5.1 The structure of the UK court system
6 min read•august 16, 2024
The UK court system is a complex hierarchy designed to handle various legal matters. From local Magistrates' Courts to the , each level plays a specific role in administering justice. This structure ensures cases are heard at the appropriate level and allows for appeals to higher courts.
Understanding the differences between civil and criminal courts is crucial. Civil courts resolve disputes between individuals or organizations, while criminal courts deal with offenses against society. The court structure, procedures, and standards of proof vary between these two types of cases.
UK Court Hierarchy
Structure and Levels
Top images from around the web for Structure and Levels
The British Political System - lernen mit Serlo! View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Diagram of the court system of England and Wales 2014.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
File:English court system.png - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
The British Political System - lernen mit Serlo! View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Diagram of the court system of England and Wales 2014.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Structure and Levels
The British Political System - lernen mit Serlo! View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Diagram of the court system of England and Wales 2014.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
File:English court system.png - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
The British Political System - lernen mit Serlo! View original
Is this image relevant?
File:Diagram of the court system of England and Wales 2014.svg - Wikimedia Commons View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- UK court system structured hierarchically with lower courts at base and higher courts at top
- Culminates in Supreme Court at apex of system
- Lower level courts include Magistrates' Courts and County Courts
- Magistrates' Courts handle minor criminal offenses and preliminary hearings
- County Courts deal with civil matters like small claims and debt cases
- Intermediate level courts comprise Crown Courts and High Courts
- Crown Courts handle more serious criminal cases and appeals from Magistrates' Courts
- divided into , , and Family divisions for complex civil matters
- Highest level courts are and Supreme Court
- Court of Appeal hears appeals from lower courts
- Supreme Court is final court of appeal for all UK civil cases and criminal cases from England, Wales, and Northern Ireland
Specialized Courts and Regional Differences
- operate alongside main court system
- Handle specialized areas of law (employment tribunals, immigration tribunals)
- Court structure differs slightly between UK nations
- Reflects devolved justice system in Scotland, Northern Ireland
- Scotland has separate High Court of Justiciary for criminal cases
- Northern Ireland has similar structure to England/Wales with some unique courts
- Supreme Court established in 2009
- Replaced judicial functions of House of Lords
- Acts as final appellate court for whole UK
Precedent and Hierarchy
- () crucial in court hierarchy
- Decisions of higher courts binding on lower courts
- Ensures consistency and predictability in legal rulings
- Vertical precedent binds lower courts to higher court decisions
- Supreme Court decisions binding on all lower UK courts
- Court of Appeal decisions binding on High Court and lower courts
- Horizontal precedent generally binds courts to their own prior decisions
- Supreme Court can overrule its own previous decisions in rare cases
Civil vs Criminal Courts
Key Differences
- Civil courts resolve disputes between individuals or organizations
- Handle cases like contract disputes, property issues, family law matters
- Criminal courts address cases brought by state against accused lawbreakers
- Deal with offenses against society (theft, assault, murder)
- Burden of proof differs between civil and criminal cases
- Criminal cases require proof "beyond reasonable doubt"
- Civil cases use "balance of probabilities" standard
- Primary aims of civil and criminal courts differ
- Civil courts focus on dispute resolution and providing remedies (damages, injunctions)
- Criminal courts determine guilt and impose punishments (fines, imprisonment)
Court Structure for Civil and Criminal Cases
- In England and Wales, different courts handle civil and criminal matters
- Magistrates' Courts and Crown Courts primarily handle criminal cases
- County Courts and High Court mainly deal with civil matters
- Court of Appeal has separate Civil and Criminal Divisions
- hears appeals from County Courts and High Court
- handles appeals from
- Some courts have both civil and criminal
- High Court can hear both types of cases through different divisions
- Magistrates' Courts have limited civil jurisdiction (family proceedings)
Procedural Differences
- Civil cases typically initiated by the (plaintiff)
- Claimant files a claim form outlining their case
- Criminal cases usually initiated by police or Crown Prosecution Service
- brings charges against the
- Civil cases often allow for out-of-court settlements
- Mediation and alternative dispute resolution encouraged
- Criminal cases generally require full court proceedings
- Plea bargaining possible but less common than in some other jurisdictions
Court Jurisdiction in the UK
Lower Courts' Jurisdiction
- Magistrates' Courts have jurisdiction over:
- (less serious crimes)
- Some (can be tried in Magistrates' or Crown Court)
- Early stages of more serious criminal cases (committal hearings)
- Limited civil matters (family proceedings, licensing applications)
- County Courts handle wide range of civil disputes:
- Small claims (usually up to £10,000)
- Consumer cases (faulty goods, poor services)
- Some family matters (divorce proceedings)
- Landlord-tenant disputes
- Personal injury claims below certain value
Higher Courts' Jurisdiction
- Crown Courts have jurisdiction over:
- Serious criminal cases ()
- Appeals from Magistrates' Courts
- Some civil matters (rarely exercised)
- High Court divided into three divisions with specific jurisdictions:
- Queen's Bench Division: contract and cases,
- Chancery Division: business law, trusts, probate, intellectual property
- : complex family matters, wardship
- Court of Appeal jurisdiction:
- Civil Division hears appeals from High Court and County Courts
- Criminal Division handles appeals from Crown Court
- Supreme Court has ultimate jurisdiction over:
- All civil matters in the UK
- Criminal matters in England, Wales, and Northern Ireland
- Constitutional issues and devolution matters
Specialized and Regional Jurisdictions
- Tribunals have jurisdiction over specialized areas:
- Employment tribunals handle workplace disputes
- Immigration tribunals deal with asylum and immigration cases
- Scottish courts operate under separate legal system:
- Court of Session is supreme civil court
- High Court of Justiciary is supreme criminal court
- Northern Ireland has similar structure to England/Wales
- Some unique courts like Coroners' Courts have specific jurisdictions
Appeals Process in the UK Courts
Grounds and Limitations of Appeals
- Right to appeal generally based on points of law rather than facts
- Exceptions exist for cases with new evidence or procedural irregularities
- Appeals typically require permission ()
- Granted if case raises important point of law or principle
- Principle of finality limits number of appeals possible
- Most cases conclude after one or two levels of appeal
- Time limits apply for filing appeals
- Vary depending on court and type of case (usually 14-28 days)
Appeal Routes in England and Wales
- Appeals from Magistrates' Courts:
- Criminal cases typically heard in Crown Court
- Civil matters appealed to High Court
- Crown Court decisions appealed to Court of Appeal (Criminal Division)
- decisions appealed to:
- High Court for most cases
- Court of Appeal (Civil Division) for some matters
- High Court decisions generally appealed to Court of Appeal
- Court of Appeal decisions may be appealed to Supreme Court
- Requires permission and involves points of law of general public importance
Special Appeal Procedures
- 'Leapfrog' procedure allows some cases to bypass Court of Appeal
- Direct appeal from High Court to Supreme Court
- Subject to strict criteria (point of law of general public importance)
- Case stated procedure for appealing on point of law
- Used for appeals from Magistrates' Courts to High Court
- Judicial review process for challenging public body decisions
- Heard in Administrative Court (part of High Court)
- Further appeals possible to Court of Appeal and Supreme Court
Scottish and Northern Irish Appeal Routes
- Scottish appeal system differs from England and Wales
- Sheriff Court appeals heard by Sheriff Appeal Court
- Court of Session Inner House hears civil appeals
- High Court of Justiciary hears criminal appeals
- Northern Irish system similar to England/Wales
- County Court appeals to Court of Appeal
- Crown Court appeals to Court of Appeal
- Both systems allow final appeals to UK Supreme Court
- Limited to civil cases and points of law for criminal cases
Key Terms to Review (30)
Appeal process: The appeal process is the legal procedure through which a party seeks a higher court's review of a decision made by a lower court. This process allows for the correction of errors made in the initial trial, ensuring that justice is served and that legal standards are upheld. It serves as a critical check within the judicial system, facilitating the possibility of reversing or modifying lower court rulings based on various grounds such as procedural mistakes or misinterpretation of law.
Chancery: Chancery refers to a specific type of court in the UK court system, traditionally responsible for dealing with matters of equity, such as trusts, wills, and guardianship. It operates alongside common law courts and is known for its flexibility and focus on fairness rather than strict adherence to legal precedents. The Chancery Division is now part of the High Court of Justice, reflecting its important role in the overall structure of the UK judicial system.
Civil division: Civil division refers to the branch of the court system that deals with non-criminal legal disputes between individuals, organizations, or government entities. This area of the court system handles matters such as contracts, property disputes, family law issues, and tort claims. Civil division is crucial for resolving conflicts and ensuring that rights and obligations are enforced within the legal framework.
Claimant: A claimant is an individual or entity that asserts a right or seeks a remedy from a court or tribunal, often in the context of civil litigation. In the UK court system, claimants play a crucial role as they initiate legal proceedings by making claims for damages or specific performance against defendants. Understanding the role of claimants helps to clarify the procedural dynamics within the various levels of courts and the nature of disputes being resolved.
County court: A county court is a type of court in England and Wales that handles civil cases, as well as certain family law matters. It serves as an important tier in the judicial system, dealing with claims and disputes typically involving amounts of money below a specific threshold, and is a key player in ensuring access to justice at a local level.
Court of Appeal: The Court of Appeal is a key component of the UK court system that hears appeals from lower courts and tribunals. It plays a critical role in ensuring the uniform application of law and offers a platform for correcting legal errors made in earlier judgments. Comprised of two divisions—Civil and Criminal—the Court of Appeal serves as an essential mechanism for maintaining justice and safeguarding legal principles across the UK.
Criminal Division: The Criminal Division is a part of the UK court system responsible for handling criminal cases, including serious offenses such as murder, robbery, and drug trafficking. This division operates at different levels of the court system, with cases initially heard in the Magistrates' Court and more serious cases being escalated to the Crown Court. The structure ensures that justice is served through a tiered approach, reflecting the severity and complexity of various crimes.
Crown court: A crown court is a type of court in the UK that deals primarily with serious criminal cases, including those that involve indictable offenses. It operates under the authority of the Crown and is crucial for the judiciary's role in upholding justice, ensuring that laws are interpreted fairly and applied correctly in serious matters. Crown courts handle trials by jury, emphasizing the importance of public participation in the legal process and upholding defendants' rights.
Defendant: A defendant is an individual or entity accused of committing a crime or being sued in a court of law. This term is fundamental to the legal process, as it represents the party that must respond to the allegations made against them, whether in a civil or criminal case. The role of a defendant is crucial because they have the right to defend themselves, present evidence, and challenge the claims made by the opposing party.
Doctrine of precedent: The doctrine of precedent, also known as stare decisis, is a legal principle that obligates courts to follow established case law when making decisions in similar cases. This principle ensures consistency and predictability in the law by requiring lower courts to adhere to the rulings of higher courts within the same jurisdiction. The doctrine plays a crucial role in shaping the UK court system by providing a framework for legal decision-making and allowing for the evolution of the law over time.
Due process: Due process is a legal principle that ensures fair treatment through the normal judicial system, especially as a citizen's entitlement. It connects to various essential features like the right to a fair trial, the protection against arbitrary denial of life, liberty, or property, and the overall functioning of the legal system within a democracy.
Either-way offenses: Either-way offenses are criminal offenses in the UK that can be tried either in the Magistrates' Court or the Crown Court, depending on the seriousness of the crime and the preferences of the defendant. These offenses represent a middle category in the criminal justice system, providing flexibility in how cases are prosecuted and allowing for different legal procedures based on various factors, such as the defendant's plea and prior criminal history.
Family Division: Family Division refers to a specialized segment of the court system in the UK that deals primarily with legal issues related to family law, including divorce, child custody, and domestic disputes. This division ensures that family matters are handled by judges who have specific expertise and experience in the complexities of familial relationships and associated legalities.
High Court: The High Court is a senior court in the UK judicial system, responsible for handling serious civil and criminal cases. It sits above the County Courts and below the Court of Appeal, playing a crucial role in interpreting and applying the law. The High Court consists of three divisions: the Queen's Bench Division, the Chancery Division, and the Family Division, each focusing on different areas of law and providing an essential function in maintaining justice and upholding rights.
Indictable offenses: Indictable offenses are serious criminal offenses in the UK that are typically tried in the Crown Court. These offenses can result in severe penalties, including imprisonment, and they often involve crimes such as murder, rape, and robbery. Due to their severity, indictable offenses have specific legal procedures for prosecution and trial, distinguishing them from less serious offenses, which may be handled in a different court system.
Judicial Review: Judicial review is the power of courts to assess whether a law, policy, or action by the government is constitutional and to invalidate those that are not. This mechanism plays a crucial role in maintaining the balance of power between branches of government and protecting individual rights within the legal framework.
Jurisdiction: Jurisdiction refers to the authority granted to a legal body, such as a court, to make decisions and enforce laws within a specific geographic area or over certain types of legal matters. This concept is essential in understanding how courts operate, as it determines which cases a court can hear and the scope of its power. Jurisdiction can be divided into various categories, including original jurisdiction, appellate jurisdiction, and subject matter jurisdiction, all of which help clarify the role and limits of different courts in the legal system.
Leave to appeal: Leave to appeal is a legal term that refers to the permission granted by a court for a party to challenge a decision made by a lower court in a higher court. This process is crucial within the judicial system as it ensures that not every case automatically moves up the hierarchy, but rather, only those deemed worthy of further scrutiny are allowed to proceed, maintaining efficiency and focusing resources on significant legal questions.
Magistrates' court: A magistrates' court is a lower-level court in the UK that primarily handles summary offenses and preliminary hearings for more serious offenses. These courts are essential for the functioning of the criminal justice system, as they manage a large volume of cases, providing swift and accessible justice. Magistrates' courts typically consist of a panel of lay magistrates or a district judge who presides over proceedings, making them an integral part of the judiciary in maintaining law and order.
Prosecutor: A prosecutor is a legal representative of the state or government who brings charges against individuals accused of committing crimes in a court of law. They play a crucial role in the criminal justice system by presenting evidence, guiding investigations, and advocating for justice on behalf of the state. Prosecutors work within the framework of the court system, collaborating with law enforcement and ensuring that the legal process is followed fairly and effectively.
Queen's bench: The Queen's Bench is a division of the High Court of Justice in England and Wales, primarily dealing with civil cases and providing a forum for significant legal disputes. It has the authority to hear a wide range of cases, including personal injury claims, breach of contract, and judicial reviews. As part of the wider court system, it plays a crucial role in interpreting laws and ensuring justice is served in civil matters.
Sentence: In the context of the UK court system, a sentence refers to the judicial decision regarding the punishment of a convicted individual. It encompasses the duration and type of punishment imposed by the court, which can include imprisonment, fines, community service, or other forms of rehabilitation. The nature of the sentence is influenced by various factors including the severity of the crime, mitigating circumstances, and statutory guidelines.
Stare decisis: Stare decisis is a legal principle that dictates that courts should follow precedents set by previous decisions when ruling on similar cases. This doctrine promotes consistency and stability in the law, as it encourages judges to rely on established legal interpretations rather than creating new ones each time. By adhering to past rulings, stare decisis plays a crucial role in both the structure of the court system and the judiciary's function in applying and interpreting laws.
Summary offenses: Summary offenses are the least serious category of criminal offenses in the UK legal system, typically tried in a magistrates' court. These offenses often involve minor crimes such as petty theft or public disorder and are generally punishable by a fine or a short prison sentence. Because they are less severe, summary offenses do not carry the same legal complexities as indictable offenses, allowing for quicker resolutions in the judicial process.
Supreme Court: The Supreme Court is the highest court in the United Kingdom, serving as the final court of appeal in civil and criminal cases. It plays a crucial role in ensuring the law is interpreted consistently and fairly, impacting the overall structure of the judicial system and the application of law across the country.
Tort: A tort is a civil wrong that causes harm or loss to another person, leading to legal liability for the person who commits the act. This concept is crucial in the UK legal system as it provides a framework for individuals to seek compensation for damages caused by the wrongful acts of others. Torts can arise from various situations, including negligence, defamation, and trespass, and they can result in civil suits being filed in court.
Trial by jury: Trial by jury is a legal process where a group of citizens is convened to assess the evidence in a case and determine the verdict, playing a vital role in the justice system. This process ensures that the accused has their case heard by peers, reflecting the democratic principles of fairness and impartiality in legal proceedings. It is an important safeguard against potential abuses of power in both criminal and civil cases.
Tribunals: Tribunals are specialized judicial bodies in the UK that deal with specific areas of law, distinct from traditional courts. They are designed to provide a more accessible and informal environment for resolving disputes, often focused on areas like immigration, employment, and social security. Tribunals play a crucial role in ensuring that individuals can seek justice in specialized matters without the complexities of higher court systems.
Verdict: A verdict is the formal decision or finding made by a jury or judge in a court case, determining the outcome of a trial. It signifies the conclusion of legal proceedings, establishing whether the accused is guilty or not guilty in criminal cases, or who wins in civil cases. The verdict serves as a critical component of the judicial process and reflects the application of law and justice within the court system.
Writ: A writ is a formal legal order issued by a court that commands the person to whom it is addressed to perform or refrain from performing a specific act. Writs serve as crucial mechanisms in the judicial system, ensuring that legal rights are upheld and providing a means for parties to seek remedies through the court. They can take various forms, such as a writ of habeas corpus, which protects against unlawful detention, or a writ of certiorari, which directs a lower court to send records for review.