12.6 Marxist criticism
9 min read•august 21, 2024
Marxist criticism examines literature through the lens of and economic forces. It emerged from and ' theories, emphasizing how material conditions shape cultural production. This approach analyzes how texts reflect or challenge existing power structures and ideologies.
Key concepts include , , and . Marxist critics explore class representation, economic influences on narrative, and power dynamics in fiction. They aim to uncover the socioeconomic forces at work within texts and their role in shaping social consciousness.
Origins of Marxist criticism
- Marxist criticism emerged from the philosophical and economic theories of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in the 19th century
- This critical approach examines literature through the lens of class struggle, economic determinism, and
- Marxist criticism in art and literature seeks to uncover the underlying social and economic forces that shape cultural production
Marx and Engels' theories
Top images from around the web for Marx and Engels' theories
“Cartas sobre o Capital”, de Marx e Engels, é lançado pela | Geral View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Marx and Engels.jpg - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
“Cartas sobre o Capital”, de Marx e Engels, é lançado pela | Geral View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Marx and Engels.jpg - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Marx and Engels' theories
“Cartas sobre o Capital”, de Marx e Engels, é lançado pela | Geral View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Marx and Engels.jpg - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Pyramid of Capitalist System - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
“Cartas sobre o Capital”, de Marx e Engels, é lançado pela | Geral View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Marx and Engels.jpg - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Developed a materialist conception of history emphasizing economic factors as primary drivers of social change
- Argued that the mode of production in material life determines the general character of social, political, and intellectual processes
- Introduced the concept of class struggle as the engine of historical development
- Critiqued capitalism as an exploitative system that alienates workers from their labor and its products
Historical materialism
- Philosophical framework that interprets history as a series of economic and material developments
- Posits that changes in the economic base of society lead to transformations in social and cultural superstructures
- Applies this perspective to analyze how economic conditions influence literary production and themes
- Examines how literature reflects and sometimes challenges the dominant mode of production
Class struggle in literature
- Analyzes how literary works represent conflicts between social classes (proletariat vs bourgeoisie)
- Investigates the ways authors portray working-class experiences and struggles
- Examines how literature can reinforce or subvert existing class hierarchies
- Explores the role of literature in raising class consciousness and promoting social change
Key concepts in Marxist criticism
- Marxist criticism employs a set of analytical tools to interpret literature within its socio-economic context
- This approach views literary works as products of their historical and material conditions
- Marxist critics aim to reveal the hidden ideological assumptions and power structures in texts
Base and superstructure
- Base refers to the economic foundation of society, including means of production and relations of production
- Superstructure encompasses social, political, and cultural institutions built upon the economic base
- Literature is seen as part of the superstructure, influenced by and sometimes influencing the economic base
- Critics examine how literary works reflect or challenge the relationship between base and superstructure
Ideology and hegemony
- Ideology defined as the system of ideas and beliefs that shape social consciousness
- describes the dominance of one social group over others through cultural means
- Analyzes how literature perpetuates or resists dominant ideologies
- Examines the role of cultural institutions (publishing, education) in maintaining hegemonic control
Alienation in art
- Concept of alienation applied to artistic production and consumption
- Explores how capitalist modes of production can alienate artists from their creative work
- Examines the of art and its impact on artistic expression
- Investigates how literature can either reinforce or challenge feelings of alienation in society
Marxist analysis of literature
- Marxist literary analysis focuses on uncovering the social and economic forces at work within texts
- This approach examines how literature reflects, reinforces, or challenges existing power structures
- Marxist critics aim to reveal the ideological underpinnings of literary works and their role in shaping social consciousness
Class representation in texts
- Analyzes how different social classes are portrayed in literary works
- Examines the author's class background and its influence on their writing
- Investigates stereotypes and biases in the depiction of working-class characters
- Explores how narrative perspective can privilege certain class viewpoints over others
Economic influences on narrative
- Studies how economic conditions of the time period shape plot, setting, and character development
- Examines the role of money, property, and labor in driving narrative conflicts
- Analyzes how economic systems (feudalism, capitalism) are represented or critiqued in literature
- Investigates the impact of economic crises or transitions on literary themes and forms
Power dynamics in fiction
- Explores how power relationships between characters reflect broader social hierarchies
- Examines the ways in which characters resist or conform to existing power structures
- Analyzes the role of institutions (family, church, state) in maintaining or challenging power dynamics
- Investigates how narrative resolution often reinforces or subverts dominant power relations
Prominent Marxist critics
- Marxist literary criticism has been shaped by numerous influential thinkers and scholars
- These critics have developed and refined Marxist approaches to literature over time
- Their work has had a significant impact on literary theory and cultural studies
Georg Lukács
- Hungarian Marxist philosopher and literary critic active in the early 20th century
- Developed the concept of "typicality" in literature, emphasizing characters who embody historical forces
- Argued for the importance of realism in depicting social totality and class consciousness
- Critiqued modernist literature for its focus on subjective experience over social reality
Walter Benjamin
- German-Jewish philosopher and cultural critic associated with the Frankfurt School
- Explored the impact of mechanical reproduction on art and literature in the modern age
- Developed the concept of the "aura" of original artworks and its loss in mass reproduction
- Analyzed how new media forms (film, photography) transform artistic production and reception
Fredric Jameson
- American literary critic and Marxist political theorist
- Developed the concept of "cognitive mapping" to understand cultural productions in late capitalism
- Analyzed postmodernism as the cultural logic of late capitalism
- Explored the relationship between utopian impulses and ideological constraints in literature
Marxist approach to literary genres
- Marxist criticism examines how different literary genres reflect and engage with social and economic realities
- This approach analyzes the historical development of genres in relation to changing modes of production
- Marxist critics explore how genres can reinforce or challenge dominant ideologies
Proletarian literature
- Focuses on literature written by or about the working class
- Examines themes of labor struggles, class consciousness, and social revolution
- Analyzes the use of realist techniques to depict working-class experiences
- Explores the tension between political message and artistic form in proletarian works
Socialist realism
- Official artistic doctrine of the Soviet Union from the 1930s to 1980s
- Emphasizes positive depictions of communist values and working-class heroes
- Analyzes the use of idealized characters and situations to promote socialist ideology
- Examines the impact of state control on artistic expression and innovation
Bourgeois vs working-class narratives
- Compares and contrasts literary works from different class perspectives
- Analyzes how bourgeois literature often naturalizes capitalist social relations
- Examines working-class narratives that challenge dominant social and economic structures
- Explores the role of class consciousness in shaping narrative form and content
Critique of capitalist culture
- Marxist criticism offers a systematic critique of cultural production under capitalism
- This approach examines how economic structures shape artistic creation and consumption
- Marxist critics analyze the ways in which capitalist ideology permeates cultural forms
Commodification of art
- Examines how art becomes a commodity to be bought and sold in capitalist markets
- Analyzes the impact of market forces on artistic production and valuation
- Explores the tension between art's use value and exchange value
- Investigates how commodification affects the social function and meaning of art
Mass culture vs high culture
- Critiques the division between "high" and "low" cultural forms
- Examines how class distinctions are reinforced through cultural consumption
- Analyzes the role of mass media in shaping cultural tastes and values
- Explores the potential for popular culture to challenge or reinforce dominant ideologies
Literature as social commentary
- Examines how literary works critique or reflect social and economic conditions
- Analyzes the use of , , and other literary devices to comment on society
- Explores the role of literature in raising social consciousness and promoting change
- Investigates the limitations and possibilities of literature as a form of social critique
Marxism and postcolonial literature
- Marxist criticism intersects with postcolonial studies to examine literature in the context of global capitalism and imperialism
- This approach analyzes how colonial and neocolonial power structures shape literary production and reception
- Marxist postcolonial critics explore the relationship between economic and cultural domination
Imperialism in texts
- Examines representations of colonial and imperial power in literature
- Analyzes how texts reinforce or challenge imperialist ideologies
- Explores the economic motivations behind colonial expansion as depicted in literature
- Investigates the role of literature in justifying or critiquing imperial projects
Subaltern voices
- Focuses on literary representations of marginalized groups in colonial and postcolonial contexts
- Examines how subaltern characters challenge dominant narratives and power structures
- Analyzes the difficulties of representing subaltern experiences in literature
- Explores the role of language and translation in mediating subaltern voices
Cultural hegemony in world literature
- Examines how Western cultural forms and values dominate global literary production
- Analyzes the impact of global publishing industries on non-Western literatures
- Explores resistance to cultural hegemony through alternative literary forms and languages
- Investigates the role of world literature in reinforcing or challenging global power dynamics
Feminist intersections with Marxism
- Marxist feminist criticism combines class analysis with gender critique to examine literature
- This approach explores how patriarchal and capitalist structures intersect in shaping women's experiences
- Marxist feminist critics analyze the relationship between economic exploitation and gender oppression in texts
Socialist feminism in literature
- Examines literary works that combine feminist and socialist perspectives
- Analyzes representations of women's labor and class struggles in fiction
- Explores the role of literature in promoting both gender and economic equality
- Investigates the tensions between feminist and socialist goals in literary texts
Gender and class analysis
- Examines how gender and class identities intersect in literary characters and narratives
- Analyzes the different experiences of working-class and bourgeois women in literature
- Explores how gender roles are shaped by economic conditions and vice versa
- Investigates the ways in which literature can reinforce or challenge gender and class hierarchies
Domestic labor in fiction
- Examines representations of unpaid domestic work in literary texts
- Analyzes how literature portrays the economic value and social importance of domestic labor
- Explores the gendered division of labor in fictional households
- Investigates how domestic settings can serve as microcosms for broader social and economic conflicts
Marxist criticism in contemporary context
- Marxist literary criticism continues to evolve in response to changing global economic and social conditions
- This approach examines how contemporary literature engages with late capitalism, globalization, and technological change
- Marxist critics explore new forms of cultural production and consumption in the digital age
Globalization and literature
- Examines how global economic processes are represented in contemporary fiction
- Analyzes the impact of transnational corporations and free trade on literary themes and forms
- Explores the concept of "world literature" in the context of global capitalism
- Investigates how literature can challenge or reinforce narratives of globalization
Neoliberalism in modern texts
- Examines literary representations of neoliberal economic policies and their social impacts
- Analyzes how contemporary fiction engages with themes of privatization, deregulation, and individualism
- Explores the role of literature in critiquing or normalizing neoliberal ideologies
- Investigates how neoliberal values shape character development and narrative structures
Digital age and Marxist theory
- Examines how digital technologies transform literary production, distribution, and consumption
- Analyzes the impact of social media and online platforms on contemporary literature
- Explores new forms of collective authorship and reader participation in digital contexts
- Investigates how Marxist concepts can be applied to understand digital labor and virtual economies in literature
Limitations and criticisms
- Marxist literary criticism has faced various challenges and critiques from other theoretical perspectives
- Critics have pointed out potential limitations in the Marxist approach to literature
- These debates have led to refinements and new developments in Marxist literary theory
Reductionism in Marxist analysis
- Addresses the criticism that Marxist approaches can oversimplify complex literary works
- Examines the tension between economic determinism and artistic autonomy
- Explores ways to balance social analysis with attention to formal and aesthetic elements
- Investigates how Marxist critics have responded to charges of reductionism in their work
Aesthetic value vs social content
- Examines the debate over the relative importance of artistic form and social message
- Analyzes how Marxist critics have approached works of high artistic merit but conservative politics
- Explores the concept of "commitment" in literature and its relationship to aesthetic value
- Investigates how Marxist criticism can engage with both formal innovation and social critique
Post-Marxist approaches
- Examines how post-structuralist and postmodern theories have influenced Marxist literary criticism
- Analyzes the concept of "post-Marxism" and its relationship to traditional Marxist approaches
- Explores new theoretical syntheses that combine Marxist insights with other critical perspectives
- Investigates how contemporary Marxist critics engage with issues of identity, difference, and cultural pluralism
Key Terms to Review (21)
Alienation: Alienation refers to a state of disconnection or estrangement from oneself, others, or society. It highlights feelings of isolation and lack of belonging, often experienced as a result of modern life's complexities and societal changes. This term resonates through various cultural expressions, reflecting how individuals navigate their roles within the broader social fabric.
Allegory: Allegory is a narrative technique in which characters, events, and details represent abstract ideas or moral qualities, often conveying deeper meanings and moral lessons. This method allows writers to explore complex themes in a more relatable way by using symbolic figures and actions, making it a powerful tool across various forms of literature and art.
Base and Superstructure: Base and superstructure is a key concept in Marxist theory that describes the relationship between the economic foundation of society (the base) and its cultural, political, and ideological aspects (the superstructure). The base consists of the forces and relations of production, while the superstructure encompasses institutions like law, politics, and art, which are shaped by the economic base. This relationship is crucial for understanding how societal change occurs, as shifts in the base can lead to changes in the superstructure.
Class struggle: Class struggle refers to the conflict of interests between different social classes, primarily between the working class and the ruling class, which shapes society and drives historical change. This concept highlights how economic disparities lead to tensions and conflicts that can influence social, political, and economic structures. It emphasizes the ongoing battle for resources, rights, and power, often leading to revolutionary movements or reforms.
Commodification: Commodification is the process of turning goods, services, ideas, or even people into items that can be bought and sold in a market. This transformation often involves stripping away unique qualities and values, reducing them to their economic worth. Commodification highlights the relationship between culture and capitalism, showing how societal values can become intertwined with market dynamics.
Das Kapital: Das Kapital is a foundational text in Marxist theory written by Karl Marx, focusing on the critique of political economy and the capitalist system. The work examines how capitalism operates, including the relationship between labor and capital, the exploitation of workers, and the dynamics of commodity production. It plays a crucial role in understanding class struggle and economic inequality within capitalist societies.
Engels: Friedrich Engels was a German philosopher, social scientist, and co-founder of Marxist theory alongside Karl Marx. His work laid the foundation for many concepts within Marxist criticism, particularly in analyzing the effects of capitalism on society and advocating for socialist ideas. Engels provided essential insights into class struggle and the importance of material conditions in shaping human experience, which remain central to understanding Marxist critique in literature and culture.
Exploitation: Exploitation refers to the unfair or unethical use of individuals, resources, or systems for personal gain, often at the expense of others. This concept is especially relevant in understanding how labor and capital dynamics operate within economic systems, where the imbalance of power can lead to the oppression of workers and communities. The ramifications of exploitation can be seen in various forms, including social inequality and economic injustice.
Fredric Jameson: Fredric Jameson is a prominent Marxist literary critic and theorist known for his analysis of contemporary culture and its relationship to capitalism. He emphasizes the ways that cultural products reflect and are shaped by economic conditions, advocating for a critical understanding of culture through a Marxist lens. His work often critiques postmodernism, arguing that it represents a specific cultural logic of late capitalism.
Georg Lukács: Georg Lukács was a Hungarian Marxist philosopher and literary critic, known for his influential ideas on realism, historical materialism, and the role of class consciousness in literature. His works emphasize the importance of social context in shaping literary narratives and critique the capitalist society's impact on culture. By applying Marxist theory to literature, he sought to reveal the underlying socio-economic forces that inform artistic expression.
Hegemony: Hegemony refers to the dominance of one group over others, often exercised through cultural, ideological, or political means. This concept is crucial in understanding how power structures maintain control, influencing societal norms and values to create a consensus that benefits the dominant group while marginalizing others.
Historical materialism: Historical materialism is a Marxist framework for understanding societal development that emphasizes the role of material conditions, such as economic factors and class relations, in shaping history. It argues that the organization of society is primarily influenced by the means of production and the relationships between different social classes, leading to the idea that human history is driven by economic and material forces rather than ideas or culture alone.
Ideology: Ideology refers to a set of beliefs, values, and ideas that shape how individuals and groups perceive the world and their place in it. These frameworks influence social, political, and cultural perspectives, often guiding actions and policies. Ideologies are critical in understanding conflicts, societal structures, and movements throughout history, as they provide a lens through which people interpret reality and their roles within it.
Interpretive community: An interpretive community is a group of people who share common values, beliefs, and practices that influence how they understand and interpret texts or artworks. This concept emphasizes that meaning is not solely derived from the text itself but is shaped by the experiences and perspectives of the community engaging with it. Interpretive communities highlight the social nature of interpretation, suggesting that context, culture, and shared knowledge play critical roles in the reading process.
Marx: Marx refers to Karl Marx, a 19th-century philosopher, economist, and revolutionary socialist whose ideas laid the foundation for Marxist criticism. His theories focus on the struggles between classes, particularly the conflict between the bourgeoisie (capitalist class) and the proletariat (working class). Marx's work is essential for understanding how economic structures influence social relations and cultural production.
Proletarian literature: Proletarian literature refers to a body of literary works that focus on the experiences, struggles, and aspirations of the working class. This genre seeks to amplify the voices of ordinary people and often serves as a critique of capitalist society, highlighting class struggle and advocating for social change. It connects deeply with Marxist principles by portraying the impact of economic systems on individuals and communities.
Reader-response theory: Reader-response theory is a literary approach that emphasizes the reader's role in creating meaning from a text. It suggests that a reader's personal experiences, emotions, and interpretations play a crucial part in understanding literature, making the reading experience unique for each individual. This perspective shifts the focus from the author’s intentions or the text itself to the active engagement of readers with the work, highlighting how their backgrounds and contexts influence their interpretations.
Satire: Satire is a genre of literature and art that uses humor, irony, exaggeration, or ridicule to criticize or mock societal norms, individuals, or institutions. It often aims to provoke thought and inspire change by exposing flaws and contradictions within society. Through its clever use of wit and irony, satire has been a powerful tool for commentary throughout history, making it relevant across various literary forms and movements.
Social realism: Social realism is an artistic and literary movement that emerged in the early 20th century, focusing on depicting everyday life and the struggles of ordinary people, particularly in relation to social issues and injustices. This movement often highlights the plight of the working class and critiques societal norms, aiming to provoke thought and inspire change. By capturing the realities of life for marginalized groups, social realism connects deeply with the themes of empathy, community, and social justice.
The Communist Manifesto: The Communist Manifesto is a political pamphlet written by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, published in 1848, which outlines the principles of communism and critiques capitalism. It calls for the working class to unite against the bourgeoisie and emphasizes the idea that all history is the history of class struggles, aiming to inspire revolutionary action for a classless society.
Walter Benjamin: Walter Benjamin was a German-Jewish philosopher, cultural critic, and essayist known for his contributions to aesthetics, literary theory, and Marxist thought. His work emphasizes the relationship between art and society, exploring how the conditions of capitalism affect culture and the perception of art. Benjamin's ideas challenge traditional notions of originality and authorship, making him a crucial figure in understanding the intersection of Marxism and cultural criticism.