Sourcing and Situation asks you to analyze who created a source, why they created it, when and where it was created, and who the intended audience was. Critically, you must then explain how those factors shape what the source reveals or conceals. Identifying point of view alone does not earn a DBQ sourcing point.
- Point of view (POV): The perspective shaped by the author's identity, experiences, or position, which influences what they emphasize or omit.
- Purpose: The reason the source was created, such as to persuade, inform, justify, or commemorate.
- Historical situation: The broader context at the time of creation that shapes what the author could or would say.
- Audience: The intended recipient of the source, which affects the language, tone, and content the author chose.
- Limitation: What the source cannot tell you because of the author's position, purpose, or audience.
Can you explain how a source's point of view, purpose, situation, or audience affects its reliability or what it reveals, not just name those features?
| Weak sourcing | Strong sourcing |
|---|
| The author is a Catholic bishop, so he is biased. | Because the author is a Catholic bishop writing during the Council of Trent, his defense of Church authority reflects the institutional pressure to respond to Protestant critiques, which means the source overstates clerical unity. |