5.4 Gothic elements and Romanticism in Brontë novels
4 min read•august 1, 2024
The Brontë sisters masterfully blended Gothic elements with Romanticism in their novels. Eerie settings, occurrences, and complex characters create a haunting atmosphere, while intense emotions and 's significance reflect Romantic ideals.
Their works pushed beyond mere horror, adding psychological depth and social commentary. By combining these elements, the Brontës created a unique subgenre that continues to captivate readers and influence modern Gothic fiction.
Gothic Elements in Brontë
Atmospheric Settings and Supernatural Occurrences
Top images from around the web for Atmospheric Settings and Supernatural Occurrences
The Ghost That Wasn’t There | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
Gothic Architecture two by JackSivyer on DeviantArt View original
Is this image relevant?
The ruins at Nymans © Marathon cc-by-sa/2.0 :: Geograph Britain and Ireland View original
Is this image relevant?
The Ghost That Wasn’t There | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
Gothic Architecture two by JackSivyer on DeviantArt View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Atmospheric Settings and Supernatural Occurrences
The Ghost That Wasn’t There | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
Gothic Architecture two by JackSivyer on DeviantArt View original
Is this image relevant?
The ruins at Nymans © Marathon cc-by-sa/2.0 :: Geograph Britain and Ireland View original
Is this image relevant?
The Ghost That Wasn’t There | Getty Iris View original
Is this image relevant?
Gothic Architecture two by JackSivyer on DeviantArt View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Gothic literature characterized by , horror, and supernatural elements prominently featured in Brontë sisters' novels
- Isolated and foreboding settings create atmosphere of dread and uncertainty
- in ""
- in the eponymous novel
- Supernatural occurrences and unexplained events contribute to Gothic atmosphere
- Ghostly appearances in "Jane Eyre"
- Mysterious sounds echoing through halls
- Dreams, visions, and premonitions add to supernatural elements
- Create sense of foreboding in narratives
- Foreshadow future events or reveal hidden truths
Complex Characters and Psychological Themes
- , Byronic heroes embody complex and tormented male protagonists typical of Gothic literature
- Mr. Rochester in "Jane Eyre"
- Heathcliff in "Wuthering Heights"
- Themes of madness, imprisonment, and psychological torment explored in depth
- Bertha Mason's character in "Jane Eyre" exemplifies these themes
- Cathy's descent into madness in "Wuthering Heights"
- Gothic symbolism reinforces dark and mysterious tone
- Weather (storms, fog)
- Nature (wild moors, gnarled trees)
- Architectural elements (secret passages, attics)
Romanticism's Influence on Brontë
Emotional Intensity and Nature's Significance
- Romanticism emphasized emotion, , and beauty of nature, central themes in Brontë sisters' works
- Exploration of intense and turbulent emotions, particularly love and passion
- Catherine and Heathcliff's all-consuming love in "Wuthering Heights"
- Jane and Rochester's passionate connection in "Jane Eyre"
- Nature plays significant role in Brontë sisters' writing
- Reflects characters' emotions
- Serves as powerful force in narrative
- Moors in "Wuthering Heights" symbolize wildness and freedom
- Concept of the sublime evident in descriptions of landscapes and natural phenomena
- Evokes awe and terror in readers
- Storms on in "Wuthering Heights"
- Dramatic weather changes in "Jane Eyre"
Individual Experience and Poetic Style
- Focus on individual experience and inner life of characters aligns with Romantic ideals
- Subjectivity and introspection emphasized
- First-person narration in "Jane Eyre" provides intimate access to protagonist's thoughts
- Rebellious protagonists challenge societal norms, reflecting Romantic emphasis on nonconformity
- Jane Eyre's outspoken nature and quest for independence
- Heathcliff's rejection of social hierarchy
- Poetic language and vivid imagery in prose demonstrates influence of Romantic poetry
- Lyrical descriptions of nature
- Metaphorical language to convey emotions
Gothic vs Romantic in Brontë Novels
Thematic and Stylistic Comparisons
- Both "Jane Eyre" and "Wuthering Heights" incorporate Gothic elements
- Mysterious settings (Thornfield Hall, Wuthering Heights)
- Supernatural occurrences (ghostly apparitions, unexplained sounds)
- "Wuthering Heights" leans more heavily into Gothic tradition
- Darker tone and more ambiguous moral landscape
- More overt supernatural elements central to plot
- Romantic influence evident in exploration of passionate love
- "Wuthering Heights" presents more destructive and obsessive form of love
- "Jane Eyre" depicts ultimately redemptive love
- Nature's role differs between novels
- "Wuthering Heights": moors integral part of characters' identities
- "Jane Eyre": nature often reflects Jane's inner state
Narrative Structure and Character Development
- Narrative structures differ between novels
- "Jane Eyre": linear, first-person narrative typical of Romantic bildungsromans
- "Wuthering Heights": complex, nested narrative structure enhancing Gothic atmosphere
- Both feature complex, Byronic heroes
- Heathcliff in "Wuthering Heights" more extreme and morally ambiguous
- Mr. Rochester in "Jane Eyre" more redeemable and conventionally heroic
- Social critique present in both novels
- "Jane Eyre" ultimately conforms more to social expectations
- "Wuthering Heights" presents more radical challenge to societal norms
Brontë's Contribution to Gothic Novels
Psychological Depth and Social Commentary
- Brontë sisters expanded scope of Gothic literature
- Incorporated psychological depth and social commentary
- Moved beyond mere sensationalism of earlier Gothic works
- Blended Gothic elements with Romantic sensibilities
- Created unique subgenre often referred to as "Gothic Romanticism"
- Focus on female protagonists and their inner lives brought new perspective to Gothic genre
- Previously dominated by male authors and characters
- Jane Eyre and Catherine Earnshaw as complex, multifaceted heroines
- Contributed to evolution of Gothic novel
- Shifted from purely supernatural tales to explorations of psychological terror
- Examined "horrors" of everyday life (social injustice, gender inequality)
Innovative Techniques and Lasting Impact
- Use of Gothic elements to critique social institutions
- Particularly those affecting women (marriage, education, class system)
- Innovative narrative techniques influenced development of complex storytelling within Gothic tradition
- Multiple narrators in "Wuthering Heights"
- in "The Tenant of Wildfell Hall"
- Enduring popularity and critical acclaim cemented Brontës' place in Gothic canon
- Continue to influence contemporary Gothic and neo-Gothic literature
- Inspired numerous adaptations and reinterpretations across various media
Key Terms to Review (26)
Brooding: Brooding refers to a deep, often melancholic contemplation or reflection, characterized by a sense of darkness and intensity. This emotional state connects to Gothic elements and Romanticism, as it often explores themes of despair, isolation, and the darker aspects of human experience. In literature, particularly in the works of Brontë, brooding characters grapple with their inner turmoil and the oppressive environments surrounding them, enhancing the atmosphere of mystery and emotional depth.
Charlotte brontë: Charlotte Brontë was a prominent English novelist and poet, best known for her novel 'Jane Eyre', which explores themes of love, morality, and social criticism. Her works are characterized by their emotional depth, complex characters, and pioneering use of Gothic elements, which have influenced both Romantic literature and modern feminist perspectives.
Civilization vs. savagery: The concept of civilization vs. savagery refers to the dichotomy between the orderly, cultured aspects of society and the primal, chaotic nature of humanity. This theme often highlights the tension between the norms and values of a structured society and the instinctual impulses that can lead to chaos and brutality. In literary contexts, especially within Gothic elements and Romanticism, this clash serves as a critique of societal norms and the darker aspects of human nature.
Decay: Decay refers to the process of decline or deterioration, often associated with the gradual loss of vitality or structure. In literature, it symbolizes not only physical decomposition but also moral and emotional decline, resonating with themes of loss and the passage of time. This concept is deeply intertwined with Gothic elements and Romanticism, where decay often represents the fragility of human existence and the inevitable approach of death, reflecting the darker aspects of the human experience.
Doppelgänger: A doppelgänger is a literary and psychological term that refers to a double or counterpart of a character, often representing an alter ego or a darker side of their personality. This concept is prevalent in Gothic literature, where it embodies themes of duality, identity, and the struggle between good and evil. In the context of Gothic elements and Romanticism, the doppelgänger serves as a powerful symbol for internal conflict, societal norms, and the exploration of human psychology.
Emily Brontë: Emily Brontë was a 19th-century English novelist and poet, best known for her only novel, 'Wuthering Heights,' which explores complex themes of love, revenge, and the supernatural. Her writing is marked by a distinctive style that combines poetic language with intense emotional depth, showcasing the inner lives of her characters against the backdrop of the Yorkshire moors. This connection to landscape and human emotion is a key feature in her work and influences the broader literary context of her time.
Emotion over reason: Emotion over reason refers to a philosophical and literary concept where feelings and instincts are prioritized over rational thought and logic. In literature, especially within the Gothic and Romantic movements, this idea emphasizes the depth of human experience, often exploring intense emotions like love, despair, and passion that drive characters’ actions and decisions, challenging the rationalist ideals of the Enlightenment.
Feminist theory: Feminist theory is an analytical framework that seeks to understand the ways in which gender shapes social structures, cultural norms, and individual identities. It examines the inequality and power dynamics between genders, advocating for social change and gender equity. This perspective often explores how literature and art reflect and reinforce these gendered experiences, particularly in the context of female authorship and representation.
Fire: Fire symbolizes passion, destruction, and transformation, often representing the intense emotions and turbulent experiences of characters. In the context of Gothic elements and Romanticism, fire is a powerful motif that evokes both the beauty and peril associated with desire and the human experience.
Forbidden love: Forbidden love refers to a romantic relationship that is disapproved of or restricted by societal norms, laws, or family expectations. This concept often creates intense emotional conflict and tension within narratives, especially in literature, as characters navigate the obstacles standing in the way of their love. In various stories, such relationships can highlight themes of passion, rebellion, and the struggle against oppressive forces.
Gothic literature: Gothic literature is a genre that blends elements of horror, romance, and the supernatural, often set against dark, mysterious backdrops. It explores themes of isolation, madness, and the uncanny, frequently featuring haunted settings, eerie atmospheres, and complex characters grappling with their inner demons. This genre significantly influences the works of writers like the Brontë sisters, where their unique styles reflect gothic motifs intertwined with romantic ideals.
Gothic setting: A gothic setting is characterized by dark, mysterious, and often foreboding environments that evoke feelings of terror and unease. These settings commonly feature elements such as decaying castles, remote landscapes, and oppressive atmospheres, reflecting the emotional and psychological states of characters within the narrative. This type of setting plays a crucial role in shaping the themes and moods of gothic literature, particularly in works influenced by Romanticism.
Individualism: Individualism is a social and political philosophy that emphasizes the moral worth of the individual and the importance of personal freedom and self-reliance. It champions individual rights and independence, often positioning personal identity and autonomy against societal norms or collective expectations. This philosophy deeply influences various literary movements, reflecting the complexities of personal identity in relation to broader social constructs.
Industrial Revolution: The Industrial Revolution was a period of significant economic and social change that began in the late 18th century and continued into the 19th century, marked by the transition from agrarian economies to industrialized and urbanized societies. This transformation had profound effects on literature, particularly in how narratives reflected the complexities of modern life, class struggles, and changing societal norms.
Jane Eyre: Jane Eyre is a novel written by Charlotte Brontë, first published in 1847, that tells the story of an orphaned girl who overcomes hardships to find love and independence. This novel is a key example of Victorian literature, showcasing social realism and exploring themes such as gender equality, morality, and personal growth within the constraints of the era.
Mystery: Mystery refers to a narrative element that involves the exploration of unknown or enigmatic circumstances, often leading to a suspenseful revelation. In literature, it creates tension and intrigue, prompting readers to engage with the unfolding plot while seeking to uncover hidden truths. This theme can be deeply connected to emotional experiences and the darker aspects of human nature, especially in works that intertwine mystery with Gothic elements or sensationalism.
Nature: In literature, 'nature' refers to the natural world and its elements, encompassing landscapes, flora, fauna, and the overall environment that characters inhabit. It often serves as a backdrop for human emotion and actions, reflecting themes of beauty, isolation, and the sublime, particularly in the works of the Brontë sisters, where it frequently intertwines with human experiences and psychological states.
Passion vs. restraint: Passion vs. restraint refers to the tension between intense emotional expression and the control or suppression of those emotions. In literature, this concept often reflects characters' struggles between their desires and societal expectations, especially within Gothic and Romantic contexts where heightened emotions and inner turmoil are prominent.
Psychoanalytic Criticism: Psychoanalytic criticism is an approach to literary analysis that uses the principles of psychoanalysis, especially those developed by Sigmund Freud, to explore the unconscious motivations of characters and authors. This method examines how psychological forces shape narratives, character development, and themes, often focusing on desires, fears, and internal conflicts. It connects deeply with themes of repression and the interplay between conscious and unconscious thought.
Rebellion: Rebellion is an act of violent or open resistance to an established government or ruler, often driven by the desire for social, political, or economic change. In literature, particularly in the context of Gothic elements and Romanticism, rebellion embodies the struggle against oppressive forces and reflects the characters' internal conflicts and desires for freedom and self-identity.
Supernatural: The supernatural refers to phenomena or entities that go beyond the natural world, often involving elements that defy scientific explanation or the laws of nature. In literature, the supernatural is frequently linked to themes of mystery, fear, and the uncanny, and it serves as a device to explore human emotions and moral questions. This concept plays a significant role in creating atmospheric tension and emotional depth in various literary works.
The moors: The moors refer to the vast, uncultivated upland areas, often characterized by heather, peat bogs, and a stark, desolate beauty, particularly found in England. This landscape plays a significant role in creating the atmospheric backdrop for various narratives, enhancing themes of isolation, passion, and tumultuous emotions within the story.
Thornfield Hall: Thornfield Hall is the imposing mansion that serves as the primary setting in Charlotte Brontë's 'Jane Eyre.' It embodies the Gothic tradition with its mysterious atmosphere, hidden secrets, and a sense of foreboding that contributes to the novel's themes of isolation and emotional struggle. The hall not only represents the physical space where much of the story unfolds but also acts as a symbol of social class, gender roles, and moral conflicts prevalent during the Romantic period.
Unreliable narrator: An unreliable narrator is a storytelling device where the credibility of the narrator is compromised, leading readers to question the truthfulness of their account. This can create layers of meaning, as readers are forced to discern the reality from the narrator's potentially distorted perspective.
Victorian Era: The Victorian Era refers to the period of Queen Victoria's reign from 1837 to 1901, characterized by significant industrial, cultural, political, scientific, and military changes in the United Kingdom. It was marked by a strict moral code, the expansion of the British Empire, and the rise of new literary forms and genres that explored complex social issues.
Wuthering Heights: Wuthering Heights is a classic Gothic novel by Emily Brontë, published in 1847, that explores themes of passion, revenge, and the complexities of human relationships through the tumultuous lives of its characters. This novel stands as a hallmark of the Gothic genre, showcasing dark settings, intense emotions, and supernatural elements, while also reflecting the unique literary style and themes characteristic of the Brontë sisters. It intertwines Gothic elements with Romanticism, creating a rich tapestry of emotion and conflict.