Skip to main content

5.12 Exploring Behaviors of Implicit Relations

add to ChatGPT
Verified for the 2027 examUpdated October 2026Fiveable Content Team
Fiveable

♾️AP Calculus AB/BC Unit 5 Review

QR code for AP Calculus AB/BC practice questions

5.12 Exploring Behaviors of Implicit Relations

Implicit relations like x2+y2=25x^2+y^2=25 have critical points wherever dydx\frac{dy}{dx} equals zero or does not exist. You find these by using implicit differentiation, then analyzing the first and second derivatives to describe how the curve behaves, just like you would with a regular function. For AP Calculus, keep xx and yy values attached to each point you classify.

This is the last topic in Unit 5, so it pulls together everything you learned about analyzing functions with derivatives.

Critical Points and Concavity of Implicit Curves

  • A critical point of an implicit relation is any point where dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx} = 0 or dydx\frac{dy}{dx} does not exist.
  • dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx} = 0 usually signals a horizontal tangent; dydx\frac{dy}{dx} undefined (denominator zero) usually signals a vertical tangent.
  • The same increasing, decreasing, and concavity rules from earlier topics apply to implicit relations.
  • The second derivative of an implicit relation often contains xx, yy, and dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, so substitute your first derivative before simplifying.
  • To classify a point, check how dydx\frac{dy}{dx} changes sign around it, but remember some points on closed curves can't be labeled max or min.
  • Always solve dydx\frac{dy}{dx} in terms of both variables before setting it equal to zero or finding where it is undefined.

Understanding Implicit Relations

An implicit relation is an equation where the variables are mixed together on the same side, instead of being solved as y=f(x)y = f(x). Before this unit you mostly saw explicit functions that pass the vertical line test, like:

y=f(x)y = f(x)

An implicit relation can have multiple variables on the same side and sometimes does not pass the vertical line test. Even so, you can still describe its behavior using derivatives.

Here is a classic example:

x2+y2=1x^2 + y^2 = 1

Implicit differentiation lets you work with these by taking ddx\frac{d}{dx} of both sides to find dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, which is usually written in terms of both xx and yy.

First Derivative Applications

Critical Points on Implicit Relations

On an implicit relation, a critical point is any point where the first derivative is zero or is undefined. If you want a refresher on critical points in general, check 5.2 Extreme Value Theorem, Global vs Local Extrema, and Critical Points. These points are potential locations for extrema, horizontal tangents, or vertical tangents.

Steps to Find Critical Points

  1. Differentiate both sides of the equation with respect to xx by taking ddx\frac{d}{dx}.
  2. Solve for dydx\frac{dy}{dx}. This gives the derivative in implicit form.
  3. Set dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx} = 0 to find points with horizontal tangents, and find where dydx\frac{dy}{dx} is undefined (where the denominator is zero) for vertical tangents.
  4. Make a conclusion about each critical point by checking how dydx\frac{dy}{dx} changes sign around that point.

Reading Behavior from the First Derivative

The same rules you used for explicit functions still apply:

  • If f′(x)f'(x) is positive, the graph of f(x)f(x) is increasing.
  • If f′(x)f'(x) is negative, the graph of f(x)f(x) is decreasing.
  • If f′(x)f'(x) is increasing (positive slope), the graph of f(x)f(x) is concave up.
  • If f′(x)f'(x) is decreasing (negative slope), the graph of f(x)f(x) is concave down.
  • If f′(x)f'(x) changes from positive to negative at x=kx = k, then f(x)f(x) has a relative maximum at x=kx = k.
  • If f′(x)f'(x) changes from negative to positive at x=kx = k, then f(x)f(x) has a relative minimum at x=kx = k.

For implicit relations, relative minimums and maximums can be less intuitive than they are for explicit functions, so analyze the sign changes carefully.

To review these ideas, check out:

Second Derivative Applications

After finding the first derivative implicitly, differentiate again with respect to xx to find the second derivative. The second derivative of an implicit relation may involve xx, yy, and dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, so substitute your expression for dydx\frac{dy}{dx} to simplify.

Once you have the second derivative, you can analyze concavity and look for points of inflection:

  1. If f′′(x)f''(x) is positive, the function is concave up.
  2. If f′′(x)f''(x) is negative, the function is concave down.
  3. A point of inflection is a point where concavity changes. Candidates occur where f′′(x)=0f''(x) = 0 or f′′(x)f''(x) does not exist. Confirm the change by checking the sign of f′′(x)f''(x) just before and just after the candidate point.

To review concavity, check out 5.6 Determining Concavity.

Worked Examples

Example 1: Critical Points on a Circle

Untitled
Picture of the circle represented by x2+y2=25x^2 + y^2 = 25 with a blue dot on (−5,0)(-5, 0) and a green dot on (5,0)(5,0), courtesy of Desmos

Consider the implicit equation x2+y2=25x^2 + y^2 = 25. Find the critical points and determine their nature.

Differentiate implicitly:

2x+2ydydx=02x + 2y\frac{dy}{dx} = 0

Solve for dydx\frac{dy}{dx}:

dydx=−xy\frac{dy}{dx} = -\frac{x}{y}

Set dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx} = 0:

0=−xy0 = -\frac{x}{y}

x=0x = 0

From x2+y2=25x^2 + y^2 = 25, if x=0x = 0 then y2=25y^2 = 25 and y=±5y = \pm 5. So two candidate points are (0,5)(0, 5) and (0,−5)(0, -5).

Also set dydx\frac{dy}{dx} undefined. The derivative is undefined when the denominator is zero, so y=0y = 0. Plugging back in gives x=±5x = \pm 5, so (5,0)(5, 0) and (−5,0)(-5, 0) are also candidates.

First Derivative Test Chart

The Pointdy/dx to the Leftdy/dx to the RightConclusion
(0, 5)+-Maximum
(0, -5)-+Minimum
(5, 0)+ OR -+ OR -Undefined
(-5, 0)+ OR -+ OR -Undefined

Why are two of the points not labeled max or min? Look at the graph of the circle. Below (−5,0)(-5, 0) in the third quadrant, the slope is negative; above it in the second quadrant, the slope is positive. The point (5,0)(5, 0) has a similar sign change.

Despite these sign changes, these points are not conclusively maxima or minima at the level of Calculus AB. To classify a max or min, you need valid points with xx-values both greater than and less than the critical point. Here there are no points to the left of (−5,0)(-5, 0) and none to the right of (5,0)(5, 0), so the curve's shape makes these vertical-tangent points instead of clear extrema.

Think of it this way: if you travel the circle clockwise, (5,0)(5, 0) acts like a minimum and (−5,0)(-5, 0) acts like a maximum. Travel counter-clockwise and they switch. Because the labeling depends on direction, these points are vertical tangents rather than true extrema.

A ladder leans against a wall. The bottom slides away from the wall at a constant rate of 2 ft/s. If the ladder is 10 feet long and its bottom starts 6 feet from the wall, how fast is the top sliding down when the bottom is 8 feet from the wall?

This is a related rates application that uses the same implicit setup. List the given information:

  • Horizontal rate of the bottom: dxdt=2\frac{dx}{dt} = 2 ft/s
  • Length of the ladder: 10 ft
  • What to find: vertical rate dydt\frac{dy}{dt} when x=8x = 8

Use the Pythagorean Theorem to model the ladder, with xx as horizontal distance and yy as vertical distance:

x2+y2=102x^2 + y^2 = 10^2

Differentiate with respect to time:

2xdxdt+2ydydt=02x\frac{dx}{dt} + 2y\frac{dy}{dt} = 0

Solve for dydt\frac{dy}{dt}:

dydt=−xy⋅dxdt\frac{dy}{dt} = -\frac{x}{y}\cdot\frac{dx}{dt}

Find yy when x=8x = 8:

82+y2=1008^2 + y^2 = 100

y2=100−64=36y^2 = 100 - 64 = 36

y=6y = 6

Substitute x=8x = 8, y=6y = 6, and dxdt=2\frac{dx}{dt} = 2:

dydt=−86⋅(2)=−83 ft/s\frac{dy}{dt} = -\frac{8}{6}\cdot(2) = -\frac{8}{3}\text{ ft/s}

The top of the ladder slides down at 83\frac{8}{3} ft/s when the bottom is 8 feet from the wall. The negative sign tells you the height is decreasing, which matches "sliding down."

Solving and Justifying Implicit Relation Problems

Problem Solving: When you see an implicit relation, follow a consistent process:

  1. List the given information and your goal.
  2. Differentiate both sides with respect to xx (or with respect to tt for related rates).
  3. Solve for dydx\frac{dy}{dx} (or dydt\frac{dy}{dt}).
  4. Set the derivative equal to zero for horizontal tangents and find where it is undefined for vertical tangents.
  5. For the second derivative, differentiate again and substitute your dydx\frac{dy}{dx} expression.
  6. Check your sign changes and confirm any positive or negative results make sense.

Free Response: If a free response question asks you to justify behavior, refer to ff, f′f', and f′′f'' by name rather than saying "it." For example, state that the curve is concave up on an interval because d2ydx2\frac{d^2y}{dx^2} is positive there. A clear justification names the evidence and connects it to the conclusion.

Common Trap: Watch the denominator. The derivative dydx=−xy\frac{dy}{dx} = -\frac{x}{y} is undefined when y=0y = 0, and that condition signals a vertical tangent, not a place to ignore. Always check both where the derivative is zero and where it is undefined.

Common Misconceptions

  • Misconception: A critical point occurs only where the derivative is zero.
    Actually: A critical point is not only where dydx=0\frac{dy}{dx} = 0. It also includes points where dydx\frac{dy}{dx} does not exist, such as vertical tangents.
  • Misconception: A sign change in dydx\frac{dy}{dx} always means a max or min on a closed curve.
    Actually: A sign change in dydx\frac{dy}{dx} does not always mean a max or min on a closed curve. Points like (5,0)(5, 0) and (−5,0)(-5, 0) on a circle are vertical tangents, not true extrema.
  • Misconception: The second derivative of an implicit relation is usually just a function of xx.
    Actually: The second derivative of an implicit relation is usually not just a function of xx. It often depends on xx, yy, and dydx\frac{dy}{dx}, so you must substitute before finishing.
  • Misconception: You do not need to include a dydx\frac{dy}{dx} factor when differentiating yy.
    Actually: Forgetting the dydx\frac{dy}{dx} term when differentiating yy is a common error. Every time you differentiate a yy term, the chain rule adds a dydx\frac{dy}{dx} factor.
  • Misconception: Setting only the numerator to zero is enough to find critical points.
    Actually: Setting only the numerator to zero misses vertical tangents. Check the denominator for where the derivative is undefined too.

Practice Questions for 5.12

1 of 10

The graph above shows the upper branch (y≥0y \ge 0) of the implicit relation 4x2+y2=44x^2 + y^2 = 4, which has the derivative dydx=−4xy\frac{dy}{dx} = -\frac{4x}{y}.

Which of the following correctly verifies whether the point (1,0)(1, 0) is a critical point of the implicit relation?

A.

(1,0)(1, 0) is not a critical point because dydx\frac{dy}{dx} is undefined at y=0y = 0, and a critical point requires the derivative to exist and equal zero.

B.

(1,0)(1, 0) is a critical point because it lies on the curve and makes the denominator of dydx\frac{dy}{dx} equal to zero, meaning the derivative is undefined.

C.

(1,0)(1, 0) is a critical point because the numerator of dydx\frac{dy}{dx} evaluates to −4-4, indicating a constant rate of change at the endpoint.

D.

(1,0)(1, 0) is not a critical point because the numerator of dydx\frac{dy}{dx} is not zero, which is the only condition that creates a critical point.

Vocabulary

The following words are mentioned explicitly in the AP® course framework for this topic.

Term

Definition

critical point

A point in the domain of a function where the derivative is zero or undefined, which are candidates for local and absolute extrema.

derivative

The instantaneous rate of change of a function at a specific point, representing the slope of the tangent line to the function at that point.

first derivative

The derivative of a function, denoted f', which describes the rate of change and indicates where a function is increasing or decreasing.

implicit differentiation

A technique for finding the derivative of a function defined implicitly by differentiating both sides of an equation with respect to the independent variable.

implicit relation

A relation defined by an equation in which the dependent variable is not explicitly solved in terms of the independent variable.

implicitly defined function

A function defined by an equation relating x and y, where y is not explicitly solved in terms of x.

second derivative

The derivative of the first derivative, denoted f'', which describes the concavity of a function and indicates where it is concave up or concave down.

See Fiveable more often in Google

Mark Fiveable as a preferred source and Google is more likely to show you our guides in Top Stories, with a "preferred" badge in AI Mode and AI Overviews.

Prefer us on Google