🤕Torts Unit 7 – Negligence – Damages

What's the Deal with Damages?

• Damages aim to compensate the plaintiff for losses suffered due to the defendant's negligence
• Serve as a way to make the plaintiff "whole" again by providing monetary compensation for their injuries or losses
• Damages are not meant to punish the defendant, but rather to restore the plaintiff to their pre-injury state as much as possible
• The burden of proving damages falls on the plaintiff, who must provide evidence to support their claim
• Damages can include both economic losses (medical bills, lost wages) and non-economic losses (pain and suffering, emotional distress)
• The amount of damages awarded depends on the specific circumstances of the case and the extent of the plaintiff's injuries or losses
• Damages are a critical component of negligence cases, as they provide a remedy for the plaintiff and hold the defendant accountable for their actions

Types of Damages You Can Get

• Compensatory damages are the most common type and aim to compensate the plaintiff for their actual losses
  • Include economic damages (medical expenses, lost wages, property damage) and non-economic damages (pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life)
• Punitive damages may be awarded in cases of particularly egregious or reckless behavior to punish the defendant and deter similar conduct in the future
• Nominal damages are a small sum awarded when the plaintiff has suffered no substantial losses but the defendant is still found liable
• Statutory damages are set by law for certain types of cases (copyright infringement) and may be awarded instead of or in addition to other types of damages
• Liquidated damages are predetermined amounts specified in a contract for breaches of that contract
• Aggravated damages may be awarded in cases where the defendant's conduct was particularly malicious or oppressive
• Restitutionary damages aim to prevent the defendant from being unjustly enriched by their wrongful conduct

Proving Damages: Show Me the Evidence!

• Plaintiffs must provide evidence to support their claim for damages, which can include medical records, bills, receipts, and expert testimony
• For economic damages, plaintiffs should gather documentation of medical expenses, lost wages, and property damage
  • Medical records and bills can establish the extent and cost of treatment
  • Pay stubs or tax returns can demonstrate lost income
  • Repair estimates or replacement costs can prove property damage
• Non-economic damages are more subjective and may require testimony from the plaintiff, family members, or mental health professionals
  • Plaintiffs can testify about their pain, suffering, and emotional distress
  • Family members can provide insight into how the plaintiff's life has changed since the injury
  • Mental health professionals can assess the plaintiff's emotional state and provide a diagnosis
• Expert witnesses, such as doctors or economists, can help establish the extent and long-term impact of the plaintiff's injuries or losses
• The more evidence the plaintiff can provide, the stronger their case for damages will be

Limits on Damages: When You Can't Get Everything

• Some jurisdictions place caps on certain types of damages, particularly non-economic damages, to prevent excessive awards
  • These caps may be a fixed dollar amount or a multiple of the economic damages
• Comparative negligence rules can limit the plaintiff's recovery if they are found to be partially at fault for their own injuries
  • In pure comparative negligence states, the plaintiff's damages are reduced by their percentage of fault
  • In modified comparative negligence states, the plaintiff may be barred from recovery if their fault exceeds a certain threshold (50%)
• The doctrine of avoidable consequences requires plaintiffs to take reasonable steps to mitigate their damages
  • Plaintiffs cannot recover for losses that could have been avoided through reasonable efforts
• Collateral source rules may allow defendants to introduce evidence of payments the plaintiff received from other sources (insurance) to offset damages
• Statutes of limitations set time limits for filing negligence claims, after which the plaintiff may be barred from recovering damages
• Governmental immunity may shield certain public entities or employees from liability for negligence, limiting the plaintiff's ability to recover damages

Special Cases: Wrongful Death and Loss of Consortium

• Wrongful death actions allow the family members of a person killed by negligence to recover damages for their losses
  • Damages may include funeral and burial expenses, lost income and support, and loss of companionship
  • The specific family members who can bring a wrongful death claim vary by state but typically include spouses, children, and parents
• Loss of consortium claims allow family members to recover damages for the loss of companionship, affection, and support caused by the plaintiff's injuries
  • Spouses may be able to recover for the loss of sexual relations and household services
  • Parents may be able to recover for the loss of a child's companionship and affection
  • Children may be able to recover for the loss of parental guidance and nurturing
• These claims are derivative of the primary negligence claim and require proof that the defendant's negligence caused the death or injury
• Damages in these cases can be substantial, as they aim to compensate family members for profound and often lifelong losses

Calculating Damages: Math Time

• Economic damages are typically calculated by adding up the plaintiff's actual losses, such as medical bills and lost wages
  • Future economic losses, such as ongoing medical care or reduced earning capacity, may require expert testimony to project and discount to present value
• Non-economic damages are more subjective and often left to the jury's discretion
  • Juries may consider factors such as the severity and duration of the plaintiff's pain and suffering, the impact on their daily life, and their age and life expectancy
• Punitive damages, when awarded, are often based on a multiple of the compensatory damages or a percentage of the defendant's net worth
• In cases involving multiple defendants, the court may apportion damages based on each defendant's degree of fault
• Comparative negligence rules may require the court to reduce the plaintiff's damages by their percentage of fault
• Collateral source payments, such as insurance benefits, may be subtracted from the plaintiff's damages in some jurisdictions
• Calculating damages can be complex and often requires the assistance of experts in fields such as medicine, economics, and vocational rehabilitation

Real-World Examples: Damages in Action

• In a medical malpractice case, a plaintiff who suffered a permanent disability due to a surgical error was awarded $5 million in damages, including$2 million for future medical expenses and $3 million for pain and suffering
• A plaintiff who was severely burned by a defective product received $10 million in damages, including$4 million for past and future medical expenses, $3 million for lost wages and earning capacity, and$3 million for pain and suffering
• In a wrongful death case, the family of a person killed by a drunk driver was awarded $8 million in damages, including$2 million for funeral and burial expenses, $3 million for lost income and support, and$3 million for loss of companionship
• A plaintiff who suffered a traumatic brain injury in a car accident caused by a negligent driver received $12 million in damages, including$5 million for future medical care, $4 million for lost earning capacity, and$3 million for pain and suffering
• In a slip-and-fall case, a plaintiff who fractured their hip and required surgery was awarded $500,000 in damages, including$100,000 for medical expenses, $50,000 for lost wages, and$350,000 for pain and suffering

Key Takeaways: Remember This Stuff

• Damages are a critical component of negligence cases and aim to compensate the plaintiff for their losses
• There are several types of damages, including compensatory, punitive, nominal, statutory, liquidated, aggravated, and restitutionary damages
• Plaintiffs must provide evidence to support their claim for damages, which can include medical records, bills, receipts, and expert testimony
• Damages may be limited by caps, comparative negligence rules, the doctrine of avoidable consequences, collateral source rules, statutes of limitations, and governmental immunity
• Wrongful death and loss of consortium claims allow family members to recover damages for their losses in cases of fatal or severe injuries
• Calculating damages can be complex and often requires the assistance of experts in fields such as medicine, economics, and vocational rehabilitation
• Real-world examples demonstrate the significant impact that damages can have on plaintiffs' lives and the importance of holding negligent parties accountable for their actions