πŸ“š

All Subjects

Β >Β 

πŸ”Β 

AP Research

Β >Β 

πŸŽ“

The Academic Paper

Academic Paper: Discussion and Analysis

5 min readβ€’november 3, 2020

Dylan Black


Introduction

After presenting your data and results to readers, you have one final step before you can finally wrap up your paper and write a conclusion: analyzing your data! This is the big part of your paper that finally takes all the stuff you've been talking about - your method, the data you collected, the information presented in your literature review - and uses it to make a point!
The major question to be answered in your analysis section is simply "we have all this data, but what does it mean?" What questions does this data answer? How does it relate to your research question? Can this data be explained by, and is it consistent with, other papers? If not, why? These are the types of questions you'll be discussing in this section.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-C6qluzbKeV4m.gif?alt=media&token=250056fc-a2aa-41bc-9f9a-d1ac008fc1b9

Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Writing a πŸ”₯ Discussion and Analysis

Explain What Your Data Means

The primary point of a discussion section is to explain to your readers, through both statistical means and thorough explanation, what your results mean for your project. In doing so, you want to be succinct, clear, and specific about how your data backs up the claims you are making. These claims should be directly tied back to the overall focus of your paper.
What is this overall focus, you may ask? Your research question! This discussion along with your conclusion forms the final analysis of your research - what answers did we find? Was our research successful? How do the results we found tie into and relate to the current consensus by the research community? Were our results expected or unexpected? Why or why not? These are all questions you may consider in writing your discussion section.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-GFd156PnlIc2.gif?alt=media&token=97ea6513-8066-4d0f-9ddd-56d3f1064832

You showing off all of the cool findings of your research! Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Why Did Your Results Happen?

After presenting your results in your results section, you may also want to explain why your results actually occurred. This is integral to gaining a full understanding of your results and the conclusions you can draw from them. For example, if data you found contradicts certain data points found in other studies, one of the most important aspects of your discussion of said data is going to be theorizing as to why this disparity took place.
Note that making broad, sweeping claims based on your data is not enough! Everything, and I mean just about everything you say in your discussions section must be backed up either by your own findings that you showed in your results section or past research that has been performed in your field.
For many situations, finding these answers is not easy, and a lot of thinking must be done as to why your results actually occurred the way they did. For some fields, specifically STEM-related fields, a discussion might dive into the theoretical foundations of your research, explaining interactions between parts of your study that led to your results. For others, like social sciences and humanities, results may be open to more interpretation.
However, "open to more interpretation" does not mean you can make claims willy nilly and claim "author's interpretation". In fact, such interpretation may be harder than STEM explanations! You will have to synthesize existing analysis on your topic and incorporate that in your analysis.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-UyDu2dG2M4mf.gif?alt=media&token=7097ba11-2f10-4f2f-bde8-89374215ce39

Liam Neeson explains the major question of your analysis. Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Discussion vs. Summary & Repetition

Quite possibly the biggest mistake made within a discussion section is simply restating your data in a different format. The role of the discussion section is to explain your data and what it means for your project. Many students, thinking they're making discussion and analysis, simply regurgitate their numbers back in full sentences with a surface-level explanation.
Phrases like "this shows" and others similar, while good building blocks and great planning tools, often lead to a relatively weak discussion that isn't very nuanced and doesn't lead to much new understanding.
Instead, your goal will be to, through this section and your conclusion, establish a new understanding and in the end, close your gap! To do this effectively, you not only will have to present the numbers and results of your study, but you'll also have to describe how such data forms a new idea that has not been found in prior research.
This, in essence, is the heart of research - finding something new that hasn't been studied before! I don't know if it's just us, but that's pretty darn cool and something that you as the researcher should be incredibly proud of yourself for accomplishing.

Rubric Points

Before we close out this guide, let's take a quick peek at our best friend: the AP Research Rubric for the Discussion and Conclusion sections.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-ZhTL4asMd9fA.png?alt=media&token=ef89cc5b-e85a-480a-a51c-0f3f6158be44

Image Courtesy of CollegeBoard

Scores of One and Two: Nothing New, Your Standard Essay

Responses that earn a score of one or two on this section of the AP Research Academic Paper typically don't find much new and by this point may not have a fully developed method nor well-thought-out results. For the most part, these are more similar to essays you may have written in a prior English class or AP Seminar than a true Research paper. Instead of finding new ideas, they summarize already existing information about a topic.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-FeoWavGnXCWk.webp?alt=media&token=c0c111d5-37af-428c-aef7-44711143e633

Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Score of Three: New Understanding, Not Enough Support

A score of three is the first row that establishes a new understanding! This is a great step forward from a one or a two. However, what differentiates a three from a four or a five is the explanation and support of such a new understanding. A paper that earns a three lacks in building a line of reasoning and does not present enough evidence, both from their results section and from already published research.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-aC8ouxxNd2jb.gif?alt=media&token=25b43b6b-f06c-4f71-b9c1-1acdc285b2f4

Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Scores of Four and Five: New Understanding With A Line of Reasoning

We've made it to the best of the best! With scores of four and five, successful papers describe a new understanding with an effective line of reasoning, sufficient evidence, and an all-around great presentation of how their results signify filling a gap and answering a research question.
As far as the discussions section goes, the difference between a four and a five is more on the side of complexity and nuance. Where a four hits all the marks and does it well, a five exceeds this and writes a truly exceptional analysis. Another area where these two sections differ is in the limitations described, which we discuss in the Conclusion section guide.
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-rqPia7AnPCYJ.webp?alt=media&token=cda3a169-92db-41cb-a40b-9369a90a3744

Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Conclusion

You did it!!!! You have, for the most part, finished the brunt of your research paper and are over the hump! All that's left to do is tackle the conclusion, which tends to be for most the easiest section to write because all you do is summarize how your research question was answered and make some final points about how your research impacts your field. Finally, as always...
https://firebasestorage.googleapis.com/v0/b/fiveable-92889.appspot.com/o/images%2F-7Gq1HyLaboLC.webp?alt=media&token=9277c610-aff1-4599-9a4b-bd089909c677

Image Courtesy of GIPHY

Was this guide helpful?

Hours Logo
Studying with Hours = the ultimate focus mode
Start a free study session
Join us on Discord
Thousands of students are studying with us for the AP Research exam.
join now
πŸ“± Stressed or struggling and need to talk to someone?
Talk to a trained counselor for free. It's 100% anonymous.
Text FIVEABLE to 741741
Β© 2021 Fiveable, Inc.