Fundamental Health Behavior Change Models

Why This Matters

Health behavior change models are the theoretical backbone of every intervention you'll design, implement, or evaluate in public health practice. You're being tested not just on what these models say, but on when to apply each one—whether you're targeting an individual's beliefs, working through group dynamics, or designing policy-level change. Understanding the distinctions between perception-based models, stage-based models, and multi-level frameworks will help you match the right theory to the right problem on exams and in practice.

These models answer fundamentally different questions: Why don't people act on health information? How do behaviors spread through communities? What makes someone ready to change? Don't just memorize the components—know what level of influence each model targets (individual cognition, social environment, or systemic factors) and what type of intervention it supports. That's what separates a passing answer from an excellent one.

---

Perception and Belief-Based Models

These models focus on how individuals think about health threats and their own ability to respond. They assume that changing beliefs and perceptions is the key to changing behavior.

Health Belief Model

• Perceived susceptibility and severity—individuals must believe they're at risk for a condition and that the condition is serious enough to warrant action
• Perceived benefits vs. barriers—behavior change happens when people see the benefits of action as outweighing the costs or obstacles
• Cues to action trigger behavior—these can be internal (symptoms) or external (media campaigns, physician advice)

Theory of Planned Behavior

• Behavioral intention is the strongest predictor of actual behavior—intention is shaped by attitudes, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control
• Subjective norms capture social pressure—what do important others think about the behavior?
• Perceived behavioral control reflects confidence in one's ability to perform the behavior, similar to self-efficacy but specific to the planned action

Information-Motivation-Behavioral Skills Model

• Three necessary components—information alone isn't enough; people also need motivation and the practical skills to act
• Behavioral skills mediate the relationship between information/motivation and behavior—knowing how to perform a behavior is as critical as wanting to
• Originally developed for HIV prevention—demonstrates how knowledge without skills or motivation fails to produce change

---

Stage-Based Models

These models recognize that behavior change is a process, not an event. They help practitioners meet people where they are and tailor interventions accordingly.

Transtheoretical Model (Stages of Change)

• Five stages—Precontemplation (not considering change), Contemplation (thinking about it), Preparation (planning), Action (actively changing), and Maintenance (sustaining change)
• Stage matching is essential—consciousness-raising works for precontemplators; action planning works for those in preparation
• Relapse is expected—individuals cycle through stages, and interventions should support re-engagement rather than treating setbacks as failures

Precaution Adoption Process Model

• Seven distinct stages—from unaware of the issue through to maintaining the precautionary behavior
• Distinguishes "unaware" from "unengaged"—someone may know about a risk but not see it as personally relevant, requiring different messaging
• Best for one-time protective behaviors—like radon testing or genetic screening, rather than ongoing lifestyle changes

Health Action Process Approach

• Two phases—the motivational phase (forming intentions) and the volitional phase (planning and executing action)
• Action and coping planning bridge the intention-behavior gap—people need specific plans for when, where, and how to act
• Self-regulation is critical—this model emphasizes ongoing self-monitoring and adjustment during the volitional phase

---

Social and Environmental Models

These models shift focus from individual cognition to social context—recognizing that behavior is shaped by relationships, communities, and systems.

Social Cognitive Theory

• Reciprocal determinism—behavior, personal factors (beliefs, self-efficacy), and environment continuously influence each other
• Observational learning is powerful—people learn behaviors by watching others, especially credible role models
• Self-efficacy is the central construct—confidence in one's ability to perform a behavior predicts both initiation and persistence

Social Ecological Model

• Five nested levels of influence—individual, interpersonal, organizational, community, and policy
• Multi-level interventions are most effective—addressing only individual factors while ignoring environmental barriers limits impact
• Emphasizes context—the same individual may behave differently in different settings, so environments must support healthy choices

COM-B Model (Capability, Opportunity, Motivation - Behavior)

• Three interacting components—Capability (physical and psychological), Opportunity (physical and social environment), and Motivation (reflective and automatic)
• Diagnostic framework—use COM-B to identify which component is the barrier before selecting intervention strategies
• Links to the Behavior Change Wheel—COM-B is the hub of a larger framework that maps barriers to specific intervention functions and policy categories

---

Diffusion and Adoption Models

These models explain how behaviors and innovations spread through populations—essential for scaling interventions and understanding adoption patterns.

Diffusion of Innovations Theory

• Five adopter categories—innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority, and laggards, each requiring different communication strategies
• Five attributes predict adoption—relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and observability
• Opinion leaders and change agents accelerate diffusion—identifying and engaging these individuals is a key implementation strategy

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two models both emphasize self-efficacy but differ in whether they focus on individual learning versus bridging the intention-behavior gap?

2. A community health worker wants to increase colorectal cancer screening rates. Compare the Health Belief Model and the Precaution Adoption Process Model—which would better guide intervention design for people who are aware of screening but haven't considered it personally, and why?

3. You're designing a workplace wellness program and realize that employees have the knowledge and motivation to exercise but lack time and facilities. Which model provides the best diagnostic framework for identifying this barrier, and what component does it represent?

4. Explain how Diffusion of Innovations Theory and the Social Ecological Model might be used together when scaling up an evidence-based HIV prevention program to new communities.

5. An FRQ asks you to design a smoking cessation intervention for pregnant women in the "contemplation" stage. Which model defines this stage, and what intervention strategies does it suggest for moving individuals to the next stage?