Major Philosophical Theories

Why This Matters

Philosophy isn't just abstract thinking for its own sake—it's the foundation of how we understand reality, knowledge, ethics, and meaning. Every debate you've ever had about what's "true," what's "right," or what makes life worth living traces back to these theories. Whether you're analyzing political systems, scientific methods, or ethical dilemmas, you're drawing on philosophical frameworks that thinkers developed over millennia.

You're being tested on your ability to distinguish between theories that might sound similar but differ in crucial ways. Can you explain why a Stoic and an Epicurean would give different advice about pursuing pleasure? Do you understand the fundamental split between rationalists and empiricists about where knowledge comes from? Don't just memorize names and dates—know what core question each theory answers and what mechanism it proposes. That's what separates surface-level recall from genuine understanding.

---

Theories of Reality: What Actually Exists?

These theories tackle the most fundamental question in philosophy: what is the nature of reality itself? Before we can discuss knowledge or ethics, we need to understand what kind of universe we're living in.

Platonism

• Abstract Forms are ultimate reality—the physical world is merely a shadow or imperfect copy of eternal, unchanging Ideas
• Knowledge is innate and accessed through reason; we "remember" the Forms rather than learning from scratch
• Philosopher-kings should govern because only those who understand the Form of the Good can lead justly

Idealism

• Reality is fundamentally mental—the material world exists only as it's perceived or constructed by consciousness
• Perception shapes existence; Berkeley argued that "to be is to be perceived" (esse est percipi)
• Key figures include Berkeley and Hegel, who took idealism in different directions—subjective and absolute

Materialism

• Only physical matter exists—consciousness, thoughts, and emotions are ultimately reducible to physical processes
• Rejects mind-body dualism, arguing there's no separate "mental substance" distinct from the brain
• Foundational for modern neuroscience and philosophy of mind; influences debates about artificial intelligence

---

Sources of Knowledge: How Do We Know What We Know?

The epistemological debate centers on where reliable knowledge comes from. This split shaped the development of modern science and continues to influence how we evaluate claims today.

Rationalism

• Reason is the primary source of knowledge—some truths can be known independently of sensory experience
• Innate ideas exist in the mind; we can deduce knowledge through logical analysis alone
• Descartes, Spinoza, and Leibniz sought certain knowledge through deductive reasoning (cogito ergo sum)

Empiricism

• Sensory experience is the foundation of knowledge—the mind begins as a tabula rasa (blank slate)
• Experimentation and observation are essential; claims must be verified through evidence
• Locke, Berkeley, and Hume challenged rationalist assumptions about innate ideas

Skepticism

• Certain knowledge may be impossible—we should question accepted beliefs and examine our assumptions
• Epoché (suspension of judgment) leads to mental tranquility by freeing us from dogmatic attachment
• Critical thinking is paramount; doubt is a tool for intellectual rigor, not paralysis

Phenomenology

• Direct examination of experience reveals the structures of consciousness itself
• Brackets preconceived theories to describe how phenomena actually appear to us (phenomenological reduction)
• Husserl and Heidegger explored how we encounter being and meaning before theoretical reflection

---

Ethics and the Good Life: How Should We Live?

These theories address what makes actions right and lives meaningful. They offer competing frameworks for moral decision-making that remain relevant in contemporary debates.

Aristotelian Philosophy

• Virtue ethics centers on character—moral excellence comes from developing habits that lead to eudaimonia (flourishing)
• Empirical observation grounds knowledge; Aristotle rejected Plato's abstract Forms for studying actual things
• The "golden mean" locates virtue between extremes of excess and deficiency

Stoicism

• Self-control overcomes destructive emotions—we suffer not from events but from our judgments about them
• Live according to nature and accept what's beyond your control (amor fati)
• Virtue is the only true good—external circumstances like wealth or health are "indifferent"

Epicureanism

• Mental pleasure (ataraxia) is the highest good—tranquility and freedom from anxiety, not sensory indulgence
• Simple pleasures and moderation prevent the pain that comes from unfulfilled desires
• Friendship is essential—community and meaningful relationships are central to the good life

Utilitarianism

• Maximize overall happiness—the right action produces the greatest good for the greatest number
• Consequences determine morality, not intentions or adherence to rules (consequentialist ethics)
• Bentham and Mill developed the "hedonic calculus" and distinguished higher from lower pleasures

---

Meaning, Freedom, and the Modern Condition

These theories emerged largely in response to modernity's challenges: the death of traditional certainties, the problem of meaning in a scientific age, and questions about human freedom.

Existentialism

• Existence precedes essence—we're not born with a fixed nature; we create ourselves through choices
• Absurdity and alienation arise when we seek meaning in an indifferent universe
• Sartre, Camus, and Kierkegaard emphasized radical freedom and personal responsibility

Nihilism

• Life lacks inherent meaning—there are no objective values, purposes, or truths built into existence
• Rejects traditional moral and metaphysical beliefs as unfounded illusions
• Nietzsche diagnosed nihilism as a cultural crisis and sought ways to overcome it through self-creation

Pragmatism

• Truth is what works—beliefs are evaluated by their practical consequences and usefulness
• Experience and action shape knowledge; abstract speculation divorced from practice is empty
• James and Dewey advocated flexible, experimental approaches to truth and democracy

Postmodernism

• Rejects universal narratives and objective truth—knowledge is always situated, partial, and shaped by power
• Language constructs reality rather than simply describing it; meaning is unstable
• Foucault, Derrida, and Lyotard analyzed how discourse and institutions shape what counts as "true"

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Both Stoicism and Epicureanism emerged in the Hellenistic period and sought tranquility. What is the key difference in how each theory says we should achieve it?

2. A rationalist and an empiricist disagree about whether mathematical knowledge requires sensory experience. Which position would each take, and why?

3. Compare and contrast Nihilism and Existentialism: How does each view the question of life's meaning, and what response (if any) does each offer?

4. If asked to explain the difference between Platonism and Materialism on an FRQ about metaphysics, what would be the central contrast you'd emphasize?

5. Utilitarianism and Aristotelian virtue ethics both aim at human flourishing. How do they differ in determining what makes an action morally right?