Major Presidential Policies

Why This Matters

Presidential policies don't exist in a vacuum—they're responses to specific historical pressures and reflect evolving ideas about federal power, American identity, and the nation's role in the world. When you encounter these policies on the AP exam, you're being tested on your ability to connect executive decisions to broader themes like constitutional interpretation, expansion and its consequences, the growth of federal authority, and America's shifting position in global affairs. Understanding the "why" behind each policy matters far more than memorizing dates.

Think of presidential policies as windows into the debates that defined each era. Whether it's Jefferson wrestling with strict constructionism while doubling the nation's size, or FDR fundamentally reshaping the relationship between citizens and government, these decisions reveal tensions between ideology and pragmatism, liberty and security, isolationism and intervention. Don't just memorize what each president did—know what constitutional questions it raised, what precedent it set, and how it connects to the policies that came before and after.

---

Establishing National Identity and Precedent

The earliest presidential policies focused on defining what kind of nation the United States would be. These decisions established precedents that would shape American governance and foreign relations for generations.

Washington's Proclamation of Neutrality

• Established the precedent of non-entanglement—declared the U.S. neutral in the conflict between France and Britain in 1793, despite the Franco-American alliance
• Asserted executive authority in foreign policy, sparking debate over whether the president could unilaterally declare neutrality without congressional approval
• Protected the fragile new nation from being drawn into European conflicts that could have devastated American commerce and stability

Jefferson's Louisiana Purchase

• Doubled the nation's size by acquiring 828,000 square miles from France in 1803 for approximately $15 million
• Challenged strict constructionism—Jefferson, who believed in limited federal power, had to justify a purchase not explicitly authorized by the Constitution
• Intensified sectional tensions by raising questions about whether slavery would expand into new territories, foreshadowing conflicts that would culminate in civil war

Monroe Doctrine

• Declared the Western Hemisphere closed to European colonization—issued in 1823, warning European powers against intervention in the Americas
• Asserted U.S. regional dominance by positioning America as the protector of newly independent Latin American nations
• Became foundational to American foreign policy, later invoked to justify interventions throughout Latin America in the 20th century

---

Expansion and Its Human Costs

The mid-19th century saw aggressive territorial expansion justified by Manifest Destiny—the belief that American expansion was divinely ordained. These policies had devastating consequences for Native Americans and Mexico while intensifying the slavery debate.

Jackson's Indian Removal Policy

• Forced relocation of approximately 100,000 Native Americans through the Indian Removal Act of 1830, opening southeastern lands to white settlement and cotton cultivation
• Resulted in the Trail of Tears—the Cherokee removal alone killed an estimated 4,000 people from exposure, disease, and starvation
• Demonstrated federal power over states when Jackson defied the Supreme Court's Worcester v. Georgia ruling, reportedly saying the Court could not enforce its decision

Polk's Manifest Destiny

• Achieved continental expansion through the annexation of Texas (1845), the Oregon Treaty with Britain (1846), and the Mexican Cession (1848)
• Provoked the Mexican-American War—critics like Abraham Lincoln questioned whether American blood had truly been shed on American soil
• Reignited sectional crisis by adding vast territories that forced the question: would new states be slave or free?

---

Civil War and Reconstruction

The policies of Lincoln and Johnson during and after the Civil War addressed the fundamental questions of slavery's abolition, the meaning of freedom, and how to rebuild a divided nation.

Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation

• Freed enslaved people in Confederate-held territory—issued January 1, 1863, it transformed the war's purpose from preserving the Union to ending slavery
• Authorized Black military service, leading approximately 180,000 African Americans to serve in the Union Army by war's end
• Used war powers, not constitutional amendment—Lincoln framed it as a military necessity, which limited its scope but avoided constitutional challenges

Reconstruction Policies of Lincoln and Johnson

• Lincoln's Ten Percent Plan offered lenient terms—states could rejoin when 10% of 1860 voters swore loyalty and accepted emancipation
• Johnson's approach proved even more lenient, allowing former Confederate leaders to regain power and Southern states to enact Black Codes restricting freedpeople's rights
• Congressional Radical Republicans responded by seizing control of Reconstruction, passing the 14th and 15th Amendments and temporarily transforming Southern society

---

Progressive Era Reform

The early 20th century saw presidents respond to the problems of industrialization—corporate monopolies, unsafe products, and environmental destruction—by expanding federal regulatory power.

Roosevelt's Square Deal

• "Three Cs": consumer protection, conservation, and control of corporations—TR used executive power to regulate business and protect public interests
• Landmark legislation included the Pure Food and Drug Act, Meat Inspection Act (both 1906), and the Hepburn Act strengthening the ICC
• Conservation legacy included establishing the U.S. Forest Service and protecting approximately 230 million acres of public land

Wilson's Fourteen Points

• Proposed a framework for post-WWI peace in January 1918, emphasizing self-determination, free trade, freedom of the seas, and open diplomacy
• Called for the League of Nations—an international organization for collective security that Wilson considered the cornerstone of lasting peace
• Failed domestically when the Senate rejected the Treaty of Versailles, reflecting American reluctance to abandon traditional isolationism

---

Depression, War, and the Expanded Federal Role

The crises of the 1930s and 1940s permanently transformed the relationship between American citizens and their government. The New Deal established the expectation that the federal government would provide economic security and social welfare.

FDR's New Deal

• Created the modern welfare state through programs like Social Security (1935), which provided old-age pensions and unemployment insurance
• Employed millions directly through agencies like the CCC (Civilian Conservation Corps) and WPA (Works Progress Administration), fundamentally changing expectations about government's role in the economy
• Faced constitutional challenges—the Supreme Court initially struck down key programs, leading to FDR's controversial court-packing plan

---

Cold War Containment

From 1947 through the 1980s, American foreign policy centered on containment—preventing the spread of communism. Each administration adapted this strategy to changing circumstances and regions.

Truman Doctrine

• Committed the U.S. to supporting "free peoples" resisting communism—announced in March 1947, initially providing $400 million in aid to Greece and Turkey
• Marked the official beginning of containment policy, replacing wartime cooperation with the Soviet Union with ideological confrontation
• Established precedent for global intervention that would shape American foreign policy for four decades

Eisenhower Doctrine

• Extended containment to the Middle East in 1957, promising economic and military aid to nations resisting "international communism"
• Authorized military intervention—Eisenhower sent troops to Lebanon in 1958 to support the pro-Western government
• Reflected Cold War globalization as superpower competition spread beyond Europe to the developing world

Kennedy's New Frontier

• Confronted Cold War crises including the Bay of Pigs invasion (1961), Cuban Missile Crisis (1962), and escalating involvement in Vietnam
• Launched the Peace Corps and Apollo program—both served Cold War purposes by demonstrating American values and technological superiority
• Advanced civil rights cautiously, eventually introducing legislation that would become the Civil Rights Act of 1964

Nixon's Détente

• Eased Cold War tensions through diplomatic engagement with both the Soviet Union and China, breaking from rigid confrontation
• Achieved arms control through SALT I (Strategic Arms Limitation Talks), the first agreement limiting nuclear weapons
• Opened relations with China in 1972, exploiting the Sino-Soviet split and fundamentally reshaping Cold War dynamics

---

Expanding and Contracting the Welfare State

From the 1960s onward, domestic policy debates centered on the proper scope of federal social programs. Johnson dramatically expanded the welfare state; Reagan and Clinton sought to limit it.

Johnson's Great Society

• Declared "war on poverty" through programs like Medicare, Medicaid, Head Start, and federal aid to education
• Achieved landmark civil rights legislation—the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Voting Rights Act of 1965 used federal power to dismantle Jim Crow
• Represented the high point of liberal reform, expanding New Deal principles to address poverty and racial injustice

Reagan's Supply-Side Economics

• Cut taxes dramatically—the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 reduced the top marginal rate from 70% to 50% (later 28%)
• Argued that benefits would "trickle down" from wealthy investors to workers through increased investment and job creation
• Increased military spending while cutting domestic programs, leading to significant budget deficits despite promises of balanced budgets

Clinton's Welfare Reform

• "Ended welfare as we know it" by signing the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act (1996)
• Imposed time limits and work requirements, replacing the New Deal-era AFDC with TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families)
• Represented "triangulation"—a Democratic president adopting traditionally Republican positions, reflecting the rightward shift in American politics

---

Post-Cold War and 21st Century Challenges

After the Cold War's end, presidents faced new challenges including terrorism, healthcare access, and America's role in a changing global order.

Bush's War on Terror

• Responded to September 11, 2001 by launching military operations in Afghanistan (2001) and Iraq (2003)
• Expanded executive power through the USA PATRIOT Act, enhanced interrogation techniques, and warrantless surveillance programs
• Raised constitutional questions about the balance between national security and civil liberties that remain contested

Obama's Affordable Care Act

• Expanded healthcare coverage to approximately 20 million previously uninsured Americans through insurance exchanges and Medicaid expansion
• Required individual mandate—Americans had to obtain coverage or pay a penalty, a provision later struck down
• Represented the most significant healthcare reform since Medicare, though it fell short of the universal coverage many progressives sought

Trump's America First Policy

• Prioritized economic nationalism through tariffs on Chinese goods and renegotiation of trade agreements like NAFTA (replaced by USMCA)
• Withdrew from international commitments including the Paris Climate Agreement and Iran nuclear deal
• Restricted immigration through travel bans, family separation policies, and efforts to build a border wall

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two policies best illustrate the tension between strict constitutional interpretation and pragmatic expansion of federal power? What constitutional questions did each raise?

2. Compare the Truman Doctrine and Nixon's Détente. How did each approach the challenge of containing communism, and what does the shift between them reveal about Cold War evolution?

3. Identify three policies that significantly expanded the federal government's role in citizens' daily lives. What common justifications did presidents use for this expansion?

4. How do Jackson's Indian Removal and Polk's Manifest Destiny connect? If an FRQ asked you to analyze the consequences of mid-19th century expansion, what groups would you discuss and what evidence would you use?

5. Compare Johnson's Great Society with Reagan's Supply-Side Economics. How did each president define the government's responsibility to address poverty, and what were the long-term consequences of each approach?