8.6 Conversational analysis
8 min read•august 21, 2024
Conversational analysis examines how people use language to achieve social goals and maintain relationships. It uncovers the underlying rules and patterns that govern social interaction, analyzing features like , , and .
This field contributes to our understanding of communication patterns, social norms, and cultural differences in conversation. It has applications in various settings, including healthcare, education, and business, helping to improve communication effectiveness and interpersonal dynamics.
Fundamentals of conversational analysis
- Examines the structure and organization of human interaction through spoken language
- Provides insights into how people use language to achieve social goals and maintain relationships
- Contributes to our understanding of communication patterns, social norms, and cultural differences in conversation
Definition and purpose
Top images from around the web for Definition and purpose
Session-level Language Modeling for Conversational Speech - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
A Dynamic Speaker Model for Conversational Interactions - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Dynamic Reactance Interaction – How Vested Interests Affect People’s Experience ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Session-level Language Modeling for Conversational Speech - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
A Dynamic Speaker Model for Conversational Interactions - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
Top images from around the web for Definition and purpose
Session-level Language Modeling for Conversational Speech - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
A Dynamic Speaker Model for Conversational Interactions - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
Frontiers | The Dynamic Reactance Interaction – How Vested Interests Affect People’s Experience ... View original
Is this image relevant?
Session-level Language Modeling for Conversational Speech - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
A Dynamic Speaker Model for Conversational Interactions - ACL Anthology View original
Is this image relevant?
1 of 3
- Systematic study of talk-in-interaction focuses on naturally occurring conversations
- Aims to uncover the underlying rules and patterns that govern social interaction
- Analyzes features such as turn-taking, sequence organization, and repair mechanisms
- Helps reveal how participants create and maintain social order through conversation
- Used to improve communication in various settings (healthcare, education, business)
Historical development
- Emerged in the 1960s as a branch of ethnomethodology developed by Harold Garfinkel
- , , and Gail Jefferson pioneered the field in the 1970s
- Evolved from focus on everyday conversations to include institutional and professional contexts
- Incorporated insights from linguistics, sociology, and anthropology over time
- Expanded to include analysis of non-verbal communication and technology-mediated interactions
Key theoretical approaches
- Ethnomethodology emphasizes how people make sense of their social world through interaction
- Conversation Analysis (CA) focuses on the sequential organization of talk and social actions
- Interactional Sociolinguistics examines how social and cultural contexts influence conversation
- Discourse Analysis explores how language use reflects and constructs social realities
- Pragmatics investigates how context and speaker intentions shape meaning in conversation
Structure of conversations
Turn-taking mechanisms
- Allocate speaking rights among participants in a conversation
- Include techniques for selecting the next speaker (direct address, gaze)
- Involve recognizing and utilizing transition-relevant places (TRPs)
- Manage and interruptions to maintain conversational flow
- Vary across cultures and contexts (formal meetings vs casual chats)
Adjacency pairs
- Consist of two related utterances produced by different speakers
- Include common examples (greeting-greeting, question-answer, offer-acceptance/refusal)
- Establish expectations for appropriate responses in conversation
- Can be expanded or inserted within other
- Help maintain coherence and structure in dialogues
Repair strategies
- Address problems in speaking, hearing, or understanding during conversation
- Include self-initiated repair (speaker corrects their own mistake)
- Involve other-initiated repair (listener signals a problem or offers correction)
- Use techniques like repetition, clarification requests, or reformulation
- Play a crucial role in maintaining mutual understanding and preventing communication breakdowns
Conversational norms and expectations
Cooperative principle
- Proposed by philosopher H. Paul Grice to explain how effective communication occurs
- Assumes participants in a conversation cooperate to achieve mutual understanding
- Consists of four maxims (quantity, quality, relevance, manner)
- Guides speakers to provide appropriate amount and type of information
- Helps listeners interpret implied meanings based on adherence to or flouting of maxims
Conversational implicature
- Refers to meaning conveyed indirectly or implicitly in conversation
- Arises from the interaction between what is said and the context of the utterance
- Can be generalized (based on general knowledge) or particularized (context-specific)
- Relies on shared background knowledge and assumptions between speakers
- Allows for efficient communication by conveying more information than explicitly stated
Politeness theory
- Developed by Penelope Brown and Stephen Levinson to explain linguistic politeness
- Based on the concept of face (public self-image) and face-threatening acts (FTAs)
- Identifies strategies for mitigating FTAs (positive politeness, negative politeness, off-record)
- Varies across cultures and social contexts
- Influences choice of words, phrases, and conversational strategies
Nonverbal aspects in conversation
Paralanguage and prosody
- Encompass vocal features that accompany speech (pitch, volume, rhythm, intonation)
- Convey emotional states, attitudes, and intentions of speakers
- Influence interpretation of spoken messages (sarcasm, emphasis, uncertainty)
- Vary across languages and cultures in their use and meaning
- Play crucial role in turn-taking and signaling speaker transitions
Gestures and facial expressions
- Complement and enhance verbal communication in conversations
- Include emblems (culturally specific with fixed meanings)
- Involve illustrators (movements that accompany and reinforce speech)
- Comprise regulators (nonverbal cues that manage turn-taking and feedback)
- Provide important cues for interpreting speaker emotions and attitudes
Proxemics and posture
- Refer to use of space and body positioning during interactions
- Influence perception of intimacy, dominance, and engagement in conversation
- Vary significantly across cultures (acceptable interpersonal distances)
- Include concepts like personal space and territorial behavior
- Affect comfort levels and rapport-building in face-to-face conversations
Cultural influences on conversation
Cross-cultural communication styles
- Encompass differences in directness, formality, and expressiveness
- Include variations in turn-taking patterns and interruption norms
- Affect use of silence and in conversation across cultures
- Influence preferences for explicit vs implicit communication
- Impact interpretation of politeness and face-saving strategies
High-context vs low-context cultures
- Distinguish between cultures based on reliance on contextual information
- depend more on implicit communication and shared understanding
- prioritize explicit, direct verbal messages
- Affect expectations for detail and background information in conversations
- Influence interpretation of nonverbal cues and indirect speech acts
Intercultural pragmatics
- Studies how cultural differences impact language use in interaction
- Examines cross-cultural variations in speech acts (requests, apologies, compliments)
- Investigates cultural differences in conversational routines and rituals
- Explores impact of cultural values on politeness strategies and face management
- Aims to improve intercultural communication and prevent misunderstandings
Conversation in different contexts
Institutional vs casual talk
- Compares formal, goal-oriented interactions with informal, social conversations
- Examines differences in turn-taking systems and topic management
- Analyzes power dynamics and role expectations in institutional settings
- Investigates how institutional constraints shape language use and interaction
- Explores how participants navigate between institutional and casual talk modes
Online vs face-to-face interaction
- Contrasts features of computer-mediated communication with in-person conversations
- Examines impact of asynchronous communication on turn-taking and repair
- Analyzes use of emoticons, emojis, and other digital paralinguistic cues
- Investigates how online platforms shape conversational norms and expectations
- Explores challenges and opportunities of multimodal online interactions
Group vs dyadic conversations
- Compares dynamics of conversations involving multiple participants vs two people
- Examines differences in turn allocation and speaker selection processes
- Analyzes formation of alliances and subgroups within larger conversations
- Investigates how group size affects topic development and maintenance
- Explores challenges of managing multiple conversational threads in group settings
Analytical methods in conversational analysis
Transcription techniques
- Involve detailed notation systems to capture verbal and nonverbal aspects of talk
- Include Jefferson transcription system for representing timing, intonation, and overlap
- Utilize specialized symbols to indicate features like pauses, laughter, and emphasis
- Require decisions about level of detail and features to include in transcripts
- Serve as foundation for subsequent analysis and interpretation of conversational data
Coding systems
- Provide systematic ways to categorize and analyze conversational phenomena
- Include schemes for coding speech acts, turn-taking behaviors, and repair strategies
- Involve development of codebooks with clear definitions and examples
- Require training of coders to ensure reliability and consistency in application
- Allow for quantitative analysis of conversational patterns and frequencies
Discourse analysis tools
- Encompass various approaches to examining language use in social contexts
- Include critical discourse analysis for exploring power relations in conversation
- Utilize corpus linguistics techniques for analyzing large datasets of conversational data
- Involve software tools for automated analysis of linguistic features and patterns
- Combine qualitative and quantitative methods to provide comprehensive insights
Applications of conversational analysis
Therapy and counseling
- Utilizes CA insights to improve therapeutic communication and outcomes
- Examines how therapists and clients co-construct meaning in sessions
- Analyzes patterns of resistance, alignment, and change in therapeutic discourse
- Informs development of more effective counseling techniques and interventions
- Helps identify markers of therapeutic progress and alliance formation
Workplace communication
- Applies CA principles to enhance organizational communication effectiveness
- Examines patterns in meetings, negotiations, and customer interactions
- Analyzes how power dynamics and hierarchies manifest in workplace conversations
- Informs training programs for improving leadership and team communication skills
- Helps identify and address communication breakdowns in professional settings
Language teaching and learning
- Utilizes CA findings to inform second language acquisition theories and practices
- Examines how learners develop interactional competence in the target language
- Analyzes classroom discourse patterns and teacher-student interactions
- Informs design of more authentic and effective language learning activities
- Helps identify areas of pragmatic difficulty for language learners across cultures
Challenges and limitations
Subjectivity in interpretation
- Acknowledges potential for researcher bias in analysis of conversational data
- Requires careful consideration of context and participant perspectives
- Involves challenges in determining speakers' intentions and implicit meanings
- Necessitates rigorous methods for ensuring reliability and validity of interpretations
- Raises questions about generalizability of findings from specific interactions
Ethical considerations
- Involves issues of privacy and consent in recording and analyzing natural conversations
- Requires careful handling of sensitive or confidential information in transcripts
- Raises concerns about potential impact of analysis on participants' relationships
- Necessitates consideration of power dynamics between researchers and subjects
- Involves ethical dilemmas in deciding how to present and disseminate findings
Technological constraints
- Includes limitations of audio and video recording equipment in capturing all aspects of interaction
- Involves challenges in accurately transcribing and representing multimodal communication
- Raises issues of data storage, security, and long-term accessibility of conversational corpora
- Requires ongoing adaptation to evolving forms of technology-mediated communication
- Necessitates development of new tools and methods for analyzing digital interactions
Future directions in conversational analysis
Artificial intelligence and chatbots
- Explores application of CA principles to design more natural and effective AI conversational agents
- Examines how humans interact with AI systems and adapt their conversational strategies
- Investigates ethical implications of AI-human conversations and issues of trust and deception
- Analyzes potential of AI for automating aspects of conversational analysis and coding
- Considers impact of widespread AI adoption on human conversational norms and skills
Multimodal conversation analysis
- Expands focus to include analysis of gestures, gaze, and other bodily conduct in interaction
- Utilizes advanced video analysis techniques to capture fine-grained details of embodied communication
- Examines how different modalities (speech, gesture, gaze) work together in meaning-making
- Investigates impact of technology-mediated multimodal communication (video calls, virtual reality)
- Explores potential of wearable sensors and motion capture for studying nonverbal aspects of conversation
Neurolinguistic approaches
- Integrates insights from neuroscience to understand cognitive processes underlying conversation
- Utilizes neuroimaging techniques to study brain activity during real-time social interactions
- Examines neural correlates of turn-taking, repair, and other conversational phenomena
- Investigates how neurological conditions affect conversational abilities and strategies
- Explores potential for neurofeedback and brain-computer interfaces in conversation analysis and therapy
Key Terms to Review (32)
Adjacency pairs: Adjacency pairs are conversational structures that consist of two related utterances, typically produced by two speakers in a dialogue, where the first utterance prompts a response from the second. These pairs are fundamental to the flow of conversation, as they establish expectations for turn-taking and coherence, allowing speakers to understand how their contributions fit into the larger interaction. Common examples include questions and answers, greetings and responses, or requests and confirmations.
Assertive: Assertive communication is a style that expresses one’s thoughts, feelings, and needs in an open and honest way while respecting others. This approach is key in maintaining a balance between being passive and aggressive in interactions. It promotes clarity and encourages effective dialogue by allowing individuals to communicate their perspectives confidently without undermining or dismissing the views of others.
Backchanneling: Backchanneling refers to the use of non-verbal and verbal cues by listeners to indicate their engagement and understanding during a conversation, without interrupting the speaker. These cues can include nodding, utterances like 'uh-huh', or facial expressions that show attentiveness. This practice helps facilitate smooth communication by providing feedback to the speaker, enhancing both the flow of dialogue and the overall understanding of discourse.
Contextualization cues: Contextualization cues are verbal and non-verbal signals that help participants in a conversation to understand the context or meaning of the communication. These cues can include tone of voice, facial expressions, gestures, and even the choice of words, all of which contribute to shaping the interpretation of messages during interactions.
Conversation Coding: Conversation coding is a systematic method used to analyze and categorize the elements of spoken interactions between individuals, focusing on the structure and organization of conversations. This process helps to identify patterns in how people communicate, the roles they assume, and the strategies they employ to manage dialogue, which are essential for understanding conversational dynamics and social interactions.
Conversational implicature: Conversational implicature refers to the way in which speakers imply meaning through their statements without explicitly stating it. It relies on the context of the conversation and the shared knowledge between the speakers, often guided by cooperative principles such as relevance and quantity. This phenomenon plays a crucial role in communication, enhancing our understanding of what is meant beyond the literal interpretation of words.
Cooperative Principle: The cooperative principle is a fundamental theory in pragmatics that posits that participants in a conversation typically work together to achieve mutual understanding and effective communication. This principle suggests that speakers and listeners are generally expected to contribute relevant, truthful, clear, and concise information to discussions, which facilitates the flow of conversation and enhances comprehension.
Cross-cultural communication styles: Cross-cultural communication styles refer to the diverse ways in which people from different cultural backgrounds express themselves and interpret messages during interactions. These styles can significantly influence conversations, as factors like cultural norms, values, and social contexts shape how individuals engage in dialogue, convey meaning, and respond to others. Understanding these variations is crucial for effective communication across cultures and can lead to improved relationships and reduced misunderstandings.
Directive: A directive is a speech act that aims to get the listener to do something, such as making requests, giving commands, or offering suggestions. Directives play a crucial role in communication, as they involve the speaker attempting to influence the behavior or actions of the listener. This can include various forms, such as polite requests or forceful commands, depending on the context and the relationship between the speaker and listener.
Emanuel Schegloff: Emanuel Schegloff is a prominent sociologist and one of the founders of conversational analysis, a method for studying the structure and organization of talk in interaction. His work emphasizes how conversations are organized through turn-taking, repair mechanisms, and how participants construct meaning through their interactions. Schegloff's contributions have been critical in understanding the nuances of human communication and social interaction.
Facial expressions: Facial expressions are the visible configurations of the face that communicate emotions and social signals to others. They play a crucial role in interpersonal communication, enhancing or contradicting verbal messages and influencing social interactions. These expressions can convey a range of feelings, from happiness and sadness to anger and surprise, and are an essential part of non-verbal communication.
Gestures: Gestures are non-verbal movements or signals made with the hands, arms, or body that communicate ideas, emotions, or information. They play a crucial role in enhancing verbal communication, providing additional context and meaning to spoken language, and can vary significantly across cultures.
Grice's Maxims: Grice's Maxims are a set of conversational principles proposed by philosopher H.P. Grice that describe how people typically communicate effectively and meaningfully. These maxims—Quantity, Quality, Relation, and Manner—serve as guidelines for cooperative conversation, helping speakers and listeners navigate the implicit meanings in dialogue, which connects to broader aspects like implicature, conversational analysis, and discourse processing.
Harvey Sacks: Harvey Sacks was an influential sociologist and a key figure in the development of conversation analysis, which focuses on the structure and organization of talk in social interactions. His work laid the groundwork for understanding how people communicate in everyday situations, revealing the underlying rules and patterns that govern conversations. Sacks emphasized the importance of analyzing natural speech to uncover how meaning is created through dialogue, contributing significantly to the field of sociology and linguistics.
High-context cultures: High-context cultures are social or cultural environments where communication relies heavily on implicit messages, contextual cues, and shared understanding, rather than explicit verbal expression. In these cultures, non-verbal signals, body language, and the situational context play a crucial role in conveying meaning, making the relationship between communicators significantly important.
Intercultural pragmatics: Intercultural pragmatics is the study of how people from different cultural backgrounds communicate and interpret meaning in social interactions. It examines how cultural norms, values, and contexts influence language use and the strategies individuals employ to navigate conversations across cultural boundaries. This field emphasizes the importance of understanding both verbal and non-verbal cues in communication, as well as the impact of cultural differences on conversational dynamics.
Intertextuality: Intertextuality refers to the relationship between texts and how they influence, reference, or echo each other. This concept highlights that no text exists in isolation; rather, it is shaped by its connections to other texts, whether through direct quotes, allusions, or shared themes. Understanding intertextuality can deepen the analysis of communication and dialogue in various contexts.
Intonation Patterns: Intonation patterns refer to the variations in pitch while speaking that convey meaning, emotions, or intentions. These patterns play a crucial role in communication by helping to indicate questions, statements, excitement, or sarcasm, influencing how a listener interprets the message being conveyed.
Low-context cultures: Low-context cultures are societies where communication relies heavily on explicit verbal expression and clarity, emphasizing the content of the message over the surrounding context. In these cultures, people prefer straightforward and clear communication styles, often using direct language to convey their thoughts and intentions, which minimizes ambiguity and misunderstanding.
Overlaps: Overlaps refer to the instances in conversations where multiple speakers begin to talk at the same time, creating a momentary interruption or competition for the floor. This phenomenon highlights the dynamics of turn-taking in conversations and can convey various social meanings, such as enthusiasm, urgency, or disagreement. Overlaps are an essential part of conversational analysis, providing insight into how people manage speaking rights and navigate social interactions.
Paralanguage: Paralanguage refers to the non-verbal elements that accompany speech, such as tone, pitch, volume, and speech rate, which can convey meaning beyond the actual words spoken. These vocal characteristics play a critical role in communication, as they help express emotions, attitudes, and social signals that enhance or alter the spoken message. Understanding paralanguage is essential for interpreting conversational dynamics and the subtleties of human interaction.
Pauses: Pauses are intentional breaks in speech that serve various functions in communication, such as signaling the end of a thought, allowing for listener processing, or indicating a shift in topics. These breaks can occur at different lengths and are often influenced by social norms, context, and the dynamics of conversation. They are essential in conversational analysis as they help reveal how speakers manage turn-taking and maintain coherence in interactions.
Politeness Theory: Politeness theory is a framework in linguistics that explains how individuals manage social relationships through language, focusing on the strategies used to maintain face and show respect in communication. This theory emphasizes that communication is not just about conveying information but also about managing interpersonal relationships, which involves understanding context and meaning, as well as conversational dynamics.
Posture: Posture refers to the position or alignment of the body, particularly during communication, and can convey various social signals and meanings. In interactions, the way a person holds their body can reflect their emotional state, engagement level, and relationship with others, playing a critical role in the dynamics of conversation.
Prosody: Prosody refers to the rhythm, stress, and intonation of speech that conveys meaning beyond the words themselves. It plays a vital role in communication by helping to express emotions, indicate questions or statements, and emphasize particular information. This vocal aspect is essential in understanding the nuances of language, as it can alter the intended message significantly.
Proxemics: Proxemics is the study of personal space and the physical distance between individuals during communication. This concept examines how spatial relationships affect interactions, revealing insights into social dynamics, cultural norms, and individual behaviors. Understanding proxemics can shed light on how people perceive intimacy, authority, and social hierarchies in various contexts.
Repair mechanisms: Repair mechanisms are strategies employed in conversation to address and correct misunderstandings or breakdowns in communication. These mechanisms can be initiated by either party in the conversation and include methods such as self-repair, where the speaker corrects their own error, and other-repair, where the listener prompts for clarification or correction. These interactions help maintain the flow of conversation and ensure that meaning is accurately conveyed.
Sacks' Model: Sacks' Model, developed by sociologist Harvey Sacks, is a framework that examines how people construct meaning and manage conversations in everyday interactions. It emphasizes the sequential organization of talk, focusing on how speakers use turn-taking and other conversational mechanisms to create coherence and establish social order within dialogue.
Sequence organization: Sequence organization refers to the structured way in which turns and actions are arranged in conversation. This organization is crucial for facilitating understanding and maintaining coherence in interactions, as speakers take turns in a manner that reflects social norms and conversational cues. By following these sequences, participants can ensure that conversations flow smoothly, allowing for effective communication.
Sequences: Sequences refer to the ordered arrangement of conversational turns in interaction, highlighting how speakers construct dialogue through specific patterns and structures. These sequences can reveal the organization of talk, including how participants manage the flow of conversation, respond to each other, and create meaning together. Understanding sequences helps in analyzing the nuances of communication and how social norms influence conversational exchanges.
Transcription techniques: Transcription techniques are systematic methods used to convert spoken language into written text, capturing the nuances of conversation such as intonation, pauses, and overlapping speech. These techniques are essential in analyzing conversational dynamics, allowing researchers to study the structure and flow of interactions between speakers. By documenting how people communicate, transcription techniques provide a framework for examining language use in various contexts.
Turn-taking: Turn-taking is a fundamental aspect of conversational interaction where participants alternate in speaking and listening, ensuring smooth dialogue flow. This practice is essential for effective communication as it allows speakers to convey their messages while listeners remain engaged. Understanding turn-taking helps reveal how people manage conversations, including how they signal readiness to speak, how interruptions occur, and how context shapes these exchanges.