Science and the Sacred

โ˜ฏ๏ธScience and the Sacred Unit 9 โ€“ Science and Religion: Life's Meaning

Science and religion offer different perspectives on life's meaning. Ancient philosophers, medieval theologians, and Enlightenment thinkers have grappled with this question throughout history. Modern science challenges traditional religious views, while some seek reconciliation. Evolutionary biology, neuroscience, and physics provide scientific insights into existence. Religious traditions offer diverse views on life's purpose, from serving God to achieving spiritual liberation. Philosophical debates explore moral realism, relativism, and the relationship between facts and values.

Key Concepts and Definitions

  • Meaning of life refers to the philosophical and religious question concerning the purpose and significance of human existence
  • Teleology is the explanation of phenomena in terms of the purpose they serve rather than of the cause by which they arise
  • Existentialism emphasizes individual existence, freedom and choice, and that life has no inherent meaning or purpose
    • Existential nihilism posits that life is without objective meaning, purpose, or intrinsic value
  • Theistic worldviews assert that God created the universe and gives life meaning and purpose
    • Divine command theory is the belief that what is moral is determined by what God commands
  • Secular humanism seeks meaning in life through human values and scientific inquiry rather than religious belief
  • Absurdism is the belief that the human tendency to seek inherent meaning in life is ultimately futile and absurd
  • Ontology is the branch of metaphysics dealing with the nature of being and existence

Historical Context

  • Ancient Greek philosophers (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle) contemplated the meaning of life and the nature of human existence
  • Medieval Christian theologians (Augustine, Aquinas) viewed life's purpose through the lens of serving God and achieving salvation
  • The Scientific Revolution and Enlightenment challenged traditional religious views and emphasized reason and empiricism
    • Copernican heliocentrism and Newtonian mechanics undermined the notion of a Earth-centered, divinely ordered cosmos
  • 19th century thinkers (Kierkegaard, Nietzsche) grappled with the implications of a world without inherent meaning or purpose
  • 20th century existentialists (Sartre, Camus) explored the human condition and the absurdity of seeking meaning in a meaningless universe
  • Postmodern thought has questioned the possibility of objective truth and universal narratives about life's meaning
  • The rise of secularism and decline of religious belief in many societies has reshaped debates about life's purpose

Scientific Perspectives on Life's Meaning

  • Evolutionary biology explains the diversity and complexity of life through natural selection and adaptation
    • Life evolves without inherent purpose or direction, driven by the survival and reproduction of genes
  • Neuroscience and cognitive science investigate the neural basis of consciousness, emotion, and subjective experience
  • Physics describes a universe governed by impersonal laws and forces, without apparent concern for human existence
    • The vastness of the cosmos and the ultimate fate of the universe (heat death, Big Rip) suggest cosmic insignificance
  • Chemistry and biochemistry reveal the intricate molecular machinery that underlies life processes
  • Genetics and molecular biology have uncovered the genetic code and the mechanisms of heredity and development
  • Scientific materialism holds that only the physical world exists and that consciousness and meaning are emergent properties of matter
  • Some scientists (Carl Sagan, Richard Dawkins) have argued that science itself can provide a sense of awe and wonder at the universe

Religious Views on Life's Purpose

  • Abrahamic religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) teach that life's purpose is to know, love, and serve God
    • Humans are created in God's image and have a special role and destiny in the divine plan
  • Eastern religions (Hinduism, Buddhism) emphasize spiritual liberation from the cycle of birth and death
    • The ultimate goal is to achieve moksha (Hinduism) or nirvana (Buddhism) and end suffering
  • Theistic religions generally posit an afterlife where the righteous are rewarded and the wicked are punished
  • Deism holds that God created the universe but does not intervene in it, leaving humans to find their own purpose
  • Process theology sees God and the world as interdependent and evolving, with humans as co-creators in the divine process
  • Pantheism identifies God with the universe itself, so that nature and existence are inherently sacred and meaningful
  • Religious pluralism acknowledges the diversity of religious beliefs and the possibility of multiple paths to truth and meaning

Intersections and Conflicts

  • The Galileo affair and the trial of Galileo highlighted tensions between science and religious authority
  • Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection conflicted with literal interpretations of biblical creation narratives
    • The Scopes "Monkey" Trial tested the teaching of human evolution in public schools
  • Scientific explanations for the origin of the universe (Big Bang) and of life (abiogenesis) challenge religious cosmologies
  • Neuroscientific explanations of religious experience as brain states question the validity of spiritual revelation
  • The problem of evil and suffering raises doubts about the existence of an all-powerful, all-good God
  • Scientific determinism and the denial of free will undermine notions of moral responsibility and purpose
  • Secular and scientific critiques of religion as irrational, superstitious, or harmful to society and human progress
  • Attempts at reconciling science and religion through ideas like theistic evolution, intelligent design, or non-overlapping magisteria (NOMA)

Philosophical Debates

  • The is-ought problem questions whether statements about what ought to be can be derived from statements about what is
  • The fact-value distinction separates objective facts from subjective values and challenges the objectivity of moral truths
  • Hume's guillotine argues that prescriptive statements (about what ought to be) cannot be deduced from descriptive statements (about what is)
    • "You can't derive an 'ought' from an 'is'"
  • The naturalistic fallacy is the alleged error of inferring evaluative conclusions from purely factual premises
  • Moral realism holds that there are objective moral truths independent of human opinion, while moral anti-realism denies this
  • Moral relativism maintains that moral judgments are relative to individual or cultural beliefs and practices
  • The Euthyphro dilemma asks whether something is good because God commands it, or whether God commands it because it is good
  • Theodicy is the attempt to reconcile the existence of evil and suffering with the existence of an all-powerful, all-good God

Modern Interpretations and Synthesis

  • Existential psychotherapy helps individuals confront existential concerns and create personal meaning in their lives
  • Secular humanism affirms the dignity and worth of all people, and their ability to determine right and wrong and live meaningful lives
    • Humanist Manifesto III (2003) outlines a naturalistic worldview and progressive values
  • Religious naturalism integrates religious attitudes and spiritual practices with a scientific understanding of nature
  • Process philosophy and theology emphasize becoming, creativity, and the interconnectedness of all things
  • The Epic of Evolution situates human life within the grand narrative of cosmic evolution and the emergence of complexity
  • The Gaia hypothesis views the Earth as a self-regulating system and highlights the interdependence of life and environment
  • Integral theory seeks to integrate insights from various fields (science, religion, philosophy) into a comprehensive worldview
  • Constructive postmodernism affirms the importance of meaning-making while recognizing the limitations of grand narratives

Practical Applications and Ethics

  • Meaning-centered psychotherapy helps patients with terminal illness or existential distress find purpose and peace
  • Eco-spirituality and environmental ethics derive a sense of meaning and moral obligation from the sacredness of nature
  • The Cosmic Perspective (Carl Sagan) invites wonder at the vastness of the universe and gratitude for the rarity of life
  • Bioethics grapples with the moral implications of new technologies (genetic engineering, cloning, AI) for the meaning of life
    • The transhumanist movement seeks to enhance human capacities and transcend biological limitations
  • Effective altruism applies reason and evidence to determine the most effective ways to benefit others and reduce suffering
  • Interfaith dialogue and cooperation seek to build understanding and common ground among diverse religious traditions
  • Contemplative practices (meditation, prayer, mindfulness) can cultivate a sense of meaning, purpose, and connection
  • Existential positive psychology focuses on the development of character strengths, resilience, and post-traumatic growth in the face of adversity


ยฉ 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
APยฎ and SATยฎ are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.

ยฉ 2024 Fiveable Inc. All rights reserved.
APยฎ and SATยฎ are trademarks registered by the College Board, which is not affiliated with, and does not endorse this website.
Glossary
Glossary