Fiveable
Fiveable
Business Microeconomics

📈business microeconomics review

13.2 Market efficiency and anomalies

Last Updated on July 30, 2024

Market efficiency is a key concept in financial markets, measuring how well asset prices reflect available information. The Efficient Market Hypothesis suggests it's tough to beat the market consistently, as prices quickly adjust to new info. This impacts investment strategies and corporate finance.

Market efficiency comes in three forms: weak, semi-strong, and strong. Each level reflects different amounts of information in prices. Despite this theory, market anomalies exist, like the size effect and January effect, challenging the idea of perfect efficiency.

Market Efficiency and Asset Prices

Concept of Market Efficiency

Top images from around the web for Concept of Market Efficiency
Top images from around the web for Concept of Market Efficiency
  • Market efficiency measures how asset prices reflect all available market information
  • Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) states financial markets are informationally efficient
    • Makes consistently outperforming the market impossible
  • Asset prices in efficient markets quickly adjust to new information
    • Limits opportunities to exploit mispricing
  • Current prices represent best estimate of asset's intrinsic value based on available information
  • Challenges effectiveness of technical and fundamental analysis for excess returns
  • Impacts corporate finance concepts
    • Suggests dividend policy and capital structure irrelevance in perfect markets

Implications for Asset Pricing

  • Asset prices rapidly incorporate new information in efficient markets
  • Price movements become more random and unpredictable
  • Fundamental analysis may not provide significant advantages
  • Technical analysis loses effectiveness in predicting future price movements
  • Risk-adjusted returns tend to equalize across different assets and strategies
  • Market efficiency promotes more accurate asset valuation
    • Reduces instances of severe mispricing or bubbles

Forms of Market Efficiency

Weak-Form Efficiency

  • Asset prices reflect all historical price and volume information
  • Renders technical analysis ineffective for generating excess returns
  • Future price movements cannot be predicted using past price patterns or trading volume
  • Challenges strategies based on identifying trends or cycles in historical data
  • Examples of ineffective strategies in weak-form efficient markets:
    • Moving average crossovers
    • Relative strength indicators

Semi-Strong Form Efficiency

  • Asset prices incorporate all publicly available information
    • Includes financial statements, economic reports, and news releases
  • Fundamental analysis unlikely to consistently generate excess returns
  • Public information rapidly reflected in prices, limiting arbitrage opportunities
  • Challenges strategies relying on public information analysis
  • Examples of publicly available information reflected in prices:
    • Earnings announcements
    • Macroeconomic indicators (GDP growth, inflation rates)

Strong-Form Efficiency

  • Asset prices reflect all information, both public and private
  • Impossible for anyone to consistently outperform the market
  • Even insider information provides no advantage
    • Prices instantly adjust to reflect new information
  • Represents the highest level of market efficiency
  • Encompasses weak-form and semi-strong form efficiencies
  • Examples of private information in strong-form efficient markets:
    • Upcoming merger announcements
    • Unreleased financial projections

Market Anomalies and Causes

Common Market Anomalies

  • Size effect shows small-cap stocks historically outperform large-cap stocks long-term
  • Value effect reveals stocks with low price-to-book ratios outperform high ratio stocks
  • January effect demonstrates higher stock returns in January, especially for small-caps
  • Momentum anomaly indicates recent high (low) performers continue trend short-term
  • Post-earnings announcement drift shows stock prices continue moving in direction of earnings surprise
  • Examples of other market anomalies:
    • Weekend effect (lower returns on Mondays)
    • Holiday effect (higher returns before market holidays)

Causes of Market Anomalies

  • Behavioral finance theories explain anomalies through psychological biases
    • Overconfidence, loss aversion, herding behavior
  • Risk factors not captured by traditional asset pricing models
    • Liquidity risk, distress risk
  • Market frictions limit perfect efficiency
    • Transaction costs, taxes, short-selling constraints
  • Limits to arbitrage prevent complete elimination of mispricing
    • Capital constraints, implementation costs
  • Data mining and statistical artifacts may create apparent anomalies
  • Examples of behavioral biases contributing to anomalies:
    • Disposition effect (tendency to sell winners too early and hold losers too long)
    • Anchoring bias (relying too heavily on one piece of information when making decisions)

Implications of Market Efficiency for Investment

Investment Strategies

  • Passive strategies (index investing) often more effective than active management
  • Diversification benefits outweigh individual stock selection in portfolio management
  • Challenges value of professional money managers and analysts for superior returns
  • Affects effectiveness of trading strategies
    • Momentum investing
    • Contrarian approaches
  • Examples of passive investment strategies:
    • Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tracking broad market indices
    • Asset allocation based on modern portfolio theory

Market Participants and Regulation

  • Corporate insiders should not consistently profit from privileged information
    • Supports need for insider trading regulations
  • Crucial for regulators in designing fair and transparent financial market policies
  • Impacts corporate financial decisions
    • Timing and pricing of new security issuances
  • Influences market structure and trading mechanisms
  • Examples of regulatory implications:
    • Disclosure requirements for public companies
    • Circuit breakers to prevent extreme price movements