Key Native American Philosophers

Why This Matters

Native American philosophy offers a fundamentally different approach to questions that Western philosophy has grappled with for centuries—the nature of knowledge, the relationship between humans and the environment, the role of community in identity, and the sources of ethical obligation. You're being tested not just on who these thinkers are, but on how their ideas challenge and complement Western philosophical frameworks. Understanding these philosophers means grasping concepts like relational ontology, place-based epistemology, and narrative as philosophy—ideas that appear throughout exam questions on comparative philosophy and environmental ethics.

These thinkers aren't working in isolation from each other. They share common threads—critiques of Western dualism, emphasis on interconnectedness, and the philosophical weight of storytelling—while bringing distinct perspectives shaped by their nations, genders, and historical moments. Don't just memorize names and book titles; know what philosophical problems each thinker addresses and how their approaches differ from (and sometimes directly challenge) the Western canon you've studied elsewhere.

---

Sovereignty and Decolonial Critique

These philosophers directly confronted colonial structures and Western philosophy's complicity in Indigenous dispossession. Their work treats political resistance as inseparable from philosophical inquiry.

Vine Deloria Jr.

• Critiqued Western philosophy's universalism—argued that Western thought falsely claims objectivity while serving colonial interests
• Developed place-based theology in contrast to Christianity's time-based narrative; land is sacred and constitutive of identity, not merely property
• "God Is Red" (1973) remains the foundational text for understanding how Indigenous spirituality challenges Western religious and philosophical assumptions

Luther Standing Bear

• First-generation boarding school survivor who turned assimilationist education against itself—used English literacy to preserve Lakota knowledge
• Challenged the "savage" narrative by demonstrating the philosophical sophistication of Indigenous child-rearing, governance, and environmental ethics
• "Land of the Spotted Eagle" (1933) articulates a complete alternative worldview, arguing that true civilization means harmony with nature, not domination of it

Viola Cordova

• Systematically critiqued Western epistemology—showed how concepts like "objectivity" and "individual knowledge" are culturally specific, not universal
• Developed relational ontology as a formal philosophical position; being itself is constituted through relationships, not prior to them
• Posthumous works collected in "How It Is" provide the most rigorous academic treatment of Native American philosophy as philosophy

---

Spirituality and Vision

These thinkers articulate Indigenous spirituality not as "religion" in the Western sense, but as a comprehensive understanding of reality that integrates the sacred into daily existence and ecological relationship.

Black Elk

• Lakota holy man whose vision at age nine became one of the most analyzed spiritual experiences in American religious history
• "Black Elk Speaks" (1932) presents a circular cosmology where time, space, and beings are interconnected—contrast this with linear Western metaphysics
• The Sacred Hoop concept illustrates relational wholeness; brokenness comes from severed relationships, healing from their restoration

John (Fire) Lame Deer

• Medicine man and trickster figure who used humor and paradox as philosophical tools—wisdom through disruption of expectations
• Critiqued materialism not abstractly but through lived contrast; argued modern Americans are spiritually impoverished despite material wealth
• "Lame Deer, Seeker of Visions" (1972) models experiential epistemology—knowledge comes through vision, ceremony, and relationship, not detached observation

---

Narrative and Identity

These writers demonstrate that storytelling is itself a philosophical method—not merely illustration of ideas but the primary way Indigenous communities generate and transmit knowledge.

N. Scott Momaday

• Pulitzer Prize winner (1969) for "House Made of Dawn"—first Native American to receive this recognition, legitimizing Indigenous literature in American letters
• Developed "memory in the blood" concept; identity is carried through ancestral narrative, not just individual experience
• "The Way to Rainy Mountain" models tri-vocal narrative—personal, historical, and mythic voices interweave to create meaning no single perspective could achieve

Leslie Marmon Silko

• "Ceremony" (1977) presents healing as narrative reconstruction—the protagonist recovers from trauma by finding his place within traditional stories
• Challenged Western linear plot structure by embedding Laguna oral traditions directly into novelistic form; form enacts philosophy
• Explored mixed-blood identity as philosophically generative rather than tragic—hybridity creates new possibilities for meaning

Paula Gunn Allen

• Recovered gynocentric traditions obscured by both colonialism and patriarchal anthropology; argued many Indigenous societies were matrilineal and woman-centered
• "The Sacred Hoop" (1986) established Native American feminist theory—showed how colonialism and sexism operated together
• Challenged Western feminism to recognize its own cultural specificity; liberation looks different from Indigenous perspectives

---

Indigenous Knowledge Systems and Education

These scholars work to articulate Indigenous knowledge as systematic, rigorous, and philosophically coherent—not merely "traditional beliefs" but genuine alternatives to Western frameworks.

Gregory Cajete

• Developed "Native Science" as a comprehensive knowledge system—includes ecology, astronomy, medicine, and psychology integrated through relational principles
• "Look to the Mountain" (1994) argues Indigenous education is inherently place-based and ecological; learning happens through relationship with specific landscapes
• Bridges Indigenous and Western science by showing complementary rather than contradictory approaches to understanding natural phenomena

Anne Waters

• Edited "American Indian Thought" (2004)—the first major anthology bringing Native American philosophy into academic philosophical discourse
• Developed non-discrete ontology—argues Indigenous thought rejects sharp boundaries between categories that Western philosophy assumes (mind/body, human/nature, individual/community)
• Emphasized oral tradition as philosophy—stories aren't pre-philosophical material but sophisticated philosophical arguments in narrative form

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Both Vine Deloria Jr. and Viola Cordova critique Western philosophy—what distinguishes their approaches, and which would you use to answer a question about epistemology versus theology?

2. How do Black Elk and Lame Deer represent different aspects of Lakota spiritual philosophy, and what does each contribute to understanding Indigenous metaphysics?

3. Compare how Momaday and Silko use narrative as a philosophical method. What does each suggest about the relationship between storytelling and knowledge?

4. If an FRQ asked you to explain how Indigenous philosophy challenges the Western separation of humans from nature, which three thinkers would provide your strongest evidence, and why?

5. Paula Gunn Allen and Anne Waters both address Indigenous women's contributions to philosophy—how do their emphases differ, and what does each reveal about the intersection of gender and Indigenous thought?