15.2 Thermoeconomic Analysis and Optimization
6 min read•july 30, 2024
combines thermodynamics and economics to optimize energy systems. It considers both efficiency and cost, helping engineers make smart decisions about system design and operation. This approach quantifies trade-offs between performance and expenses.
Exergy, the maximum useful work from a system, is a key concept. By assigning costs to exergy streams and analyzing , engineers can identify inefficiencies and their financial impact. This guides improvements for better overall system performance and cost-effectiveness.
Thermoeconomic Analysis Principles
Combining Thermodynamics and Economics
Top images from around the web for Combining Thermodynamics and Economics
Equilibrium, Price, and Quantity | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Delving Into Thermoeconomics: A Brief Theoretical Comparison of Thermoeconomic ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Equilibrium, Price, and Quantity | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Delving Into Thermoeconomics: A Brief Theoretical Comparison of Thermoeconomic ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
Top images from around the web for Combining Thermodynamics and Economics
Equilibrium, Price, and Quantity | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Delving Into Thermoeconomics: A Brief Theoretical Comparison of Thermoeconomic ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Equilibrium, Price, and Quantity | Introduction to Business View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | Delving Into Thermoeconomics: A Brief Theoretical Comparison of Thermoeconomic ... View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 2
- Thermoeconomic analysis integrates thermodynamic analysis with economic principles
- Optimizes the design and operation of energy systems for cost-effectiveness
- Considers both the thermodynamic efficiency and the economic viability of a system
- Enables informed decision-making by quantifying the trade-offs between efficiency and cost
Exergy and Exergy Destruction
- Exergy represents the maximum useful work that can be obtained from a system
- Measures the quality and potential of energy streams
- Accounts for both the quantity and the usefulness of energy
- Exergy destruction represents the lost potential for useful work
- Occurs due to irreversibilities and inefficiencies in the system
- Directly related to the cost of operating the system
- Reducing exergy destruction improves system efficiency and cost-effectiveness
Exergy Costing Method
- The assigns a cost to each exergy stream in the system
- Based on the cost of the resources required to produce the exergy stream
- Considers the cost of fuel, raw materials, and other inputs
- The cost of exergy destruction and exergy losses can be quantified using exergy costing
- Provides a monetary value for the inefficiencies in the system
- Helps identify the most cost-effective opportunities for improvement
Thermoeconomic Optimization Process
- involves minimizing the total cost of the system
- Includes both the capital cost of equipment and the cost of exergy destruction and losses
- Considers the system's performance over its entire lifetime
- The thermoeconomic analysis process typically involves several steps:
- Creating an exergy flow diagram to visualize the exergy streams and interactions
- Performing an to quantify exergy flows, destruction, and losses
- Assigning costs to exergy streams using the exergy costing method
- Optimizing the system design and operating parameters for minimum total cost
- Conducting to assess the impact of uncertainties and assumptions
Cost Allocation and Optimization
Thermoeconomic Cost Allocation Methods
- Thermoeconomic cost allocation distributes the total cost of a system among its components or products
- Based on their exergy consumption and destruction
- Ensures that each component or product is charged for its share of the system's cost
- The SPECO (Specific Exergy Costing) method is a widely used approach for cost allocation
- Assigns costs to exergy streams based on the premise that each stream should be charged for the exergy it consumes and the exergy destruction it causes
- Provides a rational and consistent framework for cost allocation
- The MOPSA (Modified Productive Structure Analysis) method is another cost allocation approach
- Takes into account the interactions between components and the cost of the final products
- Considers the productive purpose of each component in the system
Optimization Techniques and Sensitivity Analysis
- Thermoeconomic optimization can be performed using various techniques
- Mathematical programming (linear, nonlinear, and mixed-integer programming)
- and evolutionary optimization
- and other metaheuristic methods
- The objective of thermoeconomic optimization is to find the optimal design and operating parameters that minimize the total cost of the system
- Considers the trade-offs between capital cost and operating cost (exergy destruction cost)
- Balances the investment in efficiency improvements with the resulting cost savings
- Sensitivity analysis is an important aspect of thermoeconomic optimization
- Helps identify the most influential parameters and their impact on the optimal solution
- Quantifies the effect of uncertainties in input data and assumptions on the optimization results
- Provides insights into the robustness and reliability of the optimal design
Economic Impact of System Design
Thermodynamic Design Decisions and Economic Performance
- have a significant impact on the system's exergy efficiency and economic performance
- Choice of working fluid (water, air, refrigerants) affects the system's operating conditions and efficiency
- Operating temperatures and pressures influence the exergy flows and destruction in the system
- Component efficiencies (turbines, compressors, heat exchangers) directly impact the system's performance and cost
- The represents the ratio of the capital cost to the total cost (capital cost + exergy destruction cost)
- Indicates the relative importance of improving component efficiency versus reducing capital cost
- Helps prioritize design improvements based on their impact on the total cost
Exergy Destruction and Loss Analysis
- Exergy destruction and loss analysis identifies the components or processes with the highest potential for cost reduction
- Quantifies the exergy destruction and losses in each component or process
- Reveals the sources of inefficiencies and their contribution to the total cost
- Helps focus efficiency improvement efforts on the most critical components or processes
- Efficiency improvements can reduce exergy destruction and operating costs
- Upgrading to higher efficiency components (advanced turbine designs, high-performance heat exchangers)
- Optimizing process conditions (temperatures, pressures, flow rates) to minimize irreversibilities
- Implementing and waste heat recovery to reduce external utility consumption
Life Cycle Cost Analysis
- evaluates the long-term economic impact of design decisions
- Considers the initial capital cost, operating and maintenance costs, and the system's salvage value
- Accounts for the time value of money and the system's expected lifetime
- Provides a comprehensive assessment of the system's economic performance over its entire life cycle
- Trade-offs between capital cost and operating cost should be carefully considered
- Higher efficiency components may have a higher capital cost but lower operating cost over the system's lifetime
- The optimal balance depends on factors such as the system's utilization, energy prices, and discount rates
- Life cycle cost analysis helps identify the most cost-effective design options in the long run
Strategies for Cost-Effective Optimization
Holistic Approach to System Optimization
- Cost-effective system optimization requires a holistic approach
- Considers the interactions between components and the trade-offs between capital and operating costs
- Accounts for the system's performance over its entire lifetime
- Incorporates the impact of external factors (energy prices, environmental regulations, technological advancements)
- A comprehensive optimization strategy should address multiple aspects of the system
- Thermodynamic efficiency and exergy utilization
- Economic viability and cost-effectiveness
- Environmental sustainability and compliance with regulations
- Reliability, maintainability, and operational flexibility
Advanced Optimization Techniques
- Pinch analysis optimizes heat exchanger networks and minimizes the cost of external utilities
- Based on the principles of heat integration and the pinch point concept
- Identifies the minimum utility requirements and the optimal heat exchanger network design
- Helps reduce energy consumption and operating costs
- Advanced exergy analysis distinguishes between avoidable and unavoidable exergy destruction
- Avoidable exergy destruction can be eliminated through design improvements or operational changes
- Unavoidable exergy destruction is inherent to the system and cannot be eliminated
- Focuses optimization efforts on the components with the greatest potential for improvement
- find Pareto-optimal solutions that balance conflicting objectives
- The ε-constraint method optimizes one objective while treating the others as constraints
- The weighted sum method combines multiple objectives into a single objective function using weighting factors
- Helps decision-makers explore the trade-offs between cost, efficiency, and other performance metrics
Thermoeconomic Diagnosis and Maintenance Optimization
- Thermoeconomic diagnosis combines fault detection and diagnosis with thermoeconomic analysis
- Identifies and diagnoses performance degradation and component faults
- Assesses the economic impact of faults and inefficiencies on the system's performance
- Prioritizes maintenance actions based on their cost-effectiveness and impact on system performance
- Maintenance optimization balances the cost of maintenance with the benefits of improved system performance
- Determines the optimal maintenance schedule and strategies
- Considers the trade-offs between preventive and corrective maintenance
- Incorporates condition-based monitoring and predictive maintenance techniques
- Thermoeconomic diagnosis and maintenance optimization help ensure the long-term economic viability of the system
- Reduce unplanned downtime and extend equipment life
- Improve system efficiency and reduce operating costs
- Optimize maintenance resources and minimize total lifecycle costs
Key Terms to Review (30)
Capital Recovery Factor: The capital recovery factor is a financial formula that determines the annual amount needed to recover the initial investment over a specified period of time, accounting for interest rates. This factor is essential in assessing the economic feasibility of energy systems and other investments by allowing comparisons between different projects. It plays a crucial role in optimizing design and operation by incorporating financial considerations into technical evaluations.
Carnot Efficiency: Carnot efficiency is the maximum theoretical efficiency of a heat engine operating between two temperature reservoirs, defined by the temperatures of the hot and cold reservoirs. It represents an ideal benchmark for real engines, highlighting the impact of temperature differences on energy conversion and serving as a critical reference for evaluating the performance of various thermodynamic cycles.
Combined heat and power systems: Combined heat and power systems, often abbreviated as CHP systems, are energy systems that simultaneously generate electricity and useful heat from the same energy source. These systems are designed to increase overall energy efficiency by capturing and utilizing heat that would otherwise be wasted in conventional power generation, making them an essential component in the pursuit of sustainable energy solutions.
Cost of energy: The cost of energy refers to the total expenses associated with the production, transmission, and consumption of energy. This includes not only the direct monetary costs but also environmental and societal impacts, which are increasingly considered in the evaluation of energy systems. Understanding the cost of energy is crucial for assessing the economic viability and efficiency of different energy sources and technologies.
Dynamic Programming: Dynamic programming is a mathematical optimization technique used to solve complex problems by breaking them down into simpler subproblems and solving each of those just once, storing their solutions. This method is especially powerful in making decisions that involve multiple stages, where the solution of one stage affects subsequent stages. It’s commonly applied in fields such as operations research, economics, and computer science for optimization problems.
Eco-efficiency: Eco-efficiency is a concept that combines economic and environmental performance, aiming to create more value with less resource consumption and waste generation. It encourages businesses to adopt practices that reduce ecological impacts while maintaining or improving profitability, emphasizing a sustainable approach to production and consumption.
Efficiency Ratio: The efficiency ratio is a measure that evaluates the effectiveness of a system in converting input energy into useful output energy. It is typically expressed as a percentage, highlighting how much of the input energy is utilized effectively versus wasted, thus providing insight into performance optimization and economic feasibility.
Energy-economic modeling: Energy-economic modeling is a quantitative approach that analyzes the relationships between energy systems and economic factors to optimize resource allocation and assess policy impacts. This type of modeling helps to evaluate the economic feasibility of energy projects, forecast energy consumption, and understand how changes in energy policies might affect overall economic performance. By integrating thermodynamic principles with economic analysis, it provides a comprehensive view of how energy resources are utilized efficiently.
Exergoeconomic factor: The exergoeconomic factor is a measure that combines exergy analysis with economic assessment to evaluate the performance and efficiency of energy systems. It helps in identifying not only how much useful work is produced but also how cost-effective the energy conversion processes are. This concept integrates thermodynamic principles with economic implications, enabling better decision-making in system design and operation.
Exergy analysis: Exergy analysis is a method used to evaluate the efficiency and performance of energy systems by quantifying the useful work potential of energy as it flows through a system. It helps identify irreversibilities and losses in processes, allowing for better design and optimization of energy systems. By focusing on the maximum work that can be extracted from energy resources, this analysis connects closely with efficiency improvements in various thermodynamic applications.
Exergy Costing Method: The exergy costing method is a technique that assigns costs to the different components of a system based on their exergy values, which represent the maximum useful work obtainable from a system as it comes into equilibrium with its environment. This method highlights inefficiencies by linking the economic value of energy use to the thermodynamic performance of a process, ultimately aiding in the optimization of energy systems.
Exergy destruction: Exergy destruction refers to the loss of useful work potential in a system due to irreversibilities, which arise from factors like friction, heat transfer across finite temperature differences, and mixing of different substances. This concept is crucial in understanding the efficiency of energy conversion processes, as it highlights how real-world systems deviate from idealized performance, ultimately impacting system efficiency and overall energy utilization.
Genetic algorithms: Genetic algorithms are a type of optimization technique inspired by the process of natural selection, used to solve complex problems by evolving solutions over successive generations. These algorithms work by simulating the principles of genetics, such as selection, crossover, and mutation, allowing them to explore a wide range of possible solutions and converge on optimal or near-optimal solutions for a given problem.
Heat Integration: Heat integration is a process that involves optimizing the use of thermal energy within a system to reduce energy consumption and costs while enhancing efficiency. By systematically analyzing and rearranging the flow of heat in processes, it aims to minimize exergy destruction and maximize the recovery of waste heat, linking closely with overall system performance and economic viability.
Lagrange Multipliers: Lagrange multipliers are a mathematical technique used to find the local maxima and minima of a function subject to equality constraints. This method introduces additional variables, known as Lagrange multipliers, which allow for the transformation of a constrained optimization problem into an unconstrained one. This is particularly useful in thermoeconomic analysis and optimization, where maximizing efficiency or minimizing cost often involves various constraints related to resources and energy.
Levelized Cost of Energy: Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) is a metric used to compare the cost of generating energy from different sources over their lifetimes, expressed as a constant dollar value per unit of energy produced. It takes into account all costs associated with production, including initial investment, operational and maintenance expenses, fuel costs, and the expected output of energy over time. LCOE helps in making informed decisions regarding energy investments and evaluating the economic viability of different energy technologies.
Life cycle cost analysis: Life cycle cost analysis is a method used to assess the total cost of ownership of a project or system over its entire life span, from initial acquisition through operation and maintenance to eventual disposal. This approach allows for more informed decision-making by considering not only the initial purchase price but also ongoing costs such as energy use, maintenance, and end-of-life disposal, leading to better economic and environmental outcomes.
Linear programming: Linear programming is a mathematical optimization technique used to achieve the best outcome in a mathematical model whose requirements are represented by linear relationships. This method is particularly useful for optimizing resource allocation, minimizing costs, or maximizing profits while adhering to constraints. By using linear programming, engineers and economists can efficiently allocate limited resources to achieve their goals in thermoeconomic analysis and optimization.
Mopsa method: The mopsa method is a thermoeconomic analysis approach that aims to optimize the performance of energy systems by integrating both thermodynamic and economic evaluations. This method emphasizes the importance of analyzing energy conversion processes not only in terms of efficiency but also in relation to their economic viability, allowing for a holistic assessment of system performance.
Multi-objective optimization techniques: Multi-objective optimization techniques are methods used to solve problems that involve multiple conflicting objectives, seeking to find solutions that provide the best trade-offs among these objectives. These techniques help in balancing different performance criteria, such as cost, efficiency, and environmental impact, making them essential in thermoeconomic analysis and optimization. By identifying Pareto optimal solutions, these methods enable decision-makers to evaluate various alternatives based on a comprehensive understanding of their impacts.
Net Present Value: Net Present Value (NPV) is a financial metric that calculates the current value of a series of cash flows generated by an investment, discounted back to present terms using a specific rate. This metric helps in evaluating the profitability and efficiency of different projects by comparing the present value of cash inflows to outflows, thereby guiding decision-making on investments.
Second Law of Thermodynamics: The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that the total entropy of an isolated system can never decrease over time, and any reversible process must increase the entropy of the universe. This principle highlights the directionality of processes, indicating that energy transformations are inherently inefficient and that some energy is always lost as waste heat.
Sensitivity analysis: Sensitivity analysis is a method used to determine how different values of an input variable can impact a given output variable under a set of assumptions. This approach helps identify which variables have the most influence on outcomes, allowing for better decision-making and optimization strategies. By assessing the effects of changing parameters, it reveals the robustness and reliability of models in various contexts, including performance evaluation and economic assessments.
Simulated annealing: Simulated annealing is an optimization technique inspired by the annealing process in metallurgy, where controlled heating and cooling are used to reduce defects in materials. This method helps in finding approximate solutions to complex optimization problems by allowing the system to explore a wide solution space, balancing between exploration and exploitation, much like cooling metal to reach a low-energy state.
Solar thermal systems: Solar thermal systems are technologies that convert sunlight into thermal energy for heating purposes. They are widely used for applications like water heating, space heating, and even power generation through steam production. By capturing solar energy and transforming it into heat, these systems play a crucial role in enhancing energy efficiency and reducing reliance on fossil fuels.
Specific Fuel Consumption: Specific fuel consumption (SFC) is a measure of the fuel efficiency of an engine design, typically expressed in terms of the amount of fuel consumed per unit of power produced per hour. It is a critical parameter in assessing the performance of engines, particularly gas turbines, as it provides insight into how effectively an engine converts fuel into useful work and how this efficiency can vary based on different configurations and technologies.
Speco Method: The Speco Method is a systematic approach used in thermoeconomic analysis that integrates both thermodynamic performance and economic evaluation to optimize energy systems. By examining the cost of energy production alongside efficiency metrics, this method helps identify the most economically viable solutions for various energy technologies, enabling better decision-making in engineering and design.
Thermodynamic system design decisions: Thermodynamic system design decisions refer to the strategic choices made during the engineering and optimization of thermodynamic systems, focusing on enhancing efficiency, performance, and economic viability. These decisions often involve trade-offs among various factors such as material selection, process configuration, and operational parameters to achieve desired performance metrics while minimizing costs. An effective design can significantly impact energy consumption, environmental footprint, and the overall sustainability of the system.
Thermoeconomic analysis: Thermoeconomic analysis is a method that integrates thermodynamics and economics to evaluate the performance and efficiency of energy systems. This approach helps in identifying the optimal design and operation of systems by analyzing both energy conversion processes and associated costs, allowing for informed decision-making in energy management.
Thermoeconomic optimization: Thermoeconomic optimization is a systematic approach that combines thermodynamic analysis with economic evaluation to enhance the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of energy systems. This concept focuses on minimizing exergy destruction while simultaneously considering the economic implications of design and operational decisions, resulting in improved performance of thermal systems. By integrating thermodynamic principles with economic factors, it leads to sustainable energy solutions that are both technically and financially viable.