9.3 Strategies for decolonizing museums and art institutions in the contemporary context
5 min read•Last Updated on August 13, 2024
Museums and art institutions are grappling with their colonial pasts. They're trying new strategies like returning artifacts, collaborating with indigenous communities, and changing how they operate. These efforts aim to make museums more inclusive and representative of diverse voices and experiences.
Decolonizing isn't easy though. Museums face challenges like deep-rooted biases, limited resources, and internal conflicts. But by reimagining their roles, museums can become spaces for dialogue, justice, and community engagement. It's an ongoing process of reflection and action.
Decolonizing Museums and Art Institutions
Repatriation and Collaborative Curation
Top images from around the web for Repatriation and Collaborative Curation
Curating Ododo Wa/Our Stories - Active History View original
Is this image relevant?
Q&A: The Indigenous design perspective | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Afrikaabteilung in Ethnological Museum Berlin 29.JPG - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Curating Ododo Wa/Our Stories - Active History View original
Is this image relevant?
Q&A: The Indigenous design perspective | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Repatriation and Collaborative Curation
Curating Ododo Wa/Our Stories - Active History View original
Is this image relevant?
Q&A: The Indigenous design perspective | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Afrikaabteilung in Ethnological Museum Berlin 29.JPG - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
Curating Ododo Wa/Our Stories - Active History View original
Is this image relevant?
Q&A: The Indigenous design perspective | Pursuit by The University of Melbourne View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Repatriation involves the return of cultural artifacts and human remains to their communities of origin, acknowledging the historical theft and unethical acquisition of these items during the colonial era
Collaborative curation engages indigenous and colonized communities in the process of designing and presenting exhibitions, ensuring their perspectives and narratives are centered and accurately represented
Examples of repatriation include the return of the Benin Bronzes to Nigeria and the return of Maori ancestral remains to New Zealand
Collaborative curation projects such as the "Our Lives: Contemporary Life and Identities" exhibition at the National Museum of the American Indian showcase the power of centering indigenous voices and experiences
Institutional Transformation and Community Engagement
Hiring practices that prioritize diversity and inclusion, particularly in leadership and curatorial positions, can help shift institutional power dynamics and decision-making processes to be more equitable and representative
Educational programming and public engagement initiatives that critically examine colonial histories and their ongoing impacts can foster dialogue, awareness, and accountability within museum and art institution spaces
Developing long-term, reciprocal relationships with colonized and indigenous communities based on trust, respect, and shared authority can transform how museums and art institutions operate and serve their audiences
The Montreal Museum of Fine Arts has implemented a comprehensive diversity and inclusion plan that includes hiring diverse staff, engaging with local communities, and presenting exhibitions that reflect the city's cultural diversity
The Detroit Institute of Arts has established a Community Advisory Council to guide its programming, exhibitions, and outreach efforts in collaboration with the diverse communities it serves
Challenges of Decolonization in Museums
Entrenched Colonial Ideologies and Limited Resources
Deeply entrenched colonial ideologies, practices, and biases within museum and art institution cultures can resist and undermine decolonizing efforts, requiring sustained commitment and systemic change
Limited financial resources and competing priorities can hinder the implementation and sustainability of decolonizing initiatives, especially when they challenge traditional funding models and donor expectations
Many museums struggle to confront their colonial origins and the ways in which their collections and exhibitions have perpetuated harmful narratives and stereotypes about colonized and indigenous peoples
Decolonizing efforts often require significant investments in staff training, community outreach, and exhibition redesign, which can be difficult to secure in the face of budget constraints and competing institutional priorities
Internal Tensions and Ethical Complexities
Disagreements and power struggles among staff, leadership, and stakeholders regarding the pace, scope, and direction of decolonizing efforts can create internal tensions and obstacles to progress
Balancing the need for meaningful community engagement and collaboration with the practical constraints of institutional timelines, budgets, and capacities can be a difficult negotiation
Navigating the complex legal and ethical dimensions of repatriation, particularly when multiple communities claim ownership or when objects have unclear or disputed provenance, can complicate decolonizing processes
Overcoming the persistent lack of diversity and representation within museum and art institution workforces, especially in positions of power and influence, remains an ongoing challenge to enacting decolonial change
The controversy surrounding the planned repatriation of the Maori warrior Toi moko from the American Museum of Natural History highlights the legal and ethical complexities of returning human remains to indigenous communities
The Guggenheim Museum's 2019 exhibition "Basquiat's 'Defacement': The Untold Story" faced criticism for its lack of engagement with the Afro-Caribbean community and its framing of the artist's work through a primarily white curatorial lens
Reimagining Museums for Dialogue and Justice
Curatorial and Artistic Interventions
Curators have the power to shape narratives, select voices, and frame conversations through their exhibition-making and collection development choices, and can use this influence to challenge colonial paradigms and center marginalized perspectives
Artists, particularly those from colonized and indigenous communities, can create works that subvert, critique, and reimagine colonial histories and representations, as well as propose alternative visions for museums and art institutions
The "Hearts of Our People: Native Women Artists" exhibition at the Minneapolis Institute of Art, curated by a team of Native women scholars and artists, centered indigenous women's voices and challenged stereotypical representations of Native art and culture
Fred Wilson's "Mining the Museum" installation at the Maryland Historical Society juxtaposed objects from the museum's collection to reveal the hidden histories of slavery and racism in American culture
Activism, Community Agency, and Collaboration
Activists and grassroots organizers can apply pressure from outside institutions to demand accountability, transparency, and change, as well as build solidarity networks and movements to amplify decolonizing efforts
Communities that have been historically excluded, exploited, or misrepresented by museums and art institutions can assert their agency and authority in shaping how their cultures are collected, interpreted, and displayed
Collaborations and partnerships among curators, artists, activists, and communities can generate innovative, experimental, and transformative approaches to decolonizing museums and art institutions and creating more equitable and inclusive spaces
Decolonizing museums and art institutions requires an ongoing, iterative process of critical reflection, dialogue, and action that is responsive to the evolving needs and priorities of the communities they serve
The "Take Back the Bronx" campaign, led by Bronx-based activists and artists, successfully pressured the Bronx Museum of the Arts to cancel a controversial exhibition and engage in a community-driven process of institutional reform
The "Healing Gardens" project at the Penn Museum, developed in collaboration with the Lenape Nation of Pennsylvania, created a space for indigenous healing practices and cultural programming within the museum's grounds