Glossary

9.6 Impact of dams and water diversion on indigenous communities

10 min read•august 21, 2024

Dams and water diversion projects have profound impacts on indigenous communities worldwide. These projects alter ecosystems, disrupt traditional practices, and often force relocation, challenging indigenous rights and cultural continuity.

Indigenous peoples face environmental, social, and economic consequences from dam construction. While some mitigation strategies exist, balancing development needs with indigenous rights and cultural preservation remains a complex challenge in water resource management.

Environmental impacts of dams

  • Dams significantly alter natural ecosystems and water cycles, profoundly affecting Native People's traditional relationships with their environment
  • Construction and operation of dams often conflict with indigenous land management practices and ecological knowledge
  • Environmental changes caused by dams can disrupt the delicate balance between Native communities and their surroundings

Ecosystem disruption

Top images from around the web for Ecosystem disruption

  • Free-flowing Andes Amazon rivers are vital to aquatic and terrestrial species, and to indigenous ... View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Dams Versus Northeast India | Celebrating Indigenous Peoples – The Northeast India Travel Blog View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Free-flowing Andes Amazon rivers are vital to aquatic and terrestrial species, and to indigenous ... View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Ecosystem disruption

  • Free-flowing Andes Amazon rivers are vital to aquatic and terrestrial species, and to indigenous ... View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Dams Versus Northeast India | Celebrating Indigenous Peoples – The Northeast India Travel Blog View original

    Is this image relevant?

  • Free-flowing Andes Amazon rivers are vital to aquatic and terrestrial species, and to indigenous ... View original

    Is this image relevant?

1 of 3
  • Fragmentation of river ecosystems leads to loss of biodiversity
  • Altered habitats impact both aquatic and terrestrial species
  • Disruption of natural flood cycles affects floodplain ecosystems
  • Changes in sediment transport alter downstream habitats (deltas, estuaries)

Altered river flow patterns

  • Seasonal flow variations become regulated, impacting natural cycles
  • Reduced flow downstream affects riparian vegetation and wildlife
  • Increased water evaporation from reservoirs changes local hydrology
  • Flow alterations can lead to changes in river channel morphology

Water quality changes

  • Reservoir stratification causes temperature changes in released water
  • Increased nutrient retention in reservoirs leads to eutrophication
  • Altered dissolved oxygen levels impact aquatic life
  • Potential release of toxic substances from flooded areas (mercury)

Fish migration barriers

  • Dams block spawning routes for migratory fish species (salmon, sturgeon)
  • Fish ladders and other passage structures often have limited effectiveness
  • Altered water conditions affect fish navigation and breeding cues
  • Impacts on fish populations can disrupt entire food webs

Social consequences for indigenous communities

  • Dam projects often disproportionately affect indigenous peoples due to their close ties to land and water resources
  • Social impacts extend beyond physical displacement, affecting community structures and cultural continuity
  • Indigenous communities frequently bear the brunt of negative consequences while receiving minimal benefits from dam projects

Displacement and relocation

  • Forced relocation of communities from ancestral lands to make way for reservoirs
  • Inadequate compensation and resettlement plans often fail to address long-term impacts
  • Disruption of social networks and community cohesion
  • Challenges in adapting to new environments and lifestyles

Loss of traditional lands

  • Inundation of territories with cultural, spiritual, and historical significance
  • Reduction in land available for traditional activities (hunting, gathering, agriculture)
  • Erosion of land-based knowledge and practices
  • Impacts on indigenous land rights and territorial claims

Disruption of cultural practices

  • Interruption of ceremonies and rituals tied to specific locations
  • Loss of access to medicinal plants and sacred sites
  • Alteration of traditional calendars based on natural cycles
  • Challenges in transmitting cultural knowledge to younger generations

Changes in subsistence activities

  • Transformation of fishing practices due to altered river ecosystems
  • Shifts in agricultural methods with changes in soil fertility and water availability
  • Reduction in gathering opportunities for wild foods and materials
  • Forced transition to cash economies and wage labor

Economic effects on indigenous peoples

  • Dam projects often create economic upheaval for indigenous communities, altering traditional livelihoods and resource management systems
  • Economic impacts extend beyond immediate displacement, affecting long-term community sustainability
  • Indigenous peoples frequently struggle to access economic benefits generated by dam projects

Loss of livelihoods

  • Disruption of traditional fishing economies due to altered river ecosystems
  • Reduction in agricultural productivity from changes in soil fertility and water access
  • Loss of income from forest products in flooded areas
  • Displacement from areas used for small-scale mining or other resource extraction

Altered resource access

  • Changes in availability and distribution of natural resources (fish, game, plants)
  • Increased competition for remaining resources with non-indigenous populations
  • New restrictions on land and water use in project areas
  • Challenges in accessing alternative resources in resettlement areas

Compensation vs long-term impacts

  • One-time compensation payments often inadequate for sustained livelihood changes
  • Difficulty in quantifying cultural and spiritual losses for compensation purposes
  • Lack of long-term economic planning in many resettlement schemes
  • Intergenerational impacts often not considered in compensation packages

New economic opportunities

  • Potential for employment in dam construction and operation
  • Development of new industries (tourism, fisheries) around reservoirs
  • Improved infrastructure (roads, electricity) can facilitate economic diversification
  • Challenges in ensuring equitable access to new opportunities for indigenous people

Health implications

  • Dam projects can have profound effects on the physical and mental health of indigenous communities
  • Changes in environmental conditions often lead to new health challenges for which traditional knowledge may be inadequate
  • Access to healthcare services can be disrupted or altered by displacement and relocation

Water-borne diseases

  • Increased prevalence of vector-borne diseases (malaria, schistosomiasis) in reservoir areas
  • Changes in water quality leading to gastrointestinal illnesses
  • Potential for mercury contamination in fish from submerged forests
  • Challenges in maintaining traditional water purification practices

Nutritional changes

  • Alterations in diet due to loss of traditional food sources (fish, wild game, plants)
  • Increased reliance on processed foods in resettlement areas
  • Nutritional deficiencies from reduced dietary diversity
  • Changes in food preparation methods affecting nutritional intake

Mental health effects

  • Psychological stress from displacement and loss of ancestral lands
  • Increased rates of depression and anxiety in affected communities
  • Intergenerational trauma from disruption of cultural continuity
  • Social issues (substance abuse, domestic violence) stemming from community upheaval

Access to healthcare

  • Disruption of traditional healing practices tied to specific environments
  • Challenges in accessing modern healthcare facilities in resettlement areas
  • Loss of medicinal plants and traditional pharmacopeia
  • Cultural barriers in utilizing non-indigenous healthcare systems

Cultural heritage preservation

  • Dam projects pose significant threats to the tangible and intangible cultural heritage of indigenous peoples
  • Preservation efforts often struggle to capture the full complexity of living cultural landscapes
  • Indigenous communities face challenges in maintaining cultural continuity in the face of rapid environmental change

Submerged archaeological sites

  • Inundation of ancient settlements, burial grounds, and rock art sites
  • Loss of physical evidence of indigenous history and prehistory
  • Challenges in documenting and preserving underwater cultural heritage
  • Ethical issues surrounding the relocation of cultural artifacts

Loss of sacred places

  • Flooding of sites with spiritual and ceremonial significance
  • Disruption of pilgrimage routes and traditional gathering places
  • Challenges in recreating or relocating sacred spaces
  • Impacts on indigenous cosmologies and spiritual practices

Erosion of traditional knowledge

  • Disconnection from land-based knowledge systems
  • Challenges in transmitting ecological knowledge to younger generations
  • Loss of specialized knowledge related to specific ecosystems
  • Reduction in linguistic diversity tied to environmental knowledge

Efforts for cultural documentation

  • Increased focus on recording oral histories and traditional practices
  • Development of indigenous-led cultural heritage management plans
  • Use of digital technologies for cultural mapping and preservation
  • Challenges in capturing intangible aspects of cultural heritage

Indigenous rights and dam projects

  • Dam construction often intersects with complex issues of indigenous rights and sovereignty
  • International frameworks for indigenous rights provide tools for engagement and resistance
  • Indigenous communities increasingly assert their rights to self-determination in development processes
  • Principle requiring indigenous approval before project implementation
  • Challenges in ensuring genuine consent processes free from coercion
  • Varying interpretations and implementations of FPIC across different countries
  • Importance of culturally appropriate information sharing and decision-making

Consultation processes

  • Requirements for meaningful engagement with affected indigenous communities
  • Issues of representation and legitimacy in consultation mechanisms
  • Time frames for consultation often inadequate for traditional decision-making processes
  • Power imbalances affecting the outcomes of consultations
  • Use of national and international legal systems to contest dam projects
  • Development of indigenous-led protest movements and coalitions
  • Media campaigns to raise awareness of indigenous perspectives
  • Challenges in accessing legal resources and navigating complex bureaucracies

International indigenous rights frameworks

  • Relevance of UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP)
  • Application of ILO Convention 169 on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples
  • Role of international financial institutions in safeguarding indigenous rights
  • Tensions between national development agendas and international rights frameworks

Water sovereignty issues

  • Dam projects often challenge indigenous concepts of water ownership and management
  • Conflicts arise between traditional water use practices and modern water governance systems
  • Indigenous communities assert their rights to water as integral to cultural survival

Control over water resources

  • Shift in water management from local to centralized authorities
  • Loss of traditional water allocation and distribution systems
  • Impacts on indigenous water governance structures
  • Challenges in maintaining customary water rights in changed environments

Traditional vs modern water management

  • Contrasts between holistic indigenous approaches and sectoral modern management
  • Integration of spiritual and cultural values in water resource decisions
  • Challenges in reconciling traditional knowledge with scientific water management
  • Potential for hybrid approaches combining indigenous and modern practices

Indigenous water rights

  • Legal recognition of indigenous rights to water resources
  • Challenges in quantifying and codifying traditional water uses
  • Conflicts with state water allocation systems and prior appropriation doctrines
  • Efforts to establish cultural flow requirements in water management plans

Conflicts with state policies

  • Tensions between national water development goals and indigenous water needs
  • Impacts of water privatization on indigenous access and control
  • Challenges in incorporating indigenous perspectives in national water policies
  • Legal and political struggles over and self-determination

Mitigation and adaptation strategies

  • Indigenous communities develop diverse strategies to mitigate dam impacts and adapt to changed environments
  • Increasing recognition of the value of indigenous knowledge in sustainable water management
  • Emergence of collaborative approaches integrating indigenous and scientific perspectives

Indigenous-led impact assessments

  • Development of culturally appropriate environmental and social impact methodologies
  • Incorporation of in assessment processes
  • Community-based monitoring of environmental and social changes
  • Challenges in ensuring indigenous assessments influence decision-making

Co-management of water resources

  • Establishment of joint management structures involving indigenous communities
  • Integration of traditional and scientific knowledge in resource management
  • Development of culturally appropriate indicators for ecosystem health
  • Challenges in balancing power dynamics in co-management arrangements

Cultural flow requirements

  • Efforts to define and implement water allocations for cultural purposes
  • Recognition of the spiritual and ceremonial significance of water flows
  • Integration of cultural flow needs in dam operation schedules
  • Challenges in quantifying and prioritizing cultural water requirements

Alternative energy solutions

  • Exploration of small-scale, locally controlled renewable energy projects
  • Development of off-grid solutions compatible with indigenous lifestyles
  • Integration of traditional energy practices with modern technologies
  • Challenges in accessing funding and technical support for alternative solutions

Case studies of dam impacts

  • Examination of specific dam projects provides insights into the diverse experiences of indigenous peoples worldwide
  • Case studies highlight both the challenges faced by communities and innovative responses to dam impacts
  • Lessons from past projects inform current debates on indigenous rights and water development

Specific examples worldwide

  • Impacts of the Three Gorges Dam on ethnic minorities in China
  • Displacement of indigenous communities by the Belo Monte Dam in Brazil
  • Effects of the Sardar Sarovar Dam on Adivasi peoples in India
  • Consequences of the Site C Dam for First Nations in Canada

Lessons learned from past projects

  • Importance of early and meaningful indigenous involvement in planning
  • Need for comprehensive, long-term impact assessments and monitoring
  • Value of flexible, adaptive management approaches in dam operation
  • Recognition of the limitations of monetary compensation for cultural losses

Successful indigenous resistance movements

  • Cancellation of the Myitsone Dam project in Myanmar due to local opposition
  • Indigenous-led legal challenges to the Dakota Access Pipeline in the United States
  • Community mobilization against the Alto Maipo hydroelectric project in Chile
  • Renegotiation of benefit-sharing agreements for the Keeyask Dam in Canada

Collaborative dam management models

  • Co-management of the Columbia River system by tribes and government agencies
  • Indigenous participation in environmental flow management in Australia's Murray-Darling Basin
  • Integration of Sami knowledge in hydropower operations in northern Scandinavia
  • Community-based monitoring programs for the Mekong River dams

Future outlook

  • Climate change adds new complexities to the relationship between dams, water resources, and indigenous communities
  • Growing recognition of indigenous rights and knowledge offers opportunities for more equitable water management
  • Balancing development needs with environmental and cultural preservation remains a key challenge

Climate change considerations

  • Increased water variability affecting dam operations and indigenous livelihoods
  • Potential for more frequent extreme weather events impacting dam safety
  • Changes in ecosystem dynamics altering traditional resource use patterns
  • Indigenous knowledge as a resource for climate change adaptation strategies

Sustainable water management approaches

  • Integration of ecosystem-based approaches in water infrastructure planning
  • Development of multi-purpose water management schemes with indigenous input
  • Exploration of nature-based solutions as alternatives to large dams
  • Challenges in balancing water security, energy needs, and ecosystem health

Indigenous perspectives in planning

  • Increasing inclusion of indigenous representatives in water governance bodies
  • Development of indigenous-led water management plans and strategies
  • Integration of traditional ecological knowledge in watershed planning
  • Challenges in translating indigenous perspectives into policy and practice

Balancing development and rights

  • Exploration of alternative development models respecting indigenous rights
  • Efforts to align national development goals with international rights frameworks
  • Development of benefit-sharing mechanisms ensuring equitable outcomes
  • Ongoing tensions between economic growth imperatives and indigenous self-determination

Key Terms to Review (18)

Cultural Erosion: Cultural erosion refers to the gradual loss or degradation of cultural identity, practices, and knowledge within a community, often due to external pressures such as globalization, environmental changes, and socio-economic factors. This phenomenon significantly impacts the ways in which knowledge and traditions are passed down through generations, affecting not just individual communities but also the broader cultural landscape.
Economic displacement: Economic displacement refers to the forced removal of individuals or communities from their economic base, often due to external factors like infrastructure projects or resource extraction. This loss not only affects livelihoods but can also lead to social disintegration and a sense of loss of cultural identity, particularly among indigenous communities who are deeply connected to their land and resources.
Ecosystem disruption: Ecosystem disruption refers to significant changes in the structure and function of an ecosystem, often caused by human activities or natural events that alter the balance of the environment. This disruption can lead to loss of biodiversity, changes in species interactions, and the degradation of natural resources, significantly impacting local communities, especially those relying on these ecosystems for their livelihoods and cultural practices.
Environmental Racism: Environmental racism refers to the systematic placement of environmentally hazardous waste sites, pollution, and other toxic infrastructures disproportionately in communities of color and low-income neighborhoods. This term highlights the unfair distribution of environmental burdens and the often-neglected voices of marginalized communities in environmental decision-making processes.
Fish migration blockage: Fish migration blockage refers to the obstacles that prevent fish from traveling freely along their natural migratory routes, typically caused by human-made structures such as dams or water diversions. This disruption can severely impact fish populations, especially species that rely on specific spawning grounds and seasonal migrations. Understanding this blockage is crucial for assessing the ecological consequences of water management practices and their effects on indigenous communities that depend on these fish populations for sustenance and cultural practices.
Glen Canyon Dam Controversy: The Glen Canyon Dam Controversy refers to the ongoing debate surrounding the construction and operation of the Glen Canyon Dam on the Colorado River in Arizona, which began in the 1960s. This debate highlights the environmental and cultural impacts of the dam on indigenous communities, particularly the Navajo Nation and other tribes whose ancestral lands and water rights were affected by the dam's creation and the subsequent changes to the river ecosystem.
Indian Reorganization Act: The Indian Reorganization Act, passed in 1934, aimed to reverse the assimilationist policies of the Dawes Act and restore some degree of self-governance and land rights to Native American tribes. This legislation was a significant shift in federal policy, recognizing tribal sovereignty and promoting the establishment of tribal governments, which connected to issues of resource management, governance, and land rights for indigenous communities.
Land back movement: The land back movement is a social and political initiative advocating for the return of indigenous lands to their original stewards, emphasizing the restoration of rights and sovereignty over ancestral territories. This movement addresses historical injustices by challenging colonial practices and seeking to re-establish indigenous relationships with their land, which are essential for cultural preservation, environmental stewardship, and community wellbeing.
Land reclamation: Land reclamation is the process of creating new land from oceans, riverbeds, or lake beds, or restoring previously degraded land to make it usable again. This practice can be crucial for enhancing agricultural productivity, restoring ecosystems, and supporting sustainable development, particularly in areas affected by environmental degradation or urban expansion.
National Historic Preservation Act: The National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA) is a U.S. law enacted in 1966 to preserve historical and archaeological sites. This act established a framework for protecting cultural resources and mandates federal agencies to consider the impact of their actions on historic properties, which is essential for maintaining the cultural heritage of communities, including Indigenous peoples. The NHPA promotes public participation in preservation efforts and highlights the ecological significance of sacred sites, while also addressing the implications of development projects like dams and water diversion that can adversely affect Indigenous communities.
Navajo Nation: The Navajo Nation is a semi-autonomous territory of the Navajo people, located in the southwestern United States, primarily in Arizona, New Mexico, and Utah. It is the largest Native American reservation in the U.S. and has its own government, legal system, and educational institutions, reflecting the cultural and historical significance of the Navajo tribe. This unique status allows for self-governance and the preservation of traditional practices and beliefs.
Sacred waters: Sacred waters refer to bodies of water that hold spiritual significance for Indigenous communities, often regarded as living entities that provide sustenance, healing, and a connection to ancestral traditions. These waters are not merely physical resources but are intertwined with cultural practices, religious beliefs, and the identity of the people, emphasizing the deep respect and reverence held for water within these communities.
Shoshone-Bannock Tribes: The Shoshone-Bannock Tribes are a federally recognized Native American tribe located in southeastern Idaho, composed of two distinct groups: the Shoshone and the Bannock. Historically, these tribes were semi-nomadic, relying on fishing, hunting, and gathering in the Great Basin and surrounding regions. Their traditional way of life and cultural practices have been significantly impacted by modern developments such as dams and water diversion projects.
The flooding of the Klamath River: The flooding of the Klamath River refers to the significant overflow of water in the Klamath River basin, which has been heavily impacted by dam constructions and water diversion projects. This flooding has had severe consequences for indigenous communities, who rely on the river for cultural, spiritual, and economic practices, disrupting their traditional way of life and the ecosystems they depend on.
Traditional Ecological Knowledge: Traditional ecological knowledge (TEK) refers to the understandings, skills, and philosophies developed by Indigenous and local communities over generations through their direct interaction with their environment. This body of knowledge includes ecological observations and cultural practices that inform sustainable resource management and conservation strategies, emphasizing the interconnectedness of all living beings.
Tribal consultation processes: Tribal consultation processes are formal mechanisms that allow governments and agencies to engage with Native American tribes regarding decisions that may impact their lands, resources, and cultural heritage. These processes aim to respect tribal sovereignty and ensure that indigenous voices are heard, especially in matters such as land use, environmental policies, and development projects. Successful tribal consultations promote collaboration and mutual respect between tribal nations and governmental entities, ultimately striving for informed decision-making.
Water protectors: Water protectors refer to individuals or groups, often from indigenous communities, who advocate for the preservation and protection of water sources. They emphasize the spiritual and cultural significance of water, often fighting against environmental degradation, corporate exploitation, and governmental policies that threaten these vital resources. This advocacy is closely linked to the protection of sacred water sources, conflicts over water rights and access, and the impacts of dams and water diversion on their communities.
Water sovereignty: Water sovereignty refers to the inherent rights of communities, particularly Indigenous peoples, to manage and control their water resources according to their own cultural values and traditions. This concept emphasizes that water is not merely a resource for consumption but a living entity with spiritual significance, leading to a deep connection between communities and their water sources. It encompasses the political, social, and environmental dimensions of water rights, highlighting the need for Indigenous governance in managing water access and usage.
© 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
AP® and SAT® are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Back
Practice QuizGlossary
Practice QuizGlossary
Next guide