Debt Repayment Methods

Why This Matters

Debt repayment isn't just about writing checks—it's about understanding the time value of money and how interest compounds against you when you're the borrower instead of the investor. You're being tested on your ability to analyze different repayment strategies, calculate their true costs, and recommend the right approach for different financial situations. The concepts here connect directly to interest rate calculations, opportunity cost, behavioral finance, and credit management.

Every method in this guide represents a trade-off between mathematical optimization and psychological motivation. Some strategies minimize total interest paid; others maximize your likelihood of actually sticking with the plan. Don't just memorize what each method does—know why someone would choose one over another and what financial principle each strategy leverages.

---

Interest-Focused Strategies

These methods prioritize minimizing the total cost of debt by targeting high-interest balances first. The underlying principle is simple: every dollar of interest you don't pay is a dollar that stays in your pocket.

Debt Avalanche Method

• Targets highest-interest debt first—you list all debts by interest rate and attack the most expensive one while making minimums on everything else
• Mathematically optimal for minimizing total interest paid over the life of your debts
• Requires patience since your highest-rate debt may also be your largest, meaning early wins take longer to achieve

Debt Acceleration

• Making payments above the minimum—any extra amount goes directly toward principal, reducing the base on which interest compounds
• Works with any repayment method as a turbo-charge; combine it with avalanche or snowball for faster results
• Requires sustainable budgeting to ensure you're not sacrificing emergency funds or essential expenses for aggressive payoff

---

Psychology-Driven Strategies

Behavioral finance research shows that motivation matters as much as math. These methods leverage quick wins and emotional momentum to keep you engaged in the repayment process.

Debt Snowball Method

• Smallest balance first—ignore interest rates and eliminate your lowest-balance debt as fast as possible
• Creates psychological momentum through quick wins that release dopamine and reinforce positive financial behavior
• Costs more in total interest than the avalanche method, but higher completion rates may offset this for people who struggle with long-term discipline

Debt Stacking

• Personal priority ordering—you choose which debts to attack based on emotional burden, relationship stress, or other non-financial factors
• Flexible hybrid approach that might target a debt to an ex-spouse or a loan from family before higher-rate debts
• Acknowledges that money is emotional—sometimes eliminating a psychologically painful debt improves your overall financial behavior

Debt Snowflaking

• Micro-payments from windfalls—tax refunds, birthday cash, sold items, or work bonuses go directly toward debt
• No strict budget required—you simply redirect "found money" rather than committing to fixed extra payments
• Best as a supplement to another primary strategy; snowflaking alone rarely provides enough structure for serious debt reduction

---

Restructuring Strategies

These methods change the terms of your debt rather than just the payment order. They work by negotiating new rates, combining balances, or settling for less than owed.

Debt Consolidation

• Combines multiple debts into one loan—ideally at a lower weighted-average interest rate than your current debts
• Simplifies cash flow management by replacing several due dates and creditors with a single monthly payment
• May extend repayment timeline—lower monthly payments can mean more total interest if you don't accelerate; watch for origination fees

Balance Transfer

• Moves high-interest credit card debt to a new card offering 0% APR promotional periods (typically 12–21 months)
• Can eliminate interest entirely during the promotional window if you pay off the balance before it expires
• Hidden costs include transfer fees (usually 3–5% of the balance) and deferred interest if you miss the payoff deadline

---

Third-Party Assistance Strategies

When debt becomes unmanageable, outside help can provide structure, negotiation power, or settlement options. These methods involve working with credit counselors or creditors directly.

Debt Management Plans (DMPs)

• Administered by nonprofit credit counseling agencies—they negotiate lower interest rates and create a structured 3–5 year repayment schedule
• Single monthly payment goes to the agency, which distributes funds to your creditors
• Requires closing credit accounts in the plan, which can temporarily impact credit scores and spending flexibility

Debt Settlement

• Negotiating to pay less than owed—creditors may accept 40–60% of the balance as full payment, especially on severely delinquent accounts
• Significant credit score damage because settlement typically requires you to stop paying while negotiating, leading to missed payment records
• Tax implications—forgiven debt over $600$ is considered taxable income by the IRS

---

The Baseline (What Not to Do Long-Term)

Understanding the default approach helps you see why active strategies matter.

Minimum Payment Method

• Pays only the required minimum—keeps accounts current and avoids late fees but barely touches principal
• Maximizes total interest paid because low payments extend repayment for decades; a $5,000$ balance at 18% APR takes 30+ years paying minimums
• Only appropriate short-term during financial emergencies when cash flow is critically limited

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two methods prioritize mathematical optimization over psychological motivation, and what principle do they share?

2. A client has five credit cards with balances ranging from $500$ to $8,000$ and interest rates from 12% to 24%. They've tried budgeting before but always quit after a few months. Which repayment method would you recommend and why?

3. Compare and contrast debt consolidation and balance transfers: what type of borrower benefits most from each, and what risks does each carry?

4. Why might debt settlement result in a tax bill, and how does this connect to the IRS definition of income?

5. An FRQ asks you to calculate the total interest paid under the minimum payment method versus the debt avalanche method for the same debt load. What variables would you need, and which method would show lower total cost?