Why This Matters
Understanding rhetorical devices isn't just about identifying techniques in ads—it's about recognizing how persuasion actually works. In Communication and Popular Culture, you're being tested on your ability to analyze media messages critically, which means understanding the mechanisms of influence, audience psychology, and the relationship between form and meaning. These devices show up everywhere: political campaigns, social media marketing, public health messaging, and brand storytelling.
When you encounter an advertisement on an exam, you need to do more than name the device. You need to explain why that technique works on audiences and what cultural values it taps into. Don't just memorize definitions—know what psychological or logical principle each device exploits and be ready to analyze how multiple devices work together in a single message.
The Classical Appeals: Aristotle's Persuasion Triangle
These three appeals form the foundation of all persuasive communication. Aristotle identified them over 2,000 years ago, and advertisers still rely on them because they target the three ways humans process arguments: through trust, emotion, and reason.
Ethos (Appeal to Credibility)
- Establishes trust through source authority—brands leverage their reputation, history, or expertise to make claims believable
- Celebrity and expert endorsements transfer credibility from a trusted figure to the product (this is why athletes sell sneakers and doctors sell toothpaste)
- Transparency and ethical positioning increasingly matter to audiences who research brands before purchasing
Pathos (Appeal to Emotion)
- Targets feelings to bypass rational resistance—emotional responses happen faster than logical analysis
- Storytelling and imagery create identification with characters or situations, making the audience feel the message
- Specific emotions serve different goals: fear motivates immediate action, nostalgia builds brand loyalty, happiness creates positive associations
Logos (Appeal to Logic)
- Uses evidence to build rational arguments—statistics, research findings, and factual claims give audiences "permission" to buy
- Cause-and-effect reasoning shows how the product solves a problem ("clinically proven to reduce wrinkles by 40%")
- Comparisons and demonstrations provide concrete proof that audiences can evaluate and verify
Compare: Pathos vs. Logos—both aim to persuade, but pathos works through feeling while logos works through thinking. On FRQs, note that effective ads often combine both: an emotional hook grabs attention, then logical evidence closes the sale.
Language Manipulation: How Words Shape Perception
These devices exploit the sonic and semantic properties of language itself—they work because our brains process rhythm, repetition, and word choice in ways that bypass critical thinking.
Repetition
- Reinforces messages through strategic redundancy—hearing something multiple times increases both recall and perceived truth
- Creates rhythm and structure that makes slogans feel inevitable ("Maybe she's born with it. Maybe it's Maybelline.")
- The "illusory truth effect" means repeated claims feel more credible, even without evidence
Alliteration
- Repeating initial consonant sounds creates phonetic patterns that stick in memory ("Best Buy," "Coca-Cola," "PayPal")
- Adds playfulness and polish that signals brand sophistication and intentionality
- Enhances brand recall because alliterative phrases are cognitively easier to process and remember
Loaded Language
- Emotionally charged word choices shape perception before audiences consciously evaluate claims
- Connotation matters more than denotation—"natural" and "chemical-free" trigger positive responses regardless of accuracy
- Creates implicit arguments without making explicit claims that could be challenged or regulated
Compare: Repetition vs. Alliteration—both enhance memorability, but repetition works through frequency while alliteration works through sound patterns. Repetition is about what you say; alliteration is about how it sounds.
Figurative Language: Creating Mental Images
Figurative devices work by activating the audience's imagination—they make abstract benefits concrete and create emotional resonance through vivid mental pictures.
- Compares unlike things to transfer meaning—"Red Bull gives you wings" doesn't promise flight but suggests freedom and energy
- Simplifies complex value propositions by connecting unfamiliar products to familiar experiences
- Creates implicit arguments that feel discovered rather than imposed, increasing persuasive impact
Hyperbole
- Deliberate exaggeration signals enthusiasm rather than literal claims ("The best coffee in the world")
- Captures attention through surprise and can add humor that increases likability
- Establishes category dominance by positioning products as exceptional rather than merely adequate
Personification
- Gives human traits to products or brands—the Geico gecko, the M&M characters, Siri's personality
- Creates emotional relationships with inanimate objects, making brands feel like companions
- Brand mascots leverage personification to build long-term recognition and affection
Compare: Metaphor vs. Personification—metaphor compares the product to something else, while personification makes the product become something relatable. Both create emotional connections, but personification specifically humanizes the brand.
Social Proof: Leveraging Group Psychology
These devices exploit our fundamental need for social belonging and validation—humans are wired to look to others when making decisions, especially under uncertainty.
Bandwagon
- Appeals to conformity and belonging—"Join millions of satisfied customers" suggests safety in numbers
- FOMO (fear of missing out) drives action by implying exclusion from a desirable group
- Works because social proof reduces perceived risk—if everyone else chose it, it must be good
Testimonial
- Features real or relatable endorsers sharing personal experiences with the product
- Builds credibility through identification—audiences trust people who seem similar to themselves
- User-generated content has amplified this device, with reviews and influencer posts serving as modern testimonials
Compare: Bandwagon vs. Testimonial—bandwagon emphasizes quantity ("everyone's doing it") while testimonial emphasizes quality of individual experiences. Both leverage social proof, but testimonials add narrative depth.
Audience Engagement: Creating Participation
These devices involve the audience in the persuasive process—rather than passively receiving messages, viewers become active participants in constructing meaning.
Rhetorical Questions
- Questions that imply their own answers guide audiences to predetermined conclusions ("Isn't your family worth the best?")
- Creates engagement by prompting internal dialogue—audiences feel they're reasoning independently
- Highlights problems the product solves without making direct claims that could face resistance
Juxtaposition
- Places contrasting elements side by side to emphasize differences—before/after photos, competitor comparisons
- Creates visual or conceptual tension that demands resolution, keeping audiences engaged
- Transformation narratives use juxtaposition to dramatize product benefits
Call to Action
- Directs audience behavior with imperative commands—"Buy now," "Subscribe today," "Learn more"
- Reduces decision friction by telling audiences exactly what to do next
- Creates urgency through language that implies immediate action is necessary
Compare: Rhetorical Questions vs. Call to Action—rhetorical questions engage the mind, while calls to action direct behavior. Effective ads often use rhetorical questions to create desire, then calls to action to convert that desire into purchase.
These devices exploit loss aversion—the psychological principle that people fear losing opportunities more than they value gaining equivalent benefits.
Scarcity Appeal
- Limited availability increases perceived value—"Only 3 left in stock" triggers fear of missing out
- Time pressure forces quick decisions that bypass careful deliberation ("24-hour flash sale")
- Exclusivity framing makes products feel special and purchasers feel fortunate
Compare: Scarcity Appeal vs. Bandwagon—both create urgency, but through opposite mechanisms. Scarcity says "few people can have this," while bandwagon says "everyone wants this." Both work because they tap into social comparison.
Quick Reference Table
|
| Classical Appeals (Aristotle) | Ethos, Pathos, Logos |
| Language Manipulation | Repetition, Alliteration, Loaded Language |
| Figurative Language | Metaphor, Hyperbole, Personification |
| Social Proof | Bandwagon, Testimonial |
| Audience Engagement | Rhetorical Questions, Juxtaposition, Call to Action |
| Urgency Triggers | Scarcity Appeal |
| Credibility-Based | Ethos, Testimonial |
| Emotion-Based | Pathos, Loaded Language, Hyperbole |
Self-Check Questions
-
Which two devices both rely on social proof but differ in whether they emphasize group size or individual experience? How would you explain this distinction on an FRQ?
-
If an advertisement shows a "before and after" transformation photo alongside the tagline "Why wait to become your best self?"—identify the two rhetorical devices at work and explain how they function together.
-
Compare and contrast ethos and testimonial. Both involve credibility—what distinguishes how each device establishes trust with audiences?
-
A commercial shows a talking car that jokes with its owner, uses the slogan "Built Ford Tough," and ends with "Visit your dealer today." Identify three rhetorical devices present and explain what psychological principle each exploits.
-
Why might an advertiser combine scarcity appeal with bandwagon in the same message, even though they seem contradictory? What does this reveal about how persuasion works?