American Exceptionalism

Definition

American exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is inherently different from other nations, often characterized by a unique set of ideals, political systems, and historical experiences that shape its identity. This concept is closely tied to notions of democracy, liberty, and the idea that America has a special role in promoting these values globally. The belief in American exceptionalism can influence foreign policy decisions and domestic attitudes toward national identity and purpose.

5 Must Know Facts For Your Next Test

1. American exceptionalism emerged as a distinct idea during the early 19th century and has roots in the Puritan belief that America was a 'city upon a hill' meant to exemplify moral and political ideals.
2. The concept has often been invoked to justify military interventions and expansionist policies, suggesting that America has a moral obligation to spread democracy and freedom.
3. Critics argue that American exceptionalism can lead to a sense of superiority and entitlement, sometimes ignoring the complexities of global issues and undermining diplomatic relations.
4. The idea is often linked to historical events like the overthrow of Queen Liliuokalani, where the U.S. justified its involvement in Hawaii's political changes through a lens of spreading democracy.
5. American exceptionalism continues to influence contemporary discussions about national identity, immigration policy, and international relations, shaping how citizens view their country's role on the world stage.

Review Questions

• How did American exceptionalism influence U.S. foreign policy during the late 19th century, particularly in relation to Hawaii?
  • American exceptionalism significantly influenced U.S. foreign policy during the late 19th century by framing America's role as a promoter of democracy and civilization. In the case of Hawaii, American interests sought to overthrow Queen Liliuokalani under the justification that establishing a pro-American government would bring stability and progress. This mindset reflects how beliefs in American superiority drove expansionist policies and interventions in foreign governments.
• What are some criticisms of American exceptionalism, particularly concerning its impact on international relations?
  • Critics of American exceptionalism argue that it fosters an attitude of superiority and entitlement among Americans, which can lead to neglecting global perspectives. This mindset may cause the U.S. to overlook diplomatic avenues in favor of unilateral actions, ultimately straining international relations. By viewing itself as an arbiter of democracy, the U.S. might engage in interventions without fully considering the consequences for affected nations.
• Evaluate how the belief in American exceptionalism has shaped contemporary debates around immigration policy in the U.S.
  • The belief in American exceptionalism has played a crucial role in shaping contemporary debates around immigration policy by framing America as a unique land of opportunity. Proponents argue that accepting immigrants aligns with America's foundational ideals of liberty and equality, suggesting that newcomers contribute to its exceptional nature. Conversely, critics contend that this belief can lead to exclusionary policies, arguing that not all immigrants are seen as equally contributing to or deserving of this 'exceptional' status, which complicates discussions about national identity and inclusivity.

Related terms

Manifest Destiny: The 19th-century doctrine that the expansion of the United States across the American continents was both justified and inevitable, reflecting a belief in the nation's unique destiny.

Isolationism: A foreign policy approach that advocates for a nation to avoid involvement in international affairs, focusing instead on domestic issues and self-reliance.

Nationalism: A political ideology that emphasizes loyalty and devotion to a nation, often in relation to its culture, language, or interests, which can sometimes overlap with ideas of exceptionalism.