Skip to main content

Judiciary Act of 1789 in AP US History

The Judiciary Act of 1789 was the law passed by the first Congress and signed by George Washington that built the federal court system the Constitution had only outlined. It set the Supreme Court at six justices, created district and circuit courts beneath it, and established the office of Attorney General.

This definition is part of Fiveable's AP US History review, which also has guided practice questions.

Verified for the 2027 AP US History exam•Last updated November 2026•Fiveable Content Team

What Article III left blank and the 1789 act filled in

Article III says there will be "one Supreme Court" plus whatever lower courts Congress chooses to set up. It doesn't say how many justices, where courts sit, or how cases move between state and federal systems. Congress had to decide all of that.

The act, largely drafted by Senator Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut, answered those questions:

  • A Supreme Court of six justices: one Chief Justice and five associate justices. John Jay became the first Chief Justice.
  • Thirteen district courts, the bottom layer of federal courts.
  • Three judicial circuits, with circuit courts held in their districts by Supreme Court justices who traveled ("rode circuit") alongside district judges.
  • An Attorney General to argue the government's cases. Edmund Randolph was the first.

The number of justices isn't in the Constitution. Congress set it, and later Congresses changed it.

Washington's government had to invent its own machinery

The act is evidence for Unit 3: Conflict and American Independence, 1754-1800, Topic 3.10: Shaping a New Republic. That topic asks how the Washington and Adams administrations built institutions and set precedents that turned the Constitution's principles into working practice.

The Judiciary Act is a clean example because the gap was so obvious. In 1789 there was no federal court anywhere. Within months of the new government starting, Congress had created a whole branch from scratch. It belongs alongside other 1789 firsts, like Washington forming a cabinet and Congress proposing the amendments that became the Bill of Rights.

The argument this supports is that the Constitution was a framework, and the first Congresses and presidents decided what it would actually look like in daily government.

Section 25 and the debate over national versus state power

Section 25 let the Supreme Court review state court decisions that rejected a claim based on the U.S. Constitution, federal laws, or treaties. That meant a state's highest court didn't get the final word on federal law.

This ties the act to the 1790s debate over how the national government should relate to the states. Federalists like Alexander Hamilton favored a strong central government, and a federal court with authority over state rulings fit that vision. People who worried about consolidated national power, many of whom ended up in the Democratic-Republican Party, were more suspicious of it. The act predates the parties, but it reflects the same federal-versus-state tension that helped produce them.

Why "established judicial review" is the wrong answer

The trap answer credits the Judiciary Act of 1789 with creating judicial review, the power of courts to strike down laws as unconstitutional. It didn't. Marbury v. Madison (1803), which you'll see later in the course, established the Supreme Court's power to strike down an act of Congress as unconstitutional.

The connection runs the opposite way. In Marbury, Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that Section 13 of the 1789 act was itself unconstitutional, because it tried to expand the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction beyond what Article III allowed. So the Judiciary Act was the law the Court struck down, and that ruling made the Court's power to invalidate federal legislation a landmark precedent.

Keep it separate from the Judiciary Act of 1801 too. That later law came from the lame-duck Federalist Congress after Adams lost in 1800, and Jefferson's supporters repealed it in 1802.

Using the 1789 act as evidence in a written response

The act's value on the exam is that it's concrete. If it shows up in a multiple-choice set built around a source on Washington's administration or federal power, the correct answer will be structural: it organized the federal courts.

In a Short-answer Question about how the new government took shape, the act gives you a specific piece of evidence instead of a vague "Washington set precedents." Name what it created and explain that this turned Article III into a working branch.

For a Long Essay Question or Document-Based Question on the growth of federal power, a strong response links forward. Cite the 1789 act as the starting structure, Section 25 as an early claim of national authority over state courts, and Marbury v. Madison as the point where the Court asserted the power to strike down acts of Congress. That chain shows change over time, which earns more than mentioning the act by itself.

Where this sits in APUSH

Keep studying APUSH Unit 3