1.4 Critical geopolitics
5 min read•august 20, 2024
challenges traditional views of state power and territorial control. It examines how geopolitical knowledge is shaped by power relations and ideologies, questioning assumptions of objectivity in geopolitical thinking.
Key thinkers like Ó Tuathail, Dalby, and Sharp have developed critical approaches to geopolitics. These include analyzing discursive constructions of space, exploring links between geopolitics and environmental issues, and examining gender in geopolitical discourse.
Origins of critical geopolitics
- Emerged in the late 1980s and early 1990s as a response to traditional geopolitical thinking that focused on state power and territorial control
- Draws from critical social theory, poststructuralism, and postcolonial studies to interrogate the assumptions and power relations underlying geopolitical knowledge production
- Seeks to deconstruct and challenge dominant geopolitical discourses and practices, exposing their political and ideological nature
Key thinkers in critical geopolitics
- (Gerard Toal) developed the concept of "geo-power" and emphasized the need to analyze the discursive construction of geopolitical spaces and identities
- explored the links between geopolitics, security, and environmental issues, highlighting the importance of considering the ecological dimensions of global politics
- examined the gendered nature of geopolitical discourse and the ways in which women's experiences and perspectives are often marginalized in geopolitical analysis
Critique of traditional geopolitics
Challenging assumptions of objectivity
Top images from around the web for Challenging assumptions of objectivity
Public Opinion: How is it formed? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
File:SLECO chart.png View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The ideological divide and climate change opinion: “top-down” and “bottom-up ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Public Opinion: How is it formed? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
File:SLECO chart.png View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Challenging assumptions of objectivity
Public Opinion: How is it formed? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
File:SLECO chart.png View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The ideological divide and climate change opinion: “top-down” and “bottom-up ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Public Opinion: How is it formed? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
File:SLECO chart.png View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Questions the notion that geopolitical knowledge is neutral, objective, or value-free
- Argues that geopolitical theories and practices are always situated within specific historical, cultural, and political contexts
- Emphasizes the need to critically examine the power relations and ideological assumptions that shape geopolitical thinking
Exposing power relations
- Highlights the ways in which geopolitical discourses and practices serve to legitimize and reproduce unequal power relations between states, regions, and social groups
- Analyzes how geopolitical knowledge is used to justify and naturalize forms of domination, exploitation, and exclusion
- Investigates the role of geopolitical expertise in shaping foreign policy decisions and public opinion
Discourse analysis in critical geopolitics
Deconstructing geopolitical texts
- Applies techniques of to examine the language, metaphors, and narratives used in geopolitical texts (policy documents, speeches, media reports)
- Reveals the underlying assumptions, biases, and power relations embedded in these texts
- Explores how geopolitical discourses construct particular representations of places, peoples, and events
Examining popular culture representations
- Extends the analysis of geopolitical discourse to include popular culture forms such as films, television shows, video games, and social media
- Investigates how these representations shape public understandings and imaginaries of global politics
- Considers the ways in which popular culture can both reinforce and challenge dominant geopolitical narratives
Feminist approaches to critical geopolitics
Gender and geopolitical discourse
- Examines the gendered nature of geopolitical discourse and practice, highlighting the ways in which masculinist assumptions and values often underpin geopolitical thinking
- Explores how gender identities and relations are constructed and negotiated through geopolitical processes
- Analyzes the marginalization and exclusion of women's voices and experiences in geopolitical analysis and decision-making
Embodiment and everyday experiences
- Emphasizes the importance of considering the embodied and everyday dimensions of geopolitics, moving beyond a focus on state-level actors and processes
- Investigates how geopolitical dynamics shape the lived experiences of individuals and communities, particularly those who are marginalized or oppressed
- Explores the ways in which everyday practices of resistance and solidarity can challenge dominant geopolitical power relations
Postcolonial perspectives in critical geopolitics
Decentering Western dominance
- Critiques the Eurocentrism and colonial legacies that have shaped much of traditional geopolitical thinking
- Seeks to decenter Western perspectives and knowledge claims, foregrounding the voices and experiences of people in the Global South
- Highlights the ongoing effects of colonialism and imperialism in shaping contemporary geopolitical relations and imaginaries
Subaltern geographies and resistance
- Examines the geopolitics of marginalized and oppressed groups, such as indigenous peoples, refugees, and ethnic minorities
- Explores the ways in which these groups navigate and resist dominant geopolitical power structures
- Investigates forms of subaltern agency and knowledge production that challenge hegemonic geopolitical discourses and practices
Critical geopolitics of borders and boundaries
Problematizing territorial divisions
- Questions the naturalness and inevitability of territorial borders and boundaries, highlighting their social and political construction
- Examines the ways in which borders are used to include and exclude, to control and regulate flows of people, goods, and ideas
- Explores the violence and inequality that often characterize border regions and borderland communities
Hybrid spaces and identities
- Investigates the emergence of hybrid and transnational spaces that challenge traditional understandings of and
- Examines the ways in which migration, diaspora, and cultural exchange produce new forms of identity and belonging that transcend national boundaries
- Explores the potential for these hybrid spaces and identities to disrupt and transform dominant geopolitical imaginaries
Critical geopolitics in the post-9/11 world
Security discourses and the "war on terror"
- Analyzes the geopolitical discourses and practices that have emerged in the wake of the September 11th attacks and the subsequent "war on terror"
- Examines how these discourses have been used to justify military interventions, security policies, and restrictions on civil liberties
- Investigates the ways in which the "war on terror" has reshaped global power relations and geopolitical imaginaries
Geopolitics of fear and surveillance
- Explores the ways in which fear and insecurity have become central to contemporary geopolitical discourses and practices
- Examines the proliferation of surveillance technologies and practices in the name of security, and their implications for privacy, freedom, and democracy
- Investigates the ways in which the geopolitics of fear and surveillance disproportionately impact marginalized and racialized communities
Future directions for critical geopolitics
Engaging with other critical theories
- Explores the potential for critical geopolitics to engage with and learn from other critical theoretical approaches, such as critical race theory, queer theory, and posthumanism
- Investigates the ways in which these approaches can enrich and expand the analytical and political horizons of critical geopolitics
- Considers the challenges and opportunities of developing more intersectional and interdisciplinary approaches to geopolitical analysis
Praxis and political activism
- Emphasizes the importance of linking critical geopolitical analysis to political practice and activism
- Explores the ways in which critical geopolitics can inform and support social movements, resistance struggles, and alternative political projects
- Investigates the potential for critical geopolitics to contribute to the development of more just, equitable, and sustainable forms of global politics
Key Terms to Review (20)
Borderlands: Borderlands are geographical areas that exist at the fringes of two or more distinct political entities, often marked by overlapping cultural, social, and economic interactions. These zones can serve as sites of conflict, cooperation, or identity formation, showcasing the complex relationships between neighboring regions. The unique characteristics of borderlands make them significant for understanding issues related to sovereignty, migration, and security.
Critical Geopolitics: Critical geopolitics is a field of study that examines the ways in which geopolitical knowledge is constructed and how it influences political power, identity, and conflict. It challenges traditional geopolitical narratives by emphasizing the importance of discourse, representation, and the social contexts in which geopolitical ideas are produced. This perspective connects to various aspects, such as how borders are perceived, the political implications of environmental change, and the experiences of displaced populations.
Deterritorialization: Deterritorialization refers to the process by which social, cultural, and political ties to specific geographic territories are weakened or removed. This concept highlights how globalization and advancements in technology can lead to a diminishing influence of borders and localities on people's identities and experiences. The idea underscores the fluid nature of geography in an interconnected world, where local contexts are increasingly shaped by global forces.
Discourse Analysis: Discourse analysis is a method used to study written or spoken communication by examining the language, context, and meaning behind the words. It investigates how language shapes social realities, power relations, and political ideologies. This approach is particularly important in understanding how geopolitical narratives are constructed and perpetuated, revealing underlying assumptions and biases in political discourse.
Ethnographic research: Ethnographic research is a qualitative method focused on exploring cultural phenomena by immersing researchers in the daily lives and environments of the subjects they study. It involves collecting detailed, in-depth information about people’s behaviors, beliefs, and social interactions through participant observation, interviews, and other immersive techniques. This approach is particularly valuable in understanding complex social dynamics and cultural contexts, especially within political geography.
Feminist geopolitics: Feminist geopolitics is a critical framework that examines how gender intersects with geographical and political processes, challenging traditional geopolitical narratives that often overlook women's experiences and perspectives. It emphasizes the importance of understanding power relations, security issues, and spatial practices through a feminist lens, advocating for inclusivity in geopolitical discussions.
Gearóid ó tuathail: Gearóid Ó Tuathail is a prominent Irish political geographer known for his contributions to critical geopolitics and the understanding of how power, identity, and space interact in global politics. His work emphasizes the importance of narratives and discourses in shaping geopolitical realities and challenges conventional approaches to international relations.
Geopolitical imaginations: Geopolitical imaginations refer to the ways in which individuals and societies perceive and conceptualize the political world, including the relationships between places, power, and identity. These imaginations influence how people understand global events, shape national narratives, and construct their own identities in relation to others. Essentially, they are the mental maps that guide people's interpretations of geopolitics and can be shaped by historical context, media representation, and cultural narratives.
Geopolitical rivalry: Geopolitical rivalry refers to the competition between nations or groups for power, influence, and control over geographical areas, resources, and strategic locations. This concept often involves the interplay of political, economic, and military factors that shape international relations and can lead to conflicts or cooperation among states. It highlights how geographical considerations impact global politics, revealing underlying tensions in various regions.
Globalization: Globalization is the process through which businesses, cultures, and economies become interconnected and integrated across global borders. It influences various aspects of society, including state formation, economic policies, and cultural exchanges, leading to a more interdependent world where local practices can be impacted by global dynamics.
Joanne Sharp: Joanne Sharp is a prominent scholar in the field of political geography, known for her contributions to critical geopolitics and the study of spatial relations in politics. Her work emphasizes the importance of understanding how geopolitical narratives are constructed and the implications these narratives have on identity and power dynamics in global contexts. Sharp's insights challenge traditional views of geopolitics, focusing instead on the social and cultural dimensions that shape geopolitical practices and representations.
Mapping practices: Mapping practices refer to the various methods and techniques used to create, interpret, and analyze maps in a geographic context. These practices involve not just the technical aspects of map-making but also the social and political implications of how maps are produced and used. By examining mapping practices, one can understand how geographic information shapes perceptions of space, power dynamics, and geopolitical narratives.
Militarization: Militarization refers to the process of a society or state becoming increasingly organized around military principles and preparing for armed conflict. This can involve the expansion of military capabilities, the integration of military practices into civilian life, and a heightened focus on national security. As societies militarize, there may be significant impacts on political policies, social structures, and cultural norms.
National Identity: National identity refers to a person's sense of belonging to a nation and the characteristics that define that nation, including shared culture, language, history, and values. It shapes how individuals perceive themselves in relation to their country and influences their loyalty and commitment to it. This concept is crucial for understanding various geopolitical issues, including the formation of states, conflicts driven by ethnic nationalism, and the critical evaluation of power dynamics in global politics.
Postcolonialism: Postcolonialism is an intellectual framework that examines the lasting impacts of colonialism on cultures, societies, and politics in formerly colonized countries. It critiques colonial narratives and power dynamics, focusing on issues of identity, representation, and the ongoing effects of colonial practices. This perspective connects deeply with the understanding of geopolitical relations, indigenous rights, and the voices of marginalized groups in historical and contemporary contexts.
Reterritorialization: Reterritorialization refers to the process through which a social, political, or cultural phenomenon is re-established in a new geographical or political context after experiencing a disruption or dislocation. This term is often used to understand how power dynamics shift in response to changes in governance, borders, or identity, making it key to discussions about the interactions between global and local forces.
Simon Dalby: Simon Dalby is a prominent political geographer known for his contributions to critical geopolitics, particularly in examining the relationship between geopolitics and environmental issues. His work emphasizes the ways in which geopolitical discourse shapes our understanding of global politics, and how this, in turn, influences environmental policies and practices. Dalby argues that traditional geopolitical frameworks often overlook crucial environmental dimensions, making his insights essential for a comprehensive understanding of contemporary political geography.
Sovereignty: Sovereignty is the authority of a state to govern itself or another state, signifying complete independence and control over its territory and political affairs. This concept is essential for understanding the dynamics of power, territorial integrity, and international relations, as it lays the foundation for border disputes, international treaties, and the legitimacy of political entities.
Territoriality: Territoriality refers to the emotional or physical attachment individuals or groups have to a specific geographic area, often influencing their behavior, governance, and interactions with others. This concept plays a crucial role in defining borders, spheres of influence, and political strategies as it shapes how states and communities assert control over land and resources.
Transnationalism: Transnationalism refers to the process by which individuals, communities, and organizations operate across national borders, forming networks that transcend traditional state boundaries. This phenomenon is marked by the flow of people, ideas, goods, and capital, leading to social, political, and economic interactions that challenge the notion of fixed national identities. The implications of transnationalism are evident in various contexts, such as migration patterns, political affiliations, and cultural exchanges that reshape how we understand global interconnectedness.