Essential Gemstone Varieties

Why This Matters

Gemstones aren't just pretty rocks—they're windows into the fundamental principles of mineralogy that you'll be tested on throughout this course. Each gemstone variety demonstrates key concepts like crystal structure, chemical composition, trace element coloration, optical phenomena, and the relationship between atomic arrangement and physical properties. When you study why a diamond is hard or why a ruby is red, you're actually learning about bonding types, lattice structures, and how impurities affect mineral behavior.

The gemstones in this guide illustrate how the same mineral species can produce dramatically different gems (corundum gives us both rubies and sapphires), how crystal structure determines durability, and how light interacts with different atomic arrangements. Don't just memorize names and colors—know what concept each gemstone illustrates. If an exam question asks about hardness, optical properties, or trace element coloration, you need to connect specific examples to underlying mechanisms.

---

Carbon and Elemental Minerals

Some gemstones form from a single element arranged in a specific crystal structure. The arrangement of atoms—not just their identity—determines physical properties like hardness and optical behavior.

Diamond

• Pure carbon in a tetrahedral crystal lattice—each carbon atom bonds covalently to four neighbors, creating the hardest known natural material (10 on Mohs scale)
• High refractive index (2.42) and strong dispersion produce the characteristic brilliance and "fire" that make diamonds prized for jewelry
• Industrial applications leverage extreme hardness for cutting, grinding, and drilling tools—demonstrating how crystal structure determines practical use

---

Corundum Varieties: Same Mineral, Different Colors

Corundum ($Al_2O_3$) demonstrates a critical mineralogy concept: trace element substitution. The same mineral structure produces completely different gemstones depending on which impurity atoms replace aluminum in the crystal lattice.

Ruby

• Chromium substitution ($Cr^{3+}$ replacing $Al^{3+}$) causes the red color—the more chromium, the deeper the red
• Mohs hardness of 9 makes corundum second only to diamond, ideal for jewelry that withstands daily wear
• Fluorescence under UV light occurs in many rubies due to chromium, a useful identification tool in gemological testing

Sapphire

• Iron and titanium impurities create the classic blue color through intervalence charge transfer between $Fe^{2+}$ and $Ti^{4+}$ ions
• "Fancy sapphires" occur in yellow, pink, orange, and green—any corundum color except red (which is ruby by definition)
• Same hardness (9) and crystal structure as ruby, demonstrating that trace elements affect color without changing fundamental properties

---

Beryl Varieties: Cyclosilicate Gems

Beryl ($Be_3Al_2Si_6O_{18}$) is a cyclosilicate mineral that forms hexagonal crystals. Like corundum, different trace elements produce distinct gemstone varieties from the same base mineral.

Emerald

• Chromium and/or vanadium create the characteristic green color in this beryl variety
• Inclusions called "jardin" (French for garden) are so common that flawless emeralds are exceptionally rare—these inclusions actually help authenticate natural stones
• Hardness of 7.5–8 is respectable, but inclusions make emeralds more brittle and prone to chipping than their hardness suggests

Aquamarine

• Iron ($Fe^{2+}$) causes the blue to blue-green color—a paler, more subtle coloration than emerald's vivid green
• Typically much cleaner than emerald, with fewer inclusions, making it more durable despite similar hardness (7.5–8)
• Pleochroism (showing different colors from different angles) is visible in deeper-colored specimens, demonstrating how light interacts with crystal structure

---

Quartz and Silica-Based Gems

Quartz ($SiO_2$) is one of Earth's most abundant minerals, and its gemstone varieties demonstrate how trace elements and structural variations create diversity within a single mineral species.

Amethyst

• Iron impurities plus natural irradiation produce the purple color—heat treatment can convert amethyst to yellow citrine
• Mohs hardness of 7 makes quartz durable enough for most jewelry applications
• Color zoning is common, with bands of lighter and darker purple reflecting changing conditions during crystal growth

Opal

• Amorphous silica structure (not crystalline)—technically a mineraloid rather than a true mineral
• Play-of-color results from light diffraction through microscopic silica spheres arranged in a grid pattern; sphere size determines which colors appear
• Lower hardness (5.5–6.5) and water content (up to 20%) make opals delicate and sensitive to dehydration and temperature changes

---

Silicate Mineral Gems

These gemstones represent various silicate mineral groups, each with distinct crystal structures that determine their properties. Understanding silicate classification (nesosilicates, cyclosilicates, etc.) helps predict gemstone behavior.

Garnet

• Nesosilicate mineral group with the general formula $X_3Y_2(SiO_4)_3$—different X and Y cations produce varieties like almandine, pyrope, and grossular
• Hardness of 6.5–7.5 varies by composition; garnets also serve as industrial abrasives
• Isometric crystal system produces distinctive dodecahedral or trapezohedral crystal shapes useful for identification

Tourmaline

• Complex boron cyclosilicate with highly variable composition—one of the most chemically complex mineral groups
• Color zoning within single crystals creates "watermelon tourmaline" (pink core, green rim), demonstrating how composition changes during growth
• Piezoelectric and pyroelectric properties result from its crystal structure—tourmaline generates electric charge under pressure or temperature change

Peridot

• Gem-quality olivine ($Mg,Fe)_2SiO_4$)—a nesosilicate where iron content determines color intensity
• One of few gems occurring in only one color (green), though shade varies from yellow-green to olive depending on iron-to-magnesium ratio
• Forms in the mantle and reaches the surface through volcanic activity or in meteorites—one of the few extraterrestrial gemstones

---

Gems with Exceptional Optical Properties

Some gemstones are prized primarily for unusual optical phenomena that result from their crystal structure or internal features. These properties connect directly to concepts of light interaction with matter.

Alexandrite

• Color-change effect (alexandrite effect) occurs because chromium absorption bands transmit both red and green light; the balance shifts depending on light source spectrum
• Chrysoberyl variety ($BeAl_2O_4$) with hardness of 8.5—one of the hardest gemstones after diamond and corundum
• Extreme rarity makes natural alexandrite more valuable per carat than most diamonds; most "alexandrite" on the market is synthetic

Tanzanite

• Strong pleochroism shows blue, violet, and burgundy from different crystal orientations—typically heat-treated to minimize brown tones
• Zoisite variety (calcium aluminum silicate) found only in a small area of Tanzania, making it geologically unique
• Moderate hardness (6–7) requires protective settings in jewelry; relatively soft for a high-value gemstone

Zircon

• Highest refractive index of common gemstones (1.93–1.98) creates exceptional brilliance and fire
• Strong birefringence causes visible doubling of back facets when viewed through the stone—a key identification feature
• Zirconium silicate ($ZrSiO_4$), not to be confused with synthetic cubic zirconia ($ZrO_2$); natural zircon is used in radiometric dating due to uranium content

---

Tough vs. Hard: Jade and Aggregate Minerals

Hardness and toughness are different properties. Hardness resists scratching; toughness resists breaking. Jade exemplifies how aggregate structure creates exceptional toughness even at moderate hardness.

Jade

• Two distinct minerals—jadeite (pyroxene, hardness 6.5–7) and nephrite (amphibole, hardness 6–6.5)—both called jade due to similar appearance and properties
• Interlocking fibrous crystal structure creates exceptional toughness; jade is harder to break than most gems despite moderate Mohs hardness
• Jadeite is rarer and more valuable, with "imperial jade" (vivid green from chromium) commanding premium prices; nephrite is more common and typically occurs in creamy white to green

---

Topaz: Silicate with Perfect Cleavage

Topaz

• Aluminum silicate fluoride hydroxide ($Al_2SiO_4(F,OH)_2$) with hardness of 8—harder than quartz but with a critical weakness
• Perfect basal cleavage means topaz can split along atomic planes despite high hardness; this affects durability in jewelry
• Natural colors include yellow, orange, and pink; most blue topaz is irradiated and heat-treated colorless material

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Ruby and sapphire are both varieties of corundum—what specific trace elements cause their different colors, and what does this demonstrate about mineral coloration?

2. Compare emerald and aquamarine: How does their shared beryl structure but different trace element content affect their appearance and practical durability?

3. Why is opal classified as a mineraloid rather than a true mineral, and how does its structure produce the play-of-color effect?

4. A gem has Mohs hardness of 8 but chips easily, while another gem has hardness of 6.5 but is extremely difficult to break. Which gems fit this description, and what explains the difference between hardness and toughness?

5. If an FRQ asks you to explain how the same mineral species can produce gemstones of completely different colors, which two mineral groups provide the best examples, and what mechanism would you describe?