Usability Heuristics

Why This Matters

Jakob Nielsen's 10 usability heuristics aren't just a checklist—they're the foundation of every design critique, portfolio review, and user testing analysis you'll encounter. When you're asked to evaluate an interface or justify a design decision, these principles give you the vocabulary and framework to articulate why something works or fails. You're being tested on your ability to identify which heuristic applies to a given scenario and explain how it improves (or harms) the user experience.

Think of these heuristics as falling into three core categories: keeping users informed, giving users power, and reducing cognitive burden. Don't just memorize the names—know what problem each heuristic solves and be ready to apply them to real interfaces. When a design critique asks "what would you change?", these are your go-to diagnostic tools.

---

Keeping Users Informed

Users should never have to guess what's happening. These heuristics ensure the system communicates clearly and speaks the user's language.

Visibility of System Status

• Real-time feedback—users must always know what the system is doing, whether it's loading, saving, or processing
• Progress indicators like loading bars, spinners, and percentage counters reduce anxiety during wait times
• Confirmation messages after actions (form submitted, item added to cart) close the feedback loop and build trust

Match Between System and the Real World

• Familiar language means using words your users actually say, not internal jargon or technical terms
• Real-world metaphors like folders, trash cans, and shopping carts leverage existing mental models
• Logical organization follows conventions users expect—newest first, alphabetical order, or spatial layouts that mirror physical experiences

---

Giving Users Power and Control

Great interfaces don't trap users—they empower them to explore confidently, knowing they can always recover from mistakes.

User Control and Freedom

• Undo and redo functionality lets users experiment without fear of permanent consequences
• Clear exit points like cancel buttons and back navigation prevent users from feeling stuck
• Customization options respect that different users have different workflows and preferences

Error Prevention

• Constraints and guardrails make it physically impossible to enter invalid data (date pickers, dropdown menus)
• Confirmation dialogs for destructive actions ("Are you sure you want to delete?") catch mistakes before they happen
• Smart defaults and inline validation guide users toward correct input before submission

Help Users Recognize, Diagnose, and Recover from Errors

• Plain-language error messages explain what went wrong without technical codes or blame
• Specific solutions tell users exactly how to fix the problem, not just that one exists
• Visual highlighting draws attention to the error location so users don't have to hunt for it

---

Reducing Cognitive Load

Users have limited mental bandwidth. These heuristics minimize the thinking required to use an interface effectively.

Recognition Rather Than Recall

• Visible options mean users select from what they see rather than remembering commands or paths
• Recognizable icons with labels reduce guesswork—don't rely on icons alone for critical actions
• Consistent patterns let users transfer knowledge from one part of the interface to another

Consistency and Standards

• Internal consistency means the same action looks and works the same way throughout your product
• External consistency follows platform conventions—iOS apps should feel like iOS apps
• Predictable outcomes ensure that clicking similar-looking buttons produces similar results

---

Optimizing for Different Users

Not all users are the same. These heuristics ensure interfaces work for beginners and experts alike while remaining clean and supportive.

Flexibility and Efficiency of Use

• Keyboard shortcuts and accelerators let expert users bypass menus and work faster
• Multiple pathways to the same goal accommodate different mental models and skill levels
• Customizable interfaces allow users to hide features they don't need and surface ones they use constantly

Aesthetic and Minimalist Design

• Visual hierarchy uses size, color, and spacing to direct attention to what matters most
• Ruthless editing removes every element that doesn't serve a clear purpose—every pixel must earn its place
• White space isn't wasted space; it reduces visual noise and improves scanability

Help and Documentation

• Searchable help systems let users find answers without reading entire manuals
• Context-sensitive assistance appears when and where users need it, not buried in a help menu
• Visual examples and tutorials demonstrate rather than just describe, especially for complex features

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. A user accidentally deletes an important file and can't get it back. Which two heuristics failed, and how would you fix each?

2. You're reviewing an app that uses a unique icon system with no labels. Which heuristic does this violate, and what's the underlying principle?

3. Compare and contrast Error Prevention and Help Users Recover from Errors—when would you prioritize one over the other in your design?

4. A form shows "Error 4032" when users enter invalid data. Identify the violated heuristic and rewrite the message to comply with best practices.

5. An expert user complains that an interface is "too slow" even though it loads quickly. Which heuristic likely needs attention, and what features might you add?