Key Reconstruction Policies

Why This Matters

Reconstruction wasn't just about rebuilding Southern infrastructure—it was America's first attempt to define what freedom and citizenship actually meant in practice. You're being tested on how the federal government expanded its power to protect individual rights, how formerly enslaved people gained and then lost political ground, and why this period set patterns that would echo through the Civil Rights Movement a century later. The tension between federal authority vs. state power, legal rights vs. lived reality, and radical reform vs. conservative resistance runs through every policy you'll study here.

Don't just memorize dates and amendment numbers. Know what problem each policy tried to solve, who supported or opposed it, and why so many of these gains were rolled back by the 1870s. When you see an FRQ about continuity and change in American democracy, Reconstruction is your goldmine—these policies show both the promise and the limits of constitutional change.

---

Constitutional Foundations: The Reconstruction Amendments

The Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments fundamentally rewrote the relationship between individuals and government. These amendments shifted power from states to the federal government by making citizenship and rights national rather than state-defined.

Thirteenth Amendment

• Abolished slavery and involuntary servitude—the first constitutional amendment to directly limit state power over individuals within their borders
• Ratified December 6, 1865, making it the quickest amendment to pass during Reconstruction and the legal foundation for all civil rights legislation that followed
• Exception clause for criminal punishment created a loophole that Southern states later exploited through convict leasing systems

Fourteenth Amendment

• Birthright citizenship granted to all persons born or naturalized in the U.S.—directly overturning the Dred Scott decision that had denied citizenship to African Americans
• Equal protection and due process clauses became the constitutional basis for civil rights cases for the next 150 years, including Brown v. Board of Education
• Section 2 penalized states that denied voting rights by reducing their congressional representation—though this provision was never effectively enforced

Fifteenth Amendment

• Prohibited denying the vote based on race, color, or previous condition of servitude—notably did NOT guarantee the right to vote, only prohibited certain reasons for denial
• Ratified February 3, 1870, completing the constitutional framework of Reconstruction but leaving loopholes for literacy tests, poll taxes, and grandfather clauses
• Did not include women, causing a split in the suffrage movement between those who supported it and those who opposed ratifying without gender inclusion

---

Congressional Power Plays: Legislation and Executive Conflict

Congress used its legislative authority to define and enforce the new constitutional rights, often in direct conflict with President Andrew Johnson. These laws established the precedent that Congress—not the president—would control Reconstruction policy.

Civil Rights Act of 1866

• First federal law to define U.S. citizenship and guarantee that all citizens receive equal protection—passed before the Fourteenth Amendment to establish these rights by statute
• Directly targeted Black Codes by declaring that all persons born in the U.S. (except Native Americans) were citizens entitled to make contracts, sue, and own property
• Johnson's veto was overridden by Congress, marking a critical shift in power and setting up the confrontational relationship that would lead to impeachment

Reconstruction Acts of 1867

• Divided the former Confederacy into five military districts under Union generals—essentially treating the South as conquered territory rather than states with full rights
• Required new state constitutions guaranteeing Black male suffrage before states could be readmitted to the Union and regain congressional representation
• Disenfranchised former Confederate leaders under Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment, temporarily shifting Southern political power to Republicans and freedmen

Tenure of Office Act

• Restricted presidential removal power by requiring Senate approval to fire cabinet members—a direct attempt to protect Radical Republicans in Lincoln's cabinet
• Johnson's violation by firing Edwin Stanton became the basis for his impeachment, though he was acquitted by one vote in the Senate
• Later declared unconstitutional and repealed, but it demonstrated Congress's willingness to use any tool to control Reconstruction policy

---

Enforcement and Resistance: Federal Power vs. White Supremacy

The federal government created institutions and laws to make constitutional rights real on the ground, while white Southerners developed systematic resistance. This section shows the gap between legal rights and lived reality—a theme that appears constantly on AP exams.

Freedmen's Bureau

• Established March 1865 as the first federal welfare agency, providing food, housing, medical aid, and education to freedmen and poor whites in the South
• Negotiated labor contracts between freedmen and planters, attempting to create a free labor system while often reinforcing exploitative sharecropping arrangements
• Founded over 1,000 schools including historically Black colleges like Howard and Fisk—education was seen as the key to meaningful freedom

Military Reconstruction

• Federal troops deployed throughout the South to oversee elections, protect Republican voters, and enforce civil rights legislation
• Suppressed Klan violence and enabled African Americans to vote, hold office, and participate in constitutional conventions during Radical Reconstruction
• Troop withdrawal after 1877 effectively ended federal protection and allowed the "Redemption" of Southern state governments by white Democrats

Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871

• Authorized federal prosecution of Klan members for civil rights violations, making certain crimes against individuals into federal offenses for the first time
• Allowed the president to suspend habeas corpus and use military force to suppress "armed combinations" that deprived citizens of constitutional rights
• Temporarily effective in breaking Klan power in the early 1870s, but enforcement declined as Northern support for Reconstruction waned

---

Southern Resistance: The Limits of Federal Power

Southern whites developed legal and extralegal methods to maintain white supremacy and control Black labor. Understanding these resistance strategies explains why Reconstruction's constitutional gains failed to produce lasting equality.

Black Codes

• Passed by Southern legislatures in 1865-1866 immediately after the war, these laws restricted freedmen's movement, employment options, and civil rights
• Vagrancy laws allowed authorities to arrest unemployed Black men and force them into labor contracts—essentially recreating slavery under a different name
• Directly provoked Congressional Reconstruction by demonstrating that Southern states would not protect freedmen's rights voluntarily, leading to the Civil Rights Act and Fourteenth Amendment

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two Reconstruction policies most directly responded to the Black Codes, and how did their approaches differ?

2. Compare the Thirteenth and Fifteenth Amendments: why was one more easily circumvented than the other in the decades following Reconstruction?

3. If an FRQ asks you to explain the expansion of federal power during Reconstruction, which three policies would you use as evidence, and what specific powers did each establish?

4. How did the Freedmen's Bureau and Military Reconstruction work together to protect freedmen's rights, and why did both ultimately fail to produce lasting change?

5. The Tenure of Office Act led to Johnson's impeachment but was later ruled unconstitutional. What does this reveal about the relationship between constitutional principles and political conflict during Reconstruction?