Revenue Recognition Criteria

Why This Matters

Revenue recognition isn't just an accounting rule—it's the foundation of how businesses communicate their financial performance to investors, regulators, and stakeholders. Under ASC 606 (and its international counterpart IFRS 15), you're being tested on a principles-based framework that applies across virtually every industry. Exam questions will push you beyond memorizing the five steps; they'll ask you to apply judgment in complex scenarios involving variable consideration, multiple performance obligations, principal-agent relationships, and timing of control transfer.

The criteria you'll study here demonstrate core accounting principles: matching revenues to the periods when they're earned, faithful representation of economic substance over legal form, and consistency in measurement. When you encounter an exam problem, don't just identify which step applies—understand why that step exists and how it ensures revenue reflects the actual transfer of value to customers. Master the underlying logic, and you'll handle any scenario they throw at you.

---

The Five-Step Model: Your Framework for Everything

The ASC 606 five-step model provides the structure for all revenue recognition decisions. Every exam question ultimately traces back to one or more of these steps, so understanding how they interconnect is essential.

Five-Step Revenue Recognition Model

• The foundational framework—identifies the contract, performance obligations, transaction price, allocation, and recognition timing in sequence
• Principles-based approach means you'll need to exercise judgment rather than follow rigid rules—examiners love testing gray areas
• Universal application across industries replaced dozens of industry-specific standards, making comparability a key benefit

---

Step 1: Establishing the Contract

Before any revenue can be recognized, you must confirm a valid contract exists. This step ensures that only enforceable arrangements with commercial substance enter the revenue recognition process.

Identification of the Contract with a Customer

• Legal enforceability required—contracts can be written, oral, or implied by customary business practices, but must create enforceable rights and obligations
• Commercial substance means the contract must be expected to change the entity's future cash flows in terms of risk, timing, or amount
• Collection probability must be assessed—if payment is unlikely, the arrangement may not qualify as a contract under ASC 606

Contract Modifications and Their Accounting Treatment

• Scope or price changes trigger reassessment—modifications may be treated as a separate contract, prospective adjustment, or cumulative catch-up
• Distinct goods/services test determines treatment: if the modification adds distinct items at standalone prices, it's a new contract
• Cumulative catch-up method applies when modifications change existing obligations—requires recalculating progress and adjusting revenue accordingly

---

Step 2: Identifying What You Promised

Performance obligations are the building blocks of revenue recognition. Each distinct promise to transfer goods or services must be identified separately because it affects both timing and amount of revenue.

Identification of Performance Obligations in the Contract

• Distinct goods or services are those the customer can benefit from on their own or with readily available resources
• Separately identifiable means the promise is not highly integrated with other promises—look for whether items are inputs to a combined output
• Series of distinct goods that are substantially the same and transferred over time can be treated as a single performance obligation (think: monthly cleaning services)

Warranties and Their Accounting Treatment

• Assurance-type warranties provide assurance the product meets specifications—accounted for as a cost accrual, not a separate performance obligation
• Service-type warranties provide additional services beyond defect coverage—treated as a separate performance obligation with allocated revenue
• Recognition timing differs: assurance warranties hit expense at sale; service warranty revenue is recognized over the warranty period as service is provided

---

Step 3: Measuring the Transaction Price

The transaction price represents what you expect to receive in exchange for your promises. This step requires careful consideration of variable amounts, financing effects, and non-cash elements.

Determination of the Transaction Price

• Expected consideration includes fixed amounts plus estimates of variable components—this is your starting point for allocation
• Constraint on variable consideration prevents over-recognition; include variable amounts only to the extent it's highly probable a significant reversal won't occur
• Exclude amounts collected on behalf of third parties (like sales taxes)—these aren't your revenue

Variable Consideration and Constraints

• Common forms include discounts, rebates, refunds, price concessions, incentives, performance bonuses, and penalties
• Two estimation methods: expected value (probability-weighted amounts) or most likely amount—use whichever better predicts the outcome
• Constraint application requires ongoing reassessment at each reporting date; update estimates as uncertainty resolves

Significant Financing Components

• Time value of money adjustment required when payment timing provides a significant financing benefit to either party
• Practical expedient available when the period between transfer and payment is one year or less—no adjustment needed
• Interest revenue or expense is recognized separately from revenue using the effective interest method

Non-Cash Consideration

• Fair value measurement at contract inception determines the amount included in the transaction price
• Variable fair value (e.g., shares whose value fluctuates) is measured at contract inception, not when received
• If fair value isn't determinable, use the standalone selling price of goods/services transferred as a proxy

Consideration Payable to Customers

• Reduces transaction price unless the payment is for a distinct good or service from the customer
• Common examples: slotting fees, cooperative advertising, volume rebates paid in cash
• Timing matters—recognize the reduction at the later of when revenue is recognized or when payment is promised

---

Step 4: Allocating to Performance Obligations

When contracts contain multiple promises, the transaction price must be divided among them. Relative standalone selling prices drive this allocation, affecting both timing and amounts recognized.

Allocation of the Transaction Price to Performance Obligations

• Relative standalone selling price method allocates the total transaction price proportionally based on what each obligation would sell for independently
• Observable prices preferred—use actual prices charged when the good/service is sold separately in similar circumstances
• Estimation required when standalone prices aren't directly observable: adjusted market assessment, expected cost plus margin, or residual approach

---

Step 5: Recognizing Revenue

Revenue recognition occurs when (or as) you satisfy performance obligations by transferring control to the customer. The timing question—point in time or over time—is one of the most heavily tested areas.

Recognition of Revenue When (or as) Performance Obligations Are Satisfied

• Control transfer is the trigger—not completion of performance, not payment, not legal title alone
• Point in time recognition applies when control transfers at a specific moment (most goods sales)
• Over time recognition applies when one of three criteria is met during the performance period

Transfer of Control to the Customer

• Control defined as the ability to direct the use of and obtain substantially all remaining benefits from the asset
• Indicators include: present right to payment, legal title transfer, physical possession, significant risks and rewards passed, customer acceptance
• No single indicator is determinative—evaluate all factors in context of the specific transaction

Timing of Revenue Recognition (Point in Time vs. Over Time)

• Over time criteria (meet any one): customer simultaneously receives and consumes benefits; entity's performance creates/enhances customer-controlled asset; asset has no alternative use and entity has enforceable right to payment
• Point in time is the default when none of the over time criteria are met—assess control indicators at the moment of transfer
• Progress measurement for over time recognition uses output methods (units delivered, milestones) or input methods (costs incurred, labor hours)

---

Special Considerations: Principal vs. Agent

This determination affects whether you report gross revenue or net commission—a significant difference that examiners frequently test through complex scenarios.

Principal vs. Agent Considerations

• Control before transfer is the key question: does the entity control the good/service before it's transferred to the customer?
• Principal indicators: primary responsibility for fulfillment, inventory risk, pricing discretion
• Agent indicators: another party fulfills the obligation; entity earns a commission or fee for arranging the transaction

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. A software company sells a license bundled with two years of technical support. How would you identify the performance obligations, and what method would you use to allocate the transaction price if standalone prices aren't directly observable?

2. Compare and contrast assurance-type and service-type warranties. If a customer can purchase an extended warranty separately, which type is it, and how does this affect revenue recognition timing?

3. A construction company builds a custom facility on the customer's land. Which of the three over time recognition criteria is most clearly met, and why does this result in revenue recognition throughout the project rather than at completion?

4. An online marketplace connects buyers with third-party sellers and handles payment processing. What factors would you evaluate to determine whether the marketplace is a principal or agent, and how would this affect reported revenue?

5. A retailer offers a "buy one, get one 50% off" promotion with a 30-day return policy. Identify two transaction price considerations that must be addressed, and explain how the constraint on variable consideration applies to the return rights.