Skip to main content

Federalist No. 39 in AP US Government

Federalist No. 39 is James Madison's 1788 essay arguing that the proposed Constitution is "in strictness, neither a national nor a federal Constitution, but a composition of both." Some features rest on the American people as one body, and others rest on the states as separate political units. AP Gov uses it to explain why dividing power between the national government and the states keeps power from concentrating in one place and gives citizens multiple access points into politics.

This definition is part of Fiveable's AP US Government review, which also has guided practice questions.

Verified for the 2027 AP US Government exam•Last updated November 2026•Fiveable Content Team

The ratification charge Madison set out to answer

Madison wrote No. 39 as "Publius" during the ratification debate in New York. Anti-Federalists warned that the Constitution would consolidate the states into one national government and wipe out their independence. Brutus No. 1 makes that case directly.

No. 39 is Madison's reply. He grants that a purely national government would be a problem, then walks through the plan piece by piece to show it isn't one.

In the course, this essay belongs to Unit 1, Foundations of American Democracy, in Topic 1.7, Relationship Between the States and National Government. That topic asks how the Constitution's split of authority between the two levels shapes American society, and No. 39 supplies the founding-era reasoning behind that split.

Madison's five national-or-federal tests

Madison first argues the plan is a republic, meaning power comes from the people and officeholders serve limited terms or during good behavior. Then he sorts the Constitution's features into two labels. National means power flows from the people as one body or acts directly on individuals. Federal means power flows from the states as distinct units.

  • Ratification: federal, because each state approved it separately, not one nationwide majority vote.
  • Sources of power: the House is national (elected by "the people of America"), the Senate is federal (states represented equally, originally chosen by state legislatures), and the presidency is a mix, since electoral votes are allotted to states partly by population.
  • Operation: national, because federal laws act directly on individual citizens, unlike under the Articles of Confederation.
  • Extent: federal, because national jurisdiction "extends to certain enumerated objects only," leaving states "a residuary and inviolable sovereignty over all other objects."
  • Amendment: a mix, since it takes a supermajority of states, neither unanimity nor a simple national majority.

A multiple-choice question could use a passage from No. 39 and ask you to identify the national or federal feature it describes. The ratification quote supports the claim that the states kept an independent role in founding the government. The "residuary" quote pairs enumerated national powers with residual state authority. The Tenth Amendment later reserves powers not delegated to the United States, nor prohibited to the states, to the states or the people.

From "composition of both" to grants, mandates, and access points

Madison's conclusion is the hybrid itself. The course draws two payoffs from it. Splitting authority across levels means no single part of government holds all the power, and it gives people more than one place to push for change.

That second payoff connects to the Concept Application question. If a scenario shows a group losing in Congress and then lobbying a state legislature, or a state acting where Washington hasn't, you can explain the outcome as multiple access points created by federalism. Colorado and Washington legalizing recreational marijuana in 2012 while it stayed illegal under federal law is the illustrative example to reach for.

The balance Madison described keeps shifting. The National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984 shows Congress using conditions on highway money to steer a policy usually left to the states. Categorical grants, block grants, and mandates are all later tools for pulling that balance one way or the other.

Keeping No. 39 separate from No. 51 and No. 10

Both essays are Madison's, and both are about dividing power, so it's easy to treat No. 39 and No. 51 as one argument. No. 39 tests the Constitution feature by feature to show it mixes national and federal elements. No. 51 explains how checks and balances keep each part of government in its place, and it adds that splitting power between the national and state governments in a "compound republic" creates "a double security" for the people's rights.

So a mention of states alone won't tell you which essay you're reading. Ratification and "residuary and inviolable sovereignty" are strong clues for No. 39, but identify the excerpt by its argument. If it sorts the Constitution's features into national and federal, it's No. 39. If it's about ambition counteracting ambition, or about the double security that comes from layers of government checking each other, it's No. 51.

No. 10 is about controlling factions through a large republic, so it answers a different question.

For the Argument Essay, No. 39 is not one of the required foundational documents listed in prompts, so it can't stand in for one. It works as extra evidence alongside a listed document. In a federalism prompt, you could cite Brutus No. 1's fear of consolidation as the opposing view, then rebut it with Madison's point that national power reaches only enumerated objects.

Where this sits in AP® Gov

Keep studying AP® Gov Unit 1