7.3 Powers and Limitations of Legislatures
3 min read•august 9, 2024
Congress wields significant power through enumerated and implied authorities. From declaring war to regulating commerce, these powers shape our nation. But ensure Congress doesn't overstep, with presidential vetoes and keeping it in check.
State legislatures have broad authority too, but within limits. They can make laws for health and safety, but federal laws can override state ones. Local governments often have less power, needing state permission for many actions.
Powers of Congress
Enumerated and Implied Powers
Top images from around the web for Enumerated and Implied Powers
The Division of Powers | American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The History of Federalism | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Division of Powers | American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The History of Federalism | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Enumerated and Implied Powers
The Division of Powers | American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The History of Federalism | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
Federalism: How should power be structurally divided? | United States Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The Division of Powers | American Government View original
Is this image relevant?
The History of Federalism | Boundless Political Science View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- explicitly listed in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution
- Includes authority to declare war, coin money, and regulate commerce
- derived from the
- Necessary and Proper Clause allows Congress to make laws "necessary and proper" for executing enumerated powers
- Expands congressional authority beyond explicitly stated powers
- McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) established broad interpretation of implied powers
Commerce and Fiscal Powers
- grants Congress power to regulate interstate and foreign commerce
- Broadly interpreted to allow regulation of activities affecting interstate commerce
- Gibbons v. Ogden (1824) established expansive view of commerce power
- authorizes Congress to levy and collect taxes
- permits Congress to allocate funds for general welfare
- United States v. Butler (1936) interpreted spending power broadly
War and Foreign Affairs Powers
- include declaring war and raising/supporting armed forces
- President serves as Commander-in-Chief, but Congress controls military funding
- of 1973 limits presidential use of armed forces without congressional approval
- involve regulating foreign commerce and immigration
- shared with the President, requiring Senate ratification
Limitations on Legislative Powers
Constitutional Constraints
- Constitution establishes framework limiting congressional authority
- divides government into three branches (legislative, executive, judicial)
- Checks and balances system allows each branch to limit others' powers
- Congressional limitations include and judicial review
- Bill of Rights restricts Congress from infringing on individual liberties
- First Amendment prohibits laws establishing religion or abridging free speech
Structural and Procedural Limitations
- requires both houses to pass legislation
- ensure minimum participation in legislative process
- mandates presidential review of legislation
- Congressional rules and procedures ( in Senate) can impede lawmaking
- for representatives (2 years) and senators (6 years) promote accountability
Federalism and States' Rights
- reserves powers not delegated to federal government to states
- principle limits federal encroachment on state authority
- prevents federal government from compelling state action
- Printz v. United States (1997) struck down federal law requiring state officials to conduct background checks
State and Local Legislative Powers
State Constitutional Authority
- State constitutions define powers of state legislatures
- allows state legislatures to legislate on any topic not prohibited
- under Tenth Amendment grant broad authority to states
- enable states to regulate for health, safety, and welfare
- shared between federal and state governments (taxation)
Local Government Powers
- limits local government authority to powers explicitly granted by state
- Originated from John Dillon's 1868 treatise on municipal corporations
- Restricts local governments from exercising powers not expressly delegated
- in state constitutions grant local governments more autonomy
- Allows local governments to adopt charters and exercise self-governance
- Varies by state, with some granting broad home rule authority and others maintaining strict Dillon's Rule
Intergovernmental Relations
- allows federal laws to supersede conflicting state laws
- encourages collaboration between federal and state governments
- provide federal funding to states with fewer restrictions
- impose federal requirements on states without providing funding
- of 1995 aims to limit unfunded federal mandates on states
Key Terms to Review (36)
Anti-commandeering doctrine: The anti-commandeering doctrine is a legal principle that prohibits the federal government from compelling states to enforce federal laws or regulations. This doctrine emphasizes the importance of state sovereignty and limits the power of Congress to impose duties on state officials. The concept reinforces the idea that states are not mere instruments of the federal government and highlights the balance of power between state and federal authorities.
Bicameral Legislature: A bicameral legislature is a legislative body that has two separate chambers or houses, typically known as the lower house and the upper house. This structure allows for a system of checks and balances within the legislative process, ensuring that laws are thoroughly debated and scrutinized before being enacted. The concept of a bicameral legislature is rooted in the desire to balance representation and power among different interests within a state, making it a key feature in both federal and state governance.
Bill of rights limitations: Bill of rights limitations refer to the constraints placed on the rights enumerated in a constitution’s Bill of Rights, often allowing for certain regulations and restrictions in order to balance individual liberties with public interests. These limitations serve to ensure that rights are not absolute and can be subject to restrictions for reasons such as national security, public safety, and order. Understanding these limitations is crucial in comprehending how legislatures can enact laws that may affect individual rights while still maintaining the rule of law.
Block grants: Block grants are large sums of money granted by the federal government to state or local governments for broad purposes, allowing the recipient governments significant discretion in how to spend the funds. This flexibility supports various initiatives, such as education, healthcare, and community development, and reflects a shift towards greater state autonomy in managing federal resources. Block grants often address contemporary issues in federal-state relations by balancing the need for federal oversight with the desire for local control.
Checks and balances: Checks and balances is a fundamental principle of governance that ensures no one branch of government becomes too powerful, by giving each branch the ability to limit the powers of the others. This system promotes accountability and prevents the abuse of power, reflecting the belief in the separation of powers that is essential to democratic governance.
Commerce Clause: The Commerce Clause is a provision in the U.S. Constitution that grants Congress the power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, among the several states, and with the Indian tribes. This clause is fundamental in establishing the scope of federal authority over economic activity and is a key element in understanding the relationship between state and federal powers.
Concurrent Powers: Concurrent powers are the authority to legislate and govern that is shared by both state and federal governments. This shared authority allows both levels of government to operate simultaneously, addressing issues that fall within their jurisdiction while ensuring cooperation. The concept of concurrent powers is vital in understanding the balance of power and responsibility between different levels of government, especially during the ratification debates, which highlighted concerns about the division and sharing of powers.
Constitutional constraints: Constitutional constraints refer to the limitations placed on the powers of government entities by a constitution, ensuring that laws and policies adhere to established principles and protect individual rights. These constraints serve to balance the exercise of power among branches of government and prevent abuses, ensuring that legislative actions remain within defined legal boundaries and respect fundamental rights.
Cooperative Federalism: Cooperative federalism is a concept where state and federal governments work together to solve problems and implement policies, blurring the lines of authority between the two levels of government. This collaboration often involves shared responsibilities, resources, and programs, highlighting interdependence rather than strict separation of powers. The approach emerged as a response to complex societal needs that neither level of government could effectively address alone.
Dillon's Rule: Dillon's Rule is a legal principle that governs the powers of local governments in relation to the state government, stating that local entities have only the powers expressly granted to them by the state. This concept emphasizes the limitations of local authority, requiring that any power exercised by local governments must be explicitly outlined in state legislation, thereby highlighting the relationship between local and state powers.
Dual sovereignty: Dual sovereignty refers to the concept where two separate levels of government—federal and state—each have the power to govern simultaneously within their respective domains. This principle allows for a division of powers, creating a system of checks and balances that ensures both levels can operate independently yet interdependently in areas such as legislation, taxation, and regulation.
Enumerated Powers: Enumerated powers are specific authorities granted to the federal government by the Constitution, primarily outlined in Article I, Section 8. These powers are distinct from implied powers and establish a clear framework for what the federal government can and cannot do. Understanding these powers is crucial for grasping the compromises made during the drafting of the Constitution, how federalism operates, and the structure and functions of Congress.
Filibuster: A filibuster is a parliamentary procedure that allows one or more members of a legislative body to delay or obstruct a vote on a proposed legislation by extending debate on the matter. This tactic is often used in the U.S. Senate, where a single senator or a group can hold the floor and speak for an extended period, effectively preventing the Senate from moving forward on legislation unless a supermajority votes to end the debate. The use of the filibuster is tied to the structure and functions of Congress, illustrating the powers and limitations of legislatures and how they operate within both federal and state legislative processes.
Foreign affairs powers: Foreign affairs powers refer to the authority of the government to conduct relations with other nations, make treaties, and engage in diplomacy. These powers are primarily held by the executive branch, particularly the President, but are also influenced by legislative actions and constitutional limitations. Understanding these powers involves recognizing the balance between federal authority and state limitations in managing international relations.
Home Rule Provisions: Home rule provisions refer to the legal authority granted to local governments to govern themselves with a degree of autonomy, allowing them to enact laws and regulations without needing state approval. This concept is significant because it empowers municipalities to tailor their governance according to the specific needs and preferences of their communities, while still operating within the framework established by state law. Home rule can foster local innovation and responsiveness, while also introducing challenges related to consistency and oversight across various jurisdictions.
Implied powers: Implied powers refer to the authority granted to Congress by the Constitution that is not explicitly stated but is necessary for carrying out its enumerated powers. These powers allow Congress to enact legislation and take actions that are deemed essential to execute its responsibilities effectively. This flexibility plays a critical role in the functioning of the legislative branch, allowing it to adapt to changing circumstances and address issues not foreseen by the framers of the Constitution.
Intergovernmental relations: Intergovernmental relations refer to the interactions and relationships between different levels of government, such as federal, state, and local authorities. These interactions involve collaboration, negotiation, and sometimes conflict as various governments work together or assert their powers in relation to one another. Understanding these relationships is crucial for grasping how powers and limitations are exercised within legislative bodies.
Judicial review: Judicial review is the power of courts to assess whether a law, policy, or executive action is in accordance with the Constitution. This process ensures that all branches of government operate within their constitutional limits, maintaining the supremacy of the Constitution as the highest law of the land.
Necessary and Proper Clause: The Necessary and Proper Clause, also known as the Elastic Clause, is a provision in the U.S. Constitution that grants Congress the power to make all laws that are necessary and proper for executing its enumerated powers. This clause allows for flexibility in governance, enabling Congress to adapt its legislative powers to meet the needs of a changing nation while ensuring that it operates within its constitutional boundaries.
Plenary Power: Plenary power refers to the complete and absolute power that a governing body, such as a legislature, possesses to enact laws and make decisions within its jurisdiction without any limitations. This concept is particularly significant as it underscores the authority of legislatures to address a wide range of issues and enact policies that govern the lives of citizens, so long as they operate within the bounds of the constitution.
Police Powers: Police powers are the inherent authority of states to enact laws and regulations to promote public health, safety, morals, and general welfare. This power allows state legislatures to maintain order and protect the well-being of their citizens through measures such as zoning laws, health regulations, and criminal laws. It is a fundamental aspect of state sovereignty, balancing individual rights with the needs of the community.
Preemption Doctrine: The preemption doctrine is a legal principle that establishes that federal law takes precedence over state law when both are in conflict. This concept is rooted in the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, which asserts that federal law is the 'supreme law of the land.' The doctrine ensures uniformity in national policies and limits the ability of states to enact laws that may contradict or interfere with federal statutes.
Presentment Clause: The Presentment Clause refers to a constitutional requirement that legislation passed by Congress must be presented to the President before it can become law. This clause, found in Article I, Section 7 of the Constitution, is a critical part of the legislative process as it establishes checks and balances between the legislative and executive branches of government, ensuring that both have a role in the lawmaking process.
Presidential veto: A presidential veto is the power of the president to reject legislation passed by Congress, preventing it from becoming law. This mechanism acts as a critical check on the legislative branch, ensuring that the executive can block laws that may be deemed unconstitutional or contrary to national interests. The veto reinforces the balance of power among branches of government, influencing legislative processes and encouraging negotiation between the president and Congress.
Quorum requirements: Quorum requirements refer to the minimum number of members that must be present for a legislative body to conduct its official business and make decisions. This concept ensures that any actions taken by the legislature are representative of a sufficient portion of its membership, preventing a small group from making decisions that could affect the entire body.
Reserved Powers: Reserved powers refer to the authority and rights that are not specifically granted to the federal government by the Constitution and are instead reserved for the states or the people. This concept emphasizes the balance of power within federalism, ensuring that states retain significant authority to govern themselves, especially in areas not expressly addressed by national legislation.
Separation of Powers: Separation of powers is a governance model that divides the responsibilities and powers of government into three distinct branches: legislative, executive, and judicial. This structure is designed to prevent any one branch from gaining too much power and to ensure a system of checks and balances that promotes accountability and fairness in government.
Spending Power: Spending power refers to the authority of the government, particularly Congress, to allocate funds and make financial decisions for various purposes, including social programs, infrastructure development, and national defense. This power is derived from the Constitution, specifically from the taxing and spending clause, allowing legislators to influence policy and priorities through financial means.
Taxing power: Taxing power refers to the authority granted to governments, both state and federal, to impose and collect taxes from individuals and entities. This power is a crucial tool for governments to generate revenue necessary for funding public services, infrastructure, and various programs. It is also subject to certain limitations that protect citizens from excessive taxation and ensure fairness in the tax system.
Tenth Amendment: The Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution asserts that powers not delegated to the federal government, nor prohibited to the states, are reserved to the states or the people. This amendment emphasizes the principle of federalism by limiting federal authority and ensuring that states retain their rights and powers.
Term Limits: Term limits are legal restrictions that limit the number of terms an elected official can serve in a particular office. These limits are intended to promote political diversity and prevent the entrenchment of power by incumbents, influencing how legislatures operate and interact with voters, as well as shaping the structure of state constitutions and the comparative analysis between state and federal governance.
Treaty-making power: Treaty-making power refers to the authority granted to the President and, in some contexts, the Senate to negotiate and enter into treaties with foreign nations. This power is significant because it allows for the formalization of international agreements that can affect trade, security, and diplomatic relations. The Constitution stipulates that treaties require a two-thirds majority approval from the Senate, illustrating a system of checks and balances between branches of government.
Unfunded Mandates: Unfunded mandates are regulations or new laws that require states or local governments to perform certain actions without providing the funding necessary to carry out those requirements. This often places a financial burden on state and local governments, leading to debates about federal authority and fiscal responsibility. The concept raises important questions about the balance of power between state and federal governments, particularly regarding how mandates affect state autonomy and budgetary constraints.
Unfunded Mandates Reform Act: The Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA) is a federal law enacted in 1995 that aims to limit the number of unfunded federal mandates imposed on state and local governments. It requires Congress to assess the financial impact of proposed legislation that would impose costs on these governments and provides for greater transparency and accountability regarding the costs of such mandates. This act is crucial in the context of legislative powers, as it addresses the balance between federal authority and state sovereignty.
War powers: War powers refer to the authority granted to a government, particularly the executive branch, to engage in military actions and manage national defense. This authority includes the ability to declare war, deploy troops, and conduct military operations, often in response to threats or conflicts. The balance of these powers between the legislative and executive branches is crucial in determining how a nation navigates issues of security and military engagement.
War Powers Resolution: The War Powers Resolution is a federal law enacted in 1973 that aims to check the president's power to commit the United States to armed conflict without the consent of Congress. It establishes specific procedures that the president must follow when deploying military forces, requiring him to notify Congress within 48 hours of sending troops into hostilities and limiting military engagement to 60 days without Congressional approval. This law highlights the ongoing tension between executive and legislative powers, especially regarding decisions on military intervention.