Key Concepts of Evidence for Evolution

Why This Matters

Evolution isn't just a theory you memorize—it's a framework you'll use to interpret biological data across every unit of this course. The evidence for evolution comes from remarkably different sources (fossils, anatomy, molecules, geographic patterns, real-time observations), yet they all converge on the same conclusion: life shares common ancestry and changes over time through natural selection. Understanding how each type of evidence works—and what it specifically demonstrates—is essential for tackling both multiple choice and free-response questions.

You're being tested on your ability to connect evidence to mechanism. Examiners don't just want you to list types of evidence; they want you to explain why homologous structures indicate common ancestry or how biogeography supports adaptive radiation. Don't just memorize facts—know what evolutionary concept each piece of evidence illustrates and be ready to compare different lines of evidence that support the same conclusion.

---

Anatomical and Developmental Evidence

These evidence types examine the physical structures of organisms—both in adults and during development—to reveal evolutionary relationships. Shared structural features that arise from common ancestry persist even when organisms adapt to vastly different environments.

Comparative Anatomy and Homologous Structures

• Homologous structures—anatomical features with the same underlying structure but different functions—demonstrate common ancestry across diverse species
• Divergent evolution explains how a single ancestral structure (like the tetrapod forelimb) becomes modified for flying, swimming, running, or grasping
• Pentadactyl limb pattern in vertebrates is a classic exam example: same bones, radically different uses from whale flippers to bat wings

Embryology and Developmental Similarities

• Pharyngeal pouches and post-anal tails appear in early embryos of fish, reptiles, birds, and mammals—structures that develop differently or disappear in adults
• Conserved developmental genes (like Hox genes) control body plans across phyla, revealing deep evolutionary connections
• Ontogeny reflects phylogeny—while not a perfect rule, embryonic similarities often reveal relationships obscured in adult forms

Vestigial Structures

• Reduced or non-functional organs—like the human appendix, whale pelvic bones, or snake leg remnants—indicate evolutionary history
• Loss of function occurs when structures no longer provide survival advantages, allowing mutations to accumulate without penalty
• Atavisms (ancestral traits that occasionally reappear, like human tails) provide additional evidence of evolutionary heritage

---

Molecular and Biochemical Evidence

Modern molecular techniques provide the most precise evidence for evolutionary relationships. DNA and protein sequences act as historical documents, accumulating changes over time that can be measured and compared.

Molecular Biology and DNA Evidence

• DNA sequence comparisons reveal evolutionary relationships—more similar sequences indicate more recent common ancestors
• Molecular clocks estimate divergence times by calculating mutation rates in conserved genes (assumes relatively constant mutation rates over time)
• Universal genetic code—all life uses the same codons for amino acids—provides powerful evidence for a single origin of life

Comparative Biochemistry

• Cytochrome c and other universal proteins show sequence similarities that correlate with evolutionary relatedness
• Metabolic pathways like glycolysis and the citric acid cycle are conserved across domains, suggesting ancient common origin
• Protein structure comparisons reveal homology even when DNA sequences have diverged significantly

---

Geographic Evidence

The distribution of species across Earth provides crucial evidence for how evolution occurs in space and time. Geographic isolation creates the conditions for populations to diverge, while continental movements explain otherwise puzzling distribution patterns.

Biogeography

• Endemic species on islands (like Darwin's finches or Hawaiian honeycreepers) demonstrate adaptive radiation from common ancestors
• Continental drift explains why similar fossils appear on now-separated continents and why marsupials dominate Australia
• Wallace's Line—the sharp boundary between Asian and Australian fauna—shows how geographic barriers limit species dispersal

---

Fossil Evidence

The fossil record provides direct physical evidence of past life and documents changes through geological time. While incomplete, fossils capture moments of evolutionary transition that no other evidence type can provide.

Fossil Record

• Transitional fossils like Tiktaalik (fish-to-tetrapod) and Archaeopteryx (dinosaur-to-bird) document major evolutionary transitions
• Stratigraphic sequence—older fossils in deeper rock layers—establishes the chronological order of life's history
• Radiometric dating provides absolute ages for fossils, allowing construction of evolutionary timelines

---

Direct Observations of Evolution

These examples demonstrate evolution happening in real time, answering critics who claim evolution can't be observed. When selection pressures are strong and generation times are short, evolutionary change becomes visible within human lifetimes.

Observed Instances of Natural Selection

• Peppered moth (Biston betularia) shifted from light to dark coloration during industrial pollution, then back when air cleaned up
• Darwin's finches show measurable beak changes within years in response to drought conditions and food availability
• Directional selection in action demonstrates the mechanism Darwin proposed over 150 years ago

Antibiotic Resistance in Bacteria

• Rapid bacterial evolution occurs because generation times are minutes to hours, allowing observable change in days
• Selection pressure from antibiotics kills susceptible bacteria while resistant mutants survive and reproduce
• MRSA and other superbugs represent evolution with immediate public health consequences—a compelling real-world application

Artificial Selection and Selective Breeding

• Dog breeds—from Chihuahuas to Great Danes—demonstrate how selection on existing variation produces dramatic changes
• Crop domestication (corn from teosinte, broccoli/kale/cabbage from wild mustard) shows artificial selection's power over thousands of years
• Model for natural selection—Darwin used artificial selection as evidence that selection can cause evolutionary change

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two types of evidence both demonstrate common ancestry but operate at completely different scales—one visible to the naked eye, one requiring sequencing technology?

2. A student claims vestigial structures disprove evolution because "why would evolution create useless parts?" How would you correct this misconception using your understanding of how vestigial structures actually form?

3. Compare and contrast the peppered moth example with antibiotic resistance in bacteria. What do both demonstrate about natural selection, and why is the bacterial example often considered more compelling evidence?

4. An FRQ asks you to explain how biogeography supports evolution. Which specific examples would you use, and what mechanism (isolation, adaptive radiation, continental drift) does each illustrate?

5. Why do evolutionary biologists consider molecular evidence particularly powerful when it agrees with anatomical evidence? What would it mean if DNA data consistently contradicted relationships suggested by comparative anatomy?