Causal Forecasting Methods

Why This Matters

Causal forecasting goes beyond asking "what happened?" to answer the more powerful question: "what causes what?" In Business Forecasting, you're being tested on your ability to select the right method based on the nature of your data, the relationships you're modeling, and the business question you're trying to answer. Understanding these methods means recognizing when a simple linear approach suffices versus when you need to account for time dependencies, categorical variables, or complex nonlinear patterns.

These techniques form the backbone of data-driven decision-making across industries—from predicting sales based on advertising spend to forecasting demand across multiple product lines simultaneously. Don't just memorize formulas and model names; know what type of relationship each method captures, when to use each approach, and how to interpret the results for business stakeholders. That conceptual clarity is what separates strong exam performance from mere recall.

---

Linear Regression Foundations

These methods assume that relationships between variables can be captured with straight-line equations. The core principle is that changes in independent variables produce proportional changes in the dependent variable.

Simple Linear Regression

• Models one predictor-one outcome relationships—expressed as $Y = \beta_0 + \beta_1X + \epsilon$, where the slope coefficient shows the unit change in Y for each unit change in X
• Coefficient interpretation is straightforward—a slope of 2.5 means each additional unit of X increases Y by 2.5 units, making it ideal for communicating findings to non-technical stakeholders
• Best for initial exploration—use when you suspect a single dominant driver before adding complexity with multiple predictors

Multiple Linear Regression

• Incorporates multiple independent variables—the equation $Y = \beta_0 + \beta_1X_1 + \beta_2X_2 + ... + \beta_nX_n + \epsilon$ allows you to isolate each variable's effect while holding others constant
• Controls for confounding factors—essential when business outcomes depend on several interrelated drivers like price, advertising, and seasonality simultaneously
• Reveals relative importance—standardized coefficients let you compare which predictors have the strongest influence on your forecast

Dummy Variable Regression

• Converts categorical data into binary indicators—transforms qualitative factors (region, product category, promotion type) into 0/1 variables that regression can process
• Enables group comparisons—coefficients show how much being in one category shifts the outcome compared to a reference group
• Critical for marketing and operations—allows you to quantify the sales lift from a promotion or the cost difference between suppliers

---

Time-Dependent Methods

When your data has a temporal structure, standard regression assumptions break down. These methods explicitly account for the fact that observations close in time tend to be related to each other.

Time Series Regression

• Adds time-based predictors to regression—incorporates trend variables, seasonal dummies, and lagged values to capture temporal patterns
• Handles autocorrelation—recognizes that this month's sales are likely correlated with last month's, violating standard regression assumptions
• Bridges regression and time series—useful when you want to include both causal predictors (like price) and time patterns in one model

Autoregressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA)

• Combines three components—autoregression (past values predict future), differencing (removes trends to achieve stationarity), and moving averages (past forecast errors inform current predictions)
• Notation (p, d, q) defines model structure—p is the number of autoregressive terms, d is differencing order, q is moving average terms; selecting these requires analyzing ACF and PACF plots
• Excels at univariate forecasting—when you have strong historical patterns but limited causal predictors, ARIMA often outperforms regression

Vector Autoregression (VAR)

• Models multiple time series simultaneously—captures how variables like sales, inventory, and marketing spend influence each other over time
• Enables impulse response analysis—shows how a shock to one variable (like a price change) ripples through the entire system across future periods
• Requires all variables to be endogenous—treats every variable as both a predictor and an outcome, unlike regression where roles are fixed

---

Nonlinear and Classification Methods

Not all relationships follow straight lines, and not all outcomes are continuous numbers. These methods handle curved relationships and categorical outcomes that linear approaches miss.

Nonlinear Regression

• Captures curved relationships—models exponential growth ($Y = ae^{bX}$), logarithmic diminishing returns ($Y = a + b\ln(X)$), or polynomial patterns that linear models cannot represent
• Requires specifying functional form—unlike linear regression, you must hypothesize the shape of the relationship before estimation
• Common in product lifecycle forecasting—growth curves, saturation models, and decay functions all require nonlinear specifications

Logistic Regression

• Predicts probability of binary outcomes—models whether an event occurs (purchase/no purchase, default/no default) rather than a continuous value
• Uses log-odds transformation—the equation $\ln\left(\frac{p}{1-p}\right) = \beta_0 + \beta_1X_1 + ...$ ensures predicted probabilities stay between 0 and 1
• Essential for classification tasks—customer churn prediction, credit scoring, and campaign response modeling all rely on logistic regression foundations

---

Advanced and Hybrid Approaches

These methods combine multiple techniques or leverage computational power to handle complexity that simpler models cannot capture. They're often used when traditional methods hit accuracy ceilings or when data relationships are too intricate for explicit specification.

Econometric Models

• Grounds forecasting in economic theory—unlike purely statistical approaches, econometric models specify relationships based on theoretical frameworks about how markets and agents behave
• Addresses endogeneity problems—uses techniques like instrumental variables and simultaneous equations when predictors are correlated with error terms
• Handles structural breaks—can model regime changes (like policy shifts or market disruptions) that would bias simpler approaches

Machine Learning Techniques

• Learns patterns without explicit specification—algorithms like neural networks and random forests discover relationships in data rather than requiring you to specify functional forms
• Handles high-dimensional data—can incorporate hundreds of predictors and automatically identify which matter most through techniques like feature importance
• Trades interpretability for accuracy—often produces superior forecasts but with "black box" mechanisms that are harder to explain to stakeholders

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. You have sales data influenced by both advertising spend and seasonal promotions (a categorical variable). Which two methods would you combine, and why?

2. Compare and contrast ARIMA and VAR: When would you choose each, and what fundamental assumption differs between them?

3. A marketing manager wants to predict whether customers will respond to a campaign (yes/no). Why would linear regression be inappropriate, and what method should you recommend?

4. Your scatterplot shows sales increasing rapidly at first, then leveling off as the market saturates. Which regression approach captures this pattern, and what functional form might you specify?

5. An FRQ asks you to forecast quarterly revenue while accounting for how revenue, inventory levels, and marketing budgets all influence each other over time. Which method is designed specifically for this scenario, and what key output would you analyze?