Skip to main content

Anne Hutchinson in AP US History

Anne Hutchinson was a Puritan midwife in the Massachusetts Bay Colony who led religious meetings in her home and accused most of the colony's ministers of preaching a false path to salvation. The colony's General Court tried her and ordered her banished in 1637, and her church excommunicated her in 1638, the year she left Massachusetts. Her case is a standard example of how Puritan New England punished religious dissent.

This definition is part of Fiveable's AP US History review, which also has guided practice questions.

Verified for the 2027 AP US History exam•Last updated November 2026•Fiveable Content Team

1634-1637: Sermon discussions that turned into a challenge

Hutchinson arrived in Boston in 1634, following the minister John Cotton, whose preaching she admired. She began hosting meetings in her home to talk through the week's sermons, and the gatherings grew to include dozens of men and women.

The trouble came from what she taught. Puritans spoke of a covenant of grace (salvation as an unearned gift from God) and warned against a covenant of works (the belief that good behavior earns salvation). Hutchinson said most of the colony's ministers were preaching a covenant of works. She praised John Cotton and John Wheelwright as exceptions, and she taught that a truly saved person could sense God's grace directly.

Her opponents called this antinomianism, from Greek words meaning "against the law." They meant that she was teaching that the saved didn't need ministers or moral rules to guide them. The dispute split Boston and is often called the Antinomian Controversy.

The 1637 trial, the revelation claim, and exile

In November 1637 the General Court, led by Governor John Winthrop, put Hutchinson on trial. Massachusetts Bay restricted voting to male church members, so political power stayed in the hands of men inside the Puritan churches. The colony's civil leaders saw her challenge to the ministers as a threat to the colony's order.

She answered the judges' questions sharply and held her ground for much of the trial. Then she said God had revealed truths to her directly, and that claim of immediate revelation gave the court what it needed. In Puritan belief, God spoke through scripture and the ministers who interpreted it, so a personal revelation looked like heresy and a threat to order. The court ordered her banished in 1637. In 1638 her church excommunicated her, and she left Massachusetts.

She moved with her family and followers to Aquidneck Island in what became Rhode Island. After her husband died, she relocated to New Netherland, where she was killed in 1643 during fighting between the Dutch and local Native Americans.

A trial excerpt could support multiple-choice questions about the relationship between religious and political authority in Massachusetts Bay or about expectations for women. Strong answers point to the merging of church and government, the authority of the clergy, and limits on women's place in public religious life.

What her banishment proves about New England's colonies

Massachusetts Bay expelled Hutchinson because its leaders believed the colony couldn't survive religious disagreement. That makes her useful evidence in Unit 2 (Colonial Society, 1607-1754), especially for Topic 2.3: The Regions of British Colonies, which asks why New England developed differently from the Chesapeake and the middle colonies, and for Topic 2.7: Colonial Society and Culture, which traces growing religious diversity and independence.

For Topic 2.3, she shows that Puritan towns were built around religious unity. Winthrop described the colony as a "city upon a hill," a godly model for the world, and leaders saw dissent as a danger to that mission. Compare that with the middle colonies, whose mix of European migrants produced more religious tolerance. Within New England, Rhode Island grew partly from exiles like Hutchinson, so dissent spread the region's religious variety even as Massachusetts tried to suppress it.

For Topic 2.7, she fits the course's argument that colonial religion became more varied and independent over time, which later fed resistance to outside authority. The ministers' fear was that a believer who claimed direct access to God no longer needed them.

Her case also works on the long essay question, in prompts about religious freedom or women's roles in the colonies. A top answer uses the specifics: ordered banished in 1637 for challenging clerical authority, she shows that Puritans wanted religious freedom for their own faith and didn't extend it to dissenters. She falls before 1754, so she can't anchor the document-based question, though she can appear as background in a short-answer response about colonial religion.

Hutchinson or Roger Williams: telling the two exiles apart

Both were driven out of Massachusetts Bay in the 1630s, and both ended up in Rhode Island, so answers often swap them.

Roger Williams was a minister banished in 1635. He argued that government shouldn't enforce religious rules and that colonists should pay Native Americans for land, and he founded Providence in 1636. Hutchinson was a layperson and a woman, and her offense centered on salvation and on claiming God spoke to her directly.

One way to sort them is by their arguments. Williams challenged how the colony's government handled religion. Hutchinson challenged the ministers' authority over what salvation required. Her gender also mattered. A woman teaching theology to mixed groups and criticizing male ministers broke Puritan social expectations as well as religious ones.

Where this sits in APUSH

Keep studying APUSH Unit 2