Why This Matters
Music videos aren't just promotional tools—they're a distinct art form that transformed how we consume and understand popular music. When MTV launched in 1981, it fundamentally changed the relationship between sound and image, creating a new visual language that artists would use to communicate identity, challenge social norms, and push technological boundaries. You're being tested on how these videos reflect broader cultural movements, technological innovation, artistic experimentation, and the commercial evolution of the music industry.
Understanding iconic music videos means recognizing the concepts they demonstrate: narrative storytelling techniques, visual effects innovation, cultural commentary, and the symbiotic relationship between music and image. Don't just memorize which video came first or who directed what—know what each video contributed to the medium, how it reflected its cultural moment, and why it influenced everything that followed.
These videos established music video as a legitimate artistic medium, proving that the format could be more than performance footage. They introduced cinematic techniques, narrative structures, and visual experimentation that defined what a music video could be.
Queen - "Bohemian Rhapsody"
- First true "concept video" (1975)—predated MTV by six years and demonstrated that visuals could match musical complexity
- Innovative multi-image effects created the iconic shot of four faces emerging from darkness, establishing visual motifs still referenced today
- Legitimized the rock opera format by proving audiences would engage with six-minute, multi-section compositions when paired with compelling visuals
The Buggles - "Video Killed the Radio Star"
- First video aired on MTV (August 1, 1981)—literally launched the music television era and symbolized the medium's cultural takeover
- Nostalgic futurism blended retro imagery with synthesizer-driven sound, capturing anxieties about technological change
- Self-referential commentary on media evolution made it both a product of and statement about the shift from radio to visual culture
Peter Gabriel - "Sledgehammer"
- Most awarded music video in history—won nine MTV Video Music Awards and demonstrated the medium's artistic credibility
- Pioneering stop-motion techniques by Aardman Animations (later of Wallace & Gromit fame) took 16 days to shoot and pushed technical boundaries
- Surrealist visual vocabulary influenced countless artists and established music video as a space for experimental filmmaking
Compare: "Bohemian Rhapsody" vs. "Video Killed the Radio Star"—both pioneered the form, but Queen proved artistic ambition before MTV existed, while The Buggles marked the commercial infrastructure that would make videos essential. If an FRQ asks about music video's emergence as an art form, these two bookend the pre-MTV and MTV-launch eras.
The Short Film Revolution
Michael Jackson and his collaborators reimagined music videos as cinematic events with budgets, narratives, and production values rivaling Hollywood. This approach transformed videos from promotional afterthoughts into cultural phenomena that could overshadow the songs themselves.
Michael Jackson - "Thriller"
- First music video with a theatrical premiere (1983)—debuted in theaters and redefined production scale with a $500,000 budget
- 14-minute runtime with full narrative arc introduced by horror legend Vincent Price, blurring the line between music video and short film
- Choreography became cultural currency—the zombie dance sequence spawned imitation worldwide and established dance as essential to pop stardom
Guns N' Roses - "November Rain"
- Epic rock balladry meets cinematic scope—the nine-minute video cost $1.5 million and featured orchestral arrangements with dramatic wedding narrative
- MTV's most-requested video of the early 1990s proved that rock audiences would embrace emotional, story-driven visuals
- Trilogy format (with "Don't Cry" and "Estranged") demonstrated serialized storytelling potential in music video
Madonna - "Like a Prayer"
- Controversy as artistic strategy (1989)—burning crosses and religious imagery caused Pepsi to cancel a $5 million sponsorship deal
- Addressed race, faith, and sexuality simultaneously through the narrative of a Black man falsely accused of crime, making explicit social commentary
- Proved videos could drive cultural conversation beyond music, establishing Madonna's reputation for provocation with purpose
Compare: "Thriller" vs. "November Rain"—both brought Hollywood production values to music video, but Jackson emphasized choreography and horror genre conventions while Guns N' Roses prioritized emotional narrative and rock authenticity. Both proved audiences would invest in long-form music video storytelling.
Visual Innovation and Effects
These videos pushed technological boundaries, using animation, special effects, and innovative production techniques to create imagery impossible in live performance. They established music video as a laboratory for visual experimentation.
A-ha - "Take On Me"
- Rotoscope animation breakthrough (1985)—combined live-action with pencil-sketch animation using a technique that required 3,000 hand-drawn frames
- Romantic narrative transcended medium as the comic-book hero literally pulls his love interest into his animated world
- Defined 1980s MTV aesthetic and demonstrated that technical innovation could serve emotional storytelling
Björk - "All Is Full of Love"
- Directed by Chris Cunningham (1999)—featured two identical robots in an intimate encounter, exploring posthuman themes of love and connection
- Groundbreaking CGI and practical effects created porcelain-white androids that remain visually striking decades later
- Art world crossover exhibited in museums including MoMA, legitimizing music video as fine art
Jamiroquai - "Virtual Insanity"
- Optical illusion engineering (1996)—the floor remained stationary while walls and furniture moved on a massive platform, creating disorienting effect
- Commentary on technology and consumerism aligned with acid jazz's intellectual positioning and Jamiroquai's social consciousness
- Won four MTV VMAs including Video of the Year, proving that clever concepts could compete with big-budget productions
Compare: "Take On Me" vs. "All Is Full of Love"—both used cutting-edge technology to explore romantic themes, but A-ha's warmth and accessibility contrasted with Björk's cold, cerebral futurism. They represent music video's visual innovation across different eras and genres.
Cultural Movements and Identity
These videos captured or catalyzed broader cultural shifts, using visual language to express generational attitudes, challenge norms, and redefine representation. They demonstrate how music videos both reflect and shape cultural identity.
Nirvana - "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
- Grunge aesthetic codified (1991)—dim lighting, cheerleaders with anarchy symbols, and chaotic mosh pit captured Generation X disillusionment
- Anti-MTV video on MTV deliberately rejected polished production values, yet became the network's most-played video
- Killed hair metal overnight—the video's success signaled a cultural shift away from 1980s excess toward authenticity and angst
Missy Elliott - "The Rain (Supa Dupa Fly)"
- Redefined female hip-hop visuals (1997)—the inflated garbage bag suit rejected conventional beauty standards and male gaze expectations
- Hype Williams' fisheye aesthetic created a surreal, Afrofuturist visual language that influenced hip-hop videos for decades
- Asserted creative control as Missy wrote, co-produced, and conceptualized her own image, modeling artistic autonomy for future artists
Britney Spears - "...Baby One More Time"
- Teen pop blueprint (1998)—the schoolgirl uniform aesthetic launched a thousand imitators and defined late-1990s pop visual language
- Spears' own concept (she suggested the school setting over the label's cartoon idea) demonstrated artist agency in an industry that often denied it
- Choreography-forward approach established dance as essential to pop stardom, building on Jackson's legacy for a new generation
Compare: "Smells Like Teen Spirit" vs. "...Baby One More Time"—both defined their respective genres' visual identities in the 1990s, but Nirvana's deliberate rejection of polish contrasted with Britney's calculated perfection. Together they represent the decade's cultural split between alternative authenticity and pop maximalism.
The Digital and Viral Era
As the internet disrupted traditional music distribution, these videos demonstrated new possibilities for reach, engagement, and creative approaches that didn't require major-label budgets. They mark the transition from MTV dominance to YouTube democratization.
OK Go - "Here It Goes Again"
- Viral video pioneer (2006)—the single-take treadmill choreography cost almost nothing but generated 50+ million views
- DIY aesthetic proved concept over budget and demonstrated that creativity could compete with corporate production values
- YouTube-native success bypassed traditional MTV gatekeeping, signaling the platform shift that would transform music promotion
Lady Gaga - "Bad Romance"
- Most-viewed video of 2009-2010—accumulated over a billion views and proved that spectacle still mattered in the YouTube era
- Fashion-as-narrative featured Alexander McQueen designs and established Gaga's visual identity as inseparable from her music
- Bridged MTV and YouTube eras by combining old-school production values with internet-friendly shareability and meme potential
Beyoncé - "Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)"
- Minimalism as statement (2008)—black-and-white, single set, no cuts, three dancers proved that choreography alone could dominate
- Meme and parody explosion from Saturday Night Live to countless YouTube tributes demonstrated new forms of cultural penetration
- J-Setting choreography drew from Southern drag ball culture, bringing underground movement vocabulary to mainstream pop
Compare: "Here It Goes Again" vs. "Bad Romance"—both succeeded in the YouTube era, but OK Go proved you didn't need money while Gaga proved spectacle still worked. They represent two viable strategies for the digital age: scrappy creativity versus maximalist production.
|
| Pioneering the form (pre-MTV/early MTV) | "Bohemian Rhapsody," "Video Killed the Radio Star," "Sledgehammer" |
| Short film/cinematic approach | "Thriller," "November Rain," "Like a Prayer" |
| Visual effects innovation | "Take On Me," "All Is Full of Love," "Virtual Insanity" |
| Cultural movement expression | "Smells Like Teen Spirit," "The Rain," "...Baby One More Time" |
| Controversy and social commentary | "Like a Prayer," "The Rain," "Smells Like Teen Spirit" |
| Choreography-centered | "Thriller," "Single Ladies," "...Baby One More Time" |
| Viral/digital era strategies | "Here It Goes Again," "Bad Romance," "Single Ladies" |
| Female artist visual autonomy | "The Rain," "Single Ladies," "Bad Romance" |
Self-Check Questions
-
Which two videos from the 1970s-80s best demonstrate the transition from music video as novelty to music video as art form, and what specific innovations did each contribute?
-
Compare and contrast how "Thriller" and "Single Ladies" use choreography—what do they share, and how do their visual approaches differ?
-
If an FRQ asked you to trace the evolution of female artists' visual self-presentation in music video, which three videos would you choose and why?
-
"Smells Like Teen Spirit" and "...Baby One More Time" both defined 1990s youth culture. How do their visual aesthetics reflect opposing cultural values of the decade?
-
How did the shift from MTV to YouTube change what made a music video "successful"? Use "Here It Goes Again" and "Bad Romance" to illustrate two different responses to this shift.