🇺🇸ap us history review
5.4 The Compromise of 1850
Verified for the 2025 AP US History exam•Citation:MLA
Following the Mexican-American War, the United States faced increasingly difficult questions about how to organize the newly acquired western territories. The Compromise of 1850 represented a major attempt to resolve these tensions and preserve the Union, though it would ultimately prove to be only a temporary solution.
The Problem: New Land, Old Conflicts
The massive territorial gains from the Mexican Cession created an immediate political crisis. As Americans rushed to settle these new lands, politicians scrambled to determine whether slavery would be permitted there.
- Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo (1848) added vast new territories to the United States
- California Gold Rush (1849) brought thousands of settlers to the region
- California applied for statehood as a free state in 1849
- No slave state was seeking admission at the same time
- Adding California would upset the delicate balance of free and slave states in the Senate
- Southerners feared losing political power and influence
- Northerners opposed slavery's expansion into new territories
- Some politicians feared the Union might break apart over these tensions
The Great Compromise: Five Key Provisions
Henry Clay, Daniel Webster, and Stephen Douglas—three of the era's most influential statesmen—worked to craft a compromise that would address concerns from both North and South. The final agreement included five separate bills passed in September 1850:
-
California admitted as a free state
- Victory for the North
- Tipped the balance in the Senate toward free states
-
New, stronger Fugitive Slave Act
- Victory for the South
- Federal government now responsible for capturing and returning escaped slaves
- Northern citizens required to help capture fugitive slaves
- Denied accused runaway slaves the right to a trial by jury
-
End to the slave trade (but not slavery itself) in Washington D.C.
- Modest victory for the North
- Slavery continued to exist in the nation's capital
-
Texas/New Mexico boundary dispute settled
- Resolved in favor of New Mexico (non-slave territory)
- Texas received $10 million as compensation
-
Popular sovereignty in Utah and New Mexico territories
- Allowed residents to decide whether to permit slavery
- Seemed fair in theory but would lead to problems later
Popular Sovereignty: A Flawed Solution
The principle of popular sovereignty was promoted as a democratic solution to the slavery question in the territories, but it contained serious flaws that would become apparent in the years following the compromise.
- Allowed voting residents of a territory to decide whether to permit slavery
- Didn't specify when during the territorial process this decision would be made
- Left open questions about the status of slavery during territorial organization
- Would later lead to violence in Kansas in the mid-1850s
Public Response and Reactions
The Compromise produced mixed reactions across the nation, with some seeing it as a breakthrough and others viewing it as a betrayal.
- Initially celebrated as saving the Union from immediate danger
- President Millard Fillmore supported and enforced the compromise
- Many moderate Americans in both sections supported the agreement
- Abolitionists strongly opposed the Fugitive Slave Act
- Some Southerners felt it didn't adequately protect their interests
- Political leaders hoped the compromise would settle the slavery issue permanently
Why the Compromise Failed
Despite high hopes, the Compromise of 1850 unraveled within just four years of its passage, proving to be only a temporary solution to the nation's deepening divisions.
-
Fugitive Slave Act created intense Northern backlash
- Many Northerners refused to comply with the law
- Some actively helped runaway slaves (Underground Railroad)
- States passed "personal liberty laws" to obstruct the federal law
- Increased sympathy for abolitionists in the North
-
Continuing admission of free states without corresponding slave states
- Further shifted the balance of power away from the South
- Heightened Southern fears of being outvoted on slavery issues
-
Failed to address fundamental moral and economic divisions over slavery
- Compromise focused on political arrangements, not the deeper issues
- Did nothing to resolve opposing views on slavery's morality
-
Ambiguity of popular sovereignty led to further conflicts
- Later battles in Kansas demonstrated the problems with this approach
The Compromise of 1850 represented the last major attempt by the older generation of political leaders to resolve sectional differences through compromise. Although it temporarily preserved the Union, it ultimately failed to address the fundamental differences between North and South. Within a few years, new crises would emerge that would push the nation even closer to civil war.
🎥 Watch: APUSH - Sectional and Regional Differences
Key Terms to Review (15)
American Civil War: The American Civil War was a conflict fought from 1861 to 1865 between the Northern states (the Union) and the Southern states that seceded from the Union (the Confederacy). This war arose primarily from tensions over slavery, states' rights, and sectionalism, ultimately leading to significant political, social, and economic changes in the United States.
California Gold Rush: The California Gold Rush was a mass migration of an estimated 300,000 people to California between 1848 and 1855 after gold was discovered at Sutter's Mill in Coloma. This event significantly influenced the westward expansion of the United States, spurring economic growth and cultural exchange, while also intensifying conflicts over land and resources.
California: California is a state located on the West Coast of the United States, known for its diverse geography and significant historical role in shaping American culture and politics. Its rapid population growth during the 19th century, particularly during the Gold Rush, was crucial in influencing national debates over slavery, immigration, and territorial expansion.
Compromise Of 1850: The Compromise of 1850 was a set of legislative measures aimed at easing tensions between free and slave states after the Mexican-American War, which included California's admission as a free state and a stricter Fugitive Slave Law. This compromise sought to balance the interests of the North and South, addressing the ongoing sectional conflict and setting the stage for future disputes over slavery.
Daniel Webster: Daniel Webster was a prominent American statesman and orator in the early 19th century, known for his strong advocacy for the Union and his influential role in shaping national policies. His involvement in the Compromise of 1850 highlighted his commitment to preventing civil conflict over slavery and maintaining national unity amidst growing sectional tensions. Webster's speeches during this period helped to articulate the need for compromise and understanding between the North and South.
Fugitive Slave Act: The Fugitive Slave Act was a law passed in 1850 that required the return of runaway slaves to their owners and imposed penalties on anyone who aided their escape. This act intensified the sectional conflict between the North and South, as it mandated cooperation in the capture of fugitive slaves, which many in the North found morally objectionable. It was a significant part of the Compromise of 1850 and ultimately contributed to the failure of these compromises to resolve tensions over slavery.
Henry Clay: Henry Clay was a prominent American statesman, lawyer, and orator who served as a U.S. Congressman and Senator in the early 19th century. Known as the 'Great Compromiser' for his role in negotiating key legislative compromises, he played a vital role in shaping American politics and addressing sectional tensions during his time.
Mexican Cession: The Mexican Cession refers to the territory that Mexico ceded to the United States in 1848 following the Mexican–American War, which included present-day California, Nevada, Utah, Arizona, and parts of Colorado and New Mexico. This significant land acquisition not only expanded U.S. territory but also heightened tensions over slavery and contributed to the sectional conflicts leading up to the Civil War.
New Mexico Territory: The New Mexico Territory was a region created in 1850 following the Compromise of 1850, which aimed to resolve tensions between free and slave states in the U.S. The territory encompassed present-day New Mexico and parts of Colorado, Utah, and Arizona. Its establishment was significant in the ongoing debate over slavery's expansion into western territories, impacting the political landscape of the time.
Popular Sovereignty: Popular sovereignty is the political doctrine that the legitimacy of government is created and sustained by the consent of its people, typically expressed through their elected representatives. This principle was crucial in the debates over the expansion of slavery into new territories, as it empowered settlers in those areas to decide whether they would allow slavery or not, impacting key events leading up to the Civil War.
Stephen Douglas: Stephen Douglas was an influential American politician and leader of the Democratic Party in the mid-19th century, best known for his role in promoting the Compromise of 1850 and the Kansas-Nebraska Act. His advocacy for popular sovereignty, which allowed settlers in territories to decide the issue of slavery, intensified sectional conflict and set the stage for his significant involvement in the events leading up to the Civil War.
Texas: Texas is a large state in the southern United States, which was originally part of Mexico before declaring independence in 1836. It became a significant player in the national debate over slavery, especially during the discussions leading up to the Compromise of 1850, as its status as a slave state was a contentious issue that shaped political alliances and tensions between free and slave states.
Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo: The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo was an 1848 agreement that ended the Mexican–American War and resulted in the U.S. acquiring a vast amount of territory. This treaty significantly altered the geographical and political landscape of North America, transferring present-day California, Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada, Utah, and parts of Colorado and Wyoming from Mexico to the United States. It also established the Rio Grande as the border between Texas and Mexico.
Utah Territory: The Utah Territory was a designated area established in 1850, created following the Compromise of 1850 to organize the land acquired from the Mexican-American War. It was significant as a place for Mormon settlement, providing refuge for members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints seeking to escape religious persecution. The territory played a crucial role in the larger narrative of westward expansion as settlers moved to claim land and establish new communities.
Washington DC: Washington DC is the capital city of the United States, established as a federal district in 1790. It serves as the political center of the country, housing all three branches of government, including the White House, the Capitol, and the Supreme Court. The city's creation and its location were part of a compromise between northern and southern states, reflecting tensions over issues like slavery and governance during the formation of the nation.