Popular Diet Plans

Why This Matters

Diet plans aren't just lifestyle trends—they're practical applications of core nutrition principles you'll be tested on. Each approach manipulates specific variables like macronutrient ratios, meal timing, food quality, and metabolic pathways to achieve different health outcomes. Understanding why each diet works (or doesn't) requires you to connect the dots between biochemistry, energy metabolism, and chronic disease prevention.

You're being tested on your ability to analyze dietary interventions through a scientific lens. Can you explain the metabolic shift that occurs during ketosis? Do you understand why reducing sodium impacts blood pressure? These diets serve as case studies for broader concepts like glycemic control, inflammatory pathways, and nutrient density. Don't just memorize what each diet includes or excludes—know what physiological principle each one demonstrates.

---

Macronutrient Manipulation Diets

These diets achieve their effects by dramatically shifting the ratio of carbohydrates, fats, and proteins. By altering substrate availability, they change which metabolic pathways the body prioritizes for energy production.

Ketogenic Diet

• Induces ketosis through severe carbohydrate restriction (typically under 50g/day)—forcing the liver to convert fatty acids into ketone bodies for fuel
• High fat intake (70-80% of calories) provides the primary energy substrate, with moderate protein to prevent gluconeogenesis from muscle tissue
• Therapeutic applications beyond weight loss—originally developed for epilepsy management; research explores benefits for neurological disorders and insulin resistance

Atkins Diet

• Phased carbohydrate reintroduction distinguishes it from strict keto—starts at ~20g carbs/day and gradually increases through four phases
• Protein emphasis allows greater flexibility than ketogenic approaches while still promoting fat oxidation
• Metabolic adaptation focus—designed to identify individual carbohydrate tolerance levels for long-term maintenance

Low-Carb Diet

• Moderate carbohydrate reduction (typically 50-150g/day)—less restrictive than keto while still improving glycemic control
• Flexible macronutrient targets allow individualization based on activity level and metabolic health goals
• Rapid initial weight loss occurs primarily through glycogen depletion and associated water loss—important to distinguish from fat loss on exams

---

Whole Foods and Ancestral Approaches

These diets prioritize food quality over macronutrient ratios, operating on the principle that minimally processed foods provide superior nutrient bioavailability and reduce exposure to inflammatory compounds.

Mediterranean Diet

• Olive oil as primary fat source—provides monounsaturated fatty acids and polyphenols linked to cardiovascular protection
• Moderate fish consumption delivers omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) associated with reduced inflammation and improved cognitive function
• Most extensively researched diet pattern—consistently shows reduced risk of heart disease, stroke, and neurodegenerative conditions in longitudinal studies

Paleo Diet

• Eliminates post-agricultural foods (grains, legumes, dairy)—based on evolutionary mismatch hypothesis suggesting modern foods cause metabolic dysfunction
• Emphasizes nutrient density through organ meats, wild-caught fish, and diverse plant foods
• Controversial exclusions—removing legumes and whole grains eliminates significant fiber and micronutrient sources; requires careful planning to avoid deficiencies

Whole30

• 30-day elimination protocol removes common inflammatory triggers—sugar, grains, dairy, legumes, and alcohol
• Diagnostic tool for food sensitivities—systematic reintroduction phase identifies individual trigger foods
• Behavioral reset focus—addresses psychological relationships with food, not just physiological responses

---

Disease-Targeted Interventions

These diets were developed specifically to address clinical conditions, with mechanisms targeting particular physiological pathways implicated in disease development.

DASH Diet

• Sodium restriction (1500-2300mg/day) combined with high potassium intake—directly impacts renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system regulation
• Emphasizes minerals affecting vascular function—calcium, magnesium, and potassium work synergistically to reduce blood pressure
• NIH-developed and clinically validated—one of few diets with robust randomized controlled trial evidence for specific health outcomes

Vegan/Plant-Based Diet

• Complete animal product elimination shifts protein sources to legumes, nuts, and whole grains—requires attention to complementary proteins and vitamin $B_{12}$ supplementation
• High fiber and phytochemical intake associated with reduced oxidative stress and improved gut microbiome diversity
• Chronic disease risk reduction—epidemiological data links plant-based eating to lower rates of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and certain cancers

---

Timing and Behavioral Approaches

These interventions focus less on what you eat and more on when and how much, manipulating hormonal rhythms and psychological relationships with food.

Intermittent Fasting

• Fasting windows trigger metabolic switching—after glycogen depletion (12-36 hours), the body upregulates autophagy and shifts to fat oxidation
• Common protocols include 16:8 and 5:2—time-restricted eating vs. periodic caloric restriction achieve similar metabolic effects through different schedules
• Hormonal effects beyond calorie reduction—fasting periods influence insulin sensitivity, growth hormone secretion, and cellular repair mechanisms

Weight Watchers (WW)

• Points-based system quantifies food choices—assigns values based on calories, saturated fat, sugar, and protein to simplify energy balance decisions
• Behavioral modification emphasis—incorporates accountability, community support, and habit tracking alongside nutritional guidance
• Flexible framework allows any food within point limits—contrasts with elimination-based approaches; useful example when discussing dietary adherence and sustainability

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two diets both restrict carbohydrates but differ in whether they induce ketosis? What carbohydrate threshold distinguishes them?

2. Compare the mechanisms by which the DASH diet and a vegan diet reduce cardiovascular disease risk. What physiological pathways does each target?

3. A patient wants to identify whether dairy causes their digestive issues. Which diet approach would you recommend as a diagnostic tool, and why?

4. Explain why initial weight loss on a ketogenic diet may not reflect true fat loss. What metabolic process accounts for the rapid early changes?

5. If an FRQ asks you to evaluate a diet for long-term nutritional adequacy, which two diets would require the most careful micronutrient planning, and what specific deficiencies might occur?