Atomic Structure Models

Why This Matters

The history of atomic models isn't just a timeline to memorize—it's a story of how scientists refined their understanding through experimental evidence. You're being tested on your ability to explain why each model was proposed, what evidence supported it, and what limitations led to the next model. This progression demonstrates the scientific method in action and connects directly to modern concepts like electron configurations, quantum numbers, and spectral analysis.

Each model builds on the last, and AP Chemistry expects you to understand the conceptual leaps between them. When you encounter questions about Coulombic attraction, energy quantization, or orbital shapes, you're applying ideas that emerged from this historical development. Don't just memorize names and dates—know what experimental evidence drove each change and how each model explains (or fails to explain) atomic behavior.

---

Early Particle Models: Establishing Atoms as Real

These foundational models established that matter is composed of discrete particles and began revealing their internal structure. The key insight was moving from philosophical speculation to experimental evidence.

Dalton's Atomic Theory

• Atoms are indivisible and indestructible—the smallest unit of an element that retains its chemical identity
• Atoms of the same element are identical in mass and properties, while different elements have different atomic masses
• Atoms combine in whole-number ratios to form compounds, explaining the law of definite proportions and conservation of mass

Thomson's Plum Pudding Model

• First model to include subatomic particles—discovered electrons through cathode ray experiments, disproving Dalton's indivisibility claim
• Positive charge distributed uniformly throughout the atom with electrons embedded like "plums in pudding"
• Atoms are electrically neutral overall, introducing the concept that positive and negative charges must balance

---

The Nuclear Atom: Discovering the Nucleus

Rutherford's work fundamentally changed our picture of atomic structure by revealing that mass and positive charge are concentrated in a tiny central region. This explained why most alpha particles passed through gold foil while some deflected dramatically.

Rutherford's Nuclear Model

• Gold foil experiment revealed the nucleus—most alpha particles passed through, but rare large-angle deflections indicated a small, dense, positively charged center
• Atoms are mostly empty space with electrons orbiting a nucleus that contains nearly all the atom's mass
• Coulombic attraction between the positive nucleus and negative electrons keeps the atom together, introducing electrostatic forces into atomic theory

---

Quantized Energy: Explaining Atomic Spectra

Bohr's model addressed a critical flaw in Rutherford's picture: classical physics predicted that orbiting electrons should continuously emit radiation and spiral into the nucleus. Quantization solved this by restricting electrons to specific energy levels.

Bohr's Atomic Model

• Electrons occupy fixed energy levels (shells) at specific distances from the nucleus, labeled by principal quantum number $n$
• Energy is quantized—electrons can only exist in discrete states, and transitions between levels emit or absorb photons of specific energies: $\Delta E = h\nu$
• Successfully explained hydrogen's line spectrum but failed for multi-electron atoms due to electron-electron repulsions not accounted for

---

The Modern Quantum Model: Probability and Orbitals

The quantum mechanical model replaced fixed orbits with probability distributions, recognizing that electrons exhibit wave-particle duality. This framework underlies everything you learn about electron configurations and periodic trends.

Quantum Mechanical Model (Electron Cloud Model)

• Electrons exist in probability clouds called orbitals, not fixed paths—we can only predict where an electron is likely to be found
• Governed by four quantum numbers ($n$, $l$, $m_l$, $m_s$) that describe energy, shape, orientation, and spin of each electron
• Explains electron configurations using Aufbau principle, Pauli exclusion principle, and Hund's rule—directly connecting to periodic trends

Schrödinger's Wave Equation

• Wave function $\psi$ describes electron behavior—solving $\hat{H}\psi = E\psi$ gives allowed energy states and orbital shapes
• $|\psi|^2$ represents probability density—the likelihood of finding an electron at a given location, creating the familiar s, p, d, f orbital shapes
• Accounts for wave-particle duality and accurately predicts properties of multi-electron atoms, unlike Bohr's model

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. Which two models both feature electrons orbiting a central nucleus, and what key concept distinguishes them?

2. What experimental evidence from Rutherford's gold foil experiment specifically disproved Thomson's plum pudding model?

3. Compare and contrast Bohr's model and the quantum mechanical model in terms of how they describe electron location—why does only one work for multi-electron atoms?

4. If an FRQ asks you to explain why atoms emit light at only specific wavelengths, which model provides the best explanation and what key term must you include?

5. Arrange Dalton, Thomson, Rutherford, and Bohr in order, and identify the experimental evidence or conceptual problem that prompted each transition to the next model.