🥸Ethics Unit 7 – Moral Dilemmas and Ethical Reasoning

Key Ethical Concepts

• Ethics involves the study of moral principles, values, and standards that guide human behavior and decision-making
• Morality refers to the set of beliefs, principles, and values that distinguish right from wrong and good from bad
• Ethical dilemmas arise when there is a conflict between two or more moral principles or values, requiring a choice between them
• Consequentialism focuses on the outcomes or consequences of actions, judging them based on the greatest good for the greatest number (utilitarianism)
• Deontology emphasizes the inherent rightness or wrongness of actions based on moral rules or duties, regardless of consequences (Kantian ethics)
• Virtue ethics concentrates on the moral character of the individual, promoting the cultivation of virtues such as courage, temperance, and justice
• Moral relativism holds that moral judgments are relative to cultural or individual perspectives, while moral absolutism asserts universal moral truths
• Ethical egoism prioritizes self-interest as the basis for moral decision-making, while altruism emphasizes concern for the welfare of others

Moral Theories and Frameworks

• Utilitarianism, developed by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, seeks to maximize overall happiness and minimize suffering for the greatest number of people
  • Act utilitarianism evaluates the morality of individual actions based on their consequences
  • Rule utilitarianism judges the morality of rules or principles based on their overall utility if universally followed
• Kantian deontology, based on the work of Immanuel Kant, focuses on the categorical imperative—acting only according to rules that could become universal laws
  • Kant emphasized the importance of moral duty and respect for persons as ends in themselves, never merely as means
• Aristotelian virtue ethics emphasizes the development of moral character through the cultivation of virtues such as courage, temperance, justice, and practical wisdom
• Care ethics, associated with the work of Carol Gilligan, prioritizes empathy, compassion, and attentiveness to the needs of others in moral decision-making
• Social contract theory, developed by philosophers such as Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, sees morality as derived from a hypothetical agreement among individuals to establish a cooperative society
• Ethical pluralism recognizes the validity of multiple moral frameworks and the need to balance and reconcile them in addressing complex ethical issues

Types of Moral Dilemmas

• Personal moral dilemmas involve conflicts between an individual's moral values and their self-interest or personal relationships (deciding whether to lie to protect a friend)
• Professional ethical dilemmas arise when the duties and responsibilities of a profession conflict with personal moral beliefs (a doctor's duty to provide medical care vs. religious objections)
• Societal moral dilemmas occur when there are competing moral claims or values at the level of social policy or law (balancing individual liberty with public safety)
• Trolley problems, such as the classic "switch" and "footbridge" scenarios, illustrate the tension between utilitarian and deontological approaches to moral decision-making
• Moral luck dilemmas highlight the role of chance or circumstance in moral judgments (two equally reckless drivers, one causing an accident and the other not)
• Moral uncertainty dilemmas involve situations where the morally correct course of action is unclear or ambiguous due to incomplete information or conflicting moral principles
• Tragic moral dilemmas present situations where all available courses of action involve moral wrongdoing or harm, requiring a choice between "lesser evils" (Sophie's Choice)

Ethical Reasoning Process

• Identify the ethical issue or dilemma, clarifying the moral principles, values, or duties in conflict
• Gather relevant facts and information about the situation, including the stakeholders involved and potential consequences of different courses of action
• Evaluate the ethical dilemma using one or more moral theories or frameworks, considering their implications and limitations
  • Apply consequentialist, deontological, virtue-based, or other approaches to assess the morality of available options
• Consider alternative perspectives and viewpoints, including those of different stakeholders and moral frameworks, to gain a more comprehensive understanding
• Make a reasoned judgment or decision based on the analysis, providing a justification for the chosen course of action
  • Acknowledge the moral residue or lingering doubts and regrets that may accompany the decision
• Reflect on the decision and its outcomes, learning from the experience and refining one's ethical reasoning skills for future dilemmas
• Engage in moral dialogue and deliberation with others to test and refine one's reasoning, remaining open to new information and perspectives

Case Studies and Real-World Examples

• The Heinz dilemma, a classic example from Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development, involves a man's decision to steal a drug to save his dying wife
• The Ford Pinto case illustrates the ethical dilemmas faced by businesses in balancing cost, safety, and legal liability in product design and manufacturing
• The Challenger space shuttle disaster raises questions about the ethics of risk assessment, informed consent, and organizational decision-making under pressure
• The Tuskegee syphilis experiment highlights the importance of informed consent, respect for persons, and the ethical conduct of medical research
• The Enron scandal demonstrates the consequences of corporate ethical failures, including deceptive accounting practices and conflicts of interest
• The use of drone strikes in military operations raises ethical concerns about the use of force, civilian casualties, and the moral responsibility of remote operators
• The allocation of scarce medical resources during a pandemic, such as ventilators or vaccines, presents moral dilemmas of distributive justice and triage
• The development and deployment of artificial intelligence systems raises ethical questions about bias, transparency, accountability, and the alignment of AI with human values

Critiques and Limitations

• Moral theories and frameworks may oversimplify the complexity of real-world ethical dilemmas, failing to capture the nuances and context-dependent factors involved
• The abstract and hypothetical nature of some moral dilemmas, such as trolley problems, may limit their applicability to actual decision-making contexts
• Moral theories can lead to conflicting or counterintuitive conclusions when applied to specific cases, requiring judgment and balance in their application
• The emphasis on individual moral reasoning may neglect the role of social, cultural, and institutional factors in shaping moral beliefs and behaviors
• Ethical reasoning processes may be subject to cognitive biases, emotional influences, and limitations in human rationality and decision-making capacities
• The reliance on moral intuitions or "common sense" in ethical reasoning can lead to inconsistencies or failures to critically examine one's assumptions
• The diversity of moral frameworks and cultural values can make it challenging to reach consensus or resolve ethical disagreements in pluralistic societies
• The abstract nature of some moral principles, such as the categorical imperative, may provide limited practical guidance in navigating real-world ethical complexities

Practical Applications

• Developing ethical codes of conduct and decision-making frameworks for professionals in fields such as medicine, law, engineering, and business
• Incorporating ethical reasoning and case-based learning into educational curricula to foster moral development and critical thinking skills
• Establishing institutional review boards (IRBs) and ethical guidelines for research involving human subjects to ensure respect for persons and beneficence
• Promoting ethical leadership and organizational cultures that prioritize integrity, transparency, and social responsibility in decision-making processes
• Engaging in public discourse and deliberation on ethical issues to build mutual understanding and inform policy decisions on topics such as bioethics, environmental ethics, and technology ethics
• Applying ethical principles and frameworks to the design and development of emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence, to align them with human values and mitigate potential risks
• Integrating ethical considerations into risk assessment and management processes to balance competing values and stakeholder interests in fields such as public health and safety
• Fostering ethical consumerism and corporate social responsibility initiatives to align business practices with moral values and promote positive social and environmental impact

Further Reading and Resources

• "The Nicomachean Ethics" by Aristotle, a foundational text in virtue ethics that explores the nature of moral character and the cultivation of practical wisdom
• "Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals" by Immanuel Kant, which presents the core arguments for Kantian deontology and the categorical imperative
• "Utilitarianism" by John Stuart Mill, a classic defense of the utilitarian approach to moral philosophy and its application to social and political issues
• "The Moral Limits of Markets" by Michael J. Sandel, which examines the ethical implications of extending market logic to various domains of life, such as health care, education, and human organs
• "The Trolley Problem" by Judith Jarvis Thomson, a seminal article that introduces and analyzes the famous thought experiment in moral philosophy
• "The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks" by Rebecca Skloot, a non-fiction book that explores the ethical issues surrounding informed consent and the use of human tissues in medical research
• The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (https://plato.stanford.edu/), an online resource that provides in-depth articles on various topics in moral philosophy and applied ethics
• The Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University (https://www.scu.edu/ethics/), which offers case studies, articles, and resources on ethical decision-making in various professional and societal contexts