Skip to main content

Rhetorical Choices in AP English Language

Rhetorical choices are the deliberate decisions a writer or speaker makes about language, structure, evidence, and tone to achieve a purpose with a particular audience. Each one is a move the writer could have made differently, so analyzing it means explaining why this version fits this audience and situation better than the alternatives.

This definition is part of Fiveable's AP English Language review, which also has guided practice questions.

Verified for the 2027 AP English Language exam•Last updated November 2026•Fiveable Content Team

Step 1: Read the situation before you hunt for choices

Choices only make sense against the situation that produced them. That's why this term starts in Unit 1: Claims, Reasoning, and Evidence, Topic 1.1: Identifying the purpose and intended audience of a text. The course's big question there is how a writer's circumstances shape what ends up on the page.

Before marking up a passage, sketch the rhetorical situation: the writer, the audience, the purpose, the exigence (whatever moved the writer to produce the text), the message, and the context (time, place, and occasion). Keep in mind that a text can have more than one purpose. The audience is also never one uniform group. Its members share some values and beliefs, and each one brings a background and needs of their own, so smart writers make choices that reach both levels.

Step 2: Find the moves the writer could have made differently

Almost anything in a text can count as a choice. Some of the most common ones:

  • word choice (diction) and sentence structure (syntax)
  • appeals to credibility, emotion, or logic (ethos, pathos, logos)
  • which evidence gets included, such as an anecdote, a statistic, or an expert
  • the order ideas appear in, including the opening and the ending
  • shifts in tone
  • what the writer leaves out

A common mix-up in AP Lang is treating a device as if it were the analysis. A metaphor, an anaphora, or an antithesis is a thing sitting in the text. The rhetorical choice is the writer's decision to use it for a reason. Writing "the author uses pathos" points at something. Explaining why the author reached for emotion at that exact moment, with that audience, is analysis.

Step 4: Build a line of reasoning in the Rhetorical Analysis essay

Question 2 (Rhetorical Analysis) asks you to analyze the rhetorical choices a writer makes in a nonfiction passage to convey a message. The rubric rewards a defensible thesis, evidence and commentary that explain how specific choices contribute to the writer's purpose or message, and sophistication in your thinking.

An essay that lists devices ("she uses ethos, pathos, and imagery") with a quote under each tends to stay in the lower commentary range. Stronger essays usually follow the passage's order or its main moves. They quote a specific choice, then explain its effect on this audience in this context, and they tie it back to the purpose. Sentences with "because" and "so that" help keep the reasoning visible.

One way to reach for sophistication is to explain how the writer's choices respond to the complexity of the situation. In the flood letter, for example, she has to hold both grief and tax skepticism in the same audience. Your thesis should name the choices together with what they accomplish, so the whole essay reads as one argument about the writer's strategy.

Where this sits in AP® English Language