Key Concepts of Credit Rating Agencies

Why This Matters

Credit rating agencies sit at the intersection of risk assessment, market efficiency, and information asymmetry—three concepts you'll see tested repeatedly in financial institutions and markets. When you understand how these agencies operate, you're really learning about how markets price risk, why borrowing costs vary between issuers, and how third-party intermediaries reduce uncertainty in complex financial systems. These agencies don't just assign letter grades; they shape capital allocation, regulatory requirements, and investor behavior across global markets.

Don't just memorize which agency uses which rating scale—know what role credit ratings play in reducing adverse selection, how they influence cost of capital, and why their methodologies matter for market stability. You're being tested on the economic function these institutions serve, not just their founding dates. If you can explain why a downgrade raises borrowing costs or how rating agency conflicts of interest contributed to the 2008 financial crisis, you're thinking at the level the exam demands.

---

The "Big Three" and Market Dominance

The credit rating industry is highly concentrated, with three agencies controlling approximately 95% of the global market. This oligopolistic structure creates both efficiency through standardization and concerns about systemic risk and conflicts of interest.

Moody's Investors Service

• Founded in 1909, Moody's pioneered the modern credit rating industry and remains one of the most influential agencies in global debt markets
• Rating scale uses modifier system—Aaa (highest) through C, with numerical modifiers (1, 2, 3) indicating position within each category
• Ratings directly impact borrowing costs—a single-notch downgrade can increase an issuer's interest expenses by millions annually, demonstrating the agency's market power

Standard & Poor's (S&P)

• Rating scale runs AAA to D—the D rating indicates actual default, making S&P's scale useful for tracking the full credit deterioration process
• S&P 500 index connection provides dual influence—the agency shapes both credit markets through ratings and equity markets through its benchmark index
• Regulatory integration means S&P ratings are embedded in banking capital requirements, insurance regulations, and investment mandates worldwide

Fitch Ratings

• Third member of the Big Three, often used as a tiebreaker when Moody's and S&P disagree on an issuer's creditworthiness
• Rating methodology emphasizes transparency—Fitch publishes detailed criteria documents explaining how it weighs factors like leverage, cash flow, and industry risk
• Sector-specific expertise in structured finance and sovereign debt makes Fitch particularly influential in these market segments

---

Emerging Competitors and Market Diversification

Newer and regional agencies challenge the Big Three's dominance by offering alternative perspectives and methodologies. This competition addresses concerns about rating shopping, conflicts of interest, and geographic concentration in the industry.

DBRS Morningstar

• Canadian origins provide North American alternative—DBRS merged with Morningstar in 2019, combining credit rating expertise with investment research capabilities
• Recognized by European regulators as a certified rating agency, giving it competitive standing in EU debt markets where diversification from U.S.-based agencies is encouraged
• Methodology transparency includes detailed public documentation of rating criteria, addressing post-2008 criticism about opaque rating processes

Kroll Bond Rating Agency (KBRA)

• Founded in 2010 as post-crisis alternative—explicitly positioned as a response to Big Three failures during the 2008 financial crisis
• Independence emphasis distinguishes KBRA's business model—the agency markets itself on rigorous analysis free from the conflicts that plagued legacy agencies
• Growing regulatory acceptance has expanded KBRA's market share, though it remains significantly smaller than the Big Three

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two agencies use nearly identical rating notation (AAA, AA+, etc.), and how does Moody's notation differ?

2. If an issuer receives different ratings from Moody's and S&P, what role might Fitch play, and what does this suggest about the value of multiple rating agencies?

3. Compare the Big Three's market position with newer agencies like KBRA—what barriers to entry explain why the oligopoly persists despite criticism?

4. How do credit rating agencies reduce information asymmetry in debt markets, and what conflict of interest arises from the issuer-pays model?

5. An FRQ asks you to explain how credit ratings affect cost of capital. Using any two agencies as examples, describe the mechanism by which a rating change influences an issuer's borrowing costs.