Why This Matters
Consumer behavior models are the theoretical backbone of every marketing decision you'll encounter on the exam. These frameworks explain why people buy what they buy, how they process marketing messages, and what triggers them to take action. You're being tested on your ability to apply these models to real marketing scenarios—whether that's designing an ad campaign, launching a new product, or understanding why a customer abandoned their cart.
The models in this guide demonstrate core marketing principles: the decision-making process, psychological motivation, persuasion mechanics, and adoption patterns. Some models focus on the internal cognitive journey (what happens in the consumer's mind), while others emphasize external influences (social pressure, marketing stimuli, situational factors). Don't just memorize the names and stages—know what concept each model illustrates and when you'd apply one framework over another.
Decision-Making Process Models
These models map the sequential stages consumers move through when making purchases. The key insight is that buying isn't a single moment—it's a journey with multiple intervention points for marketers.
Engel-Kollat-Blackwell (EKB) Model
- Five-stage decision process—problem recognition, information search, evaluation of alternatives, purchase decision, and post-purchase evaluation form the core framework
- Integrates multiple influence layers including psychological factors (motivation, perception), social factors (family, reference groups), and environmental factors (culture, economic conditions)
- Feedback loops explain how post-purchase satisfaction shapes future buying behavior and brand loyalty
Consumer Decision-Making Process
- Five key stages mirror the EKB model: problem recognition → information search → evaluation → purchase → post-purchase behavior
- Iterative nature means consumers can revisit earlier stages when new information emerges or expectations aren't met
- Internal and external factors influence every stage—internal includes memory and attitudes; external includes social norms and marketing communications
Howard-Sheth Model
- Input-process-output structure—stimuli enter, cognitive and emotional processing occurs, purchase decisions emerge
- Individual characteristics like motivation, perception, and learning shape how consumers interpret identical marketing messages differently
- Decision-making units recognize that purchases often involve multiple influencers—critical for B2B marketing and family purchase decisions
Compare: EKB Model vs. Howard-Sheth Model—both describe decision stages, but EKB emphasizes the linear process while Howard-Sheth focuses on the psychological processing that happens at each stage. If an FRQ asks about how consumers evaluate information, lean toward Howard-Sheth.
Communication and Persuasion Models
These frameworks explain how marketing messages influence consumer attitudes and behaviors. The underlying principle is that persuasion follows predictable patterns based on message characteristics and audience involvement.
AIDA Model (Attention, Interest, Desire, Action)
- Four sequential stages guide consumers from awareness to purchase: capture Attention, build Interest, create Desire, prompt Action
- Advertising framework makes this essential for designing promotional campaigns and evaluating ad effectiveness
- Funnel logic explains why conversion rates drop at each stage—marketers must optimize for each transition
Nicosia Model
- Communication-centered approach focuses on the dialogue between marketers and consumers rather than just consumer psychology
- Four fields structure the process: consumer attributes, marketing communication, consumer response, and feedback to marketer
- Consumer involvement levels determine how deeply marketing messages are processed and whether attitudes actually shift
Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM)
- Two persuasion routes—the central route involves careful argument evaluation; the peripheral route relies on superficial cues like celebrity endorsers or visual appeal
- Motivation and ability determine which route consumers take—high involvement triggers central processing; low involvement triggers peripheral
- Message tailoring means luxury car ads might use detailed specifications (central) while gum ads use catchy jingles (peripheral)
Compare: AIDA vs. ELM—AIDA describes what stages consumers move through, while ELM explains how deeply they process messages at each stage. Use AIDA for campaign structure; use ELM for message design based on audience involvement.
Stimulus-Response Models
These models treat consumer behavior as reactions to external triggers. The core assumption is that the right stimulus, delivered correctly, produces predictable behavioral responses.
Stimulus-Response Model
- Behaviorist foundation—consumers respond to external stimuli (ads, packaging, price signals) in patterns that can be studied and predicted
- Stimulus identification is the marketer's primary task—understanding which triggers prompt attention, consideration, and purchase
- Action-oriented framework is particularly useful for direct response marketing and promotional campaigns
Kotler's Black Box Model
- Internal processing mystery—the "black box" represents the consumer's mind where stimuli are transformed into responses through unobservable processes
- Inference-based marketing means marketers study inputs (stimuli) and outputs (behaviors) to deduce what happens inside
- Consumer characteristics and decision processes within the black box include cultural, social, personal, and psychological factors
Hawkins Stern Impulse Buying Model
- Unplanned purchase focus examines why consumers buy things they didn't intend to—critical for retail and e-commerce strategy
- Four impulse types: pure impulse, reminder impulse, suggestion impulse, and planned impulse buying
- Situational triggers like emotional states, store layout, and product placement drive spontaneous purchases
Compare: Kotler's Black Box vs. Stimulus-Response Model—both use S-R logic, but Kotler explicitly acknowledges we can't see inside the consumer's mind, while the basic S-R model focuses purely on observable stimulus-response relationships. Kotler's version is more realistic for complex purchases.
Motivation and Needs-Based Models
These frameworks explain the underlying drives that push consumers toward certain products and brands. The key principle is that all purchasing behavior stems from attempts to satisfy needs—whether basic or aspirational.
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs
- Five-level pyramid arranges needs from basic to complex: physiological → safety → social/belonging → esteem → self-actualization
- Sequential fulfillment suggests consumers address lower-level needs before pursuing higher-level ones—though marketing often appeals to multiple levels simultaneously
- Product positioning applications are everywhere: insurance ads target safety needs; luxury brands target esteem; education platforms target self-actualization
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA)
- Behavioral intention is predicted by two factors: personal attitudes toward the behavior and subjective norms (what important others think)
- Social influence recognition makes this model valuable for products with strong social visibility or approval components
- Prediction applications include brand loyalty, product adoption, and understanding why consumers say one thing but do another
Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB)
- Extends TRA by adding perceived behavioral control—whether consumers believe they can actually perform the behavior
- Three-factor prediction: attitudes + subjective norms + perceived control = behavioral intention
- Uncertainty contexts make TPB superior to TRA—use this when consumers face barriers like price, availability, or skill requirements
Compare: TRA vs. TPB—TPB adds perceived behavioral control, making it better for predicting behavior when consumers face real or perceived obstacles. If an exam question involves barriers to purchase (cost, complexity, access), TPB is your framework.
Adoption and Innovation Models
These models explain how new products spread through markets and why different consumers adopt at different times. The underlying insight is that innovation acceptance follows predictable patterns based on consumer characteristics and product attributes.
Diffusion of Innovation Theory
- Five adopter categories segment consumers by adoption timing: innovators (2.5%), early adopters (13.5%), early majority (34%), late majority (34%), laggards (16%)
- Innovation characteristics that speed diffusion include relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability, and observability
- Marketing strategy implications—target innovators and early adopters first; use their influence to reach the majority
Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)
- Two key predictors of technology adoption: perceived usefulness (will this help me?) and perceived ease of use (can I figure this out?)
- Attitude formation flows from these perceptions to behavioral intention to actual use
- Tech marketing applications explain why user-friendly interfaces and clear benefit communication drive adoption rates
Kano Model
- Five feature categories predict customer satisfaction: basic needs (expected), performance needs (the more, the better), excitement needs (delighters), indifferent needs (don't care), and reverse needs (actively disliked)
- Satisfaction asymmetry—basic needs only cause dissatisfaction when absent; excitement needs only cause satisfaction when present
- Product development guidance helps marketers prioritize features that differentiate rather than just meet baseline expectations
Compare: Diffusion of Innovation vs. TAM—Diffusion explains who adopts and when across a population; TAM explains why individuals decide to adopt based on perceived usefulness and ease. Use Diffusion for market segmentation strategy; use TAM for product design and messaging.
Quick Reference Table
|
| Decision-making stages | EKB Model, Consumer Decision-Making Process, Howard-Sheth Model |
| Persuasion mechanics | ELM, AIDA Model, Nicosia Model |
| Stimulus-response behavior | Kotler's Black Box, Stimulus-Response Model, Hawkins Stern Model |
| Motivation and needs | Maslow's Hierarchy, TRA, TPB |
| Innovation adoption | Diffusion of Innovation, TAM, Kano Model |
| Social influence factors | TRA, TPB, Howard-Sheth Model |
| Impulse and emotional buying | Hawkins Stern Model, Stimulus-Response Model |
| Technology and new products | TAM, Diffusion of Innovation, Kano Model |
Self-Check Questions
-
Which two models both incorporate social influence on consumer decisions, and how do they differ in their treatment of it? (Hint: Think about TRA, TPB, and Howard-Sheth)
-
A marketer is designing an ad campaign for a low-involvement product like chewing gum. According to the Elaboration Likelihood Model, which persuasion route should they prioritize, and why?
-
Compare and contrast the EKB Model and Kotler's Black Box Model. Both address decision-making, but what fundamental assumption distinguishes them?
-
Using Diffusion of Innovation Theory, explain why a tech startup might initially target a small market segment rather than the mass market. Which adopter categories should they focus on first?
-
An FRQ asks you to explain why a consumer might have a positive attitude toward buying an electric vehicle but still not purchase one. Which model best addresses this gap, and what specific factor does it add to explain the discrepancy?