Fiveable
🧬AP Biology
​

🧬AP Biology

FRQ 1 – Interpreting and Evaluating Experimental Results (Long)
​
Unit 1: Chemistry of Life
​
Practice FRQ 1 of 201/20
1. Proteins are essential macromolecules that perform a diverse range of functions within living organisms, and their function is strictly dependent on their three-dimensional structure.
Researchers are investigating the structural stability of Protein X, a secreted protein found in certain bacteria. They hypothesize that a disulfide bond between two cysteine residues is critical for the protein's stability. To test this, they created a mutant version of Protein X in which the two cysteine residues were replaced with alanine residues.
In their first experiment, the researchers purified both the wild-type Protein X and the mutant protein. They incubated samples of each protein at various temperatures ranging from 20°C to 80°C for 30 minutes and then measured the percent of protein that remained folded (functional). The results are shown in Figure 1.
To determine whether the disulfide bond formed in the wild-type protein is intermolecular (between two separate polypeptide chains) or intramolecular (within a single chain), the researchers performed a second experiment. They analyzed the wild-type and mutant proteins using SDS-PAGE gel electrophoresis under two conditions: non-reducing (which leaves disulfide bonds intact) and reducing (which breaks disulfide bonds). The results are represented in Figure 2.
A. Describe how the R-groups of amino acids contribute to the tertiary structure of a protein.

Figure 1. Effect of temperature on the stability of wild-type and mutant Protein X after 30-minute incubation. Percent of protein remaining folded is plotted versus temperature. Error bars show ±2 standard errors (±5 percentage points) at every temperature for both proteins.

Single-panel line graph with two plotted data series.

Axes (REQUIRED):
- X-axis label centered below axis: "Temperature (°C)".
- X-axis numerical range: from 20 to 80.
- X-axis tick marks and printed tick labels: 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80 (tick interval of 10 °C).
- Y-axis label centered along left axis, rotated vertical: "Percent Folded Protein".
- Y-axis numerical range: from 0 to 100.
- Y-axis tick marks and printed tick labels: 0, 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80, 90, 100 (tick interval of 10%).
- Origin requirement: the intersection of the axes is labeled "0" at the lower-left corner (y=0 at the bottom; the left end of the x-axis begins at 20 but the axis intersection still carries the visible label "0").
- Arrows on positive ends of both axes: an arrow at the right end of the x-axis and an arrow at the top end of the y-axis.
- No gridlines.

Plotted series styling:
- Wild-type Protein X: solid black line, medium thickness, with filled circular markers exactly at each measured temperature.
- Mutant Protein X (Cys→Ala substitutions): dashed black line, same thickness as wild-type, with open circular markers exactly at each measured temperature.
- A legend inside the plotting area in the upper-right quadrant: solid line labeled "Wild-type"; dashed line labeled "Mutant".

Data point placement and exact values (must match axis tick labels exactly):
- Temperatures shown with markers for BOTH series: 20°C, 40°C, 60°C, 80°C (no other markers).
- Wild-type series marker heights:
  - At 20°C, marker sits exactly on the 100% tick line.
  - At 40°C, marker sits exactly halfway between the 90% and 100% tick lines, indicating 95%.
  - At 60°C, marker sits exactly on the 50% tick line.
  - At 80°C, marker sits exactly on the 0% tick line.
- Mutant series marker heights:
  - At 20°C, marker sits exactly on the 100% tick line.
  - At 40°C, marker sits exactly on the 50% tick line.
  - At 60°C, marker sits exactly on the 0% tick line.
  - At 80°C, no mutant marker is shown (series ends at 60°C), so the dashed line does not extend to 80°C.

Curve shape description (REQUIRED):
- Wild-type curve path:
  - Starts at the leftmost wild-type marker at the top of the plot on the 100% line.
  - From 20°C to 40°C: connected by a straight line segment with a gentle negative slope (slight decrease).
  - From 40°C to 60°C: connected by a straight line segment with a steep negative slope (large decrease), creating a clear corner (change in slope) at 40°C.
  - From 60°C to 80°C: connected by a straight line segment with a steep negative slope to the bottom axis, creating a second clear corner at 60°C.
  - The series ends at 80°C with a filled circular marker on the 0% line (no continuation beyond 80°C).
- Mutant curve path:
  - Starts at the leftmost mutant marker on the 100% line at 20°C.
  - From 20°C to 40°C: connected by a straight line segment with a steep negative slope to 50%, producing a sharp drop.
  - From 40°C to 60°C: connected by a straight line segment with a steep negative slope from 50% to 0%, producing a second sharp drop.
  - The series ends at 60°C with an open circular marker exactly on the 0% line; the dashed line stops there and does not continue toward 80°C.

Curve behavior (REQUIRED):
- All segments for both series are straight-line connections between markers (no smoothing, no curvature, no concavity). 
- Two slope-change corners for the wild-type series occur exactly at the 40°C marker and exactly at the 60°C marker.
- One slope-change corner for the mutant series occurs exactly at the 40°C marker.
- No maxima or minima inside the plot other than endpoints; both series are strictly non-increasing over their displayed temperature ranges.
- No asymptotes, no discontinuities.

Error bars (must be visually exact):
- At every displayed marker for BOTH series, draw vertical error bars centered on the marker.
- Each error bar extends exactly 5 percentage points above and 5 percentage points below the marker (this equals ±2SE).
- Error bar caps are short horizontal lines.
- Ensure error bars do not change size across temperatures.
- For markers on 0% (wild-type at 80°C; mutant at 60°C), the lower half of the error bar extends below the 0% axis line (so it is visible that the bar length is symmetric), while the y-axis still spans 0–100 with the plotted point on the baseline.
B.
i. Identify the dependent variable in the experiment shown in Figure 1.
ii. Justify why the researchers compared the thermal stability of the mutant protein to the wild-type protein instead of comparing it to a protein with a random amino acid sequence.
iii. Based on Figure 1, describe the effect of the amino acid substitution on the thermal stability of Protein X.

Figure 2. SDS-PAGE analysis of wild-type and cysteine-to-alanine mutant Protein X under non-reducing and reducing conditions. Lane 1 is a molecular mass marker (kDa).

Black-and-white schematic of a vertical SDS-PAGE gel with five lanes arranged left-to-right, enclosed by a rectangular gel outline.

Overall gel layout and orientation:
- The gel is a tall rectangle (height greater than width).
- The top edge of the gel is labeled "Top" (small text above the gel), indicating the sample wells are at the top.
- Molecular mass decreases from top to bottom (high kDa bands appear higher; low kDa bands appear lower).
- A vertical label on the far left of the gel reads "Molecular mass (kDa)".

Lane arrangement (exact left-to-right order):
- Five equal-width lanes, evenly spaced, spanning the gel from left to right.
- Each lane has a lane number centered above it: "1", "2", "3", "4", "5".
- Each lane also has a condition label centered directly below the gel aligned with that lane:
  - Lane 1 label below: "Marker".
  - Lane 2 label below: "Wild-type, Non-reducing".
  - Lane 3 label below: "Wild-type, Reducing".
  - Lane 4 label below: "Mutant, Non-reducing".
  - Lane 5 label below: "Mutant, Reducing".

Marker lane (Lane 1) bands and kDa labels:
- In lane 1, draw seven thin horizontal bands.
- The seven bands are positioned at evenly separated heights from near the top toward the lower half.
- To the immediate left of lane 1 (outside the lane but inside the gel figure area), print the kDa values aligned horizontally with each band. The printed labels (from highest band at top to lowest band at bottom) are: "70", "60", "50", "40", "30", "20", "10".
- Ensure each printed kDa value is exactly level with its corresponding band.

Sample lanes (Lanes 2–5) band positions and exact masses:
- Lane 2 (Wild-type, Non-reducing):
  - Exactly one bold horizontal band.
  - The band is positioned at the same height as the "60" kDa marker band in lane 1.
  - No other bands in lane 2.
- Lane 3 (Wild-type, Reducing):
  - Exactly one bold horizontal band.
  - The band is positioned at the same height as the "30" kDa marker band in lane 1.
  - No other bands in lane 3.
- Lane 4 (Mutant, Non-reducing):
  - Exactly one bold horizontal band.
  - The band is positioned at the same height as the "30" kDa marker band in lane 1.
  - No other bands in lane 4.
- Lane 5 (Mutant, Reducing):
  - Exactly one bold horizontal band.
  - The band is positioned at the same height as the "30" kDa marker band in lane 1.
  - No other bands in lane 5.

Band styling and consistency:
- Marker bands are thin and uniform.
- Sample bands are thicker/darker than marker bands to indicate the protein signal.
- All single bands in lanes 3, 4, and 5 have identical thickness and darkness to each other.
- The single band in lane 2 has the same thickness/darkness as the other sample bands, only differing in vertical position.

No extra elements:
- No smear, no additional faint bands, no background shading.
- No title inside the gel other than lane numbers, lane labels, and the kDa scale labels.
C.
i. Identify the independent variable in the researchers' second experiment (results shown in Figure 2).
ii. Based on Figure 2, identify the specific lane(s) containing Protein X in a multimeric (dimer) state.
iii. Based on the data in Figure 2, the monomeric form of Protein X has an approximate molecular mass of 30 kDa (30,000 Daltons). Assuming the average molecular mass of an amino acid is 120 Daltons, calculate the approximate number of amino acids in the monomeric protein.
D.
i. Researchers claim that the formation of the disulfide bond in Protein X is intermolecular rather than intramolecular. Using evidence from Figure 2, support the researchers' claim.
ii. Justify the claim that replacing cysteine with alanine prevents the formation of disulfide bonds based on the chemical properties of their R-groups.






Pep