefs, values, and behaviors of a particular group or society. It provides the framework through which individuals and communities interpret and make sense of their experiences, interactions, and the world around them.
Cultural Determinism: Cultural determinism is the belief that an individual's thoughts, behaviors, and actions are primarily shaped and determined by the culture they are born into, rather than by biological or genetic factors. It emphasizes the powerful influence of cultural norms, values, and institutions on shaping human development and social behavior.
Cultural Diversity: Cultural diversity refers to the variety of human societies and cultures across the world, encompassing the differences in language, customs, beliefs, values, and ways of life. It is a central concept in anthropology that highlights the richness and complexity of the human experience.
Cultural norms: Cultural norms are the shared expectations and rules that guide the behavior of people within a specific cultural group. They shape how individuals interact with one another and influence their beliefs, values, and practices. Understanding cultural norms is essential for recognizing how different societies function and helps in making cross-cultural comparisons, as well as emphasizing the importance of cultural relativism in appreciating diverse practices.
Cultural Practices: Cultural practices refer to the customary and habitual activities, behaviors, and traditions that are shared and upheld within a particular cultural group. These practices shape and reflect the values, beliefs, and worldviews of a society, influencing how individuals interact with one another and their environment.
Cultural Relativism: Cultural relativism is the principle that an individual's beliefs and activities should be understood in terms of their own culture, rather than being judged by the standards of another culture. It is a central concept in anthropology that emphasizes the importance of understanding cultural practices and beliefs within their own context, rather than imposing external moral or ethical judgments.
Emic: Emic refers to an insider's perspective within a culture, emphasizing the understanding of cultural practices and beliefs from the viewpoint of the members of that culture. This approach contrasts with the etic perspective, which analyzes cultures from an outsider's viewpoint. By prioritizing the emic viewpoint, anthropologists can gain deeper insights into cultural meanings, practices, and values.
Ethnocentrism: Ethnocentrism is the tendency to view one's own cultural norms and practices as superior to those of other societies, often leading to the dismissal or misunderstanding of alternative ways of life. This concept is particularly relevant in the field of anthropology, as it explores the diverse cultures and belief systems of humanity.
Ethnographic Fieldwork: Ethnographic fieldwork is a core methodology in cultural anthropology that involves immersing oneself in a community or cultural setting to directly observe and document human behavior, social interactions, and cultural practices. It is a holistic approach that aims to provide a rich, in-depth understanding of a particular cultural context.
Etic: Etic refers to an analytical perspective in anthropology that examines cultural phenomena from an external viewpoint, typically using objective, universal criteria. This approach contrasts with the emic perspective, which seeks to understand cultural practices and beliefs from within the context of that specific culture. The etic perspective is crucial for cross-cultural comparison and is vital for maintaining cultural relativism by allowing anthropologists to avoid bias rooted in their own cultural experiences.
Franz Boas: Franz Boas was a pioneering anthropologist who is considered the 'father of modern anthropology' for his significant contributions to the field. Boas' holistic approach, emphasis on cultural relativism, and groundbreaking ethnographic work shaped the development of anthropology as a distinctive discipline that seeks to understand the diversity of human cultures and experiences across the globe.
Holism: Holism is the understanding that the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. It is a fundamental principle in anthropology that emphasizes the interconnectedness of cultural, biological, and social aspects of human life, rather than viewing them in isolation.
Margaret Mead: Margaret Mead was a renowned American cultural anthropologist known for her pioneering work in the field of anthropology. She is particularly recognized for her contributions to the understanding of cross-cultural comparisons, cultural relativism, participant observation, gender studies, and the use of visual anthropology and ethnographic film in the discipline.
Particularism: Particularism is the belief that cultural practices and behaviors should be understood within their specific cultural context, rather than through the lens of universal or generalized principles. It emphasizes the unique and distinct nature of each culture and rejects the notion of a single, standardized set of norms or values that can be applied across all societies.
Relativism: Relativism is the philosophical view that all beliefs, values, and knowledge are relative to the individual, culture, or context in which they exist. It challenges the idea of universal, objective truths and instead suggests that what is considered true or right can vary across different societies and perspectives.
Universalism: Universalism is the belief that certain ideas, principles, or values are universal and apply to all people, regardless of cultural differences. It is a perspective that emphasizes the common humanity and shared experiences of individuals across diverse cultural contexts.