1.1 The nature and sources of the UK constitution
4 min read•august 16, 2024
The UK constitution is unique, blending written and unwritten elements from various sources. It's flexible, allowing adaptation to changing times without formal amendments. This flexibility stems from its uncodified nature, relying on statutes, , conventions, and historical documents.
At its core, the UK constitution rests on key principles like and . These shape how government works and ensure accountability. The system's flexibility has pros and cons, enabling quick changes but potentially creating uncertainty about constitutional rules.
Characteristics of the UK Constitution
Uncodified Nature and Flexibility
Top images from around the web for Uncodified Nature and Flexibility
Fixed term Parliaments: ten observations from across the pond View original
Is this image relevant?
The Campaign for Suffrage View original
Is this image relevant?
Fixed term Parliaments: ten observations from across the pond View original
Is this image relevant?
The Campaign for Suffrage View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Uncodified Nature and Flexibility
Fixed term Parliaments: ten observations from across the pond View original
Is this image relevant?
The Campaign for Suffrage View original
Is this image relevant?
Fixed term Parliaments: ten observations from across the pond View original
Is this image relevant?
The Campaign for Suffrage View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Uncodified constitution derives from various sources rather than a single document
- Highly flexible allows evolution and adaptation to changing circumstances without formal amendments
- Adapts to new political realities ( to Scotland and Wales in late 1990s)
- Responds to societal changes (expanding voting rights over time)
- Relies heavily on conventions non-legally binding but politically obligatory practices
- Prime Minister resigning after losing a vote of no confidence
- Monarch acting on advice of ministers
Core Constitutional Principles
- Parliamentary sovereignty grants ultimate law-making authority to UK
- Parliament can make or unmake any law
- No other body can override Acts of Parliament
- Rule of law ensures all individuals and institutions subject to and accountable to law
- Government must act within legal limits
- Courts can review legality of actions
- System of checks and balances despite no formal separation of powers
- reviews legality of government actions
- Parliament scrutinizes executive through committees
Sources of the UK Constitution
Statutory and Common Law Sources
- Statutes (Acts of Parliament) form significant part of constitution
- Human Rights Act 1998 incorporated European Convention on Human Rights
- Scotland Act 1998 established Scottish Parliament and devolved powers
- Act 2005 reformed judicial appointments
- Common law developed through judicial decisions over centuries
- Right to a fair trial
- Principle of habeas corpus
- Doctrine of ministerial responsibility
Unwritten Sources and International Influences
- Constitutional conventions unwritten rules governing behavior of constitutional actors
- Prime Minister is leader of largest party in House of Commons
- Ministers must be members of Parliament
- Royal Prerogative powers exercised by ministers on behalf of monarch
- Conducting foreign affairs
- Granting honors
- Appointing ministers
- International treaties and agreements influenced constitutional framework
- EU membership shaped UK law pre-Brexit (European Communities Act 1972)
- European Convention on Human Rights incorporated via Human Rights Act
- Academic works by constitutional scholars aid interpretation
- 's Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution
- Walter Bagehot's The English Constitution
Historical Documents and the UK Constitution
Medieval and Early Modern Foundations
- (1215) established principles of limited government and individual rights
- Constrained monarchical power
- Established right to due process
- Bill of Rights (1689) further limited monarchical power and strengthened Parliament
- Prohibited monarch from suspending laws
- Established free elections for Parliament
- Act of Settlement (1701) established royal succession rules and judicial independence
- Required judges to hold office during good behavior not at monarch's pleasure
- Limited succession to Protestant heirs
Modern Constitutional Developments
- Acts of Union (1707 and 1800) created unified Kingdom of Great Britain and later UK
- Merged English and Scottish parliaments
- Incorporated Ireland into United Kingdom
- Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949 redefined relationship between Commons and Lords
- Limited Lords' power to block legislation
- Established Commons' primacy in financial matters
- European Communities Act 1972 (repealed) incorporated EU law into UK legal system
- Gave EU law supremacy over UK law in certain areas
- Allowed direct application of EU regulations
Advantages vs Disadvantages of an Uncodified Constitution
Benefits of Constitutional Flexibility
- Allows evolution without formal amendment procedures
- Constitution adapted to universal suffrage without needing formal amendments
- Devolution implemented through regular Acts of Parliament
- Permits nuanced response to political crises and changing societal needs
- War-time coalition governments formed without constitutional barriers
- Constitutional conventions evolved to limit monarch's personal power
- Fosters culture of political pragmatism and compromise
- Changes can be made through normal legislative processes
- Encourages negotiation and consensus-building in Parliament
Challenges of an Uncodified System
- Potential uncertainty and lack of clarity about constitutional rules
- Debates over extent of royal prerogative powers
- Ambiguity in conventions like ministerial responsibility
- Absence of special protection for constitutional norms
- Fundamental rights can be altered by simple majority in Parliament
- No entrenched provisions requiring supermajorities to change
- Risk of excessive concentration of power in executive
- Prime Minister's powers expanded through convention without formal checks
- Erosion of parliamentary scrutiny through use of statutory instruments
- Complexity makes constitution less accessible to general public
- Requires understanding of various sources and historical context
- Can undermine democratic engagement and constitutional literacy
Key Terms to Review (19)
A.V. Dicey: A.V. Dicey was a British jurist and constitutional theorist, best known for his influential work 'Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution,' published in 1885. His ideas helped shape the understanding of constitutional law in the UK, particularly regarding the rule of law and parliamentary sovereignty, making him a key figure in discussions around how these principles govern the political landscape.
Bill of Rights 1689: The Bill of Rights 1689 is a significant constitutional document in the UK that established key civil liberties and limited the powers of the monarchy following the Glorious Revolution. It reinforced the principle of parliamentary sovereignty and set the framework for modern democracy in Britain, establishing rights such as freedom from cruel and unusual punishment and the right to petition the monarch.
Codified constitution: A codified constitution is a single, written document that outlines the fundamental laws and principles of a state, establishing the framework for government and the rights of citizens. This type of constitution is distinct from an uncodified constitution, which may be based on statutes, conventions, and judicial decisions rather than a singular written text. Codified constitutions provide clarity and certainty in legal interpretation and governance.
Common law: Common law is a system of law developed through court decisions and judicial rulings, rather than through legislative statutes or executive branch action. It emphasizes the role of judges in interpreting laws and establishing legal precedents that guide future cases, which connects to the principles of fairness and equality before the law. This legal framework significantly influences the nature of the constitution, as it serves as a source of law that complements statutory provisions and is essential in understanding the application of parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law.
Constitutional convention: A constitutional convention is an unwritten rule or practice that evolves over time, guiding the actions of political institutions and government officials within the framework of the UK constitution. These conventions play a critical role in maintaining the functioning of the political system by filling gaps left by legal statutes and ensuring that the practices of governance align with democratic principles and accountability.
Constitutional reform: Constitutional reform refers to the process of altering the structure, rules, or provisions of a constitution to address contemporary issues, improve governance, or enhance democratic processes. This concept is particularly significant in the context of the UK constitution, which is unique due to its uncodified nature and reliance on statutes, conventions, and legal precedents. As societal needs evolve and challenges arise, the necessity for reform becomes evident to ensure that the constitutional framework remains relevant and effective.
Devolution: Devolution refers to the transfer of powers and responsibilities from a central government to local or regional governments. This process has reshaped governance in various parts of the UK, allowing for greater autonomy and self-governance, impacting political dynamics and public policy across the regions.
Executive: The executive refers to the branch of government responsible for implementing and enforcing laws, overseeing the administration of the state, and managing day-to-day operations. In the context of the UK, the executive is primarily embodied by the Prime Minister and their cabinet, who play a critical role in shaping policy and decision-making while also maintaining the balance of power with the other branches of government, especially the legislature and judiciary.
John Locke: John Locke was a 17th-century English philosopher known for his contributions to political theory, particularly regarding the concepts of natural rights, social contracts, and government legitimacy. His ideas played a crucial role in shaping modern democratic thought and have influenced the development of constitutionalism, particularly in the context of the UK constitution and comparisons with other political systems.
Judiciary: The judiciary is the system of courts that interprets and applies the law in the name of the state. It serves as a crucial pillar of democracy, ensuring that laws are upheld and justice is administered fairly. In the context of the UK Constitution, the judiciary plays a vital role in maintaining the rule of law, protecting individual rights, and checking the powers of the executive and legislative branches.
Legislature: A legislature is a deliberative assembly with the authority to make, amend, or repeal laws within a specific jurisdiction. In the context of the UK constitution, the legislature plays a fundamental role in the democratic process, reflecting the principles of parliamentary sovereignty and representative democracy. It consists of two houses, the House of Commons and the House of Lords, each contributing to the legislative process and ensuring that different perspectives are considered in law-making.
Magna Carta: The Magna Carta, signed in 1215, is a foundational legal document that established the principle that everyone, including the king, is subject to the law. Its significance extends beyond its historical context, influencing various aspects of governance, including the royal prerogative, the rule of law, and the balance of power between the state and individual liberties.
Monarchy: A monarchy is a form of government where a single ruler, known as a monarch, serves as the head of state and often holds a position for life. In the context of the UK, the monarchy represents a constitutional role, meaning the monarch's powers are limited by law and balanced by democratic institutions, reflecting the historical evolution of governance in Britain.
Moral Obligation: Moral obligation refers to the ethical duty individuals or institutions have to act in a way that upholds moral principles and values, even if there is no legal requirement to do so. In the context of governance and constitutional frameworks, it highlights the expectation that authorities should act in a manner that aligns with justice and fairness, impacting the legitimacy of laws and political actions.
Parliament: Parliament is the supreme legislative body in the United Kingdom, consisting of two houses: the House of Commons and the House of Lords. It plays a crucial role in making laws, scrutinizing the government, and representing the electorate. Parliament's functions are fundamental to the democratic framework and political culture of the UK, influencing how power is exercised and laws are created.
Parliamentary Sovereignty: Parliamentary sovereignty is a fundamental principle of the UK constitution that establishes Parliament as the supreme legal authority, with the ability to create or repeal any law without being subject to legal limitations. This means that no other body, including the judiciary, can challenge or invalidate legislation passed by Parliament.
Rule of law: The rule of law is a foundational principle stating that all individuals and institutions, including the government, are subject to and accountable under the law, which is fairly applied and enforced. This principle ensures that no one is above the law and is crucial for maintaining justice, order, and individual rights within a society.
Statute law: Statute law refers to written laws enacted by a legislative body, which in the UK is Parliament. These laws are formal expressions of the will of the legislature and serve as primary sources of law in the UK legal system. Statute law plays a crucial role in shaping the framework of government, the powers of the executive, and the rights of citizens.
Unwritten constitution: An unwritten constitution refers to a system of governance where the fundamental laws and principles are not codified in a single document but are instead based on statutes, conventions, judicial decisions, and historical documents. This type of constitution is characterized by flexibility and adaptability, allowing for gradual changes over time without the need for formal amendments.