Skip to main content

New Jersey Plan in AP US Government

The New Jersey Plan was the small states' proposal at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, introduced by William Paterson, for a unicameral (one-house) Congress in which every state had an equal vote regardless of population. It also gave Congress new powers to tax and regulate trade. It was the small-state answer to the Virginia Plan's population-based representation, and the standoff between the two was settled by the Great (Connecticut) Compromise.

This definition is part of Fiveable's AP US Government review, which also has guided practice questions.

Verified for the 2027 AP US Government exam•Last updated November 2026•Fiveable Content Team

Paterson's plan set against Madison's Virginia Plan

The easiest way to keep this term straight is to hold it next to the plan it was answering. The Virginia Plan, drafted largely by James Madison and presented by Edmund Randolph, came first. The New Jersey Plan was the counteroffer.

  • Number of houses: Virginia wanted a bicameral (two-house) legislature. New Jersey wanted one house, like Congress under the Articles of Confederation.
  • Representation: Virginia tied representation in both houses to population (or wealth), which favored big states. New Jersey gave each state one equal vote, which protected small states.
  • Executive: Virginia had Congress choose a national executive. New Jersey had Congress choose a plural executive (more than one person).
  • National power: Both plans gave the national government more power than the Articles did. New Jersey added the power to tax and regulate commerce, plus a federal judiciary.

A memory hook that works: New Jersey is a small state, so its plan defends small states. Virginia was the most populous state in 1787, so its plan rewards population.

Why backing equal votes didn't make Paterson an Anti-Federalist

A common slip is lumping the New Jersey Plan in with opposition to a stronger national government. Its supporters agreed the Articles had failed. They wanted a Congress that could actually raise money and control trade. Their objection was narrower: how seats and votes would be divided.

That makes the New Jersey Plan a dispute between big states and small states. The Anti-Federalists came later, during ratification, and their fight was over whether the finished Constitution gave the national government too much power and lacked a Bill of Rights. Paterson himself signed the Constitution.

It also helps to separate the big-state/small-state split from the North/South split. The New Jersey Plan did include a three-fifths formula, but only for tax requisitions. Congress would request money from the states based on population, with enslaved people counted as three-fifths of a person.

The Three-Fifths Compromise was a separate bargain at the Convention. It applied the formula to representation in the House as well as to taxation. So if an answer choice says the New Jersey Plan settled how enslaved people would count for representation, it's mixing up the two.

How the Great Compromise gave each plan one chamber

Topic 1.5 (Ratification of the U.S. Constitution) in Unit 1 asks you to explain how bargaining at the Convention shaped the constitutional system, and the Great (Connecticut) Compromise is the clearest example. That compromise only makes sense once you know what it was splitting, which is why the New Jersey Plan matters there.

The compromise, associated with Roger Sherman of Connecticut, created a bicameral Congress. The House of Representatives took the Virginia Plan's idea, with seats based on each state's population. The Senate took the New Jersey Plan's idea, with each state represented equally. So the Virginia Plan supplied the two-house structure, and the New Jersey Plan supplied equal state representation in one of those houses.

The small states locked that win in. Article V says no state can be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate without its own consent. When you later study Congress, the fact that Wyoming and California each have two senators traces straight back to this plan.

Putting the plan to work in Concept Application and the Argument Essay

Say a stimulus describes a proposal for one legislative house where every state casts an equal vote, and the question asks which plan it reflects or which compromise resolved it. That's the New Jersey Plan, and the Great Compromise is what settled it. The wrong answer to watch for is swapping the plans: proportional representation in both houses is the Virginia Plan, and a one-house Congress with equal votes is the New Jersey Plan.

On Question 1 (Concept Application), a scenario about a dispute between large and small states, or about Senate representation, gives you room to explain how the Great Compromise balanced the two plans. A top answer names both plans, states what each demanded, and connects the outcome to how Congress represents people in one chamber and states in the other.

On Question 4 (Argument Essay), the New Jersey Plan can't stand in for the required foundational-document evidence, so you still need to cite a foundational document. It can work as additional evidence drawn from course concepts, or as part of your reasoning. For example, in an argument about whether the Constitution balanced competing interests, you can cite the text of the Constitution (Article I's two chambers, Article V's equal-suffrage protection) and use the New Jersey Plan to explain why equal Senate representation was the price of small-state support.

Where this sits in AP® Gov

Keep studying AP® Gov Unit 1