The in American business history marked a significant shift away from heavy government oversight. It aimed to promote competition, innovation, and economic growth by reducing intervention in industries like airlines, telecommunications, and financial services.
Emerging in response to economic challenges of the 1970s, deregulation gained bipartisan support. Key legislation reshaped industries, leading to increased competition and lower prices in some sectors, but also raising concerns about safety, environmental protection, and income inequality.
Origins of deregulation
Deregulation movement emerged as a response to perceived inefficiencies in the heavily regulated post-World War II American economy
Marked a significant shift in American business history, moving away from the New Deal era's emphasis on government oversight
Aimed to promote competition, innovation, and economic growth by reducing in various industries
Post-war regulatory environment
Top images from around the web for Post-war regulatory environment
Media: How are they regulated? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
National Recovery Administration logo | A scanned and cleane… | Flickr View original
, developed by James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock, critiqued government regulation as serving special interests
's work on the role of prices in conveying information influenced deregulation proponents
Key industries affected
Deregulation movement targeted industries traditionally subject to heavy government oversight and control
Aimed to introduce market forces and competition into sectors long dominated by regulated monopolies or oligopolies
Impacted multiple sectors of the American economy, reshaping business landscapes and consumer experiences
Airlines and transportation
dissolution allowed airlines to set their own routes and fares
Entry of new carriers like Southwest Airlines increased competition and lowered prices
Trucking industry deregulation through the eliminated route restrictions
Railroad deregulation via the allowed for more flexible pricing and abandonment of unprofitable lines
Telecommunications
Breakup of AT&T monopoly in 1984 created regional Bell operating companies
Allowed entry of new long-distance carriers (MCI, Sprint) into the market
of 1996 further opened local and long-distance markets to competition
Emergence of wireless communications and internet service providers reshaped the industry landscape
Financial services
Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act of 1980 phased out interest rate ceilings on bank deposits
of 1982 deregulated savings and loan associations
Gradual erosion of Glass-Steagall Act restrictions on commercial and investment banking activities
Rise of interstate banking and emergence of national financial institutions
Energy sector
began phased deregulation of natural gas prices
encouraged development of independent power producers
promoted wholesale competition in electricity markets
State-level initiatives to introduce retail competition in electricity markets
Political landscape
Deregulation gained traction across political parties as a solution to economic challenges
Shift in political ideology towards market-oriented solutions and smaller government
Bipartisan support for deregulation reflected changing attitudes towards government's role in the economy
Carter administration initiatives
President initiated deregulation efforts despite his Democratic affiliation
Appointed pro-deregulation economist Alfred Kahn to lead the Civil Aeronautics Board
Signed the of 1978, a landmark piece of deregulatory legislation
Supported natural gas deregulation and reforms in the trucking industry
Reagan's deregulatory agenda
President made deregulation a cornerstone of his economic policy
Established Task Force on Regulatory Relief to identify and eliminate unnecessary regulations
Appointed deregulation advocates to key regulatory agencies (EPA, FCC, NLRB)
Implemented Executive Order 12291, requiring cost-benefit analysis for major regulations
Bipartisan support
Democrats and Republicans found common ground on deregulation as a means to stimulate economic growth
Senator Edward Kennedy, a liberal Democrat, supported airline deregulation
Deregulation continued under subsequent administrations, including Democrats Bill Clinton and Barack Obama
Bipartisan passage of major deregulatory legislation (Telecommunications Act of 1996, Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act of 1999)
Major legislation
Key laws passed during the deregulation era fundamentally reshaped American industries
Legislation aimed to promote competition, reduce government intervention, and stimulate economic growth
Impacts of these laws continue to shape the business landscape and regulatory environment today
Airline Deregulation Act
Passed in 1978 under President Carter, phased out Civil Aeronautics Board control over routes and fares
Allowed new airlines to enter the market and existing carriers to expand or modify their routes
Resulted in increased competition, lower fares, and a hub-and-spoke system for major carriers
Led to consolidation in the industry and challenges for some legacy carriers
Staggers Rail Act
Enacted in 1980 to deregulate the railroad industry, reducing Interstate Commerce Commission oversight
Allowed railroads more flexibility in setting rates and abandoning unprofitable routes
Promoted intermodal competition between rail and trucking
Led to increased efficiency and profitability in the rail industry, but also to consolidation and reduced service to some areas
Garn-St. Germain Act
Passed in 1982 to deregulate savings and loan associations and address the thrift crisis
Allowed S&Ls to offer adjustable-rate mortgages and expand into commercial lending
Raised federal deposit insurance limits from 40,000to100,000
Contributed to the of the late 1980s and early 1990s
Telecommunications Act of 1996
First major overhaul of telecommunications law since the Communications Act of 1934
Aimed to promote competition in local telephone service and cable television markets
Relaxed media ownership rules, leading to consolidation in the broadcasting industry
Established framework for regulating internet service providers and emerging technologies
Economic impacts
Deregulation fundamentally altered the competitive landscape across multiple industries
Resulted in both intended and unintended consequences for businesses and consumers
Continues to shape debates about the appropriate balance between market forces and government oversight
Market competition vs monopolies
Deregulation aimed to break up monopolies and promote competition in previously regulated industries
Entry of new competitors in airlines, telecommunications, and energy sectors initially increased
Some industries experienced re-consolidation over time (airlines, telecommunications)
Debates continue over the effectiveness of deregulation in promoting long-term competition
Consumer prices and choices
Airline deregulation led to lower fares and increased route options for many consumers
Telecommunications deregulation resulted in lower long-distance rates and new service offerings
Energy deregulation produced mixed results, with some markets seeing lower prices and others experiencing volatility
Financial services deregulation expanded product offerings but also increased complexity and risk for consumers
Industry consolidation
Many deregulated industries experienced waves of mergers and acquisitions
Airline industry consolidated into a handful of major carriers (American, Delta, United, Southwest)
Banking sector saw the emergence of national "megabanks" through interstate mergers
Telecommunications industry witnessed vertical integration (Comcast-NBCUniversal, AT&T-Time Warner)
Critics and controversies
Deregulation faced criticism from various quarters, highlighting potential drawbacks and unintended consequences
Debates over the appropriate balance between market forces and government oversight continue to shape policy discussions
Critics argue that deregulation may have prioritized economic efficiency over other important societal values
Safety concerns
Airline deregulation raised questions about maintenance standards and pilot fatigue
Nuclear power plant deregulation sparked debates over operational safety and emergency preparedness
Trucking deregulation led to concerns about driver working hours and vehicle maintenance
Financial deregulation criticized for increasing systemic risk in the banking sector
Environmental considerations
Energy sector deregulation faced criticism for potentially prioritizing profit over environmental protection
Reduced oversight of industries like mining and manufacturing raised concerns about pollution and habitat destruction
Critics argued that market forces alone might not adequately address long-term environmental sustainability
Debates over the role of regulation in addressing climate change and promoting renewable energy
Income inequality debates
Critics argue that deregulation contributed to widening income inequality in the United States
Financial sector deregulation linked to increased executive compensation and Wall Street profits
Decline of unionization in deregulated industries associated with stagnating wages for workers
Consolidation in deregulated industries potentially reduced competition for labor and suppressed wage growth
Legacy and long-term effects
Deregulation movement fundamentally reshaped the American business landscape and regulatory approach
Long-term impacts continue to influence economic policy debates and industry structures
Legacy of deregulation remains contested, with ongoing reassessment of its costs and benefits
Industry structure changes
Shift from regulated monopolies to oligopolistic competition in many sectors
Vertical integration and conglomeration trends in media and telecommunications
Emergence of new business models and industry disruptors (low-cost airlines, fintech companies)
Blurring of traditional industry boundaries (tech companies entering financial services)
Globalization and competitiveness
Deregulation aimed to make U.S. industries more competitive in the global marketplace
Removal of barriers facilitated international expansion of American companies
Increased foreign competition in domestic markets (automobiles, electronics)
Debates over the impact of deregulation on American jobs and manufacturing base
Regulatory cycles
Pendulum swings between deregulation and re-regulation in response to economic events
Financial crisis of 2008 led to new regulations () in the banking sector
Calls for increased oversight of tech giants and social media platforms
Ongoing debates over the appropriate level of government intervention in the economy
Case studies
Examination of specific examples illustrates the complex impacts of deregulation
Case studies reveal both successes and challenges in implementing deregulatory policies
Provide insights into the long-term consequences of major regulatory changes
AT&T breakup
1984 divestiture of AT&T's local telephone service into seven regional Bell operating companies
Resulted from antitrust lawsuit and consent decree with the U.S. Department of Justice
Opened long-distance market to competition from new entrants like MCI and Sprint
Led to innovation in telecommunications services but also to industry reconsolidation
Savings and loan crisis
Deregulation of savings and loan institutions in early 1980s through Garn-St. Germain Act
S&Ls engaged in risky lending practices and speculative investments
Crisis resulted in failure of over 1,000 S&Ls and cost to taxpayers estimated at $124 billion
Led to re-regulation of the industry and creation of Resolution Trust Corporation
Airline industry transformation
Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 fundamentally changed the aviation landscape
Entry of low-cost carriers like Southwest Airlines increased competition and lowered fares
Development of hub-and-spoke system by major carriers
Industry consolidation through mergers and bankruptcies, resulting in "Big Four" carriers
Contemporary debates
Ongoing discussions about the appropriate balance between regulation and market forces
New challenges posed by technological advancements and changing economic landscapes
Reassessment of deregulation's impacts in light of recent economic crises and social concerns
Financial crisis aftermath
2008 financial crisis sparked debates over the role of deregulation in creating systemic risks
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act introduced new regulations
Ongoing discussions about the effectiveness of post-crisis reforms and calls for further changes
Debates over the appropriate level of oversight for "too big to fail" financial institutions
Net neutrality
Controversy over regulation of internet service providers to ensure equal access to content
FCC's changing stance on classifying broadband as a telecommunications service
Debates over the impact of rules on innovation and investment in broadband infrastructure
State-level efforts to implement net neutrality rules in the absence of federal regulations
Gig economy regulation
Emergence of platform-based businesses (Uber, Airbnb) challenges traditional regulatory frameworks
Debates over worker classification and labor protections in the gig economy
Local and state efforts to regulate ride-sharing and short-term rental services
Discussions about the need for new regulatory approaches to address the unique characteristics of the digital economy
Key Terms to Review (31)
Airline Deregulation Act: The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 was a significant piece of legislation that removed government control over various aspects of the airline industry, allowing market forces to dictate routes, prices, and competition. This act shifted the airline industry from a regulated monopoly system to a more competitive environment, significantly changing how airlines operated and affecting consumers and the economy.
AT&T Breakup: The AT&T Breakup refers to the 1984 antitrust divestiture of American Telephone and Telegraph Company, which ended its monopoly over telephone services in the United States. This landmark case reshaped the telecommunications industry by breaking up AT&T into seven regional companies known as 'Baby Bells,' fostering competition and innovation in the market.
Chicago School of Economics: The Chicago School of Economics refers to a collection of economic theories and practices that originated from the University of Chicago in the mid-20th century, emphasizing free-market principles, limited government intervention, and the importance of individual choice. This school of thought has significantly influenced economic policy and academic discussions, particularly during the deregulation movement in the late 20th century, advocating for less regulation and more reliance on market forces to drive economic growth.
Civil Aeronautics Board: The Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB) was a U.S. government agency established in 1938 to regulate the aviation industry, including airline routes, fares, and safety standards. It played a crucial role in managing the growth of commercial aviation until the deregulation movement began in the late 20th century, which led to its eventual dissolution in 1985.
Consumer Choice: Consumer choice refers to the decisions that individuals make regarding the purchase and use of goods and services. It plays a crucial role in shaping market demand and is influenced by factors such as preferences, income, and the prices of goods and services. In the context of deregulation, consumer choice is significantly affected as competition increases, leading to a wider array of options and potentially better prices for consumers.
Deregulation movement: The deregulation movement refers to the political and economic process that began in the late 20th century, aimed at reducing or eliminating government rules and regulations in various industries. This movement sought to promote competition, increase efficiency, and stimulate economic growth by allowing market forces to operate more freely without excessive governmental intervention. It played a significant role in reshaping sectors such as transportation, telecommunications, and finance.
Deregulatory wave: A deregulatory wave refers to a significant period during which governments reduce or eliminate regulations on industries, aiming to promote free market principles, increase competition, and foster economic growth. This movement often arises from a belief that excessive regulation stifles innovation and creates inefficiencies in the market. Deregulatory waves can impact various sectors, leading to shifts in business practices, consumer protections, and overall economic dynamics.
Dodd-Frank Act: The Dodd-Frank Act is a comprehensive piece of financial reform legislation passed in 2010 in response to the 2008 financial crisis. It aimed to increase regulation of the financial sector, enhance consumer protection, and prevent the kind of risky behavior that led to the Great Recession. This act connects to various aspects of the financial system, including the roles of key financial leaders, regulatory bodies, and broader economic strategies for recovery.
Energy Policy Act of 1992: The Energy Policy Act of 1992 was a comprehensive piece of legislation aimed at addressing energy production, conservation, and regulation in the United States. It introduced measures to encourage energy innovations, promote renewable energy sources, and enhance energy efficiency while also reflecting the growing trend towards deregulation in the energy sector.
Federal Communications Commission: The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is an independent agency of the U.S. government responsible for regulating interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite, and cable. The FCC plays a crucial role in shaping the landscape of communication technologies and policies, especially in the context of deregulation that emerged in the late 20th century, aiming to promote competition and innovation in the telecommunications sector.
Free market capitalism: Free market capitalism is an economic system where prices for goods and services are determined by open competition between privately owned businesses. In this system, the government's role is limited, allowing for minimal intervention in economic activities, which encourages innovation and efficiency through competition.
Friedrich Hayek: Friedrich Hayek was an influential Austrian economist and political philosopher known for his defense of classical liberalism and free-market capitalism. His work emphasizes the importance of individual freedom, the limitations of government intervention in the economy, and the role of knowledge in economic decision-making. Hayek's ideas were foundational to the deregulation movement, advocating for reduced government control over markets to foster innovation and economic growth.
Garn-St. Germain Depository Institutions Act: The Garn-St. Germain Depository Institutions Act is a significant piece of legislation enacted in 1982 that aimed to deregulate the banking industry and promote increased competition among financial institutions. This act allowed banks and thrift institutions to offer a wider array of financial products and services, which ultimately led to changes in how these institutions operated, fostering innovation and flexibility within the industry.
Government intervention: Government intervention refers to the actions taken by a government to influence or regulate the economy, often aimed at correcting market failures, promoting competition, or ensuring public welfare. This can include regulations, subsidies, tariffs, or even direct control of industries. Government intervention plays a crucial role in shaping the economic landscape, particularly in scenarios like deregulation movements and the management of natural monopolies.
Interstate Commerce Commission: The Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) was a regulatory agency created in 1887 to oversee and regulate the railroad industry and later expanded its authority to other modes of transportation. It aimed to ensure fair rates, eliminate discriminatory practices, and regulate the economic activities of railroads, which were vital for commerce in the growing industrial economy. The ICC played a key role in shaping the landscape of American business by addressing the concerns raised by industrial era tycoons and establishing a framework for federal regulation.
Jimmy Carter: Jimmy Carter is the 39th President of the United States, serving from 1977 to 1981, known for his focus on human rights, energy conservation, and a shift towards deregulation in various industries. His administration aimed to promote economic efficiency by reducing government control over certain sectors, which aligns with the broader deregulation movement of the late 20th century that sought to minimize federal intervention in the economy.
Market competition: Market competition refers to the rivalry among businesses to attract customers and gain market share, typically through the use of pricing strategies, product differentiation, and marketing tactics. This concept drives innovation and efficiency in the marketplace, as companies must continuously adapt to changing consumer preferences and competitive pressures. Market competition is crucial for economic growth, ensuring that consumers have access to a variety of goods and services at competitive prices.
Milton Friedman: Milton Friedman was a prominent American economist known for his influential ideas on free-market capitalism and monetary policy. His theories advocate for minimal government intervention in the economy, promoting the idea that free markets lead to economic growth and prosperity. His work on the role of money supply in controlling inflation has significantly impacted modern economic thought and policy.
Motor Carrier Act of 1980: The Motor Carrier Act of 1980 was a significant piece of legislation that deregulated the trucking industry in the United States, allowing for increased competition and lower shipping rates. This act aimed to eliminate the restrictive practices of the Interstate Commerce Commission, enabling trucking companies to set their own rates and routes without federal approval. The changes initiated by this act played a crucial role in shaping the transportation sector, making it more competitive and responsive to market demands.
Natural Gas Policy Act of 1978: The Natural Gas Policy Act of 1978 was a significant piece of legislation aimed at deregulating the natural gas industry in the United States. It sought to encourage production, enhance competition, and provide a framework for pricing natural gas to stimulate both supply and demand in a rapidly changing energy landscape. This act was pivotal during the broader deregulation movement, reflecting a shift towards reducing government intervention in the energy sector.
Neoliberalism: Neoliberalism is an economic and political ideology that emphasizes the value of free market competition, deregulation, and reduction of government intervention in the economy. It advocates for privatization of state-owned enterprises and encourages individual entrepreneurial freedom as a means to stimulate economic growth. This ideology gained prominence in the late 20th century, particularly during the deregulation movement, when it influenced policies aimed at minimizing government oversight in various industries.
Net neutrality: Net neutrality is the principle that Internet service providers (ISPs) must treat all data on the Internet equally, without discriminating or charging differently by user, content, website, platform, application, or method of communication. This concept is significant in the context of the digital landscape, where the free flow of information is essential for innovation, competition, and consumer choice. The ongoing debates around net neutrality connect it to broader themes of regulation and deregulation in communication industries, impacting how businesses and consumers interact online.
Public Choice Theory: Public choice theory is an economic theory that uses the principles of economics to analyze political behavior, focusing on how public decisions are made and the role of incentives for individuals in political processes. It suggests that politicians and government officials are motivated by personal interests, much like individuals in the marketplace, leading to outcomes that may not necessarily benefit the public. This theory helps explain the dynamics of government action, including issues related to regulation and deregulation.
Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act of 1978: The Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) of 1978 was a landmark U.S. law aimed at promoting energy conservation and facilitating the development of alternative energy sources. It encouraged states to implement new regulatory policies for electric utilities, requiring them to purchase power from qualifying facilities, which included renewable energy sources and cogeneration plants, helping to diversify the energy market during a period of energy crisis.
Regulatory capture: Regulatory capture occurs when a regulatory agency, established to act in the public interest, ends up serving the interests of the industries it is supposed to regulate. This can lead to policies that favor certain businesses, allowing them to influence regulations, which can result in a lack of accountability and the erosion of public trust. The concept is particularly relevant in discussions about the deregulation movement, where the intention was to reduce government intervention in markets, yet it can lead to situations where regulatory bodies are swayed by industry interests.
Richard Nixon: Richard Nixon was the 37th President of the United States, serving from 1969 until his resignation in 1974. His presidency is marked by significant policy shifts, including a push for deregulation in various industries, which aimed to reduce government intervention and promote free market principles.
Ronald Reagan: Ronald Reagan was the 40th President of the United States, serving from 1981 to 1989, known for his significant role in the deregulation movement that reshaped American economic policy. His administration focused on reducing government intervention in the economy, promoting free-market principles, and cutting taxes, which greatly influenced various sectors including finance, transportation, and energy. Reagan's policies aimed to foster economic growth and reduce inflation, emphasizing the belief that a less regulated market would lead to greater prosperity.
Savings and loan crisis: The savings and loan crisis was a significant financial disaster in the United States during the 1980s and early 1990s, marked by the failure of numerous savings and loan associations (S&Ls) due to deregulation, poor management, and high-risk investments. This crisis resulted in the loss of billions of dollars, necessitating a massive federal bailout and leading to major reforms in the banking industry. The crisis highlighted the consequences of deregulation in the financial sector, which allowed S&Ls to engage in riskier lending practices without sufficient oversight.
Stagflation: Stagflation is an economic condition characterized by the simultaneous occurrence of stagnant economic growth, high unemployment, and high inflation. This paradox challenges traditional economic theories that suggest inflation and unemployment are inversely related. Stagflation often results in a complex scenario where the usual tools for addressing either inflation or unemployment may not work effectively, making it a unique challenge for policymakers.
Staggers Rail Act: The Staggers Rail Act, enacted in 1980, was a significant piece of legislation that deregulated the freight rail industry in the United States. This act aimed to reduce government control over rail rates and services, allowing railroads to set their own prices and negotiate contracts without federal oversight. By promoting competition and efficiency, the Staggers Rail Act sought to revitalize the struggling rail industry and encourage investment in infrastructure.
Telecommunications Act: The Telecommunications Act of 1996 was a landmark piece of legislation that aimed to deregulate the telecommunications industry in the United States. By promoting competition among service providers and eliminating barriers to entry, the act sought to foster innovation and improve service for consumers. It marked a significant shift in communication technologies, as it allowed companies to enter the market more freely and expand their offerings across different communication platforms.