Essential Rules of Modifiers

Why This Matters

Modifiers are the precision tools of English—they're what transform vague statements into vivid, specific communication. On standardized tests like the SAT, ACT, and AP English exams, modifier errors are among the most frequently tested grammar concepts. You'll encounter them in multiple-choice editing questions, and they're prime targets for the kinds of sentence-level errors that cost students points. Understanding modifiers means understanding sentence logic, clarity, and the relationship between ideas.

Here's the key insight: you're not just being tested on whether you can spot a dangling modifier. You're being tested on whether you understand how sentences communicate meaning through structure. Every modifier must have a clear, logical connection to what it modifies—and that connection depends on placement, form, and context. Don't just memorize the error types; know why each modifier rule exists and how breaking it creates confusion.

---

Types of Single-Word Modifiers

Single-word modifiers are the building blocks of descriptive language. They attach directly to the words they describe, and their form changes based on their grammatical function.

Adjectives

• Describe nouns and pronouns—they answer questions like which one, what kind, how many and provide essential detail about qualities or characteristics
• Appear in two positions: attributive (before the noun: "the tall building") or predicative (after a linking verb: "the building is tall")
• Form comparatives and superlatives to show degree—understanding when to use "-er/-est" versus "more/most" is a common test point

Adverbs

• Modify verbs, adjectives, or other adverbs—they answer how, when, where, why, or to what extent an action occurs
• Often end in "-ly" when derived from adjectives (quick → quickly), though many common adverbs don't (fast, well, very, too)
• Indicate degree and frequency—words like "very," "almost," "always," and "never" are adverbs that frequently appear in modifier placement questions

---

Phrase-Level Modifiers

Phrases work as modifier units, adding layers of detail to sentences. The key is recognizing what type of word the phrase modifies—this determines whether it functions as an adjective or adverb.

Prepositional Phrases

• Consist of a preposition + noun/pronoun—phrases like "in the park," "after dinner," or "with great care" provide context about location, time, manner, or direction
• Function as adjectives or adverbs depending on what they modify—"the book on the table" (adjective) vs. "she ran into the room" (adverb)
• Placement matters for clarity—moving a prepositional phrase can change meaning entirely, making these common in editing questions

Infinitive Phrases

• Begin with "to" + base verb—phrases like "to win the game" or "to improve her skills" can function as nouns, adjectives, or adverbs
• Often express purpose or intention—when modifying a verb, they typically answer why ("She studied to pass the exam")
• Versatile but must connect logically to the sentence's subject—a misplaced infinitive phrase creates the same confusion as other modifier errors

Participles and Participial Phrases

• Verb forms functioning as adjectives—present participles end in "-ing" (running water), past participles often end in "-ed" or take irregular forms (written letter, broken window)
• Participial phrases add detail by combining the participle with objects or modifiers ("Running through the rain, she reached the door")
• Must modify a clear, logical subject—participial phrases are the most common source of dangling modifier errors on exams

---

Clause-Level Modifiers

Relative clauses are dependent clauses that modify nouns. The distinction between restrictive and non-restrictive clauses affects both meaning and punctuation—a favorite testing ground.

Relative Clauses

• Begin with relative pronouns (who, whom, whose, which, that) and provide additional information about a noun in the main clause
• Restrictive clauses are essential to meaning and use no commas ("The student who studied passed"); non-restrictive clauses add extra detail and require commas ("My sister*, who lives in Boston,* visited")
• "That" vs. "which" distinction: "that" introduces restrictive clauses; "which" typically introduces non-restrictive clauses set off by commas

---

Comparison Structures

Comparatives and superlatives allow us to express relationships between items. The rules governing their formation depend on the length and origin of the adjective or adverb.

Comparative and Superlative Forms

• Comparatives compare two items using "-er" for short words (taller, faster) or "more" for longer words (more beautiful, more carefully)
• Superlatives indicate the highest degree among three or more, using "-est" (tallest) or "most" (most beautiful)
• Common errors include double comparatives ("more better") and using superlatives for only two items—both are frequently tested

---

Modifier Placement Errors

These three error types appear constantly on standardized tests. Each involves a breakdown in the logical connection between a modifier and what it's supposed to modify.

Dangling Modifiers

• Occur when the intended subject is missing from the sentence—"Running down the street, the flowers were beautiful" implies the flowers were running
• Introductory participial phrases are the usual culprit—the subject immediately following the comma must be performing the action in the phrase
• Fix by adding the correct subject or restructuring: "Running down the street, I noticed the beautiful flowers" or "As I ran down the street, the flowers looked beautiful"

Misplaced Modifiers

• Positioned too far from what they modify—"She almost drove her kids to school every day" suggests she nearly drove but didn't, when the intended meaning is she drove almost every day
• Adverbs like "only," "just," "almost," and "nearly" are frequent offenders—their placement dramatically changes meaning
• Fix by moving the modifier directly before or after the word it logically modifies: "She drove her kids to school almost every day"

Squinting Modifiers

• Can logically modify words on either side—"Students who practice often improve quickly" could mean they practice often or they often improve
• Create ambiguity that confuses readers—the sentence structure allows two valid interpretations
• Fix by repositioning for clarity: "Often, students who practice improve quickly" or "Students who practice improve quickly and often"

---

Quick Reference Table

---

Self-Check Questions

1. What's the key difference between a dangling modifier and a misplaced modifier, and how would you fix each type?

2. Which two modifier types both function as adjectives but differ in their grammatical origin—and how can you tell them apart in a sentence?

3. Compare restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses: how does removing each type affect the sentence's meaning, and what punctuation rule applies?

4. If you see the sentence "She only eats vegetables on Tuesdays," what's the ambiguity, and how would you revise it to clarify two different possible meanings?

5. An FRQ asks you to combine two sentences using a participial phrase. What must you check to ensure you haven't created a dangling modifier?