2.2 Factors contributing to historical erasure and silencing
5 min read•july 29, 2024
Historical erasure and silencing stem from a complex web of social, political, and economic factors. , , and lack of resources create barriers for marginalized voices, leading to incomplete and distorted historical narratives.
shape storytelling by deciding which stories are deemed important and credible. This reinforces dominant interests, perpetuating systems of privilege while erasing experiences that challenge these structures. Recognizing power's role in shaping narratives is key to developing a nuanced understanding of the past.
Silencing of Voices
Systemic Barriers to Marginalized Voices
Top images from around the web for Systemic Barriers to Marginalized Voices
The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original
Is this image relevant?
Black Lives Matter (BLM) Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original
Is this image relevant?
Oppression and Power – Glossary – Introduction to Human Services View original
Is this image relevant?
The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original
Is this image relevant?
Black Lives Matter (BLM) Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Systemic Barriers to Marginalized Voices
The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original
Is this image relevant?
Black Lives Matter (BLM) Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original
Is this image relevant?
Oppression and Power – Glossary – Introduction to Human Services View original
Is this image relevant?
The Role of Senior Leaders in Building a Race Equity Culture | Bridgespan View original
Is this image relevant?
Black Lives Matter (BLM) Archives : Peoples Dispatch View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- contributing to silencing include discrimination, prejudice, and oppression based on race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, disability status, or other marginalized identities
- involve the use of power by dominant groups to suppress dissenting voices and maintain control over the historical narrative
- This can include censorship, propaganda, and the manipulation of educational curricula (textbook content)
- Economic factors such as poverty, lack of access to resources, and limited educational opportunities can prevent marginalized groups from having the means to document and preserve their stories
- Lack of financial resources hinders the ability to create and maintain archives, museums, and other institutions dedicated to preserving marginalized histories
- The intersection of social, political, and economic factors creates systemic barriers that make it difficult for certain voices to be heard and acknowledged in the historical record
- These barriers operate simultaneously and reinforce each other, creating a complex web of oppression that silences marginalized voices (women, LGBTQ+ individuals, indigenous communities)
Consequences of Silencing
- Silencing of voices leads to an incomplete and distorted understanding of history that fails to capture the diverse range of human experiences
- The absence of marginalized voices in the historical record perpetuates the idea that their experiences and perspectives are unimportant or irrelevant
- Silencing reinforces the power and privilege of dominant groups by allowing them to control the narrative and shape collective memory
- The erasure of certain voices contributes to the and oppression of these groups in the present day by denying them a sense of historical identity and agency
- Efforts to recover and amplify silenced voices are crucial for creating a more inclusive and equitable society that values the contributions and experiences of all its members
Power Structures in Storytelling
Shaping the Historical Narrative
- Power structures refer to the institutions, organizations, and individuals that hold authority and influence within a society, such as governments, religious institutions, media outlets, and academic establishments
- Those in positions of power have the ability to shape the historical narrative by deciding which stories are deemed important, credible, and worthy of preservation
- This can involve the selection of certain events, figures, and perspectives to be included in official histories, textbooks, and public memorials (national monuments, school curricula)
- Power structures can actively suppress or discredit stories that challenge their authority or contradict the dominant narrative, thereby silencing alternative perspectives
- This can take the form of censorship, propaganda, and the marginalization of dissenting voices (banning of books, control of media outlets)
Reinforcing Dominant Interests
- The stories that are ultimately told and preserved often reflect the interests and values of those in power, rather than providing a comprehensive and inclusive account of history
- Power structures may prioritize stories that legitimize their authority, justify their actions, and maintain the status quo
- This can involve the glorification of certain historical figures, the downplaying of oppressive practices, and the omission of marginalized experiences (Eurocentric narratives, minimization of colonial atrocities)
- The reinforcement of dominant interests through storytelling perpetuates systems of power and privilege, while marginalizing and erasing the experiences of those who challenge these structures
- Recognizing the role of power in shaping historical narratives is essential for developing a critical and nuanced understanding of the past that takes into account multiple perspectives and experiences
Erasure of Marginalized Experiences
Dominant Cultural Narratives
- are the prevailing stories, beliefs, and values that are widely accepted and reinforced within a society
- These narratives often center the experiences of privileged groups while marginalizing others (white, male, heterosexual, cisgender, able-bodied)
- The dominance of certain cultural narratives can lead to the erasure of experiences that do not fit within the accepted framework, such as the histories of indigenous peoples, racial and ethnic minorities, LGBTQ+ individuals, and people with disabilities
- Marginalized experiences may be dismissed, trivialized, or reframed to align with the dominant narrative, thereby distorting or erasing their true significance
- This can involve the exoticization, stereotyping, or appropriation of marginalized cultures and identities (Native American mascots, "primitive" art exhibitions)
Perpetuating Incomplete Histories
- The erasure of marginalized experiences perpetuates a narrow and incomplete understanding of history, denying the complexity and diversity of human experiences
- The absence of marginalized voices in cultural narratives reinforces the idea that their experiences are unimportant, irrelevant, or nonexistent
- This can lead to a lack of recognition and respect for marginalized communities in the present day (ongoing discrimination, lack of representation in media and politics)
- The erasure of marginalized experiences also denies these communities a sense of historical identity and agency, making it difficult for them to assert their presence and advocate for their rights
- Efforts to challenge dominant cultural narratives and center marginalized experiences are crucial for creating a more inclusive and equitable society that acknowledges the value and contributions of all its members
Excluded Perspectives in Archives
Controlled Access to Historical Records
- Historical sources and archives are the primary means by which we access and interpret the past, but they are not neutral or comprehensive repositories of information
- The creation and preservation of historical sources and archives have often been controlled by those in positions of power, who may have consciously or unconsciously excluded certain perspectives
- This can involve the selection of certain types of sources to be preserved, the prioritization of written records over oral histories, and the destruction or suppression of documents that challenge (colonial archives, government censorship)
- The exclusion of certain perspectives can take many forms, such as the marginalization of oral histories and other non-traditional forms of knowledge transmission
- This can lead to the privileging of Western, written sources over indigenous and non-Western forms of knowledge (oral traditions, material culture)
Representation and Invisibility
- The lack of representation of certain groups in historical sources and archives perpetuates their invisibility and reinforces the dominant narrative, making it difficult for their stories to be known and understood
- The absence of marginalized voices in archives can lead to a distorted and incomplete understanding of the past that fails to capture the complexity and diversity of human experiences
- This can involve the erasure of women's histories, the marginalization of LGBTQ+ experiences, and the silencing of indigenous perspectives (lack of documentation, destruction of cultural heritage)
- Efforts to decolonize and diversify historical sources and archives are necessary to create a more inclusive and accurate understanding of the past
- This can involve the active collection and preservation of marginalized histories, the repatriation of cultural artifacts, and the development of community-based archives ( projects, digital archives)
- Recognizing the limitations and biases of historical sources and archives is essential for developing a critical and nuanced understanding of the past that takes into account multiple perspectives and experiences
Key Terms to Review (23)
Archival research: Archival research involves the systematic investigation of historical documents, records, and artifacts preserved in archives to uncover and interpret past events and narratives. This approach is crucial for restoring lost stories, as it allows researchers to access primary sources that shed light on overlooked or marginalized perspectives, ultimately contributing to a fuller understanding of history.
Censorship: Censorship is the suppression or prohibition of speech, public communication, or other information deemed objectionable, harmful, or sensitive by authorities or organizations. It often targets certain narratives or perspectives, resulting in gaps in historical records and contributing to the erasure of specific voices from public discourse. This practice can hinder the full understanding of historical contexts and prevent marginalized groups from sharing their stories.
Cultural amnesia: Cultural amnesia refers to the collective forgetting of a society's past, including its histories, traditions, and significant events. This phenomenon can lead to the erasure of important cultural identities and narratives, leaving individuals disconnected from their heritage and contributing to a lack of understanding of historical contexts.
Digital archiving: Digital archiving refers to the process of collecting, preserving, and providing access to digital materials and documents. This practice is essential for ensuring that important stories, historical records, and cultural heritage are maintained for future generations, especially in a time when many narratives have been lost or overlooked.
Discrimination: Discrimination refers to the unjust or prejudicial treatment of individuals or groups based on characteristics such as race, gender, sexual orientation, age, or disability. This term highlights the systemic inequalities that lead to the marginalization and exclusion of certain groups, contributing to historical erasure and silencing of their stories and experiences.
Dominant cultural narratives: Dominant cultural narratives are the prevailing stories, beliefs, and values that shape a society's collective understanding of history, identity, and morality. These narratives often reflect the perspectives of those in power, marginalizing or erasing alternative voices and experiences, which can contribute to the silencing of certain groups within society.
Dominant narratives: Dominant narratives are the prevailing stories or interpretations that shape how history and culture are understood and communicated, often reflecting the perspectives of those in power. These narratives can influence societal beliefs, values, and norms by highlighting certain events while sidelining or erasing others, which contributes to historical erasure and silencing of marginalized voices.
Economic barriers: Economic barriers are obstacles that prevent individuals or groups from accessing resources, opportunities, or services due to financial constraints or economic disparities. These barriers can result in limited social mobility and can contribute significantly to the historical erasure and silencing of marginalized communities by restricting their ability to preserve and share their stories.
Feminist historiography: Feminist historiography is an approach to historical writing and research that emphasizes the importance of women’s experiences, contributions, and perspectives, aiming to recover and highlight their roles in history. This perspective critiques traditional historiography for often marginalizing or ignoring women's narratives, thus addressing the gaps in historical records and exposing the factors that contribute to historical erasure and silencing of women's voices.
Hegemonic narratives: Hegemonic narratives refer to dominant stories or frameworks that shape the way we understand history, culture, and society, often reinforcing the perspectives of those in power while marginalizing or erasing the voices of less powerful groups. These narratives often dictate whose experiences are deemed valid or worthy of remembrance, influencing collective memory and historical interpretation. By understanding hegemonic narratives, one can better recognize the underlying biases that contribute to historical erasure and the silencing of marginalized groups.
Intersectionality: Intersectionality is a framework that examines how various social identities, such as race, gender, class, and sexuality, intersect and interact to create unique experiences of oppression and privilege. This concept helps to understand the complexity of individuals' lived experiences by considering the multiple layers of identity that shape how they are perceived and treated in society.
Marginalization: Marginalization refers to the social process of relegating individuals or groups to the fringes of society, often leading to their voices and experiences being overlooked or ignored. This process can have profound implications on identity, representation, and access to resources, resulting in those affected feeling disconnected from the larger community. Marginalization is crucial when discussing ethical storytelling and historical narratives as it highlights whose stories are told and whose remain unheard.
Memorialization: Memorialization refers to the process of creating a lasting remembrance of individuals, events, or experiences, often through physical monuments, ceremonies, or narratives. This process plays a crucial role in how societies remember and interpret their past, especially in the face of historical erasure and silencing.
Narrative suppression: Narrative suppression refers to the deliberate or systemic efforts to silence, erase, or undermine specific stories, voices, or perspectives within history and society. This can occur through various means such as censorship, marginalization, or omission in historical records, leading to a skewed understanding of events and identities.
Oral history: Oral history is a method of collecting and preserving historical information through recorded interviews with individuals who have personal experiences related to specific events or cultural practices. This approach allows for the documentation of diverse perspectives, often capturing stories that may not be found in written records.
Political Factors: Political factors refer to the influences and elements related to government policies, political stability, and the actions of political leaders that shape societies and historical narratives. These factors play a critical role in determining which stories are told, preserved, or erased from history, often aligning with the interests of those in power. They can influence public discourse, access to resources, and the recognition or marginalization of various groups within society.
Postcolonial theory: Postcolonial theory is an intellectual framework that examines the cultural, political, and economic impacts of colonialism and imperialism on formerly colonized societies. This theory highlights the voices and narratives that have been marginalized or suppressed in mainstream discourse, shedding light on the complexities of identity, power dynamics, and historical erasure.
Power structures: Power structures refer to the systems and frameworks through which authority and control are organized and exercised within a society or organization. These structures shape how resources, opportunities, and decision-making processes are distributed, ultimately influencing who holds power and who is marginalized or silenced.
Social factors: Social factors refer to the influences and dynamics within a society that affect individuals' behaviors, beliefs, and experiences. These include aspects such as cultural norms, community structures, social classes, and demographic characteristics that can lead to disparities in representation and historical acknowledgment.
Social media activism: Social media activism refers to the use of social media platforms to promote social, political, or environmental causes, encouraging awareness, engagement, and action among users. This form of activism has transformed how individuals and organizations mobilize supporters, share information, and amplify voices that are often marginalized or silenced in mainstream narratives. By leveraging the reach and immediacy of social media, activists can challenge historical erasure and facilitate conversations around issues that matter.
Subaltern Voices: Subaltern voices refer to the perspectives and narratives of marginalized groups who are often excluded from dominant historical narratives. These voices represent individuals or communities that have been historically silenced or overlooked, including but not limited to indigenous peoples, women, racial minorities, and the economically disadvantaged. Recognizing subaltern voices is essential for addressing gaps in historical records and understanding the factors that contribute to historical erasure.
The Great Migration: The Great Migration refers to the mass movement of approximately six million African Americans from the rural Southern United States to urban areas in the North and West between 1916 and 1970. This migration significantly changed the demographic landscape of America and contributed to the cultural, social, and economic evolution of cities, while also highlighting issues related to historical erasure and silencing experienced by African American communities.
The Trail of Tears: The Trail of Tears refers to the forced relocation of Native American tribes, particularly the Cherokee, from their ancestral lands in the Southeastern United States to designated Indian Territory in present-day Oklahoma during the 1830s. This tragic event symbolizes the broader patterns of historical erasure and silencing faced by Indigenous peoples as their cultures, histories, and rights were systematically disregarded by expanding American interests.