13.2 Political and social commentary in genre television
5 min read•july 30, 2024
Genre TV shows often use their unique storytelling tools to tackle real-world issues. From sci-fi imagining future societies to comedies poking fun at societal norms, these shows offer fresh perspectives on complex topics.
By presenting relatable characters facing real challenges, genre TV can humanize political and social issues. This approach sparks conversations beyond the screen, encouraging viewers to question their assumptions and consider new viewpoints.
Political Commentary in TV Genres
Conventions and Storytelling Devices as Vehicles for Commentary
Top images from around the web for Conventions and Storytelling Devices as Vehicles for Commentary
Free vector movie genres icons View original
Is this image relevant?
_(cropped).jpg&w=256&q=75)
Offred (The Handmaid's Tale episode) - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Free vector movie genres icons View original
Is this image relevant?
Offred (The Handmaid's Tale episode) - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Conventions and Storytelling Devices as Vehicles for Commentary
Free vector movie genres icons View original
Is this image relevant?
Offred (The Handmaid's Tale episode) - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
Free vector movie genres icons View original
Is this image relevant?
Offred (The Handmaid's Tale episode) - Wikipedia View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- TV genres often use their established conventions, tropes, and storytelling devices as vehicles to explore and comment on real-world political and social issues
- Science fiction and dystopian genres frequently extrapolate current sociopolitical trends to imagine future societies, highlighting the potential consequences of present-day actions and decisions (Handmaid's Tale, )
- Police procedurals and legal dramas incorporate storylines inspired by contemporary cases and controversies, offering perspectives on issues such as racial profiling, police brutality, and the failings of the justice system (, )
- Sitcoms and animated series often tackle sensitive topics through humor, using comedic exaggeration and absurdity to expose and critique societal norms, prejudices, and power structures (, All in the Family)
- Historical dramas and period pieces draw parallels between past and present, using historical settings to provide commentary on enduring political and social challenges (, )
Humanizing Complex Issues and Challenging Dominant Narratives
- Genre television can raise awareness about important issues by presenting them to a wide audience in an engaging and accessible format, sparking conversations and debates beyond the screen
- TV series have the potential to humanize complex issues by portraying relatable characters facing real-world challenges, fostering empathy and understanding among viewers
- Genre shows can challenge dominant narratives and offer alternative perspectives on political and social issues, encouraging viewers to question their assumptions and consider new viewpoints
- Television's serialized nature allows for in-depth exploration of issues over multiple episodes or seasons, enabling more nuanced and comprehensive commentary than other media formats (The Wire, )
Effectiveness of Genre Television
Audience Fragmentation and Prioritizing Sensationalism
- The effectiveness of genre television in shaping public discourse may be limited by factors such as audience fragmentation, echo chambers, and the tendency for entertainment to prioritize sensationalism over accuracy
- Audience fragmentation occurs when viewers are divided into smaller, more specialized groups based on their interests and preferences, potentially limiting the reach and impact of political and social commentary
- Echo chambers emerge when people primarily consume media that aligns with their existing beliefs and values, reinforcing their perspectives rather than challenging them
- The pressure to attract and retain viewers in a competitive media landscape can lead genre television to prioritize sensationalism, shock value, and superficial engagement with issues over nuanced and accurate portrayal
Sparking Conversations and Debates
- Genre television can raise awareness about important issues by presenting them to a wide audience in an engaging and accessible format, sparking conversations and debates beyond the screen
- TV series that address political and social topics can generate discussions on social media, in classrooms, and around the water cooler, extending the impact of their commentary
- Shows like and 13 Reasons Why have sparked national conversations about issues such as women's rights, sexual assault, and mental health, demonstrating the power of genre television to shape public discourse
- However, the quality and depth of these conversations may vary, as some viewers may engage with the issues superficially or through the lens of their preexisting biases
Satire, Allegory, and Subtext
Defining and Employing Indirect Storytelling Techniques
- uses humor, irony, and exaggeration to criticize and expose the shortcomings of individuals, institutions, and society as a whole, often by highlighting the absurdity of real-world situations (Veep, The Colbert Report)
- employs symbolic characters, settings, and events to convey deeper meanings and messages about political and social issues, allowing creators to address sensitive topics indirectly (The Twilight Zone, The Hunger Games)
- Subtext refers to the underlying themes, implications, and connotations beneath the surface of a story, enabling writers to embed political and social commentary within seemingly innocuous narratives (The Simpsons, The X-Files)
- Genre television can use these techniques to bypass censorship, avoid controversy, and encourage viewers to engage with issues on a deeper level by decoding the hidden meanings and connections
Challenges in Interpreting and Decoding Messages
- The effectiveness of satire, allegory, and subtext in conveying political and social messages depends on the audience's ability to recognize and interpret these devices, which may vary based on factors such as cultural context, media literacy, and personal beliefs
- Some viewers may miss the intended commentary if they lack the necessary background knowledge or critical thinking skills to decode the symbolic and subtextual elements
- The use of indirect storytelling techniques can sometimes lead to misinterpretation or unintended readings of a work, as audiences may project their own biases and experiences onto the narrative
- Creators must strike a balance between making their messages accessible and maintaining the artistic integrity and entertainment value of their work, as overly obscure or heavy-handed commentary can alienate viewers
Risks and Rewards of Commentary
Relevance, Critical Acclaim, and Audience Engagement
- Incorporating political and social commentary can make genre television more relevant, thought-provoking, and socially conscious, attracting viewers who seek meaningful and impactful storytelling
- Addressing important issues can generate buzz, critical acclaim, and awards recognition for a series, boosting its profile and potentially expanding its audience (The Handmaid's Tale, Atlanta)
- Shows that tackle controversial topics and challenge societal norms can foster a sense of community and loyalty among viewers who share the values and perspectives presented
- Engaging with political and social issues can help genre television remain culturally relevant and contribute to broader conversations and movements beyond the screen
Balancing Artistic Expression and Commercial Viability
- TV shows that tackle controversial topics can face backlash from viewers, advertisers, and interest groups who disagree with the perspectives presented, leading to boycotts, funding cuts, or cancellation
- Creators must navigate the tension between artistic expression and commercial viability, balancing the desire to make bold statements with the need to appeal to a broad audience and avoid alienating key demographics
- Incorporating political and social commentary can date a series, as the issues and cultural context that inspired the content may lose relevance or significance over time
- Heavy-handed or preachy messaging can undermine the entertainment value of a show, causing viewers to feel lectured or manipulated rather than engaged and enlightened
- Shows that prioritize commentary over storytelling and character development may struggle to maintain audience interest and emotional investment, as viewers primarily seek to be entertained and emotionally engaged by genre television
Key Terms to Review (24)
Aaron Sorkin: Aaron Sorkin is a renowned American screenwriter, producer, and playwright known for his distinctive writing style characterized by rapid-fire dialogue and intricate plots. His works often delve into political and social themes, making them a significant part of contemporary genre television, particularly in how they comment on real-world issues through storytelling.
Activism: Activism is the active effort to promote, impede, or direct social, political, economic, or environmental change through various forms of advocacy and protest. It often involves individuals or groups taking a stand on issues they care about, utilizing media, grassroots movements, and direct action to raise awareness and influence public opinion or policy. In the context of genre television, activism can manifest in narratives that challenge societal norms or inspire audiences to engage in real-world issues.
Allegory: An allegory is a narrative that uses characters, events, and symbols to convey deeper meanings, often related to moral, political, or social issues. This storytelling technique allows creators to explore complex themes and critiques in a way that is engaging and accessible, often making a commentary on real-world issues through metaphorical representation.
Black Mirror: Black Mirror is a critically acclaimed anthology series that explores the darker side of technology and its impact on society, often presenting dystopian futures that reflect contemporary anxieties. Each episode serves as a standalone story, utilizing various genres to comment on human behavior in a tech-driven world.
Breaking the fourth wall: Breaking the fourth wall is a theatrical and cinematic device where characters acknowledge the audience or speak directly to them, creating a self-aware experience that blurs the line between fiction and reality. This technique often serves to enhance humor, provide commentary, or deepen character engagement, making it especially prominent in various sitcoms and genre television. By engaging the audience in this way, it fosters a sense of intimacy and connection while often highlighting the absurdities within the narrative.
Civil Rights Movement: The Civil Rights Movement was a decades-long struggle in the United States aimed at ending racial discrimination and promoting equal rights for African Americans, particularly during the 1950s and 1960s. This movement sought to dismantle systemic racism through various forms of activism, including nonviolent protests, legal challenges, and grassroots organizing. The impact of the Civil Rights Movement can be seen in its influence on drama series and genre television, highlighting issues of race, identity, and social justice.
Dark humor: Dark humor is a comedic style that finds humor in subjects that are generally considered serious, taboo, or distressing. It often involves a playful approach to sensitive topics such as death, illness, or tragedy, allowing audiences to confront uncomfortable realities through laughter. This style can serve as a coping mechanism or a means to challenge societal norms and provoke thought.
Docudrama: A docudrama is a dramatic representation of real-life events, blending documentary and fictional storytelling elements to create a narrative that aims to entertain while also informing the audience about true stories. This genre often focuses on historical events, social issues, or political narratives, using dramatization to highlight the emotional and human aspects behind these occurrences. By doing so, docudramas can serve as powerful tools for commentary and reflection on societal issues and the impact of historical decisions.
Drama: Drama is a genre of television that focuses on the portrayal of realistic characters and emotional themes, often involving conflict, relationships, and moral dilemmas. This genre shapes viewer expectations by providing intense storytelling that can be both relatable and thought-provoking, making it a significant part of the television landscape.
Law & Order: Law & Order refers to a genre of television programming that focuses on the criminal justice system, showcasing the processes involved in law enforcement, legal proceedings, and the broader societal implications of crime. This genre often explores the roles of police, lawyers, and judges while addressing various themes related to justice, morality, and ethics. The portrayal of crime and justice in these shows can provide insights into societal norms and legal practices, bridging connections between individual narratives and larger social commentary.
Mad Men: Mad Men is a critically acclaimed television drama series that aired from 2007 to 2015, set in the advertising world of the 1960s. The show intricately explores themes of identity, gender roles, and the shifting cultural landscape of America during this transformative decade, making it a significant piece for analyzing how drama series reflect societal changes over time and their role in providing political and social commentary.
Media bias: Media bias refers to the perceived or real partiality of journalists and news producers within the mass media, which can influence how news stories are reported and interpreted. This bias can manifest through the selection of stories, framing of information, and the language used, ultimately shaping public perception and opinion on political and social issues.
Metafiction: Metafiction is a form of writing that self-consciously addresses the devices of fiction, often blurring the boundary between fiction and reality. This literary technique allows creators to comment on their own storytelling processes and explore the nature of narrative itself, making viewers aware that they are engaging with a constructed story. In genre television, metafiction can serve as a means to provide political and social commentary, inviting the audience to question the realities presented on screen.
Orange is the New Black: Orange is the New Black (OITNB) is a critically acclaimed dramedy series that premiered on Netflix in 2013, exploring the lives of women in a minimum-security prison. The show blends humor and drama to highlight the complexities of incarceration, race, sexuality, and gender, reshaping contemporary narratives within the prison genre and contributing to broader discussions about social justice and representation.
Political awareness: Political awareness refers to the understanding and consciousness of political events, issues, and their implications within society. This awareness enables individuals to critically engage with political discourse and recognize how media representations shape public perception and influence social behavior.
Satire: Satire is a genre that uses humor, irony, and exaggeration to criticize or mock individuals, societal norms, or political issues. It often aims to provoke thought and inspire change by highlighting flaws or absurdities in its subject matter, making it a powerful tool for social commentary and cultural reflection.
Social critique: Social critique refers to the practice of analyzing and evaluating societal norms, structures, and institutions to highlight their flaws and advocate for change. This form of commentary often addresses issues such as inequality, injustice, and cultural assumptions, using various forms of media to provoke thought and inspire action. In the realm of genre television, social critique can manifest through narrative devices, character arcs, and themes that reflect real-world issues, encouraging viewers to question the status quo.
South Park: South Park is an animated television series created by Trey Parker and Matt Stone that uses satirical humor to provide political and social commentary. The show often addresses controversial topics, making it a significant player in genre television known for pushing boundaries while tackling real-world issues, such as politics, religion, and societal norms.
The Cold War: The Cold War was a prolonged period of political tension and military rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union, roughly from the end of World War II in 1945 until the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. This conflict was characterized by indirect confrontations, ideological battles, and a significant influence on global politics, shaping cultural narratives in various media, including genre television that often reflected the fears and uncertainties of that era.
The Crown: The Crown is a historical drama series that chronicles the reign of Queen Elizabeth II, exploring the personal and political challenges she faced during her time on the throne. This show highlights significant events in British history and showcases how monarchy interacts with modern governance, shaping contemporary drama trends, narrative structures, and character development.
The Daily Show: The Daily Show is a satirical news program that combines comedic commentary with current events and political discourse, initially launched in 1996. The show uses humor and satire to critique news, politics, and societal issues, shaping public perception and discourse through its unique blend of entertainment and information.
The Handmaid's Tale: The Handmaid's Tale is a dystopian novel by Margaret Atwood, adapted into a highly acclaimed television series that explores themes of totalitarianism, gender oppression, and individual agency. Set in the near-future Republic of Gilead, the story follows women forced into servitude as 'handmaids' to bear children for elite couples, highlighting the consequences of extreme religious and political ideologies. The show not only reflects contemporary societal issues but also connects to historical precedents, prompting viewers to consider the dangers of complacency in the face of oppression.
The Wire: The Wire is a critically acclaimed American television series that aired from 2002 to 2008, known for its deep exploration of societal issues in Baltimore through the lens of law enforcement, education, and the drug trade. This series stands out for its realistic portrayal of life in an urban environment and its focus on systemic problems, influencing drama series across different decades while leaving a lasting legacy in the genre.
Tina Fey: Tina Fey is an American actress, comedian, writer, and producer best known for her groundbreaking work on the sketch comedy show 'Saturday Night Live' and the critically acclaimed sitcom '30 Rock'. Her influence extends across various sitcom styles, where she blends traditional sitcom elements with innovative storytelling and strong female characters, reflecting modern societal issues.