10.1 Attorney-client relationship

The attorney-client relationship forms the foundation of legal representation. It establishes the rights, duties, and obligations between lawyers and their clients. Understanding this relationship is crucial for effective legal services and ethical compliance.

Attorneys owe fiduciary duties to clients, including loyalty and confidentiality. The scope of representation defines the legal matters the attorney will handle. Formation of the relationship can be express or implied, triggering ethical obligations and fiduciary duties.

Foundations of attorney-client relationship

• The attorney-client relationship forms the basis for the legal representation and establishes the rights, duties, and obligations between the attorney and the client
• Understanding the foundations of this relationship is crucial for both attorneys and clients to ensure effective legal representation and compliance with ethical standards
• The formation and scope of the attorney-client relationship determine the extent of the attorney's authority and the client's expectations

Fiduciary duties owed to clients

Top images from around the web for Fiduciary duties owed to clients

• 

  Code Of Conduct - Free of Charge Creative Commons Chalkboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Legal Malpractice - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Class 13: Corporate Purpose & Fiduciary Duties | Business Organizations Law View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Code Of Conduct - Free of Charge Creative Commons Chalkboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Legal Malpractice - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

Top images from around the web for Fiduciary duties owed to clients

• 

  Code Of Conduct - Free of Charge Creative Commons Chalkboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Legal Malpractice - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Class 13: Corporate Purpose & Fiduciary Duties | Business Organizations Law View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Code Of Conduct - Free of Charge Creative Commons Chalkboard image View original

  Is this image relevant?

• 

  Legal Malpractice - Free of Charge Creative Commons Legal Engraved image View original

  Is this image relevant?

1 of 3

• Attorneys owe fiduciary duties to their clients, which means they must act in the best interests of their clients and prioritize their clients' interests above their own
• The fiduciary duties include loyalty, confidentiality, and the duty to provide competent representation
• Attorneys must avoid conflicts of interest and maintain the confidentiality of client information
• Breach of fiduciary duties can lead to disciplinary action and legal malpractice claims

Scope of representation and authority

• The scope of representation defines the legal matters and tasks the attorney is hired to handle on behalf of the client
• The attorney and client should clearly define the scope of representation in a written agreement to avoid misunderstandings and disputes
• The attorney's authority to act on behalf of the client is limited to the scope of representation agreed upon
• Attorneys must obtain client consent before expanding or modifying the scope of representation

Formation of attorney-client relationship

• The attorney-client relationship can be formed through an express agreement, such as a written retainer agreement, or implied through the parties' conduct and communications
• The relationship is typically formed when the client seeks legal advice or representation from the attorney and the attorney agrees to provide those services
• The formation of the relationship triggers the attorney's ethical obligations and fiduciary duties to the client
• In some cases, the attorney-client relationship may be formed unintentionally, such as when a prospective client discloses confidential information during an initial consultation

Ethical obligations in attorney-client relationship

• Attorneys are bound by ethical rules and professional codes of conduct that govern their behavior and obligations in the attorney-client relationship
• Compliance with ethical obligations is essential to maintain the integrity of the legal profession and protect the interests of clients
• Violation of ethical obligations can result in disciplinary action by state bar associations, including suspension or disbarment

Duty of competence

• Attorneys have a duty to provide competent representation to their clients, which means possessing the necessary legal knowledge, skills, and thoroughness to handle the client's matter
• Competence requires attorneys to stay current with changes in the law and to refer matters to other attorneys when they lack the necessary expertise
• Attorneys must also adequately prepare for and investigate the client's case to provide effective representation
• Failure to provide competent representation can lead to legal malpractice claims and disciplinary action

Duty of diligence

• Attorneys have a duty to act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing their clients
• Diligence requires attorneys to pursue the client's matter despite opposition, obstruction, or personal inconvenience
• Attorneys must keep clients reasonably informed about the status of their case and promptly comply with reasonable requests for information
• Neglecting client matters or failing to communicate with clients can violate the duty of diligence and lead to disciplinary action

Duty of loyalty

• Attorneys have a duty of loyalty to their clients, which requires them to put their clients' interests first and avoid conflicts of interest
• Attorneys must not represent clients with opposing interests or use client information to the disadvantage of the client
• The duty of loyalty continues even after the attorney-client relationship ends, and attorneys must maintain the confidentiality of former client information
• Breach of the duty of loyalty can result in disqualification from representation, disciplinary action, and legal malpractice claims

Duty of confidentiality

• Attorneys have a duty to maintain the confidentiality of client information, which includes all information related to the representation, regardless of its source
• The duty of confidentiality is broader than the attorney-client privilege and applies to all client information, not just communications between the attorney and client
• Attorneys must take reasonable steps to protect client information from unauthorized disclosure and may only reveal confidential information in limited circumstances, such as when required by law or with the client's informed consent
• Violation of the duty of confidentiality can lead to disciplinary action and breach of fiduciary duty claims

Attorney-client privilege

• The attorney-client privilege is a legal doctrine that protects confidential communications between attorneys and their clients from disclosure to third parties
• The privilege encourages clients to openly and honestly communicate with their attorneys, enabling attorneys to provide effective legal representation
• The attorney-client privilege is distinct from the duty of confidentiality, as it specifically applies to communications and has different exceptions and waiver provisions

Elements of attorney-client privilege

• For the attorney-client privilege to apply, the communication must be between an attorney and client, made in confidence, for the purpose of seeking or providing legal advice
• The communication must relate to the legal representation and not to other matters, such as business advice
• The privilege applies to both oral and written communications, including emails, letters, and text messages
• The presence of third parties during the communication, other than those necessary for the representation (such as interpreters or paralegals), can destroy the privilege

Exceptions to attorney-client privilege

• The attorney-client privilege is not absolute and is subject to several exceptions, such as the crime-fraud exception and the testamentary exception
• The crime-fraud exception applies when the client seeks the attorney's advice to commit or further a crime or fraud
• The testamentary exception allows the disclosure of privileged communications in disputes between beneficiaries of a deceased client's estate
• Other exceptions include the client's waiver of the privilege, the attorney's need to defend against malpractice claims, and court-ordered disclosure in certain circumstances

Waiver of attorney-client privilege

• The attorney-client privilege can be waived by the client, either intentionally or inadvertently
• Intentional waiver occurs when the client voluntarily discloses privileged communications to third parties or authorizes the attorney to do so
• Inadvertent waiver can occur when the client fails to take reasonable steps to protect the confidentiality of privileged communications, such as by disclosing them in a public setting or to third parties
• Once the privilege is waived, the communications are no longer protected from disclosure and can be used as evidence in legal proceedings

Crime-fraud exception

• The crime-fraud exception to the attorney-client privilege applies when the client seeks the attorney's advice or assistance to commit or further a crime or fraud
• The exception is based on the principle that the attorney-client privilege should not be used to shield criminal or fraudulent conduct
• For the exception to apply, there must be a reasonable basis to believe that the client's communications were intended to facilitate or conceal a crime or fraud
• The attorney's knowledge of the client's criminal or fraudulent intent is not required for the exception to apply, as long as the client's intent can be established

Conflicts of interest

• Conflicts of interest arise when an attorney's loyalty to a client is compromised by the attorney's own interests or the interests of another client
• Attorneys have a duty to identify and avoid conflicts of interest, as they can undermine the attorney's ability to provide competent and diligent representation
• Conflicts of interest can be categorized as concurrent conflicts (representing clients with opposing interests simultaneously) or successive conflicts (representing a client against a former client in a substantially related matter)

Concurrent conflicts of interest

• Concurrent conflicts of interest occur when an attorney represents clients with directly adverse interests or when the attorney's representation of one client is materially limited by the attorney's responsibilities to another client, a former client, or a third party
• Examples of concurrent conflicts include representing both parties in a divorce or representing a plaintiff and defendant in the same lawsuit
• Attorneys must obtain informed consent from all affected clients to waive a concurrent conflict of interest, and in some cases, the conflict may be unwaivable due to the severity of the adverse interests

Successive conflicts of interest

• Successive conflicts of interest arise when an attorney represents a client against a former client in a matter that is substantially related to the former representation
• The substantial relationship test is used to determine whether the current and former matters are sufficiently similar to create a risk that the attorney could use confidential information from the former representation to the detriment of the former client
• Attorneys must obtain informed consent from the former client to waive a successive conflict of interest, and in some cases, the conflict may be unwaivable if the risk of harm to the former client is too great

Imputed disqualification of law firms

• Conflicts of interest can be imputed to an entire law firm, even if only one attorney in the firm has the conflict
• Imputed disqualification is based on the principle that attorneys in a firm share confidential client information and have a collective duty of loyalty to their clients
• When an attorney joins a new firm, the firm must screen the attorney from any matters that present a conflict with the attorney's former clients to avoid imputed disqualification
• In some cases, informed consent from the affected clients can waive imputed disqualification, but the waiver must be obtained from all clients involved

Waiver of conflicts by informed consent

• Clients can waive conflicts of interest by providing informed consent, which requires the attorney to fully disclose the nature and potential consequences of the conflict
• Informed consent must be in writing and signed by the client, and the attorney must reasonably believe that the client understands the risks and implications of waiving the conflict
• Some conflicts, such as those involving direct adversity between current clients or a significant risk of harm to a former client, may be unwaivable even with informed consent
• Attorneys must carefully consider whether a conflict can be adequately addressed through informed consent or if withdrawal from the representation is necessary to protect the clients' interests

Termination of attorney-client relationship

• The attorney-client relationship can be terminated by either the attorney or the client, or it may end naturally upon the completion of the agreed-upon scope of representation
• Proper termination of the relationship is important to ensure that the client's interests are protected and that the attorney fulfills any remaining ethical obligations

Withdrawal by attorney

• An attorney may withdraw from representation for various reasons, such as a breakdown in the attorney-client relationship, the client's failure to pay fees, or the client's insistence on pursuing an unethical or illegal course of action
• Attorneys must comply with applicable rules of professional conduct when withdrawing from representation, which typically require the attorney to take reasonable steps to protect the client's interests and to provide notice to the client and the court
• In some cases, court permission may be required for an attorney to withdraw, particularly if the withdrawal would cause substantial prejudice to the client or disrupt ongoing legal proceedings

Discharge by client

• Clients have the right to discharge their attorney at any time, with or without cause
• Upon discharge, the attorney must promptly return the client's files and any unearned portion of advanced fees
• Attorneys may be entitled to compensation for work performed before the discharge, subject to any applicable fee agreements or quantum meruit principles
• In some cases, a client's discharge of an attorney may be considered a constructive discharge if the client's conduct makes it unreasonably difficult for the attorney to continue the representation

Completion of representation

• The attorney-client relationship may also end naturally upon the completion of the agreed-upon scope of representation, such as the resolution of a lawsuit or the closing of a transaction
• Upon completion of the representation, attorneys should provide the client with a written notice confirming the end of the relationship and any final advice or instructions
• Attorneys must also take reasonable steps to protect the client's interests, such as providing the client with important documents and cooperating with any successor counsel

Duties upon termination

• Upon termination of the attorney-client relationship, attorneys have ongoing ethical duties to their former clients
• Attorneys must maintain the confidentiality of client information and return any client property or files in their possession
• Attorneys are also prohibited from using former client information to the disadvantage of the former client or revealing such information to third parties, except as permitted by ethical rules or with the former client's informed consent
• In some cases, attorneys may have a duty to provide reasonable notice to the client of any upcoming deadlines or time-sensitive matters that require attention after the termination of the relationship

Fees and billing in attorney-client relationship

• Attorney fees and billing practices are an important aspect of the attorney-client relationship, as they can significantly impact the client's access to legal services and the attorney's ability to maintain a viable practice
• Attorneys must comply with ethical rules and professional standards when setting fees, billing clients, and handling client funds

Reasonable fee requirement

• Attorneys are required to charge reasonable fees for their services, taking into account factors such as the time and labor required, the novelty and difficulty of the legal issues involved, the attorney's skill and experience, and the customary fees charged in the locality for similar services
• Attorneys must communicate the basis or rate of their fees to clients in writing, preferably before or within a reasonable time after commencing the representation
• Contingency fees, which are based on a percentage of the client's recovery, must also be reasonable and comply with applicable ethical rules and statutory limitations

Contingency fees vs hourly fees

• Attorneys may charge for their services on a contingency fee basis, where the attorney's fee is a percentage of the client's recovery, or on an hourly basis, where the attorney charges a set rate for each hour worked
• Contingency fees can provide access to legal services for clients who cannot afford to pay hourly fees, but they also create a financial incentive for attorneys to prioritize cases with higher potential recoveries
• Hourly fees provide a more predictable income stream for attorneys but may be unaffordable for some clients and can create an incentive for attorneys to prolong cases or perform unnecessary work
• Attorneys should carefully consider which fee structure is most appropriate for each client and case, taking into account the client's financial situation, the complexity of the legal issues involved, and the likelihood of success

Retainer agreements and advance payments

• Attorneys often require clients to sign retainer agreements, which outline the scope of the representation, the attorney's fees and billing practices, and the client's responsibilities
• Retainer agreements may require clients to pay an advance fee or cost deposit, which the attorney holds in trust and applies to future services or expenses
• Attorneys must maintain client funds in a separate trust account and comply with strict record-keeping and accounting requirements to ensure that client funds are properly safeguarded and applied
• Any unearned portion of an advance fee or cost deposit must be promptly returned to the client upon termination of the representation

Fee disputes and resolution

• Fee disputes can arise when clients disagree with the amount or reasonableness of an attorney's fees or when attorneys seek to collect unpaid fees from clients
• Many jurisdictions have established fee arbitration programs or mediation services to resolve fee disputes outside of the court system
• Attorneys must comply with applicable rules of professional conduct when pursuing collection of unpaid fees, which may include providing the client with written notice of the right to arbitrate or mediate the dispute
• In some cases, attorneys may be required to submit fee disputes to mandatory arbitration or mediation before pursuing collection through the courts
• Attorneys should strive to avoid fee disputes by clearly communicating their fees and billing practices to clients, providing regular and detailed billing statements, and promptly addressing any client concerns or objections

Malpractice in attorney-client relationship

• Legal malpractice occurs when an attorney fails to exercise the degree of skill, care, and diligence that a reasonably competent attorney would exercise under similar circumstances, causing harm to the client
• Clients who suffer damages as a result of an attorney's malpractice may be entitled to recover compensation through a legal malpractice claim

Elements of legal malpractice claim

• To prevail in a legal malpractice claim, the client must establish four elements: (1) the existence of an attorney-client relationship, (2) the attorney's breach of the applicable standard of care, (3) causation, and (4) damages
• The standard of care is based on the level of skill, knowledge, and care that a reasonably competent attorney would exercise under similar circumstances
• Causation requires the client to prove that the attorney's breach of the standard of care was a proximate cause of the client's damages, meaning that the harm would not have occurred but for the attorney's negligence
• Damages may include the client's economic losses, such as lost compensation or business opportunities, as well as non-economic losses, such as emotional distress or reputational harm

Causation and damages in malpractice

• Establishing causation and damages can be challenging in legal malpractice cases, particularly when the underlying legal matter involved complex or uncertain legal issues
• In some cases, the client may need to prove "trial within a trial" or "case within a case," showing that the client would have prevailed in the underlying legal matter but for the attorney's negligence
• Expert testimony is often required to establish the applicable standard of care and to prove causation and damages
• Attorneys may also be liable for breach of fiduciary duty or breach of contract, which may have different standards of proof and damages than negligence-based malpractice claims

Defenses to malpractice claims

• Attorneys may raise various defenses to legal malpractice claims, such as lack of an attorney-client relationship, statute of limitations, comparative negligence, or assumption of risk
• The statute of limitations for legal malpractice claims varies by jurisdiction but typically begins to run when the client discovers or reasonably should have discovered the attorney's negligence and the resulting harm
• Comparative negligence may reduce the client's recovery if the client's own negligence contributed to the damages, while assumption of risk may bar recovery if the client knowingly and voluntarily assumed the risks associated with the attorney's negligence
• Attorneys may also defend against malpractice claims by arguing that their conduct was a reasonable strategic decision or judgment call based on the information available at the time

Malpractice insurance for attorneys

• Many attorneys carry professional liability insurance, also known as malpractice insurance, to protect against the financial consequences of malpractice claims
• Malpractice insurance policies typically cover the attorney's legal defense costs and any settlements or judgments up to the policy limits
• Some jurisdictions require attorneys to