The sourcing point requires you to explain how or why the point of view, purpose, historical situation, or audience of at least two documents is relevant to an argument. You must go beyond identifying the HIPP element: you need to explain what effect it has on the document's content, reliability, or meaning for your argument.
- Point of view (POV): The author's perspective shaped by their identity, position, or experience, and how that shapes what they emphasize or omit.
- Purpose: Why the document was created, such as to persuade, record, justify, or celebrate, and how that goal affects its content.
- Historical situation: The broader context in which the document was produced and how that context shaped what the author wrote.
- Audience: Who the document was intended for and how that intended readership shaped the author's choices.
- Explain, not just identify: Naming 'the author is a merchant' is not enough; you must explain how being a merchant affects what the document says or how it should be read.
For two documents in a practice set, write one sentence each that names a HIPP element and explains its effect on the document's argument or reliability.
| Identifies only (no point) | Explains effect (earns point) |
|---|
| 'The author is a European merchant, so he has a point of view.' | 'Because the author is a European merchant writing to attract investors, his emphasis on profit margins likely overstates returns to make the venture appear more appealing, which means the document reflects commercial promotion more than accurate accounting.' |